Comparing and Contrasting "Barn Burning" and "A Rose for Emily"

Better Essays
Hunter Taylor
Dr. William Bedford
English 1102-011
10 September 2013
Comparing and Contrasting “A Rose for Emily” and “Barn Burning” In William Faulkner’s short stories “A Rose for Emily” and “Barn Burning” the characters are both guilty of committing terrible crimes. However, Miss Emily in “A Rose for Emily” and Abner Snopes in “Barn Burning” are both portrayed very differently from each other. A few things to consider while reading these short stories is how each of these characters is characterized, how the author generates sympathy for these characters, and the order in which the events in these stories occur. The way Faulkner characterizes Miss Emily and Abner Snopes throughout these stories is very different. In “A Rose for Emily”, Miss Emily is characterized as a respected, helpless, and possibly mentally ill elderly woman whose pride has left her living in the past when her family was higher up on the social ladder. There are many examples of these traits being shown throughout the story. When the smell begins to emanate from Miss Emily’s house, a few men from town snuck over there in the middle of the night and “broke open the cellar door and sprinkled lime there, and in all the outbuildings” (Emily 81). This illustrates how helpless Miss Emily was to extinguish the smell by herself and how the townsfolk respected her enough to preserve her dignity. The fact that Colonel Sartoris had to invent the story that “Miss Emily’s father had loaned money to the town, which the town, as a matter of business, preferred this way of repaying” (Emily 79), in reference to her taxes being remitted, illustrates how prideful she was, and her denial of her father’s death (Emily 81) indicates her unwillingness to let go of the past and the presence of a mental illness (while her sleeping with a dead body for roughly forty years is confirmation of her mental illness). In “Barn Burning”, Abner Snopes is characterized as a psychopathic tenant farmer whose family



Cited: Faulkner, William. “Barn Burning”. Literature: Approaches to Fiction, Poetry, and Drama. Ed. Robert Diyanni. New York: McGraw-Hill, 2008. 79-84. Print. ---. “A Rose for Emily”. Literature: Approaches to Fiction, Poetry, and Drama. Ed. Robert Diyanni. New York: McGraw-Hill, 2008. 352-364. Print.

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Better Essays

    In "Barn Burning," and "A Rose for Emily" William Faulkner creates two characters that are strikingly similar. Abner Snopes is loud and obnoxious. Because of this, most people tend to avoid him at all costs. On the contrary, Emily Grierson, a very intriguing woman from Jefferson, Mississipi, is an important figure in the town, despite spending most of her life alone. If these characters were judged purely on their reputation and physical appearance, it would be clear that Abner Snopes and Emily Grierson are opposites. Although at first look both Miss Emily and Abner Snopes appear different, they have more similar qualities than one would expect. These qualities drive them into a very similar and sad lifestyle.…

    • 1083 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    In William Faulkner’s “A Rose For Emily” Faulkner divides this short story in five sections based on events in the story. The protagonist, Emily Grierson is a devastated and alone woman when her father dies. Although there is a glimps of when Emily was hopeful and well spirited, the story targets Emily’s ways with towns people and outside relationships as if she is in another world with her mind, for example when is asked to pay her tax responsibilities she simply responds with an answer that would have been said decades ago. However she did suffer from an illness. Emily eventually begins an affair with a construction worker, Homer Barron. She eventually never leaves her house and kills Homer Barron, which was also sealed in her house after…

    • 350 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    This paragraph is found near the end of the short story, “A Rose for Emily,” by William Faulkner. In this excerpt, we are thrust into the funeral of Emily, and the effect of her death upon the townsfolk. Emily, a reclusive and apparently mentally disturbed spinster, has been a talked about figure in the town for the majority of her years. Her life and death have been all about relationships – both of the ones she had, as well of the ones she did not have. We learned that, although her relationships with the townsfolk were at times both cordial and strained, they came to her funeral in order to pay a kind of tribute to an object of their pity for, ironically, another relationship she was never able to consummate. The stylistic device of irony does, in fact, weigh heavily within this single passage, through the entire town coming to the funeral of a divisive figure; the face of Emily's father looming over her death as his personality did throughout her life; and of the old men who would have courted her had they been able to do so.…

    • 683 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    A story requires two simple components: action and characters to drive the action. The way either element is presented is purely the decision of the author. The best stories make readers feel that they know the characters, so much so that the characters become real to the readers. This is the case in William Faulkner’s “A Rose for Emily”. Faulkner does an impeccable job of introducing readers to Miss Emily, and through her actions he makes it clear what kind of person she is and why she is that way. Miss Emily is the result of the overkill of love’s protection, thus making her a proud, commanding, and lonely woman.…

    • 982 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Better Essays

    Owner of two Pulitzer Prizes and a Noble Prize in literature, William Faulkner has many great poems, novels, short stories, and screen plays. Having a strong influence of a southern life style growing up in Mississippi, Faulkner portrays much of it through his writings. Having only read “A Rose for Emily” I have only seen very little of his southern influence. But in this short story it engulfs the whole story being set in the time period when slavery was still existent “A Rose for Emily” has be interpreted in so many different ways ever since it was released in 1930. Most focus on the issue of the time of the story and the meaning behind it, deciphering it as many ways as possibly.…

    • 2159 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Using the city in the south where the story takes place, Faulkner shows the various ways that the characters react with Emily as well as the conflicts and the irony in his short story “A Rose…

    • 201 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In “A Rose for Emily,” William Faulkner tells the story of Miss Emily, an aristocratic woman that is greatly respected by people of the town in Jefferson, Yoknapatawpha County, Mississippi. People look at her as “a tradition, a duty,” and a “monument.” The story starts off sorrowfully at Emily's funeral, but ends up terrifyingly when people discover her unspeakable secret. She poisons Homer Barron. She even keeps his rotting corpse on her bed and sleeps next to it for years. Even though Miss Emily's oddities gives the story an ominous feel, I believe that Emily Grierson is just an old and lonely lady who could never escape her own isolated world. Emily was born in a very well-respected family. Her…

    • 953 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    A Rose For Emily

    • 466 Words
    • 2 Pages

    The plot of “A Rose for Emily” separates from the structure of most short stories by not following the normal chronological order. William Faulkner uses flashbacks to give a better understanding of the internal conflict between the protagonist, Miss Emily, and society. The nonlinear plot structure of “A Rose for Emily” gives life to the story and creates a different way of comprehending the narrative by keeping the reader confused on what exactly is happening.…

    • 466 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    The short story “A Rose for Emily” written by William Faulkner amazes the reader with its suspenseful mood through the story. When the reader is first introduced to the story he or she is likely to not understand the exceptional form of work the author uses. They are likely to be bewildered by the flashbacks played through the setting of the story. However, after multiple readings, it is easy to comprehend the story and the intellect given by the author.…

    • 656 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Faulkner is known to be one of America’s most significant writers, A Rose for Emily was the first story he had published in a national magazine. So it could be said that this story is a start for William Faulkner’s journey to greatness. This short story covers every facet of English literature and assists students to have a better understanding of the various…

    • 655 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Upon doing some reading and research on William Faulkner, small details have begun to emerge about his upbringing and his deep ties to the south. William Faulkner’s “A Rose for Emily” was first published in an issue of Forum magazine and it was first shared with the public on April 30th, 1930. The narrator is never named although the storyteller highlights the oddities of Emily Grierson. In my opinion I see Emily as a dried up old spinster that is stuck in her ways and unwilling to change with the times. The story tells us much about Jefferson, yet it also leaves a lot of the work up to the reader. The story tells us a lot about Emily’s life, her painful relationship with her dad, her odd lover, the small town of Jefferson, and some awfully personal details about several secrets Emily is keeping, and in many ways the town is keeping.…

    • 3673 Words
    • 15 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    A Rose for Emily Summary 8

    • 2192 Words
    • 9 Pages

    In “A Rose for Emily,” we truly found out how strange Emily became as story went on, and how she lived a life that was secretive and hideous until the day she died. William Faulkner’s skillful use of words and time allows much insight into the life of Miss Emily without ever hinting at her struggle with death. Faulkner’s reference to the Old South and his unconventional plot lures his readers to places he wants them to be, giving them just enough to keep them in suspense. He uses subtle clues to foreshadow a ghastly outcome. References to smell, decay, and Miss Emily’s corpse like appearance all guide his readers to the climatic end’s ultimate irony.…

    • 2192 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Mmmkkk

    • 310 Words
    • 2 Pages

    William Faulkner's “A Rose for Emily” was originally published in the April 30, 1930, issue of Forum. It was his first short story published in a major magazine. A slightly revised version was published in two collections of his short fiction, These 13 (1931) and Collected Stories (1950). It has been published in dozens of anthologies as well. “A Rose for Emily” is the story of an eccentric spinster, Emily Grierson. An unnamed narrator details the strange circumstances of Emily’s life and her odd relationships with her father, her lover, and the town of Jefferson, and the horrible secret she hides. The story’s subtle complexities continue to inspire critics while casual readers find it one of Faulkner’s most accessible works. The popularity of the story is due in no small part to its gruesome ending.…

    • 310 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    William Faulkner’s “A Rose for Emily” and Kate Chopin’s “The Story of an Hour” are both stories about women that struggle with love. In a Rose for Emily, Emily Grierson is in the need to get married, while in The Story of an Hour, Louise Mallard is convinced that her husband is dead and we she finds out that he isn’t, it saddens Louise and ultimately kills her. The characters, the setting, and the idea of repression in both stories are three topics that can be compared in these two selections.…

    • 540 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    In the story “A Rose for Emily”, William Faulkner associates the main character, Miss Emily with a sense of beauty, privilege, and mystery. Raised in a rich southern atmosphere it is clear why the town of Jefferson is so infatuated with her life. But how does the patriarchal society and socioeconomic climate of the era contribute to and directly influence the events that occur in Miss Emily 's life? Miss Emily is a product of her time. Nobody in the town of Jefferson really knows who Miss Emily is, due to social standards and traditions. William Faulkner’s “A Rose for Emily” is a case point. While I think that we can quickly learn to see how Faulkner’s story illustrates the patriarchal ideology,…

    • 1811 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Better Essays