Emma and Clueless, are two movies that illustrate Jane Austen's novel entitled "Emma". The stories illustrate the importance of self-development and personal growth by using the theme of social status and moral worth. The protagonists, Emma and Cher, are bound to transform from callow young adults to mentally and emotionally mature women, given their similar situations.
The major difference between Emma and Clueless is the way situations in the plot of the story are illustrated, and the different time frames used in the context. The setting of Emma is in nineteenth century England, while Clueless sets in Beverly Hills, U.S.A. in the 1990s.
Both Emma and Cher are young ladies of the rich, high-class society and cultural elite. Money is important for both societies, because money is synonymous to power and high social status. Because of their wealth, the protagonists are spoiled, and they encompass a sense of vanity, arrogance, and social superiority. Emma and Cher are supposedly the "epitome of perfection" of their time frame and setting. Emma appears to encompass the beauty, charm, grace, intelligence, and wealth of an ideal woman in nineteenth century England, and Cher has everything a teenage girl could possibly want: a car, a mansion, and an endless line of expensive clothing. And with all their wealth, they have acquired the idea that they are superior to others. Emma's arrogance is first seen when she brags about her skill in matching couples. Likewise, Cher exposes a sense of her pompousness when she and her best friend, Dionne, teach Tai how to be popular.
Emma and Cher's arrogance and self-confidence has challenged them to do things beyond the norm. They have taken two lower-class girls- Harriet and Tai- "under their wing" to assimilate with the upper-class society. Emma thinks that Harriet has been associated with "unworthy" people, and embarks on a mission to introduce her to the upper-class society. In Clueless, Cher takes pity on Tai and embarks on a mission to make Tai popular. In the process, Emma and Cher tried to match Harriet and Tai to men they considered of upper-class status. However, Harriet and Tai seemed to have been interested in men of lower class- Robert and Travis. Emma disregarded Robert Martin because he was a farmer who posed a threat in her mission to improve Harriet. Likewise, Cher disregarded Travis because he was a skater boy, which was considered of lower social status in high school. Emma and Cher forced Harriet and Tai to rethink their initial judgment of the two lower-class men. Harriet and Tai, naïve as they are, were brainwashed by the protagonists, and have eventually developed a certain fondness for the upper-class men who they were being linked to. However, the guys that Emma and Cher tried to match Harriet and Tai with, were actually in love with the two protagonists.
The stories take a new direction with the arrival of the characters Frank Churchill from Emma and Christian from Clueless. Emma and Cher instantly become infatuated with Frank and Christian. But nothing would come of this infatuation because Frank Churchill is found out to be engaged with another woman, and Christian is a homosexual. It is a humbling experience for the two protagonists because they have further realized that they can make wrong judgments about other people.
The characters of Mr. Knightly in Emma and Josh from Clueless, have been seen throughout the movie, but only towards the end, did they come to the foreground of the story. Mr. Knightly and Josh became the object of Harriet and Tai's latest infatuation. Through jealously, Emma and Cher begin to realize their love for Mr. Knightly and Josh, and the two men have also realized their love for Emma and Cher.
In the end, Mr. Knightly and Emma were married, and Josh and Cher became a couple. With Emma and Cher, being a little more open-minded about social issues, Harriet and Robert Martin reestablished their wandered love, and it was likewise for Travis and Tai.
You May Also Find These Documents Helpful
-
Analyse the ways in which a comparative study of Emma and Clueless invites reflections on the role of class within society…
- 668 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
Throughout Clueless, it was simple to detect the similarities between the characters of those in the novel Emma. Cher Horowitz, the main character in Clueless, lives in the wealthy city of Beverly Hills in the United States. Emma Woodhouse, the main character in Emma lives in the more expensive side of town called Highbury in England. Because Cher and Emma both grew up in a wealthy environment, they often view themselves as well liked, posh, and classy. They both have strong, loving relationships with their fathers, and due to their excessive amount of money, the girls became spoiled.…
- 357 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
Clueless, an adaptation of Jane Austen 's 1815 novel, Emma, is a 1995 American film by director, Amy Heckerling. The comedy serves as a 20th century update of the original text that shifts into creating a contemporary Emma, one for our own era. Though Clueless seems to set forth on building its reputation on a completely new, distinct ground, it is not an entirely different work of art. Considerable amounts of uniformities between the adaptation and Emma can be pinpointed throughout. As “Clueless is most faithful to Emma in its recreation of the plot involving Mr. Elton, Harriet Smith, and Emma” (Troost, Linda, and Greenfield 124), several parallels between the two distinctive texts, concerning this matter, can be recognized. One outstanding example is the correspondence and connection between the modern photography scene in Clueless and the sketching/painting of Harriet’s portrait in Emma. Hence, along with the novel’s highly persuasive guidance and the two’s so-called loose relation, various similarities as well as differences are inevitably present.…
- 1912 Words
- 8 Pages
Powerful Essays -
Parallels are drawn between the values and attitudes of post-modern and regency society in Emma 's carriage incident and Clueless ' car scene. In Emma, Mr Elton displays complete disgust and outrage at the notion of marrying the socially inferior Harriet, exclaiming 'Good heaven! What can be the meaning of this? ' This segregation and incompatibility of differing social classes is also portrayed in Clueless through Elton 's outburst of 'Don 't you even know who my father is? ' revealing the transcending importance of family background and social connections, and the superficiality within both societies.…
- 406 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
Cher and Emma come from wealthy families. Cher’s father is a lawyer and receives $500 and hour to “fight with people”. Also she lives in a family mansion with big columns that date “to 1972!” Emma’s father is wealthy and lives in a large house, setting her apart from others in Highbury. She inherits her father’s money because she is the landed gentry. Emma has a large dowry making Mr Elton interested in her. When Emma was written the industrial revolution was under way. Families started to earn their fortune through trade. Emma isn’t sure how to react to this. This is a case of inherited wealth versus ‘new’ wealth. In both Emma and Clueless, money and wealth are status deciders. In Emma, having a substantial wealth often meant the entry into good society. You were able to host dinner parties and balls with the wealth that you had. In Clueless, there are many cases of irony throughout the film. In the very first scene, Cher says that she has a “way normal life for a teenage girl” and then goes to her computer to choose her outfit from her revolving…
- 704 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
Heckerling uses voice overs to tell the audience Cher’s thoughts and the challenges that she faces in life. This is different to Emma, as Austin uses an omniscient narrator, which explains all of the different character’s thoughts. The voice over creates a bias as Cher is the only character who is allowed to speak directly to the audience. Heckerling uses this bias to allow viewers to have an insight into a stereo typical teenage girl’s life. “I feel like such a heifer. I had two bowls of Special K, 3 pieces of turkey bacon, a handful of popcorn, 5 peanut butter M&M's and like 3 pieces of licorice.” This differs from Emma as we do not see directly into Emma’s thoughts but they are instead relayed to us by the narrator. By using the voice overs Heckerling is able to show Cher’s motives. Some of the motives behind what Emma does are overlooked by Austin as Emma herself does not get to speak to the audience. “If a woman doubts as to whether she should accept a man or not, she certainly ought to…
- 1054 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays -
Both the main characters, Emma, and Cher, have one major thing in common: money. Emma’s family lives in a huge estate, Hartfield…
- 1174 Words
- 5 Pages
Better Essays -
In “Emma”, the use of the rhetorical question “Could it be?” suggests the character’s sudden realization and perception. Additionally, ot ex[resses “Emma’s” concern and anxiety towards Knightley when she feared that he might be interested in Harriet. This however, is equivalent in contrasting with “Clueless” as the epiphany is portrayed through the “Fountain” scene in relations with “bright lights” and “trumpet fanfare”. Utilizing this hyperbole technique symbolizes Cher’s moment of recognition when she realizes her feelings for Josh. She articulates this through the voiceover “I love Josh”, drawing the audience’s attention. This intrinsic viewpoint of film presentation enables viewers in modern society to grasp the theme transformed from Jane Austen’s novel…
- 1083 Words
- 5 Pages
Better Essays -
reader to reflect on Emma’s behaviour as a reflection of the context of her society and the value put on social hierarchy and status. The opening scene of Amy Heckerling's film, Clueless, made in the 1990’s, immediately adopts Austen's ironic tone. The energetic montage and quick succession of camera angles of Cher and her fellow teenagers indulging in luxurious activities in…
- 847 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
Qualities of relationships have transformed through time along with values, the parallel worlds within postmodern Beverly Hills and Regency England display the contextual shifts brought forth. The bildungsroman novel Emma by Jane Austen exemplifies the strict values within Regency England society whilst Amy Heckerling’s film Clueless illustrates the transformation of these values within Beverly Hills. The values of social status and pride and vanity are explored through the inflexible Regency England society in comparison to the more fluid postmodern society of Beverly Hills. The use of various language and film techniques enhances the observation of the parallel values displayed within both contexts.…
- 1033 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays -
"The real evils indeed of Emma's situation were the power of rather having too much her own way, and a disposition to think a little too well of herself; [ ]." This arrogance can be seen by her matchmaking attempts. It was Emma who set up the marriage between her governess Ms. Taylor and Mr. Weston. The corresponding characters in the movie Clueless are two teachers of Cher Mr. Hall and Ms. Geist. The sequence of events, however, does not correspond to the novel. Mr. Hall and Ms. Geist only marry at the end of the…
- 1333 Words
- 6 Pages
Powerful Essays -
Social structure is seen in both “Emma” and “Clueless” and the concept is maintained throughout both of the texts. Social structure is able to influence Emma’s perception of her surroundings and matchmaking skills. Cher’s amount of knowledge and actions towards the school cliques is also influenced by the concept of social structure. “Emma” and “Clueless” both explore female gender roles in their appropriate context, highlighting the limited power and control of women in patriarchal societies. The theme of roles of women is demonstrated through the numerous women figures that help structure both “Emma” and “clueless” and the impact they have on both their perceptions and their self-awareness. Heckerling’s upholding of the themes that were originally depicted in ‘Emma’ that were transformed into ‘Clueless’ demonstrates the existence and acceptance of these notions in both contexts. Ultimately, ‘Emma’ is transformed into ‘Clueless’ by using examples and techniques in order to display these comparative…
- 1921 Words
- 8 Pages
Better Essays -
The main characters, Emma and Cher are representational products of their society and parallels can be drawn in the opening scenes, particularly in relation to self-knowledge. The Bildungsroman progression from delusion to social awareness is a universal value in both texts despite their differing contexts. Emma is introduced as “handsome, clever, and rich” who had “a disposition to think a little too well of herself.” Austen’s satirical tone as the omniscient narrator alerts the responder to Emma’s inability to understand her position in society. Furthermore, while Emma successfully matches Mr. Weston and Ms. Taylor, her motives are superficial as she sees it as “the greatest amusement in the world!” She also believes Harriet’s beauty “should not be wasted on the inferior society”, and it would be “interesting and highly becoming” to “improve her”. Austen employs verbal irony through Emma’s dialogue, which exposes her flaws of arrogance and shallowness. However, Emma eventually develops self awareness as shown when she realizes her mistake of matching Harriet with Mr. Elton and influencing her to refuse a suitable marriage with Mr. Martin.…
- 1106 Words
- 5 Pages
Better Essays -
The actions of Emma lead to the emotional pain that Harriet went though. She gave a poem to her from Mr. Elton, convincing herself and Harriet that it was a marriage proposal.(88) When Emma broke the new of Mr. Eltons true love to her, she was heartbroken. Harriet later got over the pain and found a new love. She confessed to Emma her love for Mr. Knightly.(471) Unfortunately for Harriet, Emma also loves Mr. Knightly. This is a dangerous situation for Emma because she does not want to hurt Harriet anymore than what she already had. Emma took the risk and told Harriet the truth of her heart. Again, Harriet’s emotions were hurt. (480)…
- 685 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
Additionally, Emma enters college in Southern California and meets other African Americans she soon discovers that her skin color makes her unpopular. The men on campus identify her as “Hottentot” meaning a young woman who had pronounced African features. Likewise, she is rejected by society because her skin is not light enough. She moved to Harlem after college and there she seeks a new identity as a teacher. Emma Lou tries to make her skin lighter, and it didn’t succeed it made her look worst even when she appeals excessive make up on her face. She gets into a relationship with a guy named Filipino Mulatto. At first, everything was going well then it became an abusive relationship. In the end, she accepts herself as who she is and how she looked…
- 337 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays