Preview

Compare And Contrast Burke And Thomas Paine

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
653 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Compare And Contrast Burke And Thomas Paine
Edmund Burke, Thomas Paine. Do you know much about these two philosophers? More than likely not. These two gentlemen are famous philosophers and authors who is considered to be two of the greatest political thinkers ever. The two disagreed over a numerous amount of things regularly.
Edmund Burke was a western philosopher born in Ireland who lived in the years of 1773-1792. He served as a statesman, author, philosopher, and political theorist and after moving to London in 1750 he worked as a member of parliament in the House of Commons. Burke was a supporter of the American Revolution but opposed the French revolution. Burke claimed that the French Revolution was destroying the structure of a good society and condemned the persecution of the
…show more content…
In his lifetime he served as a philosopher, revolutionary, and a political theorist. Paine is considered one of the founding fathers of the US; along with some great gentlemen like Benjamin Franklin, George Washington, Thomas Jefferson, and other great names. He was the author of two of the most influential pamphlets at the start of the American Revolution along with inspiring the rebels in 1776 to declare independence from Great Britain (Paine iii).
During the French Revolution Paine and Burke generated a major storm. The two represented antagonistic ideologies; with Thomas Paine with radical liberalism and Edmund Burke with conservatism. Thomas Paine’s main idea was to foreseeing the state; while Edmund Burke’s was the dangers of trying to shape society. The two gentleman started off as friends due to the part Burke took in the American Revolution (Paine, 5). But once Edmund Burke’s Pamphlet became known of Paine took action. Paine thought Burke’s Pamphlet contained flagrant misrepresentations of the French Revolution, principles of Liberty, and its imposition on the rest of the world. (Paine, 5) In which ignited the fire under the

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Burke argues against enlightenment and…

    • 474 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Burke’s protest of the revolution does not come from his estimates of its “extremist nature”, because he does not appreciate the extremities that are involved. He said that he was “incapable” of being in touch with those “who profess principles of extremities and who, under the name of religion, each little else than wild and dangerous politics.” That being said from what I have read about Burke, was that he was a religious man who believed that a man’s right was not an abstract principle, meaning that it was always development and it was not part of the first set of knowledgeable principles. He did not appreciate the extremist nature because he did not believe that there are rights and reasons to justify violence.…

    • 375 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In the year of 1775, he was one of the representatives to sign the Declaration of Independence and was present at the Constitutional Convention of 1787, which assembled with the purpose of drafting The Constitution of the United States of America. Here he was a very influential figure, whose ideas where heavily incorporated in one of the most important documents in history. Now both the Constitution and the Declaration of Independence bear his signatures, for all Americans to see it, on either…

    • 666 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In Reflections of the Revolution in France, Edmund Burke intellectually attacks the French for the occurrences that took place in their country during the late 1700s. Burke was strongly opposed to immense political reform. In this book, he voices his belief that it is counteractive to try new types of government because it can lead to the loss of the progress achieved by the past generations. Thus, he argues that all men are subject to a generational contract that embodies beings from the past, present and the future. This is where I begin to have a problem with Burke’s argument because, as stated in Paine’s book The Rights of Man, old forms of government cannot keep up with new elements that come about with changing times; thus, civilians…

    • 261 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Paine argued that the French revolution was to be expected as a continuation of a new era of human history, but Burke argued that the revolution brought the risk of devolving into a barbaric society and promoted the destruction of a nation’s social fabric. Paine’s beliefs that the government’s political principles of enlightenment was to protect individuals liberty and equality however Burke disagreed and was a non-believer of abstract principles guaranteeing liberty. He believed humans were a product of their environment, institutions and communities. Burke believed that the traditions of institutions were able to provide public safety. This is why Paine states he is contending for the rights of the living, he states that it is societies decision to choose their…

    • 824 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Revolution came from them-the middle class. They were just beginning to learn to read” (Document 4). Through this the middle class gained knowledge and ideas of the Enlightenment. They became philosophers. They started to believe and realized many things. Voltaire believed in freedom of speech but gone thrown in jail for making fun of a rich baron. This made the rest of the citizens to wonder about what they could say and why weren’t they allowed to talk about whatever they wanted?. John Locke was a believer of natural rights from birth and is famous for his writings on rights of life, liberty and property. His writings made people have an “oh yeah!why NOT?!” moment and questioned their rights and the other estates rights deciding that this was unfair and unjust. These people started to believe and agree with what these philosophers thought than what the king or the clergy…

    • 806 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Founding Father Thomas Paine , England born political philosopher and writer (1727-1809). He helped shape many of the ideas that marked the Age Revolution. In 1776, his high popular “Common Sense” was published and it was the first pamphlet to advocate American Independence. No other figure played a great role in moving the American People from a spirit of rebellion to one of revolution.…

    • 449 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The reason why I put Thomas Paine in this paper is because George Washington gained us our independence and Thomas Paine basically produced it. Thomas Paine had a lot to do with independence along with George Washington. Both were very great men and taught many through their words of wisdom. They were very similar and wise just one didn't fight in war. They did have their differences.…

    • 1003 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Thomas Paine was one of our nations founding fathers and one of the greatest pamphleteers of all time. He was responsible for many influential writings including Common Sense, Crisis, and The Rights of Man, his response to Edmund Burke's criticism of the French Revolution. In this declaration, Paine's message is that of a need for a Republican government that understands and carries out the natural rights of all men. Paine claims that despotism such as what was in place in France before their revolution, holds the people in ignorance and degrades them. A monarchy should never be in power because they too often do not pay attention to each individuals rights.…

    • 494 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Dbq Enlightenment Analysis

    • 1007 Words
    • 5 Pages

    In his book “Common Sense” (Document 3) he points out was that America isn’t like Britain and how it can stay different from Britain. America doesn’t have a king that solely rules over it, we have laws that help to govern us. With the absence of a king it creates a different government from Britain. Thomas Paine also points out his view on freedom. He goes with the enlightenment thinkers in saying that freedom is good, if we didn’t have freedom bad things would come. He points out that freedom was the main cause of Americans wanting to start the revolution. If people then went through all that trouble to get their freedom the government should uphold that main and arguably the most important revolutionary principle. He uses his views and writings to influence the government and create a basis for them to rule off…

    • 1007 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    George Washington emerge as the most significant leader in the founding of the United States of America, even to the extent of being called the Father of the Country. He was an important figure even then. He was the first president of the United States and was the general of the Continental Army. He was a powerful man who led our country to freedom. It was he who contributed greatly to the victory of the American Revolution. It is even believed by some that without Washington, the War for Independence would not have been accomplished. Washington lived and worked with brilliant philosophers, thinkers, writers, orators and organizers, almost every one of whom were much more educated than he. Yet at the three major junctions in the founding of the nation, the Revolution, the Constitutional Convention and the selection of…

    • 611 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Thomas Paine Thesis

    • 351 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Thomas Paine is characterized as an intellectual, a revolutionary, a supporter of American independence from England, and a pamphleteer. As a pamphleteer, Paine wrote how he thought America to be a place of gathering amongst all people of different cultures. Paine emphasized how through the simple accomplishment of an operating government focusing on the construction of the principles of society and the rights of man, would result in the cordial unison of all.…

    • 351 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    The winter of 1776 was a dreadful time for George Washington and his troops. They had little food, inadequate shelter, and many were deserting (Berstein 161). Into this horrible situation came Thomas Paine. In England, he had moved, without success, through several occupations. He then began to write essays supporting America's fight for independence, shortly after his arrival in 1774. In December of 1776, he started to write a series of articles entitled The Crisis. His words inspired many soldiers to enlist in the army and encouraged them to continue fighting. After the publication of his articles, the first anti-slavery movement, The American Antislavery Society, was found (Katz 1). His beliefs of universal order, in human perfectibility, and in the power of reason, guided him throughout his life to express himself and persuade others to fight for what they believed in. Yet Paine, a fuzzy historical figure of the 1700s, is remembered mostly for one or two sparkling patriotic quotes - "These are the times that try men's souls" - and little else (Katz 1). The Crisis gave enough courage to the Americans that when they attacked Britain at Trenton they…

    • 1086 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Hobbs believed that humans are naturally cruel, selfish, and hungry for power; Hobbs argued that people need to be protected from themselves. Hobbs believed in an idea called the social contract. The next philosopher is John Locke he believed that all people we born with natural rights, including life, liberty, and property; Locke argued that kings could be overthrown if he takes away their rights. Baron de Montesquieu agreed with Locke and their for we got the separation of powers, which is dividing power among three branches of government. Voltaire, was one of the most famous writers of the Enlightenment, he argued for the rights of freedom of speech and religion. Voltaire once said “I may disapprove of what you say, but I will defend to death your right to say it.” He criticized intolerance, prejudice, and oppression. Another philosopher was Rousseau, he believed that people are naturally good, but power corrupts them; free people formed a social contract and government based on the common good, he supported a direct democracy. The last philosopher that I will include is Cesare Beccaria, he argued that people accused of crimes, punishment and torture should be abolished. Beccaria was upset with the use of torture, corrupt judges, secret trial, and secure punishments for crimes. He criticized abuses in the justice system.These men and their ideas influenced our government, for example their ideas were used in the Constitution, Declaration of Independence and the…

    • 886 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    histroy

    • 357 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Paine presented multiple arguments in his pamphlet, Common Sense. One of his arguments that stood out to me the most is that regarding the monarchy and hereditary succession. Paine describes how nobody chooses to live poorly and cannot choose the status of their descendants and the importance and idea of equality. He describes the difference between Kinds and subjects as being unnecessary and unethical. Everyone is equal at creation. People of the colonies could relate to this on a religious aspect as well, because the Bible supports his statements. Paine supported the beliefs of freedom of property to all men and freedom on religion. Paine also discussed America and the relationship with Great-Britain. Paine stated that America had become dependent on Great-Brittan and that success and happiness should not be reliant on another country. He wrote that Great-Britain had nobody’s interest in mind but their own. Paine also pointed out the unnecessary quarrels with other countries such as France and Spain, due to the fact that we were involved with Great-Britain and pictured them as the parent country. He introduced the idea of having each colony be independent and have representatives chosen by the people.…

    • 357 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays