Preview

Comparing Maria Thins And Griet In Girl With A Pearl Earring

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
620 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Comparing Maria Thins And Griet In Girl With A Pearl Earring
In the novel, "Girl With a Pearl Earring," by Tracy Chevalier, Maria Thins and Griet have an interesting sort of relationship. At first, Maria Thins' view of Griet is on the verge of cruel and very criticizing. But that opinion that she has of Griet changes for the positive. Griet, on the other hand, fears and looks up to Maria. She feels that Maria has some qualities of a role model. But she also knows that she does not want to be exactly like her. These qualities are what make their relationship extremely complex.

Maria's thoughts of Griet at the start of the book were very harsh. She felt that Griet was just another insignificant maid that she and her family could push and order around. Maria Thins degraded her once when she was showing
…show more content…
But she often is confused about how she truly feels about her. Sometimes Maria would make her feel ashamed about a decision she made once she found out about it. But she was also kind to Griet. For example, she kept one of Griet's biggest secrets, assisting Vermeer with his paintings by grinding the paint. She also knows that Griet is posing for one of those paintings, something that Catharina, Vermeer's wife, could never know about. "You help him to paint faster, girl," she (Maria Thins) said in a low voice, "and you'll keep your place here. Not a word to my daughter or Tanneke, now." (page 110) Griet learns that for the most part, Maria Thins is a trustworthy person that can keep a secret if it is for the greater good.

In the beginning, Maria Thins is suspicious of Griet. Griet, on the other hand, is wary of Maria. They are both very aware of one another and both seem to have trust issues. Maria is always keeping a sharp eye out for trouble. Griet is quite intent on not making a mistake, especially in front of Maria; she is unsure of the consequences that may end up resulting from her actions. But they both learn to trust one another after getting to know the other's ways. Griet trusts that Maria will not give away her secrets. Maria knows that she can trust Griet to do her job and that she will do it properly as

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Better Essays

    One could argue that the love Maria is shown to feel for Sir Toby could cause her sudden rebellion, but her actions as a mother figure and how she is continuously being separated from Sir Toby and Sir Andrew even when Maria is added into scenes she was not originally present for conflict with this statement because Maria is put into a serving position that could explain her actions instead of love. After walking around with Malvolio, Maria has to go outside to collect a drunk Sir Toby, and when they re-enter the home, they are meet by Sir Andrew. Sir Toby quickly moves up the stairs to be with Sir Andrew while Maria stays on the landing looking up at the two. This disconnects the three who will later plot together against Malvolio. Maria is…

    • 1900 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Now there’s a story worth writing …” I could see all the drama and conflict in the look on her face. Vermeer had done my work for me.”…

    • 988 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In George Sand’s Marianne, Sand uses her development of the three primary characters to bring together two unlikely soul mates, and at the same time separate the two most likely paired of the three figures. Her primary characters, Marianne, Pierre, and Philippe, and their make-up play an intricate role in the story. More than just playing a key role though, their make-up leads the story in a direction that is propelled by the unique personalities each hold. The drive that each strong personality contributes to Sand’s Marianne, and their unique temperaments, brings the reader into a different sort of love story as opposed to what would be expected of a typical love story. Sand, with her characters, leads the story to a place where however unlikely it winds up, it couldn’t possibly have ended any other way than it does.…

    • 958 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Analysis Of Mrs. Larsen

    • 1032 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Mrs. Larsen is a relatable character on many levels. She was just a maid in the book and the main caretaker to Ralph. In fact, she was the first one to suspect Catherine. In a short paragraph, “ Mrs.Larsen had grown to hatte her, knowing somehow that Catherine was the cause of whatever was killing Truitt, that she was killing him because Emilia had tried to kill him” (Goolrick 222). Emilia, Ralphs dead, cheating wife, tried to kill him as well. Mrs. Larsen is protective over Ralph, not trusting a soul. I can connect with this because I have suspected my grandma of lying to me about my estranged father. Mrs. Larsen never found out if Catehrine was the cause, however, I did. I can relate to the kind of anger that surged through Mrs. Larsen.…

    • 1032 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    2. Michele and Maria seem to have a love/hate relationship. Around his friends Michele tries to act tough and look like he doesn’t care for his sisters but deep down he truly does care for her and her wellbeing. Maria looks up to her older brother Michele and just wants to do everything he does on a day-to-day basis.…

    • 2169 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    He feels guilt, sorrow, and confusion with the situation. During work one day, Tom begins to think of Maria. “Maria. Somehow the very name sounded heartbreakingly lonely and forlorn. He felt as though he had been awakened suddenly in the night by the distant echo of a cry for help” (Wilson 216). At this point, Tom begins to weigh his options and starts to realize that he must muster up enough confidence to reveal the truth to Betsy. For he knows that if he does he can return to the life he had before the war with no worries or problems. He can finally find contentment in his life again and live up to his role as a good father and husband. Although the confession leads to Betsy becoming angry and confused, Tom feels a sense of relief. He says, “I know things haven’t been good since the war, I think they’re going to be better” (Wilson 267). After some time to think Betsy states, “I realized for the first time what you went through in the war, and what different worlds we’ve been living in ever since. I’m sorry I acted like a child” (Wilson 271). Here Betsy accepts Toms betrayal and agrees to send money to Maria and her son. For the first time ever she puts someone else before herself, representing the feminine mother figure. With all secrets and worries out of the way, Tom and Betsy regain control over their lives once again. By earning Betsy’s understanding and support, Tom becomes self-directed and begins to live his role for family and…

    • 1513 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Amy Tanneke's Jealousy

    • 253 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Due to my life experiences I was able to view Tanneke as the bitter person Griet described. Throughout the novel there's a constant sense of jealousy between Griet and Tanneke. We see that when Griet first arrives at the Vermeer’s house she wants to get along with Tanneke, the other maid in the house. However, Tanneke's rude and adverse attitude along with her need for superiority over Griet, continuously puts her in an uncomfortable and vulnerable situation preventing them from becoming friends. The hatred was sparked when Griet was receiving attention from Van Ruijven and the master which made her jealous that people liked Griet more than her. This further caused Tanneke to retaliate in childish acts of revenge. In regards to this Tanneke's…

    • 253 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    In the novel “The Great Gatsby” written by F. Scott Fitzgerald, Daisy is described ieaders in various ways. In the beginning of the story Daisy is described “by far the most popular of all the young girls in Louisville”. This quote described by Fitzgerald tells the reader that Daisy holds a degree that she has immense beauty which has blinded many men. It means that she holds the popularity status because of the beauty she has. She is also described as “ a beautiful little fool.” This also indicates that Daisy is simply just beautiful just like an angel pure and white. And in which white could also means lack of morality.…

    • 595 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Throughout the story, she undergoes a series of trials put forth by her husband, known as the marquis Walter, in order to test her dedication in the marriage. The marquis goes as far as to take her first born child from her, to which Griselda responses with the persistent devotion she always bequeathed to him. As Griselda consistently demonstrates these behaviors, Walter becomes more inclined to assess her wifehood, later speaking of marrying a younger wife. Griselda agrees favorably to this proposal by her husband. However, she proceeds to kindly advise Walter on the treatment of this new bride: “One thing I beg of you, and warn you too, / Never to goad her, never put on trial / This tender girl as I have known you do; / For she was fostered preciously, a vial” (Chaucer 350). Griselda acknowledges her own strength in maintaining a supportive persona to her husband’s horrid deeds, and seeks to protect the new wife by merely asking Walter to be cautious of the delicate temperament most women were expected to possess. The marquis finds Griselda to be wholeheartedly pure in her intentions, announcing her to be the epitome of wifehood. The Clerk’s insight on the institution of marriage is described through Griselda’s persistence: “For since a woman showed such patience to / A mortal man, how much the more we ought / To take in…

    • 1530 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    My first hypothesis is that Maria is creating a triangle. Maria has a close relationship with her mother; she views her mother as her only friend at times. Maria and Paul’s relationship is strained and creating frustrations between the two of them. Since Maria is close to her mother and experiencing challenges in her relationship with Paul, she feels comfortable with her mother and they spend a great deal of time together, she confides intimate details of her relationship with Paul to her mother. By continuously involving her mother in her relationship with Paul, Maria is creating a triangle between the three individuals. Rather than addressing the issues between Paul and herself, Maria is seeking out her mother as third party to the issues.…

    • 387 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In the novel “Girl with a Pearl Earring” by Tracy Chevalier, the limitation of women of 17th century Holland was portrayed by the female protagonist Griet and how she is manipulated as a maid by all adults in her life, which means they place Griet in difficult situations and take advantages of her innocence, her feelings and love with their power and influences on her life to benefit themselves. She is put in the lowliest position which enables some other adults to abuse her, that is, they misuse their position of authorities as well as social rank, leaving her vulnerable and open to accusations as well as sexual assault. However, she managed to maintain her strong characters and show the effort to make positive choices about the future by leaving the Vermeer house and marrying Pieter.…

    • 1121 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    A Simple Heart

    • 290 Words
    • 2 Pages

    She loves Madame Aubain’s two children, Paul and Virginia, courageously saving them from an angry bull. She accidentally discovers a lost sister whose family she helps from her tiny income and whose son, Victor, becomes a favorite. Victor and Virginia both die young. Felicite’s grief at their loss is as great as Madame Aubain’s for her daughter. The two women first express simple affection for each other when they one day go through Virginia’s long-kept clothing.…

    • 290 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Compassion In Macbeth

    • 214 Words
    • 1 Page

    She show no compassion for him, insulting and treating him with the superiority of intelligence and firmness. “As she cannot attain her aim but by her husband’s assistance, she treats him with kindness; but as soon as she has gained her end and led her noble-minded husband to guilt and crime, and implicated him so deeply by her demoniac instigations that retreat has become impossible: she insults him and shows no compassion for his unfortunate condition, of which she has been the real cause.” (Pfundheller 2 )…

    • 214 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Status is a position that a person holds in a given social group or organization to which are attached certain rights, duties, and obligations (SOCI 1010H, 2014/15, Class 8/9). Maria’s ascribed status, which is assigned at birth, is female-Metis, which makes her in a visible minority group. During her life, Maria realizes she is a mother once her mother passed away leaving her to care for her younger sibling and later for her own children. Her other role is being a daughter, which pushes her to go back home and meet her father and grandma after leaving her family for many year; this is Maria’s achieved status. Maria had a hard time coping with her roles and developed role strain, which is when competing demands are built into one single role causing tension and stress. This caused Maria to abandon both roles completely and start back to her role as a single metis woman; this is when she found her second husband. Realizing her achieved status, she knows this is something she has a choice in and this concept allowed her to make the necessary changes needed for a better life for her children. Maria spoke with so much respect for her father, mother and grandma that it was surprising to read the scene where she had yelled at them for being poor and underprivileged. Interconnections with other patterns of inequality caused Maria to have a blur vision to who she was speaking to, as she was so dissatisfied with her current role in society. Maria, being the eldest had to endure first hand discrimination compared to her siblings whom she was able to prepare for. For example, she would save money for her younger sisters to buy better shoes and dresses whereas she had no one to do that for her. Social stratification is shown throughout the entire memoir with Maria wanting to marry outside her people as she had seen that her people only knew how to live in poverty. She…

    • 1758 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Another problem that she encountered was confronting her emotions especially with her feelings to the new man at the carpentry shop wherein during the interview and application for the job, Miss Mijares shows a bossy or arrogant kind of personality towards the guy, furthermore she was unwittingly drawn to the man especially during the time that both of them were stranded on an unknown street because of heavy rain and Miss Mijares driven by her feeling and emotions to the guy allowed herself to the invitation of the man.…

    • 296 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays