Preview

Lord of The Rings/Kite Runner Compare and Contrast Essay

Better Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1550 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Lord of The Rings/Kite Runner Compare and Contrast Essay
Kite Runner and Lord of the Flies: Compare and Contrast
What objects do you associate innocence with? Marriage, virginity, a childhood toy? When we think of dominance we think of war; we think of negativity. When the phrase ‘parental influence’ comes to mind, we go to our mothers tucking us into bed and watching the game with our fathers—at least that is what us lucky ones think of. Not everyone is lucky enough to have that innocence stored forever, violent free lives, and a mother and father by our side. The Kite Runner and Lord of the Flies have many similarities, particularly when comparing themes such as loss of innocence, power and dominance, and paternal influences and the ways in which they are depicted through symbolism and irony.
From the beginning of The Kite Runner Hoseinni showed innocence through Amir’s passion and longing for kites, but not any kite; Amir longed for the winning kite in the annual kite flying tournament. Kites were constantly present during Amir’s childhood. They were his goodness and his purity; the goodness and purity of Afghanistan at that time. Amir’s innocence was stolen by him when he was twelve-years-old by the neighborhood bully, Assef. Amir longed for the winning kite, but at the expense of his friend, Hassan: “But there were two things amid the garbage that I couldn’t stop looking at: One was the blue kite resting against the wall,” (75). Amir witnessed the rape of Hassan, and after he took his trophy kite home and hung it up on the wall it mocked him, reminding him of his cowardice, and the purity and the innocence that were taken from him. When Amir returned to Kabul as an adult there were no kites. Afghanistan had been run over by the Taliban and everything had been destroyed, just like the innocence that was taken by Amir and the goodness and that was stolen from him. In The Kite Runner, Amir wanted the winning kite. After witnessing the rape of Hassan—witnessing his beloved friend sacrifice himself for the first place

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    In Lord of the Flies by William Golding there is a repeated theme of children losing innocence due to their isolation from civilization. The strongest example of this loss would be when Simon, a young character in the book, discovers the Devil in his meditation area. Another prominent illustration would be Roger and his slow evolution into a creature of destruction and torture. In William Golding’s book, Lord of the Flies, there is a great loss of childhood innocence that is replaced with darkness due to the evil in man’s heart.…

    • 577 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Flying kites is a passion of both Amir and Hassan and as they win the national kite fighting championship Amirs finally wins a spot in the heart of his torn father. But after this competition the kite takes on a very different significance to the boys as Amir witnesses Hassans rape but does not step in, in the fear the perpetrators will steal his victory prize and his father will see him as a failure. Ironically Amir not standing up to the boys meant that he had become “ The boy [I] his father was afraid he would become.” Amirs actions that day and his failings to step in and save amir switched the symbolism of the Kite from victory and happiness to a sign of betrayal and guilt. Amirs guilt means that he can’t stand to be in the same house as Hassan so he frames Hassan of theft and force his father to fire him. This is the last time Amir would see Hassan. But despite all of these adversities Amir many many years later finds his redemption as the novel closes, Amir and Hassan orphan Shrobha are flying a kite, again the symvolism has done a complete turn around and the kite signifies happiness and the fact that even in the worst of circumstances redemption is attainable. Significantly the roles have also reversed as Sorbha cuts a kite Amir runs it looking back over his shoulder he…

    • 587 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Amir grew up very privileged. Baba gave him almost everything they could have wanted. He had a beautiful house, a father, and caretakers, Ali and Hassan. Hassan is just a year younger than Amir and they were raised together. Hassan proves is unrequited loyalty throughout the story but especially when he runs a kite for Amir. When Assef and other boys stop Hassan in an alley asking for the kite, Hassan refuses. Amir finds the boys and doesn’t defend Hassan when they make threats, but instead remains unseen and heard. In the end, he watches Hassan get raped. He carries this mistake with him throughout the novel. The kite was extremely important to Amir. He won a kite flying competition that Baba once won. He believed showing the kite he won off to Baba would finally secure his approval. He even says that was the key to Baba’s heart. Consequently, Amir turns into the kind of person Baba didn’t want him to become; a man who doesn’t know right from wrong. This proves to be true when Amir sacrificed Hassan for a kite. He committed this sin for selfish reasons. He thought only of himself how it would benefit his relationship he wanted so badly with his father.…

    • 591 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    `Of Mice and Men, and To Kill a Mockingbird; what do these novels have in common? Both show childlike innocence, and how it is annihilated in society by adults. However, Khaled Hosseini, author of The Kite Runner, thinks the exact opposite. His novel encompasses the topic of growing up, and how it is fueled by making and fixing mistakes that prompt mature decisions in the future. Throughout the novel, Khaled Hosseini depicts coming of age through the main character, Amir, a boy living in Afghanistan with his best friend and servant, Hassan. As a child, Amir makes bad decisions that end up hurting Hassan. The decisions he makes when he is more mature reflect Amir nearing completion on his path to manhood. In The Kite Runner, Khaled Hosseini portrays that coming of age…

    • 1417 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    It is a blessing to have both parents. Some people lost that opportunity. Losing a parent is like losing a part of yourself, it's not easy to live without it. Losing a parent can be a huge impact on someone’s life especially on a young child, they suffer from the lack of love, attention and support, which affects the child physically, mentally, and emotionally. The lost of a parent might also affect the child’s education and social life.…

    • 487 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    When you read two great stories you always notice that they have things in common and some things different. From what I read “The Bean Trees” and “The Kite Runner”, their meaning had the most in common.…

    • 836 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    From the start and through his death, Hassan remains the same: loyal, forgiving, and good-natured. Hassan grew up with a very particular role in life. He prepares Amir’s breakfast and collects his books while Amir gets ready for school. Rather than going to school as well, Hassan stays and helps his father, Ali, get groceries and complete their chores. Instead of receiving his education, he stays home and lives as a servant to those richer than he. Hassan learns early on in life that it is his duty to sacrifice himself for others. As a result of growing up this way, Hassan is not prone to envy and is even happy with the way he lives; the life he has. Even after a traumatic, violent past, he remains innocent from the beginning and to the end of his life. There is no way for Hassan to become ‘good again’ because he had never been bad. Hassan’s ability to suffer without becoming bitter, his integrity, and what his character truly shows us that there is no way for him…

    • 783 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    In The Kite Runner by Khaled Hosseini both Hassan and Amir run the kites for somebody else, the real kite runner is Hassan because he would have gone to any length with no limits just like a kite, all to have remained loyal to Amir. Also Hassan was the one who ran the kites afterall. While Hassan was the kite runner for Amir, he ran all the kites, this showed Amir to take the place to run the kite for Sohrab, trying to fix something he should have done years ago save Hassan. When Hassan tells Amir “for you a thousand time over”, thats Hassan proving he would do anything for Amir, no matter what even if meant harm to him a thousand times. For being Amir’s kite runner he got rapped, he protected Amir, had pomegranates thrown at him, and took…

    • 210 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    The differences between William Golding’s allegorical novel Lord of the Flies and its film adaptation are evident. Firstly, when marooned on the island in the book, the boys are completely isolated from any adults. This comes in complete contrast to the movie where one of the pilots, though injured and mostly unconscious, survives the crash and is stranded along with the boys. An adult would remind the children of their home in England and of society’s laws and norms; the animalistic and instinctive behavior of the boys may have been curbed with the tangible memory of civilization that the pilot gives. Another difference is the amount of cursing done in the movie as opposed to the mostly clean language of the novel. The addition of vulgar language gives the allusion that the boys are much older, to the point of near adolescence. It also gives the impression that the boys are slightly uncivilized to begin with, as the vulgarity is improper of English young men. These variations between the book and movie can completely alter the impressions the story gives and its overall plot development.…

    • 349 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    The Kite Runner by Khaled Hossenini deals primarily with the theme of guilt and redemption and subtly approaches the correlations between religion and violence through these main themes. The novel centers on the relationship between the narrator Amir and his friend/servant Hassan and Amir’s guilt when he witnesses an act of violence done to Hassan that he fails to intervene in. This personal conflict ties into the narrator’s experiences with religion as he attempts to redeem himself. Through this aspect of the novel, we can see the personal journey of finding the true Self through traumatic experience and the dichotomy of religion as a tool to explain suffering and violence as well as a justification for violence.…

    • 1618 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Kite Runner is a book all about the different choices Amir makes. Some choices he makes are good and some are bad. If Amir had chosen to make the right choices at the right time, he might not have gone through all he had to go through in The Kite Runner. In the end of the book, The Kite Runner, Amir and Soraya live with Sohrab in their house in California. Amir teaches Sohrab how to fly a kite and goes to catch the kite for Sohrab like Hassan had done for Amir. The ending of the book however had tuned out good for Amir. The Kite Runner does have a happy ending because Amir repaid Hassan for his loyalty at the end of the book by getting Sohrab out of Afghanistan and giving him a new life.…

    • 1017 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    From when Amir first flew kites as young boy in Afghanistan, to flying them years later with his nephew, the different kites in this story convey different meanings. The kite tournament occurred annually in Afghanistan during the winter and Amir described it as “the highlight of the cold season”(Hosseini, 53). The kites flying in the skies represented the happiness and freedom Amir had; however, after he saw Hassan get sexually assaulted to save the kite for him, it served as a reminder of his actions. Amir did not help Hassan as a result of fear of getting hurt. Social differences also played a role in his decision, the thought of Hassan as “just a Hazara” (Hosseini, 82) running through his mind. The incident causes a break in Hassan…

    • 938 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Battle of Conformity

    • 1001 Words
    • 5 Pages

    The narrator of The Kite Runner, Amir, has always felt like his dad, Baba, didn’t approve of him. This is why Amir tries so hard to impress him by winning the kite fighting competition. When Amir takes down the final kite left in the sky, he sends Hassan, who is his kite runner, to go retrieve it. Unfortunately, Hassan gets cornered by a boy named Assef, a brutal neighborhood terrorist, and is raped by him. Amir happens to witness the terrible crime, but doesn’t try to intervene. Even though Amir knows he should step in and defend Hassan, he pretends nothing is happening. He simply runs away, calling himself a “coward” and saying that “maybe Hassan was the price [he] had to pay” to win his father’s love and approval (Hosseini 77). When Amir finds Hassan again, he is obviously traumatized but he still clings to the treasured kite. Amir gives the kite to Baba to put on the mantle while he praises them for their good work. Amir basks in the glow of his father’s approval and love, but in the back of his mind, he can’t stop thinking about what happened to Hassan to get that kite. He tries to ignore it but his conscience continues to fight him.…

    • 1001 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Hobbit: An unexpected journey and The Hobbit: The desolation of Smaug had a great director; Peter Jackson to keep every original concept that J.R.R. Tolkien would have in mind if he was the one to direct these movies. They kept that it's not only about getting Dwarves their homeland back, but the development of a quiet, stay at home and stay safe Hobbit. Most of the characters were well interpreted into the movie like Thorin's greed for the Arkenstone, how that is his childhood and the kingdom was balanced on the Arkenstone's power. The films kept the same feeling that one would get from reading the novel. A Hobbit on his adventure, there and back again.…

    • 285 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Loss of innocence is a major theme in the book Lord Of the Flies by William Golding. Throughout the book, the boys go from civilized to savagery. Golding showed that without civilization, people will lose their innocence.…

    • 580 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays