Compare and Contrast Freud and Horney's View of Women

Good Essays
"Compare and Contrast Freud and Horney's View of Women"
Freud viewed women as incomplete men, lacking a penis and a mature superego. He based most of his views of women on his concept of penis envy. Penis envy is the concept that women view themselves as castrated males and therefore envy the penis. For the most part, it seems to me that Freud really never paid much attention to women. His psychosexual stages were largely related to men however according to our textbook, women took up most of his practice so one would assume he would have relied on women more to report his findings. This lack of "importance" of women in Freud's research clearly demonstrated the times in which he lived in.
Karen Horney, unlike Freud, believed that women didn't result from penis envy that it was instead the men that suffered from womb envy. Womb envy is described as the expressed jealousy over women's ability to bear and nurse children. This theory along with Freud's theory referring to the libido are quite similar in the sense that they each suggest that one gender is secretly jealous of the organ that the other gender possesses. Unlike Freud, Karen's views were not because of the times in which she lived in but instead she suggests that women feel inferior because we have for so long allowed men to tell us that we are inferior. Also, Karen proposes that men, because they cannot give birth to children, make up for this by working to gain impressive accomplishments. Karen differed very much from Freud, however it was stated that one of the biggest criticisms people held against her was the fact that she relied too heavily on his work. Nevertheless, she was in the end considered by many to be the first theorist to stress female

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Powerful Essays

    Critically compare and contrast Freud and Erikson’s stage theories of development, and debate how well each has been supported by research. Among early developmental theories, the most influential and controversial theory of development was proposed by Sigmund Freud. Freud proposed psychosexual stages of development, which changed the entire view on the child’s development (Storr, 1989). Erickson followed the footsteps of Freud but disagreed with his psychosexual stages to some extent and proposed…

    • 2730 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    However, whereas Freud was an id psychologist who articulated the stages of psychosexual development and attributed behavior to “libido”, Erikson was an ego psychologist who talked about the stages of psychosocial development. Specifically Erikson claimed that a human has to go through eight stages during his/her life in order to complete his development. Each stage poses a number of challenges that have to be confronted successfully. These challenges are a conflict between his or her biological…

    • 80 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    arising on how women should really be treated. Such notions give way to very controversial theatre. Ibsen and Strindberg strongly demonstrate how these issues were reasoned. It generally seems as though Ibsen and Strindberg had a very different view on women and their roles in society. However, in a closer view you tend to see that their views on women are not that different. In Ibsen's A Doll's House and in Strindberg's Miss Julie it looks as if the women are mere objects. The women appear more like…

    • 836 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    COMPARE AND CONTRAST FREUD AND ERICKSON This research paper will compare and contrast two of the most influencial psychologists who helped shape the way we understand the development of the human mind; Sigmund Freud and Erik Erikson. The paper will focus on the similarities and differences between Freud’s Psycho-sexual theory, and Erikson’s psychosocial theory. Freud was one of the very first influencial psychologists who changed the way we study humans. Erikson recognized Freud’s contributions…

    • 327 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Viridiana Arias Psychology 7 Dec. 16 Freud vs Jung Jung and Freud are both well known in the world of psychology. Both studied dreams and the reasons why we have them but both took different directions. Jung took looked for more symbolism and meanings behind dreams. Freud took a more scientific route and believed dreams to have a more primal meaning. Their different ideas seems to be what drove them apart. In 1912 Jung publicly criticized Freud's theories, thus beginning an endless feud.…

    • 476 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Compare and Contrast - Women

    • 5945 Words
    • 24 Pages

    Compare contrast women 100 years ago and women today. I. Intro 1. Women's lives have changed enormously this century and the actions of women themselves have played a vital role in the transformation. Putting women back into history is about giving individual women their history, but it should also be about making some collective sense out of women's divergent experiences. 2. At the beginning of the century most women were invisible in society, whatever their class.. II. Clothes a. Clothes…

    • 5945 Words
    • 24 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Freuds view on religion

    • 441 Words
    • 2 Pages

    What is Freud's view on religion? Sigmund Freud was an Austrian psychologist, born May 1953 and died September 1939 aged 83. He had a very Jewish upbringing, yet considered himself to be an atheist, and his later works showed that he considered religion to be a type of neurosis. At various points in his work, Freud suggests that religion is an attempt to subdue or control what is known as the Oedipus complex; a father-son mental sexual competition over the mother. This suggests that the son feels…

    • 441 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Aaron Beck summarized Freud’s theory in regards to the unconscious mind producing feelings of guilt as a result of its nasty impulses; using our sexual desires as an example. As a result of these immoral unconscious impulses individuals started to repress their thoughts and emotions which caused them to become depressed. Beck also dissucess Frueds work in dream analysis as a major key to surface uncouses thoughts and actions. In Depressed patients Beck found a pattern in there dreams of being deprived…

    • 123 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    psychosocial theory both are similar and are set out in stages. These two theorists relate there work to one another, and this shows strength as they can also support their work. This gives it a good source and shows that there is truth in their work. Both Freud and Erikson believed that trust was developed in the first stage of life, furthermore they believed that independence was also developed at the same age. However, Freud’s theory stops at an earlier stage, whereas Erikson continues his studies into…

    • 389 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    common thread with these women on display with the Library of Congress "Women Come to the Front" exhibition, is that they all seem to have wanted to convey the social strife felt by foreign and domestic communities. During War time, jobs were made more available to females in every facet of industry, including photojournalism. The eight women of the exhibit are noted for having both foreign and domestic photographic documentation of the labors of war. Of the eight, three women that seemed to have…

    • 385 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays