Preview

Comparing Laura And Lizzie

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
615 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Comparing Laura And Lizzie
In following the initial guise of children’s literature, Laura and Lizzie are presented as foils to each other within the poem. Both sisters are described as having “golden” hair and portraying themselves as the typical virtuous female of the time (Rossetti Line 184). Additionally, their lack of physical description also suggests the possibility of them being twin sisters. Which is why the important factor in distinguishing between the two relies on their personalities. Laura is a “curious” individual who is easily tempted by the goblin’s voices and fruits to disregard the warning of Jeanie’s tale (Line 69). On the other hand, her sister Lizzie is the cautious one of the two, running away, while closing her eyes and ears, from the goblin men and the one telling Jeanie’s story. …show more content…
Fitting in with the fairy tale conventions, the naughty character is punished for going pass their boundaries, in other words her curiosity, while the nice character saves her. Or as Clayton Carlyle Tarr states in “Covent Goblin Market”, “Laura’s binge on goblin fruit leaves her poisoned, and only heroic Lizzie’s corporeal sacrifice can save her” (Tarr 307). Notably, Lizzie is regarded as the heroine of the story while Laura is depicted as the fallen woman, victim or even damsel in distress, who needs to be saved for the sake of the plot. At the end of the poem, Laura proceeds to retell her story to her children, claiming “how her sister stood/[i]n deadly peril to do her good” (Rossetti Lines 557-558). By doing this, she further highlights the didactic nature of the poem. Meaning, if the reader does not attempt to deduce the moral message, Laura explicitly tells the reader by the end. Thus, these two character roles played by the women further enhances the idea of a fairy tale story for

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    The first time the two boys told the story, their voices touched the audience. The effect had been so strong that even the village headman who, for all his harshness, couldn’t hold back the years pouring from his eyes. When Luo was sick with malaria, the little Seamstress brings four sorceresses to help Luo recover. To keep the sorceresses awake and watching over Luo the narrator recounts ‘The Little Flower Seller’. When the narrator told the story, the sorceresses weren’t too engaged and did not show any sign of influence. Luo wakes up in time to say the final line ‘The saying goes that a sincere heart can make a stone blossom. So tell me, was the flower girl’s heart lacking in sincerity?’ The sorceresses could no longer hold back the tears and started crying. Those people show that even the more emotionless person can have emotions, and stories can bring it out. Stories were invented a by people at the dawn of civilization for many reasons. Some stories were invented to tell history, some to show patterns. In the book "Balzac and the Little Chinese Seamstress" they discover what stories can do to them, and how powerful they are.…

    • 531 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Her story is filled with immense grief and pain, and the drastic consequences that result from the insanity of loving loved ones. The Plague is unforgiving and unbiased, as “wealth and connection are no shield” against it. Anna, a young mother of two, loses both children to the epidemic. She loved them ‘from the moment [she] reached down and touched the crown of [their] heads” and yet the place was ‘cruel’ and threw blows upon blows “so that before you have mourned one person that you love, another is ill in your arms”. The death of two young, innocent children is not only horrifying and heart-wrenching, but reduces Anna to “not really seeing anything. It is only the tragedy of losing her ‘babes’, husband, potential lover in Mr Viccar, that she turns to Elinor and begins to learn the arts of physick. An aspect of the time era this story was set in, was the people’s avid belief of medicine and herbs being the way of the witches. Instead of accepting Any and Mem Gowdie’s goodwill and knowledge that was “old before Mem Gowdie was even thought of”, they went to hire expensive physicians which ultimately give no help. Birthing places a woman in a fragile and vulnerable state, and yet “there were few who would do without Anys in their birthing room” despite many of them fearing that Anys was a witch. Although they hated the Gowdies’, ironically, when the death toll rises to where over two-thirds of the villagers lose their lives to the Plague, many people resort to witchcraft, believing the in the “ghost of Anys”. They place themselves through unnecessary punishment and pain, such as “boiling the babe’s piss” or passing a child “through the brambles”. Through desperation, flagellants also appear, desperate to please their God through self punishment. The villager’s lack of knowledge and unwillingness to accept views which lie…

    • 1488 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    The title is repeated in the last line of every stanza, “I have been her kind.” This repetition connects the different first-person scenarios described by each stanza: a witch, an old-school midwife figure, and a whore. These scenarios are described mostly through connotations, such as “haunting the black air, braver at night” (2), “fixed the suppers for the worms and the elves: / whining, rearranging the disaligned” (11-12), and “I have ridden in your cart, driver, / waved my nude arms at villages going by” (15-16). Words like “haunting”, “black”, and “night” evoke an image of evil that strengthens the connotation of a witch as someone…

    • 815 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Hunchback and Laura

    • 670 Words
    • 3 Pages

    In the U.S. about 2% of all babies are born with physical disabilities. Physical disabilities are not only a very important talk in the population of babies; they are also very important topics in literature. Two of the most well known pieces of literature that are about physical disabilities are “Hunchback Girl” and The Glass Menagerie. The characters that have disabilities in these stories are Laura and the Hunchback Girl. They both have similarities and differences including their physical disabilities and how they feel about them, their parents, and the way society treat them.…

    • 670 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Briar Rose Allegory

    • 1465 Words
    • 6 Pages

    She has also kept to the structure of a typical fairy tale. She has done this to continue the allegory between the fairy tale and real life by the inclusion of characters and settings which feature in both stories and these characters include the villain, prince, hero and a castle and begins to show the experiences from the Holocaust. The Prince of the story was Aron Mandestein, who is also the hero of the story as he climbed into the pit filled with the bodies of people who had been gassed by the Nazi and pulled her out. Josef Potocki, is also a hero within the story, as it was Josef who help to resuscitate Gemma, and also provided her with assistance to escape the country. The villain within this story is the Hitler and his Nazi followers, who placed people into concentration camps and killed over a 1000 people a day. The castle, which Gemma is making reference to is the “castle”, which was a concentration camp, where the Nazi’s sent people before their death by gas.…

    • 1465 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    A Year of Wonders

    • 848 Words
    • 4 Pages

    The heroine of the novel, Anna Frith is a symbol of hope. She represents the underdog, a character for which has no significant importance in society, but as the story unfolds and her town becomes the breeding ground for a deathly infestation, she rises above her original character, an ordinary maid, and is transformed instead into a hero for her community. Her subservience is illustrated through her selfless act in which she helps Merry Wickford, a young orphaned girl who lost her family to the plague. To prevent Merry from living a ‘bleak future in a poorhouse’, Anna embarks on a dangerous mission to attain the required dose of lead in the Wickford mine. Such an act held many potential dangers, although aware, Anna continued with her pursuit. Described as ‘the one good, perhaps, to come out of [that] terrible year’, Anna is a clear example of how arduous times can make ‘heroes of us’.…

    • 848 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Laura and Miss Dove

    • 782 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Similarities and differences can be found within the two stories The Garden-Party and Good Morning, Miss Dove. The two main characters in these stories are Laura Sheridan, from The Garden-Party, and Miss Dove, from Good Morning, Miss Dove.…

    • 782 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    She finds a way to rebel (no matter how small), by writing all of her stories, so that in turn, all of her readers can “pass on the tradition” of her life. With her persistence in writing to God with everything she sees and hears and feels, she is unconsciously telling herself that she deserves to be heard; even if it’s just through her writing that no one is going to see but God and her sister.…

    • 943 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    What Does Red Clowns Mean

    • 907 Words
    • 4 Pages

    The narrator waited and waited but sally never came. The narrator put all her trust on Sally. “I waited such a long time. I waited by the red clowns, just like you said, but you never came, you never came for me”(Cisneros 1). This quote proves that the narrator was left in dangerous circumstances because she was left alone. The narrator trusted sally to protecter when she was afraid. If you are left alone in a carnival especially if it is by men who have been drinking you are bound to have trouble. The narrator was blinded by sally and wanting to be like her that she did not realize she was in trouble from the very beginning. If the narrator had noticed she was endangered, she would've just went home.The narrator seems to always be depending on someone to look after her. At first Sally leaves the narrator alone in a dark place next to drunk strangers telling her she will be fine. Soon after the narrator experiences the horrible event of getting raped in her desperation the narrator tries yelling her help but can not fight back and has nothing to do but cry. ”Sally, you lied, you lied. He wouldn’t let me go”(Cisneros 6). This shows Sally lied when she said the narrator was going to be fine when she was told to stay by the tilt a whirl. In the narrator's eyes she feels betrayed and used by Sally and her image of a perfect world of fairy tales soon tumbles down. The lesson that the narrator learns is do…

