Preview

Ethical Issues Concerning Fetal Tissue Research

Better Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1664 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Ethical Issues Concerning Fetal Tissue Research
Fetal tissue research is an important aspect of medical research. Fetal tissues can be obtained from many places, including hospitals, tissue banks, and abortion clinics. Conducting fetal tissue research allows us to further our education concerning diseases, vaccinations, and birth defects. Despite the importance of fetal tissue research, it raises many controversies regarding ethical issues. Many people believe that fetal tissue research should be illegal because it goes against their morals, but others see fetal tissue research as an opportunity for us to further our knowledge and education about many different medical concerns. The main ethical issue related to fetal tissue research is the concern of utilizing aborted fetuses for …show more content…
People tend to believe many different things regarding when life actually begins during gestation. A lot of people, however, believe that life begins at conception, therefore, many believe that the use of fetal tissues in research is unethical because it is disrespectful to that being. Unlike adult tissue research or organ donation where the person is able to create a will or become an organ donor before they pass away, fetuses do not get a choice because they are not even born yet. A lot of people believe that the fetus or embryonic cells need to be treated with the same respect that an elderly person would when they pass away. Some people choose to have their organs donated or to have their bodies donated to scientific research. However, many believe that since the fetus or embryonic cells cannot speak for themselves, they should not be a part of fetal tissue research. Just because the mother or parents approve of it, doesn’t mean that it is ethical to give up a living being to scientific research. They believe that it should be up to that actual person, and since they cannot decide for themselves, they should not be used in the research. Overall, there are many reasons in which people oppose fetal tissue research. The main controversies include abortion, tax money, religion, and cloning. Many people believe that the use of human cells in which that human had no choice …show more content…
People who believe that fetal tissue research is a great opportunity to broaden our knowledge of the human species, feel that researchers should utilize the aborted fetuses for this scientific research. Women are going to abort their babies, as long as it is legal, regardless of anyone else’s opinion. People who are advocates of fetal tissue research believe that these fetuses ought to be used for the advancement of our scientific knowledge instead of being disposed of in another way. Even though many people disagree with abortion, the opposition is that we can utilize these aborted fetuses for us to further our education since they are going to be aborted regardless. Fetal tissue research can be used to help us to better understand birth defects. Researchers can use fetal tissues to compare them with the tissues of fetuses with a birth defect. This can allow us to research the differences between them, which may help us to understand how birth defects occur and how they develop. If we are able to discover how certain birth defects occur, we can possibly discover a way to prevent them from occurring or reverse them by finding a cure. By utilizing fetal tissues, we may be able to save many other babies from suffering from various birth

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Satisfactory Essays

    A second set of ethical problems involves clearly separating thera- peutic from reproductive cloning. Because the techniques involved with therapeutic cloning are the same techniques that would be involved in reproductive cloning, opponents of the latter might argue that no thera- peutic cloning should be permitted because it will inevitably lead to re- productive cloning. The fear is that once cloned human embryos are created in the laboratory, there will be no way to stop scientists or phy- sicians from acceding to a person's request to have the cloned embryos…

    • 102 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    The real controversy in stem cell research lays in the termination (abortion) of the embryo, which is an entirely independent debate altogether. The embryonic stem cells extracted for research are being derived from embryos that are being aborted regardless (Johansen). Therefore, there is a macrocosmic debate more powerful than the one about stem cell research itself. By harvesting these stem cells from babies predestined to abortion, at least a contribution is being made to society – one that can benefit a multitude of people, perhaps suffering from a multitude of conditions. Even if one wants to debate the ethics of stem cell research, the researchers are being ethically unethical, with regard to the abortions guaranteed to take place.…

    • 1044 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    There are quite a few arguments against fetal tissue transplants from a woman choosing to abort. Some have said that fetal tissue transplants are the same as organ donations. They most defiantly are NOT the same. This is basic common sense. One, the death of the fetus is a choice made for it by another person and two, there is no way for the fetus to give consent signing their life away, and third, if the fetus is considered “not human” it can’t be considered a donor.…

    • 513 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The embryonic cloning debate touches down ethical issues that are each debatable. One is the debate whether it is healthy and or ethical to obtain eggs from a woman for stem cells. It calls for hormone treatment and surgery. With all surgeries, there is always a risk, but with this one it’s an ethical debate if it is right or not. Another reason why is that people are afraid that we will fall down a slippery slope into human cloning or human organ harvesting.…

    • 570 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In 2009, President Barack Obama used an executive order to lift certain limitations on federal funding for embryonic stem cell research (“Embryos and Unintended Consequences”). In 1973, the United States legalized abortion with the landmark supreme court case Roe vs. Wade. According to The Michael J. Fox Foundation for Parkinson’s Research, stems cells are, “a renewable source of tissue that can be coaxed to become different cell types of the body.” Embryonic stem cells in particular are, “stem cells derived from embryos that develop from eggs that have been fertilized in vitro—in an in vitro fertilization clinic—and then donated for research purposes with informed consent of the donors” (Stem Cell Basics III). The conflict of what is considered “ethical” in regards to unborn human…

    • 1431 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    It is an age-old question. The pro-life versus pro-choice debate has been argued for many years now. The stem cell debate is a similar concept, but the biggest difference is in most states a fetus can be aborted until they are 20 weeks old (editors, shape.com)! Whereas, embryonic stem cells come from embryos 3-5 days old. A common misconception with embryonic stem cells is that the child is getting taken away from their mother. This is because embryonic stem cells come from leftover vitro fertilizations so the cells would have gone to waste but instead are gone to help other people. These fertilization centers often have extra frozen cells. Many consider not using these cells is a waste (cirm). An important aspect to note is the difference between a fetus and an embryo. An embryo is an organism from the moment of fertilization to the 8 week mark. Whereas a fetus is from 8 weeks to the moment of birth (O’brien).According to Theresa Ellefson, mother and biology teacher, “ although I think that the pros of embryonic stem cell research outweigh the cons, I am not the mother of the embryo, and if I was it might alter my opinion.” This is a common opinion with mothers because they know how many benefits can come from the cells but they also do not want to volunteer their eggs. Although embryonic stem cells are not directly taken away from mothers, they are still sensitive with giving up their…

    • 2096 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    When does life really start? At the point when, if at any time, is it ideal to end a pregnancy? These are a portion of the ethical situations that are confronted when managing the issue of fetus removal. Premature birth is the end of a pregnancy. There are a wide range of stands hung on the issue of premature birth. Some trust that premature birth is morally worthy up to a specific purpose of fetal advancement and that a few reasons are satisfactory.…

    • 551 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    To obtain embryonic stem cells, some researchers fertilize an egg and sperm cell in a laboratory; after having grown for a few days, they destroy the embryo to extract the stem cells from the center of the embryo. Essentially, this creates a potential human being and destroys it. Creating human life only to destroy it is morally wrong because “just as an infant is a human being in the infant stage,” “a human embryo is a human in the embryonic stage.” (Amandito) This is not just a collection of human cells, but a stage in a person's life, which every human was once at. “If an embryo will later become a human being, then it should be given the respect of a human being.” (Amandito) Moreover, some researchers take embryonic stem cells from aborted fetuses and use their dead bodies to extract stem cells. Though this is still a human embryo, it is much more complex than a fertilized embryo. “An early embryo that has still not yet been implanted into the uterus does not have the psychological, emotional, or physical properties [of a grown human]” (Embryonic Stem) However, with aborted fetuses, they all have these properties. The average week for an abortion is 12 weeks. At 12 weeks, the fetus can breathe, has a heartbeat, and has measurable brain waves. Furthermore, the human fetus has fingers, toes, a nose, and all its appendages, resembling an adult human.…

    • 1586 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    When most people think about a fetus, the first thing that comes to mind is innocence. Due to the views on a fetus, experimentation is not publically endorsed. People can be uninformed about fetal experimentation, which can lead to rumors of conspiracy revolving around the research. If people would take a step back and learn about fetal tissue exploration, then these fabrications would not longer take place. Just like anything within the research field, there are going to be pros and cons. The pros outweigh the cons, then the research should then be justified, even if it is on innocent fetal tissue. With this knowledge of tissues is rising, this causes many studies to show more potential cures for illnesses, with enormous potential, and gives…

    • 342 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Embryonic stem cells can potentially cause tumors due to the rapid growth when injected into adults. Another big issue with the research of the embryonic stem cells is that in the far future, this could lead to the knowledge on human cloning. Seeing as embryonic stem cells come from the embryos, adult stem cells biggest advantage is that the body’s own stem cells can be used, effectively removing the problems of immune rejection or abnormalities. Many people who are religious would argue that harvesting the embryo is against belief. This is a main controversy because these people believe that the four-five day old embryo has a soul and is evidently murdered when harvested. They believe that the research on these cells violates the sanctuary of life. Their argument is that the embryo in the situation is a potential human being and see the fertilized egg as starting a…

    • 558 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Ethics of Stem Cell Research

    • 2751 Words
    • 12 Pages

    Stem cell research represents a new opportunity for ethical thought and debate. Stem cells are primitive cells which have yet to specialize. Through proper coaxing, stem cells can be made to differentiate into usable body cells and eventually used for medical treatment. Though stem cell technology has been in development since the 1960’s, it was not until August of 2001, when then-president George W. Bush announced that federal funds could be allotted to embryonic stem cell research, that the issue became a hot political topic. The matter is argued with vehement fervor, but the quarrels are wrought with emotivism and partisanship more than actual valid and cogent arguments. In fact, stem cell research has a very broad range of ethical implications. The normative ethical theories, the abortion debate, and even business ethics all have a place in the discussion due to the different new moral challenges which are prompted by this blossoming technology.…

    • 2751 Words
    • 12 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Ethics and morals need to be considered when the destruction of one human life is acceptable so that another human may live. The first thing to differentiate is that it is ethical to experiment on human tissue, but those experiments on human beings are not ethical. Therefore, it is perfectly ethical to proceed with any and all types of stem cell research as long as human tissue is being used, but it is completely unethical to do embryonic stem cell research, which by its very nature necessitates the killing of a living human embryo to obtain that stem cell (Willke). Science has shown that embryos contain all the necessary parts to grow into a living, breathing human. To understand this we must first review early development biology. J. C. Willke writes:…

    • 1763 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    The 70's focused on research that involved fetuses in utero. The 80's shifted to research of transplantation of fetal tissue into adults with serious medical conditions such as diabetes, Parkinson's, and spinal cord injuries. The latest saga involves using cells from days-old "spare" embryos that are created in infertility treatment process and all are considered unethical and unmoral issues.…

    • 686 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Better Essays

    Arguing Fetal Tissue

    • 938 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Working in the medical field for the past 17 years I have dealt with patients with the diagnosis. Watching how they struggle and the frustration they face on a daily basis has to be exhausting for them. I feel that we are in great need of further research for many medical ailments and diseases. Questioning the use of fetal tissue definitely strikes a nerve for many. And it is such a sensitive subject which has a power house of backing much like that of the Catholic Church whose view is that a life begins at conception. Where others say it’s not a life before the third trimester. I myself do not condone the use of farming fetal tissue. I don’t see why we cannon have access to the fetal tissue which has been aborted. Why not use that tissue and gain from it all that we can. How much is it costing to dispose of such tissue? I can see where it can easily be regulated by the government and possibly save tax payer dollars in disposal fees. These are fetuses that are electively aborted. The number of elective abortions in this nation in 2011 was 1.06 million. How many experimental transplants could have taken place using this viable…

    • 938 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    From a scientist’s point of view, embryonic stem cells have a huge potential to revolutionize the field of regenerative medicine and tissue engineering as they hold the ability to produce all cell lineages including the germ line. This would provide the gateway for the treatment of a wide range of diseases where the body is incapable of repairing itself. However, some people especially religious communities hold strong objections regarding the use of human embryos in scientific research (De Wert, 2003) (Orive, 2003). The main point being that since “new life begins at the point of conception”, the embryo should hold full human rights (Daley, G.Q. et al., 2007). Nevertheless, there are different legislations in place in different countries regarding the use of human embryonic stem cells. In UK, embryonic stem cell research can only be carried out with authority from the Human Fertilisation and Embryology Authority…

    • 479 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays