English 10 Honors
June 8th, 2012
Is Cyrano de Bergerac a tragic hero? Well, does he have any of Aristotle’s six characteristics? Aristotle’s characteristics consist of having a high social status, being imperfect, that the person’s downfall is his own fault, that his misfortune isn’t wholly deserved, the fall is not pure loss, and the tragedy doesn’t leave the audience in a state of depression (English 10 Honors Class Notes). What does Cyrano de Bergerac have in common with Don Quixote? Also, what do Cyrano de Bergerac and Don Quixote have in common with the song, “The Impossible Dream”. The characteristics are clear, but do Cyrano and Don Quixote meet the requirements, and do they live their life as an impossible dream?
The first requirement of being a tragic hero is having a high social status. Cyrano does in fact have a high social status. He has respect and fear among his fellow play goers. Ragueneau says, “Sir, have you seen Monsieur de Cyrano?” (Cyrano de Bergerac 15) Which infers that he is popular among his peers. His friends and also speak very high of him. As in fact, while Ragueneau is talking to Ligniere, he states highly of him:
“Marry, 'twould puzzle even our grim painter Philippe de Cham-
paigne to portray him! Methinks, whimsical, wild, comical as he
is, only Jacques Callot, now dead and gone, had succeeded
better, and had made of him the maddest fighter of all his vi
sored crew -- with his triple-plumed beaver and six-pointed
doublet -- the sword-point sticking up 'neath his mantle like an
insolent cocktail! He's prouder than all the fierce Artabans of
whom Gascony has ever been and will ever be the prolific
Alma Mater! Above his Toby ruff he carries a nose! -- ah, good
my lords, what a nose is his! When one sees it one is fain to cry
aloud, 'Nay! 'tis too much! He plays a joke on us!' Then one
laughs, says 'He will anon take it off.' But no! -- Monsieur de
Bergerac always keeps it on. (Cyrano de Bergerac 19-20)
Another characteristic that the hero must have, is that he must be imperfect. Cyrano is indeed physically unattractive. In Act 1, he teaches the Viscount how to joke on his nose.
Ah no! young blade! That was a trifle short! You might have said
at least a hundred things By varying the tone. . .like this, sup
pose,. . . Aggressive: 'Sir, if I had such a nose I'd amputate it!'
Friendly: 'When you sup It must annoy you, dipping in your cup;
You need a drinking-bowl of special shape!' Descriptive: ''Tis a
rock!. . .a peak!. . .a cape! -- A cape, forsooth! 'Tis a peninsular!'
Curious: 'How serves that oblong capsular? For scissor-
sheath? Or pot to hold your ink?' Gracious: 'You love the little
birds, I think? I see you've managed with a fond research To
find their tiny claws a roomy perch!' Truculent: 'When you
smoke your pipe. . .suppose That the tobacco-smoke spouts
from your nose -- Do not the neighbors, as the fumes rise high
er, Cry terror-struck: "The chimney is afire"?' Considerate: 'Take
care,. . .your head bowed low By such a weight. . .lest head o'er
heels you go!' Tender: 'Pray get a small umbrella made, Lest its
bright color in the sun should fade!' Pedantic: 'That beast Aristo
phanes Names Hippocamelelephantoles Must have possessed
just such a solid lump Of flesh and bone, beneath his forehead'
s bump!' Cavalier: 'The last fashion, friend, that hook? To hang
your hat on? 'Tis a useful crook!' Emphatic: 'No wind, O majest-
ic nose, Can give THEE cold! -- save when the mistral blows!'
Dramatic: 'When it bleeds, what a Red Sea!' Admiring: 'Sign for
a perfumery!' Lyric: 'Is this a conch?. . .a Triton you?' Simple:
'When is the monument on view?' Rustic: 'That thing a nose?
Marry-come-up! 'Tis a dwarf pumpkin, or a prize turnip!' Military:
'Point against cavalry!' Practical: 'Put it in a lottery! Assuredly
'twould be the biggest prize!' Or. . .parodying Pyramus' sighs. . ....
Cited: Dorian, Joe. “The Impossible Dream” Man of La Mancha, 1972
Please join StudyMode to read the full document