Preview

Matsumoto's Philosophy Of Asian-American Citizenship

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
2386 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Matsumoto's Philosophy Of Asian-American Citizenship
Plato's philosophy towards citizenship, in simplest terms, is an implicit decision between state and resident to obey all institutions inherent in a society. "Decisively did you choose us and agree to be a citizen under us." And such is the way that Asian Pacific Americans, a term coined not more than forty years ago, choose to tackle prejudice, ignorance, and greed throughout their four hundred year history. Citizenship is defined as broadly as: "Democracy" by Manuel Buaken, "loyalty" per Mike Masaoka, and "equality" according to Amy Uyematsu. Asian Americans always resort to accepted means within American society to pursue favorable ends. Despite a stacked deck, Alien Land laws prohibited alien ownership of land, the Immigration Act …show more content…
By organizing and creating leverage through numbers and consolidation, Asian Americans greatly increased their bargaining power. Taishi Matsumoto mourns his situation in 1937. He feels trapped in his current employ as a carrot washer with no chance of upward mobility. There are "no inspired Messias, no strong organizations to whom I can appeal not only for myself, but for others like me." As an individual he merely remains stagnant. Organization and the coming together of individuals create a strong voice, which he lacks, and therefore is unable to combat inequality or to instill change. Whereas labor unions improved wages, working conditions, and hours, the single effort of Matsumoto changes nothing. Therefore, labor organization is a key factor in Asian American history in attempting to assert the rights of citizenship. Other organizations, social organizations, such as the Chinese Six Companies (also known as the CCBA) or the Chinese American Citizens Alliance (CACA), provided a familiar environment while consolidating capabilities as well. Whether it be a supporting causes in China, bringing Chinese news, or creating public opinions and a fundraising base, social organizations such as these were instrumental in providing …show more content…
Never is this more eloquently illustrated than during the Japanese internment. Hirabayashi, a conscientious objector to the internment procedures utilized by the government, breaks the curfew set by Public Proclamation #1 and turns himself into the authorities and is arrested and conviction was upheld in the courts on the basis that Japanese Americans are not truly Americans because they are unassimilable and set themselves apart from mainstream society. The case of Korematsu, a man who deliberately evaded evacuation orders, despite being rejected from a previous attempt to enlist, went to the Supreme Court. The main point of contention was whether or not the evacuation was Constitutional; it was found to be legal due to military necessity and Korematsu was convicted. In the case involving Endo, who broke no laws and did not initiate her case, she was illegally detained because she was not a military threat. The day before the judgment, the evacuation was rescinded. The case of Endo passed unanimously (Shah). Asian Americans not only respected the legal

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    The Korematsu v. United States (1944) case was an unjustifiable case towards individuals with a particular race, but even though at the moment it seemed like the appropriate action to take for the protection of the people in our country, the action towards this race was completely inappropriate and unconstitutional. During the War of World War II, the president of the United States, Franklin Roosevelt put a float the Executive Order 9066 that targeted individuals from the Pacific Coast of Japanese ancestry both citizens and non-citizens. The order was to get any individual with in the area of the Pacific Coast to report to assembly centers where they were being detained until released by military authorities. Individuals with Japanese ancestry were being imprisoned without any evidence that they were a danger to the country and were deprived from their Constitutional rights. At first the first order was for any individual with Japanese ancestry to stay in their home with a curfew assigned to them, without…

    • 1340 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    On December 7, 1941 the Japanese Imperial Navy launched an attack on Pearl Harbor, the next day Congress declared war on Japan. Public opinion towards people of any “Asian” ancestry turned to racial hatred. Under political and public pressure Franklin Delano Roosevelt signed Executive Order 9066 on February 19th, 1942 (Alonso 30). Enter one of the Dark times in American History, the imprisonment of its own citizens because of racial backgrounds. The act was attacked in the Supreme Court case “Hirabayasi v. United States,” though the Supreme Court upheld the order as “A means of National Security in war time” (Touro Law 2). In May of 1942 Fred Korematsu sued the United States. In a 6-to-3 vote the Supreme Court…

    • 2136 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Although the Japanese-Americans were citizens of the United States and residences within the country, they did not have equivalent rights during this time in history. “The Constitution makes him a citizen of the United States by nativity and a citizen of California by residence. No claim is made that he is not loyal to this country.” Many Japanese-Americans were being treated as if they had been disloyal to the US and even alienated because of how they looked. Also, the freedom to own land was taken from them as well. “The Federal Reserve Banks took charge of property owned by evacuees, while the Farm Security Administration took over the agricultural property.” Owning property is one of the greatest freedoms and American can uphold and as history has shown it can easily be taken away in an instant. Japanese-Americans were forced to sell everything because they were very limited in what they could take with them to the internment…

    • 1180 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    In conclusion In, America is in the Heart, Carlos Bulosan, In, Desert Exile, by Yoshiko Uchida and Out of this Furnace, Thomas Bell, the authors argue that the experiences of the ethnic groups Philippines, Slovaks and Japanese Americans are characterized by discrimination, political legislation /laws. America is in the Heart is the story of how legislation in the 1900 banning of Japanese Labor, 1905 restrictions on labor, Executive Order 9066 authorized the internment of Japanese’s American citizens. The house of representative idea 1900 Japanese labor in Hawaii, 1905 Korea bars citizens from leaving, Violence against immigration…

    • 174 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    During World War II, a time of confusion and fear settled around America. Previously respected and average everyday citizens became feared and outcast by most people in the United States. “All citizens alike, both in and out of uniform feel the impact of war in greater or lesser measure (Justice Hugo Black).” The government declared that all the people of Japanese descent living along the Pacific coast be sent to live in concentration camps where the living arrangements were not the most pleasant and were overcrowded.…

    • 523 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    There are a few different directions I could see myself taking the final research paper for this Capstone. They are still general and would probably need refining and narrowing down for the completed work. First, I have been thinking about the role of fear in Americans’ relationship with the Bill of Rights, and how there have been more than a few instances when Americans have sacrificed their constitutional protections for a feeling of security. Particularly, there have been a few Supreme Court cases where rights become less important than security especially when during war. Hirabayashi was a case which upheld the conviction of a Japanese American who violated a curfew imposed on him due to his race and ancestry after Pearl Harbor. More famously, Korematsu highlights this tension, where the Supreme Court felt it was constitutional for American Citizens to be detained without any sort of due process due to their race. Even the case of Schenck…

    • 729 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Although most immigrant groups experienced the same labor injustices such as long hours, unsafe working conditions, unfair pay, and unequal pay, the challenges of the labor market divided most cultural groups rather than uniting them. In Hawaii, as described by Ronald Takaki in his article, A Larger Memory: A History of Our Diversity with Voices, Japanese and Filipinos working on sugar plantations protested together in an effort to combat the injustices they faced. The plantations even developed a means of communication between all the races working on the plantation called “pidgin English”. Although this was successful in Hawaii, where the labor market was slightly less competitive than the mainland United States, tensions between immigrants…

    • 210 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    So since, “For over 50 years… Americans has seen newcomers from Japan… as a threat to the ‘American standard of living’ (Myths, Prejudices, and War).” Being viewed as a threat automatically caused the Japanese to be seen as a liability to Americans and put the Japanese-Americans at a huge disadvantage. The Japanese Americans were not treated equally because of the previously formed bias judgements formed against them by Americans which was shown through “state and local laws [that] reflected the belief that people of Asian descent were inferior (Myths, Prejudices, and War).” Changes in the law against a certain ethnicity violates the 14th amendment which states that American citizens who should have been treated with the same rights that Caucasian American citizens were treated…

    • 792 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The indiscriminate round-up of people of Japanese ancestry demonstrated the dominant (white) American culture’s ability, through racial stereotyping, to strip minority groups of their individual identity. Throughout the preface of the novel, Okada uses the terms “Japanese-American,” “American-Japanese,” and “Japanese-Japanese” to emphasize how all people from a Japanese background were heaped together by the American government. Consequently, people of Japanese ancestry were forcibly evicted from the West Coast and moved to what were euphemistically called “relocation centers.” Okada demonstrates an awareness of how misrepresentation by the government by the use of sanitized terminology subverted the realities of incarceration. In his preface…

    • 158 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Have you ever gotten made fun of or discriminated for something that you believe in that everyone else does not? I grew up as a vegetarian. I used to get ridiculed repeatedly for not acting “manly” because I did not eat meat. This memory reminds me of the two heartbreaking stories about the migrant workers who were taken advantage of, and the poor Japanese Americans falsely thought as terrorists. There are many similarities between the Mexican migrant workers and the Japanese people, while there are just as many differences between them as well.…

    • 453 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Business was thriving, the economy was growing, and life as a whole was improving. However, there was a growing minority of workingmen whose long, difficult hours of toil were being taken advantage of by greedy, selfish employers. These poor men and their malnourished, destitute families compiled the backbone of the thriving economy. Without them, production as a whole would have been at a standstill and the growing quality of life for Americans would have been dampened. Yet these hard-working people received no recognition. On the contrary, they were sorely mistreated by their employers. Threateningly, this problem was growing vaster, until finally workers began to take a stand. Did they make any impact? Did the movement last? Throughout the decades, labor unions have shaped the state of the American economy and the value of the common…

    • 1000 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Dbq Essay On Immigration

    • 846 Words
    • 4 Pages

    There are papers written about how these people don’t have the right to be an American citizen. On a political cartoon there is a wall that is blocking the Asians from being able to get to America. It is seen how the Americans felt. There is also a ladder falling with a man attempting to get over the wall. It symbolizes the want for the immigrants who wanted to be in America so badly. The Americans are also looking down on the Asians showing a feeling of dominance (Source J). In one document there is a explanation on why the immigrants didn’t need to be in America. The writer says that “They have none of the inherited instincts and tendencies which made it comparatively easy to deal with the immigration of the olden days” meaning that the immigrants did not have the same culture as the Americans did and it angered them (Walker). It can be seen that immigration also changed over time. In a pie chart there is a visual sign of the change in who was coming over to America. It went from 93% of Northern and western Europeans to only 61%. The Asian population dropped from 1% to .5%. All of these numbers showed a dominance in people who looked more like Americans than the others (Source H). One person, Mary Antin, attempted to stick up for those people says that it was unconstitutional and incorrect. Even with these statements being as true as can…

    • 846 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    In the early 19th century, the United States began to re-think about its stance on immigration. As the numbers of immigrants increased, questions about the leniency of the American government on immigration were raised by the “Progressive Movement”. Consequently, the United States began to employ a closed door policy of immigration. Chinese male immigrants, who had been coming in masses, inspired the implementation of the Chinese Exclusion Act of 1882, which forbade further immigration of laborers of Chinese descent. This act forced prohibited Chinese males from bring over their families and destroyed possibilities of citizenship for Chinese immigrants by making them permanent aliens. Furthermore, in 1907, adding to the isolationist stance of the U.S., the city of San Francisco attempted to remove Japanese students from white schools and put them in segregated schools with Chinese students. The Japanese government was infuriated by with this comparison to the Chinese; this led to the establishment of the Gentleman’s Agreement. This was an informal agreement stating that the Japanese government would restrict further immigration of their people to the United States and, in return, Japanese children in San Francisco would be able to attend school with white children. Over the next half century, further restrictions on immigration were implemented, many based on racist assumptions that immigrants were inassimilable and could not be Americanized. However, we see examples in Nisei Daughter, where the children like Monica and her siblings became Americanized and came to detest the strict Japanese culture their parents were raised in. this contradicts the assumption that immigrants would not assimilate.…

    • 1605 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    In order to reach the best conclusion on what it means to be a citizen, a discussion of the most primitive answer to the question must be established. To put it bluntly, a citizen, without any outside considerations or sophistications, is a person who is associated with a group of people. This definition is necessary, but not sufficient to define what a citizen is. To generalize what a citizen is under a set of definiens creates complications with regards to analyzing different cultures within different time periods when those cultures existed. The best way to orient the definition is to, first; give broad sufficent definiens for the concept of being a citizen. To address the issue of varying cultures and time periods, these definiens will…

    • 774 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Unlike natural born citizens, immigrants practice two forms of citizenship: ascriptive and consensual. As defined by Rogers Smith, ascriptive citizenship is inherited at birth while consensual citizenship is a choice (Smith 20). One interpretation of Smith’s definitions of citizenship is that a person can only be defined as one type of citizen. This is a very realistic interpretation, as many who immigrate to America continue to practice traditions of their culture. However, that is not always the case. In "The Soul of an Immigrant" by Constantine Panunzio and The Melting Pot by Israel Zangwill, the main characters express deep emotions about their consensual American citizenship, not found in those who are born as Americans, which overcomes…

    • 1806 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Good Essays