    • 907 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    He claims the ballad only makes sense on a metaphorical lever, on which the elf-knight “appears as a response to the heroine's erotic yearning” (ibid). Thus, the whole ballad becomes a lesson about sexual self-discovery and sexual power. Lady Isabel is still naive in the beginning, when she lives in her “childhood condition of family and home” (ibid), and oblivious to the danger connected to her desire. Both the elf's and her own magic represent male and female sexual power. Syndergaard's reading is conclusive, but the dismissal of the narrative's literal level is unnecessary. Characters in ballads or fairy tales often act in ways that are not entirely believable by modern standards, or fall for seemingly obvious tricks. Furthermore, an elaborate scheme or lengthy struggle does not suite the compact narrative mode of the ballad.…

    • 1278 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Laura’s struggle within herself is apparent from the beginning of the story. She is seen by readers as being very different from the rest of her family and seems to struggle with being herself and conforming to the norms of her class like the rest of the family appears to be doing. “But Meg could not possibly go and supervise the men. She had washed her hair before breakfast, and she sat drinking her coffee in a green turban, with a dark wet curl stamped on each cheek. Jose, the butterfly, always came down in a silk petticoat and a kimono jacket” (Daley 206). Laura’s sisters are completely self-absorbed and their primary focus is on their outward appearance which most likely was a learned trait from their own mother. Laura does however give in to a few social norms throughout the work, but finds the outcome to be quite dissatisfying. “‘Good morning,’ she said, copying her mother’s voice. But that sounded so fearfully affected that she was ashamed, and stammered like a little girl…” (Daley 207). Laura tries to mimic her mother’s voice that she used when speaking with her…

    • 1179 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    will interpret the examples given in Chapter 8, “Hanseldee and Greteldum—using fairy tales a kid lit” to show how women treat each other and…

    • 870 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Petrarcha And Laura

    • 1175 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Laura, a very beautiful but also mysterious lady, inspired Petrarcha for poems. Petrarcha passes through emotional ''landscape'' in his life from the moment he first lied his eyes on Laura to when she rejected his courtship and after when she passed away. His feelings of love towards Laura prevail throughout whole his life, but his emotional state changes from happiness to deep despair and grief.…

    • 1175 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Ant and the Grasshopper

    • 368 Words
    • 2 Pages

    The climax of the text. While the boy was admiring the colouring of a mandarin duck, the voice of his aunt came from the gooseberry garden. She got slipped into the rain-water tank and couldn’t go out. She demanded from the boy to bring her a ladder, but he said her voice didn’t sound like his aunt’s. You may be the Evil One tempting me to be disobedient. Justice must be done. The Aunt tasted the fruit of her own punishment on the children. She is accused of falling from grace, of lying to Nicholas about jam and thus termed the Evil One. She feels what it is like to be condemned.…

    • 368 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Oscar Wilde Fairy Tales

    • 4403 Words
    • 18 Pages

    ABSTRACT: In this paper we examine the articulation of the tragic mode in Oscar Wilde‟s collection of fairy tales The Happy Prince and Other Stories, especially in “The Young King”, “The Selfish Giant” and “The Birthday of the Infanta.” By “tragic mode” we mean, in this context, the vestiges left by Greek tragedy and its development, the Elizabethan tragedy, in a piece of nineteenth century fiction. Several thematic and structural elements, as suggested by Richard Palmer – tragic heroes, tragic villains and martyrs, issues of fate, guilt, will, self-recognition, death and suffering, as well as the recurrence of paradox, tragic structure and poetic elevation of the language – lead us to conclude that the tragic mode is present and very effective in Wilde‟s fairy tales.…

    • 4403 Words
    • 18 Pages
    Powerful Essays