Compare and Contrast

Topics: Eudora Welty, A Worn Path, Short story Pages: 6 (2106 words) Published: February 27, 2013
Robert Frost’s in “The Path Not Taken” and Eudora Welty’s “A Worn Path focus on one particular theme that is “Journey”. While the two writers have displayed a similar theme, it is a different point of view. Each of them have showed particular journey through which life can change. Out of many things in these two literatures there is one thing in common, i.e. no matter what journey a person takes there is a lot of hurdles and hardship standing in their way to demotivate them. Each of the literatures has different characters, symbolism, and historical context although the theme of these two literatures is same.

The basic themes of these two works of literature is same i.e. Journey. But each of these writers has portrayed it in a different way. In Poem “Path not Taken” tells that in life a time comes when one have to decide which way he/she have to choose one path to spend their lives. The poem is not only based on only one theme i.e. taking chances but it also has themes like, experimenting new thing, not following the crowd, and taking a stand on something. But this is totally different from Eudora Welty “A Worn Path”. Eudora shows in her story that Phoenix Jackson has no choice to select her path in order to heal her grandson. She has to take a path that end in place where she could find medicine for her grandson. No matter the path is difficult or easy, right or wrong she has taken this journey just for the love of her grandson.

Journey has different meaning according to different people. Some people consider journey as only distance they have travel while they forget that there can be great meaning beyond each step is taken. While focusing on destination people neglect to recognize the value of whole process that gets them there. The exhilaration and excitement of capricious voyage allow people to learn positive and negative things of different people one meet while travelling and explore different places which turns out to be useful for the rest of the life. Journey posses’ an ultimate power in which one can change a person’s thinking, concepts along with ideas, which later on predictably change the whole person individually. Journey was and is very well described by different poets and authors. Through their writing they have showed people different aspect of journey. Let’s see how journey is explored by these three writers in their work. They are Robert Frost’s in “The Path Not Taken” and Eudora Welty’s “A Worn Path. Robert Frost and Eudora Welty have displayed their points of view about journey in their work. Each one have defined journey in a different prospective through different themes of journey in their work.

In the poem “The Path Not Taken”, Robert Frost brilliantly portrays a person’s choice taken in their life and its impact in their future. The poem displays that people have a choice today that will have a long term effect on what they become tomorrow (Tischler, 2007, 125-130). It also display that when a person reaches a certain point where they have a choice to make on their decisions, it depends on that persons adopt regular way of solution for his problem or do what few people do to find out solution of their problems. Both things cannot be done by people (Shurr, 2003, 584-590).

They have to select one path and once the decision is taken then it’s almost difficult and impossible to retrace steps. Thus, people end becoming what they are due to their choices they have made earlier (Tischler, 2007, 125-130). As a result, it is important to make right choice at the right time. Choices should be made by people on what they want rather than what the majority have done on the same thing. In this poem Robert frost has shown peoples journey towards different paths of life basing on their life and how this journey will have long term or long lasting effects on their lives.

In short story written by Eudora Welty “A Worn Path” tells a story of elderly African- American women journey through...

References: Gottschalk. Franziska; (2000) Interpretation of a Short Story: “I Used to Live Here” by Jean Rhys. Brown. J; (2010) Textual Entanglement: Jean Rhys’s Critical Discourse. Published by The Johns Hopkins University Press. 584-589.
Orr. Elaine; (2005) “Unsettling Every Definition of Otherness”: Another Reading of Eudora Welty’s “A Worn Path”, Published by: South Atlantic Modern Language Association. 57-63.
Shurr. William; (2003) Once More to the “Woods”: A New Point of Entry into Frost’s Most Famous Poem. Published by: The New England Quarterly, Inc. 584-590.
Tischler, M. Nancy (2007). Thematic guide to biblical literature. Published by Greenwood Publishing Group. ISBN 0313337098, 9780313337093. 125-130
Yaakov, Juliette (2001). Fiction catalog. Published by H.W. Wilson. ISBN 0824210050, 9780824210052. 558-563
Continue Reading

Please join StudyMode to read the full document

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Compare & Contrast Essay
  • Essay about Compare and Contrast
  • Compare and Contrast Essay
  • Compare and Contrast Essay
  • Compare and Contrast Essay
  • Compare and Contrast Essay
  • Compare and Contrast Essay
  • Compare and Contrast Essay

Become a StudyMode Member

Sign Up - It's Free