Preview

Dualism In Ma Vice La Rose

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
515 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Dualism In Ma Vice La Rose
cording to Rene Descartes there is a dualism to an individual, the physical body and the mind, and while they may be connected they are separate to each other. The movie Ma vice la rose deals with the same issue of dualism between the mind and the body, only it is in one individual.The young French boy in the movie is confused about his identity, as he believes his mind does not match his body and believes himself to be a girl. While Descarte lived in a separate time when this situation of Transgender would certainly be taboo, I believe he would be sympathetic to the child and his dilemma. I believe Descarte would point out that the boy is two beings living in one form, while the body is one thing, the mind behaves in a contrary fashion

. Descarte believes in a perfect god, and Ludwig believes god made a mistake making him a boy. The Idea of a perfect being, a perfect god is one that Descarte held heavily in his writings, but can Ludwick be seen as a mistake by god ? Ludwig believes that he is indeed a mistake, that his behaviors and what he leans toward resembles that more of a girl than a boy. I believe that Descarte would
…show more content…
In his mind Ludwig believes himself to be a female, even though his body is that of a boy. There is little to no doubt throughout the movie by the kid that he believes he is a female, even when everyone else around him disagrees. This would have made an interesting observation to Descarte as his belief of duality would have existed solely on one child. I would believe that Descarte would have agreed with Ludwig that his mind does not have to match his body, and that his mental state of a female is more important that what he physically is.The separation of the physical and mental would have been enough to convince Descarte that there is two beings in humans, that the body is just a tool for the

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    I chose a rose as the symbol because the author used direct characterization to describe the princess as semi- savage. The rose represents this well, the rose is beautiful, delicate, and proud, but to do this it must be tended to. This is where the semi savage part comes in her father the king is full savage and this affected the princess, because she was savage though she was semi savage. The leaves and her design represent her semi savageness because she grows a bit differently than her father it represents her uniqueness. Another thing that represents her semi savageness are the thorns, she is beautiful but if you try to pick her up and she doesn't want to picked her thorns sting you, but here is the thing she can twist and leave her spot…

    • 346 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In the words of Jeffery , a third-one year old man “Sometimes I just want to be a person.I don’t want to be a gender,one way or another…I want to do what I want to do.And I want to doit how I want to.and with who I want to do it .and not have to worry that men don’t do this and men don’t do that.Women dnt this and women don’t do that…I don’t like that we as a society judge people based on what we assume they have under there clothing.”(Davis 97).For jefferyits simple he judt wants to live his life with no problems, with no socital monsters judging him.jeffery is a transsexual man and he feel it…

    • 1197 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Janice Raymond’s publication “Sappho by Surgery” misrepresents, misunderstands, and misinterprets what it means to be a transsexual person. The conclusions that Janice Raymond reaches are not based on concrete science, psychology, or sociology. It also is not based off of any real interactions with transgender people. Instead, it is based off of stories, second hand reports, media misrepresentations, and weakly strung together pieces of historical fact that have been manipulated to support the author’s thesis. The author argues that the gender binary can’t be denied. In other words, “biology defines gender” and so if you are born with male reproductive organs, you are a male, and if you are born with female reproductive organs, you are a female; this can’t change and gender reassignment surgery is unnatural and wrong (Page 131). This basic idea leads her to make all kinds of conclusions that are full of anti-transsexual prejudice. In the publication “Sappho by Surgery”, Raymond attacks the “transsexually constructed lesbian-feminist”. She uses this term to refer to someone who was born a man but had surgery to become a woman and identifies as a lesbian and a feminist. Raymond’s characterization of the transsexually constructed lesbian feminist as a malicious, deceptive rapist shows a flawed understanding of the biology, mental process, and social factors surrounding transsexual people.…

    • 1592 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    A person’s sex is determined by their physical aspects, whether they have a penis or a vagina, and by their chromosomes which they have at birth (Soc 1001 Lecture 22, The Social Construction of Gender). Sometimes, though, people may fall outside of the two “main” sexes and be born as an intersex person, then given the choice to identify as male, female or neither (Psy 3666 Human Sexuality Lecture 10, Sex Education and Sexual Orientation), but are typically assigned a sex at birth via surgery and/or hormonal intervention (Soc 1001 Lecture 22, The Social Construction of Gender). Not only do intersex individuals have the choice to identify themselves as they please, everyone has a choice as to what they want to be identified as no matter if a surgery had taken place or…

    • 1464 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    When infants are born, the first words uttered from the doctor is the sex of the child. As soon as the sex is announced, the baby is already perceived a certain way. By categorizing human beings into two different genders, male or female, you are limiting these people by gender roles and societal expectations. When doing this it causes harm to anyone who strays from their gender or sex assigned at birth. A term to describe these people is transgender. A transgender person is someone whose identity is not the same as their gender assigned at birth. Many other identifying people fall under this category.It is time to deconstruct society's views on gender and provide necessary rights to transgender individuals. Transgender people not being accepted into society is a significant problem in contemporary culture that challenges the traditional norms of the gender binary.…

    • 485 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The argument over nature vs. nurture has continued to torture society by presenting cases in which we simply don’t know which rules to apply. One of these cases is sex change. Sex change is a very big step to take in a person’s life and it involves the careful consideration of many factors; but it is not a simple answer to a complex problem such as hermaphroditism or even blotched circumcisions. These choices can be difficult because we don’t quite understand which factors to consider given that we haven’t determined whether it is nature or nurture that determines a child’s sexual identity. Until we solve this riddle, people…

    • 1136 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    William Shakespeare demonstrates the idea of everything having an opposing truth in his play Romeo and Juliet. Shakespeare’s play reveals that not everything is as it appears through its plot, the character’s language, and the events that take place. He demonstrates this with two literary devices; Duality and double entendre. The dualities in his play consist of love and hate, good and evil, and light and dark.…

    • 949 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Better Essays

    Dualism is the belief that reality consists of two different, separate substances: that of the mental and that of the physical. "In philosophy of mind, the belief that the mental and physical are deeply different in kind: thus the mental is at least not identical with the physical." It directly opposes materialism, as dualism dictates that the mind is unidentifiable to the body, as opposed to stating that the mind and body exist as one. The concept of dualism is not only fundamental in philosophy, but also affects our thoughts on science, religion and psychology: for example, if a convincing rejection of dualism can be formulated, the materialist approach of modern science will be vindicated. If, conversely, dualism can be convincingly maintained, then our evidence obtained from studies of the brain would simply not suffice in gaining any form of insight into the human mind. Dualism is a logical necessity: sustained as a question that does not need to be answered as it can be fulfilled a priori, owing to the fact that humans have the ability to seek introspection regularly. Indeed, we experience the separation between our body and mind, which would support the notion that they are separate entities and empirical evidence is not required to prove such a concept. However, this does not mean that dualistic theory is foolproof: for example, can our experience be enough to prove such a concept? Indeed, many philosophers are not in favour of dualistic ontology. In the course of addressing this question, the origins of the mind and body problem will be discussed, which will then permit a fully focussed evaluation of the strengths and weaknesses of Cartesian Interactionist Dualism. Whilst looking at the support for Descartes' theory I will explore arguments from Madell, David Chalmers and T.H Huxley amongst others. Conversely, whilst addressing the criticism of Interactionist Dualism, I will explore the works of Ryle, Hume and Williams. Finally, the wider implications that…

    • 4596 Words
    • 13 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    As Nature Made Him

    • 3020 Words
    • 13 Pages

    Ronna Pearson Sociology 3337-70 July 12, 2012 As Nature Made Him The boy who was raised as a girl John Colapinto In 1967, after a baby boy -- one of a set of identical twins -- suffered a botched circumcision, a radical treatment option was agreed to by his desperate and grieving family. Encouraged by renowned medical psychologist Dr. John Money, an expert in the field of gender identity and sexual reassignment, the anonymous child was surgically altered to live life as a girl. The case would prove to be precedent-setting, becoming "proof" for the feminist movement that gender gap was purely a result of cultural conditioning. But all was not as it seemed. Initially proclaimed a resounding success, the devastating psychological cost of the procedure has only recently become known. Now living as an adult male, married and with a family of his own, this patient has granted John Colapinto unprecedented access to his story. As Nature Made Him is at once a fascinating exploration of the elusive nature of sexual identity and an examination of the ever-intensifying struggle between what medical science can do and what doctors should do. It is also a story of courage and survival that sheds light on the murkiest areas human sexuality. (Amazon.com)…

    • 3020 Words
    • 13 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Official Doctrine: This part deals with the human body and mind, how they are interconnected but still different at the same time. He displays the physical human body to be a public affair and something that all in this world can visually see; the mind however, is a much more private and personal affair. With this belief, humans can have two parts: mind (private) and body (public), these parts play different roles as one can affect the other or completely disguise the other. Ryle states that Descartes may have uncertainties about episodes in the physical world, but does not have any uncertainties when analyzing the state of his mind. For example, say Bob’s mind is expressed, no one but Bob will be able to respond to these expressions (feelings). Changes in both of the worlds can affect one another through the physical and intellectual (mind) aspects and challenges that one may face in their lifetime.…

    • 516 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    According to Dara Hoffman (2013), who has worked with transgender children, teens, adults, and the elderly, the common thing about transgender awareness is that it comes at a very young age. “There’s just an innate sense of gender, even before they know that boys do this stuff or girls do this stuff’ (p.1). Kevin Everhart, PhD (2013), is a clinical psychologist and early childhood specialist. He explains of transgender children that they have “an unshakable conviction and a knowledge that they are the sex they believe they are. (p.2).…

    • 504 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Transgenderism In Canada

    • 1205 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Transgenderism have a goal, that goal is to be happy in their skin no matter who says so. In today’s age transgender has been appearing a lot more. Welch (2011) definition of transgender is “an umbrella term, refers to people who feel that their biologically assigned gender is a false or incomplete description of themselves” (pg.53). Transgender is one of the leading outcomes of suicide. It is a worldwide problem and it has been show with research; however in Canada the rates are higher. This is shown throughout the youth populations in Canada. Today’s outcome of what transgender really is can lead to different speculations of what is right or wrong. Transgenderism can lead to many different thoughts and many different opinions. The purpose…

    • 1205 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Descartes makes us doubt everything through his new revolutionary thought process. He claims that the mind is separate from the body, and even if there is a body at all. By doubting the reality of a physical world he brings into question everything that exists except for the individual existing itself.…

    • 732 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Gender and Sex Worksheet

    • 501 Words
    • 3 Pages

    What is gender? Gender is the state of being a man or a woman (male, female or intersex), it does not matter what an individual looks like on the outside. Our gender identity is our inner most feelings about sex and gender. We define masculinity and femininity because of our culture even our background. Gender is a social way of life, could be measured by activities that our society deems to be appropriate for women and men. A simple test is how a person could see themselves to be, who they really are? (Gender/ Social, Femininity and Masculine) What is sex in biological terms? Our sex refers to the biological, social and legal status. It is common to get the two mixed up- distinction rather than definition; distinguished by the other; gender and sex that is, sex is biological in a physical term. (Male/Female –Sex- Biological).Are gender and sex the same thing? Gender and sex are not the same; they can often be used one in the same. Explain why or why not? Let’s look at a transgender have a gender identity that at times becomes a conflict for example; an individual who is not in black and white, not a standard of course on our society or community outlook. A certain way a man and women should conduct themselves but find themselves trapped because of it, born female or male at birth but do not feel like it inside, they may feel they do not fit in or belong to either, biological sex between men and women. How do gender and sex contribute to the concepts and constructions of masculinity and femininity? According to the plan Parenthood Federation of Culture in America Inc (2013) Culture determines gender? What it means to be man or woman in regards to femininity or masculinity. Gender and sex does not help with the making of masculinity or femininity but our culture can play a significant role. Do our concepts of gender and sex contribute to the way we embrace gender and sex in…

    • 501 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    If there is incongruity between someone's birth gender and their identified gender it can feel as if they do not belong their body. The following passage from the autobiography Lili describes how this feels, “I am like one who only owns the facade of his house. The mirror in front of him showed him the facade. It was the unblemished body of a man” (Lili). This quote shows how Andreas feels out of place in his body. “I informed an independent opinion, to the effect that I was both a man and a woman in one body and that the woman in this body was in the process of gaining the upperhand” (Lili) is another quote from the autobiography that describes Andreas’ internal struggle. He felt as though there were two humans inside his body and Lili was…

    • 273 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays