top-rated free essay

George Marshall and Imperatives Quality People

Aug 06, 2008 687 Words
In 1997, Army Chief of Staff General Dennis J. Reimer wrote: “As we reshape the force we will be guided by the Six Imperatives – quality people, realistic training, proper force mix, modernized equipment, the world’s best leader development program, and updated doctrine. The changes we make to the force will be passed through those six filters to ensure they make sense.” In the complex nature of today’s Army, those Six Imperatives translate into 7 such filters, Doctrine, Organization, Training, Materiel, Leadership, Personnel and Facilities (DOTMLPF). The DOTMPLF domain challenge that General George C. Marshall had to contend with that is most different from the challenges that our Army faces today is in the area of personnel, particularly force management. In 1943, the Bessel Committee was designed to recommend changes in the current military program indicated by shifting strategic conditions. The primary focus of the committee was the efficacy of building up foreign forces. This fact implies two things. The first is that the United States was actively considering reliance on other nation’s military to supplement our own numbers and capabilities. The second implication is twofold: we could clearly identify our friends (on whom we could rely) and our enemies (to forecast our strength against). Both are certainties that are rarely available in today’s force management equation. None-the-less, the committee also drew some other conclusions that provide sound guidance for using today’s DOTMLPF structure.

The Bessel Committee reported that the time had definitely come for long-term programming to guide the war machine developing in the United States. The committee determined that what was required was a broad and long-range strategic plan for the defeat of the enemies of the United States, whereby requirements might be balanced against means and resources and then translated into a realistic military program. Despite their focus on long term solutions, various other committees continued to debate the total number of personnel and divisions the Army truly needed. In 1943, the Maddocks Committee recommended putting off making a decision regarding troop strength until the end of summer based on the realization that ultimately, the size of the Army was largely dependant on the course of the Soviet-German fighting and the effectiveness of the combined British-American bomber offensive in Europe; a recommendation that reinforces a focus on planning for and against a known enemy with specific capabilities. At no time was there mention that these groups were focusing beyond the war.

The challenges that General Marshall and the Secretary of War had in determining and selling manpower numbers to Congress and the nation pale in comparison to today’s planners. Since the end of the Cold War, accurately identifying our enemies has proven to be very difficult. And unfortunately, with very few exceptions, not knowing who you are going to fight makes it difficult to determine on who you can rely.

In today’s military, the enemy may not be across an ocean or large geographical expanse but here in our own back yard. War plans have expanded beyond the design of two brigades forward and one brigade back. Today we are forced to develop TTPs that allow our military to meet Homeland Security missions such as: prevent, deter, defend, and defeat attacks on the United States, our population, and our defense critical infrastructure (homeland defense) and support civil authorities directed by the President or Secretary of Defense as part of a comprehensive national response to prevent and protect against terrorist incidents or manage the consequences of attack or disaster (homeland security).

While General Marshall and his cohorts projected manpower needs to fight a known enemy on a symmetrical battlefield, today’s planners are dealing with the issues of determining if we have the right combination of troop strength and organizational framework capable of symmetric and asymmetric responses to current, potential, and unidentified threats both locally and globally and in a joint force framework. Where General Marshall’s decision to move forward with 90 divisions may have indeed been an insightful decision (or courageous gamble), it was still a decision (gamble) made without the multitude of complexities that faces today’s DOTMLPF capabilities driven Army.

Cite This Document

Related Documents

  • Quality

    ...applied change an improvement. A good example for an organization which is people-oriented is Toyota which instructs its workers to: “Identify problems, no matter how small, trace their root causes, and implement all necessary solutions” Finally, for improvement to be possible it must be admitted that a process is never perfect or flawless a...

    Read More
  • George

    ...Messrs. Twomax Limited, Reginald A. S. Goode and John Robert Gordon raised actions for reparation on the ground of negligent misrepresentations against Messrs. Dickson M'Farlane and Robinson, a firm of chartered accountants. Twomax (UK 1983) demonstrate that audit firms may be liable to third parties in certain circumstances. It is a cas...

    Read More
  • GEORGE DAVID

    ...CASE: 1 GEORGE DAVID George David has been CEO of United Technologies Corporation (UTC) for more than a decade. During that time he has received numerous accolades and awards for his performance as a CEO. Under his leadership UTC, a $343 billion conglomerate whose operating units include manufacturers of elevators (Otis Elevator), aeros...

    Read More
  • George

    ...George Byrne Ms. Elizabeth Devore English 11002: College Writing 1 stretch February 25, 2014 Food Traditions Never Change In the autobiography, Lobster Lessons, the author Aleksandra Crapanzano tells her story of her love, John and how after a year of dating he takes her away from her comfort to a small cottage on the beach of Nantuck...

    Read More
  • Containment: Cold War and George C. Marshall

    ...1. Explain the US policy of containment abroad. What were the economic, military, and political strategies of enforcing containment? Identify at least three specific programs or institutions in your response. * First laid out by George F. Kennan in 1947, Containment stated that communism needed to be contained and isolated, or it would sp...

    Read More
  • Quality

    ...quality management history, gurus, TQM theories, process improvement, and organizational 'excellence' The history of quality management, from mere 'inspection' to Total Quality Management, and its modern 'branded interpretations such as 'Six Sigma', has led to the development of essential processes, ideas, theories and tools that are central to...

    Read More
  • The Will of the People

    ...Bart Solbach Hist 584 Professor Greene October 31, 2012 The Will of the People In modern warfare, it is important to consider, effectively winning the hearts and minds of the people. This is especially important if the war being fought is a civil war, as ultimately the most a government has to fear is its own people. Successfully doing so i...

    Read More
  • People

    ...does it cause but for me its No To Drugs. Drug abuse at the workplace is a serious issue in our society and will become even more serious in the future. In phillipines drug and alcohol abuse is already a grave workplace problem. Employees usually don’t leave their drug and alcohol abuse problems at the door when they enter the workplace. Compa...

    Read More

Discover the Best Free Essays on StudyMode

Conquer writer's block once and for all.

High Quality Essays

Our library contains thousands of carefully selected free research papers and essays.

Popular Topics

No matter the topic you're researching, chances are we have it covered.