Preview

Children Need to Play, Not Compete - Critique

Better Essays
Open Document
Open Document
847 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Children Need to Play, Not Compete - Critique
“Children Need to Play, Not Compete”, by Jessica Statsky: A Critique What makes Jessika Statsky’s “Children Need to Play, Not Compete” an effective piece in the arguments on whether the competitive sports may harm children both physically and psychologically, is her use of clear thesis statement and a full forecast of the reasons she offers to justify her position. Statsky carefully picks her key terms, such as by sports, for example, she means to describe both contact and non-contact sports that emphasize competition. Also she clearly defines to her audience that she is mainly concerned about children of age six to twelve years old.

In her article, Statsky shows clear logic supporting her thesis statement through use of believable and consistent argument, credible sources and appropriate counter-argument. While her logic is clear, her argument also has weaknesses. For instance, author fails to present a solid counter-argument showing rather positive effects of competitive sports on children. Failing to do so, Statsky fails to appeal to a much broader audience. Finally, the sources she uses to support her argument seem to be outdated, thus weakening the overall credibility of the article.

Despite that, Statsky provides a strong support for her thesis. She uses different kinds of information and sources. As well as she widely uses quotations, examples, and statistical data to support her point. Author often quotes and summarizes credible sources like “New York Times”, “Los Angeles Times”, official websites and other highly trustable resources in order to build a strong credibility for her argument as well as to support the reasons she believes competitive sports are bad for children. For example, in paragraph 3, Statsky offers the reason that “overly competitive sports” may harm children’s growing body by paraphrasing Koppett’s claim that muscle strain or more serious injury may result when a twelve-year-old throws curve balls. She then quotes Tutko on

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Satisfactory Essays

    In Statsky’s argument there are strengths and weaknesses. A strength is that in the first sentence of paragraphs 10 & 12, Statsky does show that she is thinking about her reader’s questions. A weakness is that according to Romano Stansky’s argument is incomplete in that it fails to anticipate certain objections and questions that some parents, especially those she most wants to convince are almost sure to raise.…

    • 255 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    High Cost Of Youth Sports

    • 948 Words
    • 4 Pages

    What if there was a world where no kid ever had to suffer with playing sports,where no one ever got hurt, where in the sports world kids were safe from danger. Although when you play sports you can get more fit and get more healthier. Competitive sports for the young risk a lot of injuries kids being hurt that they might give up on the sport that they play. Spending too much money can be a real threat to parents, some parents don’t have enough money to help their child achieve what they want to do with sports. Also spending too much time wanting to win, putting pressure on the child/children in which the child/children want to quit the sport, where sometimes little kids want to play for fun. Therefore competitive sports are bad for the young…

    • 948 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Fair and Foul Beyond the Myth

    • 98997 Words
    • 396 Pages

    Acknowledgments 1 2 3 The Duality of Sport Sport Unites, Sport Divides Names, Logos, Mascots, and Flags: The Contradictory Uses of Sports Symbols Sport Is Fair, Sport Is Foul Sport Is Healthy, Sport Is Destructive The Organization of Children’s Play: Peer…

    • 98997 Words
    • 396 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Statsky refers to the statement made by Martin Rablovsky that “sport becomes Job-like”. As the game starts, the smile vanishes from the children faces and their innocence disappears instantly. The sports, because of its competitive nature bring out the worst in them. they are not the only one being the victim of the harsh environment. The pressures of the games takes troll over the parents and as well as the sports teacher. I remember my parents became furious when I lost the final match and I had to practice much harder after that. which was completely torturing as it left me exhausted to concentrate on my homework. The main focus of the sports gets lost when the only outcome in the mind is scoring a victory. The perspective of sports has entirely changed since the idea of competition had been introduced in it. participating in these kind of sports is no more considered as a good development opportunity for the growth rather now its negative impact is far more greater than the positive…

    • 1105 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Nearly 65% of children say they participate in sports to be with their friends (Statistic Brain). Sports were established so that the individual could not only exercise, but also to compete against a rival. Just as there are individual sports, there are team sports in high school. The idea of a team sport is that every single person on the field or court must work in unison to have the greatest opportunity to win. In addition to the increasing popularity of sports, the average child’s age when they join a team is decreasing. For example, the age that a child joins a basketball team has shifted from fourth grade to first grade or even kindergarten in the past decade. School is the primary factor when you review the participation in athletics,…

    • 980 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Competitive Sports like football and baseball or Lacrosse are often very risky on children and even adults, and because the rules of the game are the same, and the same game plans and actions are used in both local games and even nationals, it makes the game more competitive than friendly, which mostly results in major physical and psychological injuries. Statsky stated in her article “ Highly organized competitive sports such as Peewee Football and Little League Baseball are too often played to adult standards, which are developmentally inappropriate for children and can be both physically and psychologically harmful “. From my own experience of playing Lacrosse in freshman high school, I developed more cons than pros, which was the opposite of I thought of sports. During my first season I was a beginner that wanted to learn more, and in my mind I figured that the games wouldn’t be advanced, but then I got surprised of how vicious the other team played, and it resulted in many major injuries that made the game less exciting and more freighting. Winning became a goal that everyone wanted to reach no matter what the consequences. And families and coaches play a big role on controlling the mind of the players and forcing them to even injure others in order to win, and that losing is shameful, like what Statsky said “because they emphasize competition and winning, they unfortunately provide occasions for some parents and coaches to place their own fantasies and needs ahead of children's welfare”.…

    • 384 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    When kids play competitive sports it helps them be active in sports so they don’t get childhood sickness, or become obeast. For example running down the field in soccer, football, and basketball. You can also live a healthy lifestyle by going on a diet so by not eating unhealthy food and eating vegetables, salad, and fruits you will not get sick. By playing competitive sports kids will build their muscles, and by making their bones healthier. So when kids play competitive sports they are getting exercise and living a healthy…

    • 517 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The effects of parents pushing their children is an interesting topic because many parents do this and they don’t know that it can affect their children. Children who have parents that push them in sports usually always have bad effects from it these findings are important because if parents learn about this then less children will have bad effects. That parents should not push their children in sports so less children will get hurt mentally and physically and next time you see someone pushing their children you should tell them about all the bad results of pushing their…

    • 468 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Are Sports Hurting Kids?

    • 2477 Words
    • 10 Pages

    Organized sports have a lot of effects on children, whether they be positive or negative. Children are still finding out who they are and what the world is like. I chose this topic because I wanted to know childrens’ motives to do organized sports, and what effects the sports have on the them. I wanted to know the reasons kids start playing sports and, while it may be different for every child, they all had to have had some say in it. Every sport has skills that benefit children such as learning leadership, creating realistic goals they can achieve and learning to get along with others. Children also learn about personal discipline. “What's even more interesting is that kids derive those benefits whether or not they excel at their chosen sport” (Mary Forgione). When I first saw this quote I was really surprised over the fact that children learn these important life lessons even if they aren’t good at their sport. Ever since I had the chance, I played baseball. Why? I don’t really…

    • 2477 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Sociology

    • 1904 Words
    • 8 Pages

    All of the athletes were young men ranging in ages of sixteen to twenty years old. They were all there playing because they chose to be; they tried out for this elite team and wanted to be there because of their passion for the game, and it showed. The role of the athlete is a simple one; it is to deliver. They are expected to give their best performance each and every game. Both teams on the ice played a very hard fought game.…

    • 1904 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Concussions In Sports

    • 1126 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Sports are full of competition, but this heavy amount of competition may not be so good for a person's body; plus, injuries are a common thing in sports. It wouldn’t be a sport without an injury occurring. Injuries, like concussions, are very common in sports like soccer and football. Those are caused by continuous action to the head. Concussions can have long-term effects on the brain, like memory loss and diseases like Parkinson’s(Nordqvist). Also, the violent plays in today’s sports, are not things children need to be looking up to. Athletes are supposed to be role models to the youth, but they way these athletes play on the field or court show that maybe they are not someone a person should look up to. The violent, dangerous acts, and styles…

    • 1126 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Firstly, kids should play competitive sports because they learn essential life lessons. For example, autor Kristin Chessman quotes Jim Taylor, Ph.D and sports psychology author. "Kids learn essential life skills, such as hard work, patience, persistence, and how to respond positively to setbacks and failure," (Chessman). This way, kids who never give up on their dream will try harder to become successful. In addition, children learn how to work with different people with different personalities and strengths (Chessman). This is important because…

    • 535 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Many children that compete in youth sports receive trophies for their participation. The question is, are these trophies leaving a positive or a negative impact towards children. Supporting participation trophies, Lisa Heffernan states that it does teach children good values with her argument titled “In Defense of Participation Trophies”. Opposing participation trophies, Vivian Diller states that it does not prepare children for the real world with her argument titled “Do We All Deserve Gold? Setting Kids up to Fail”.…

    • 432 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Fewer kids play amid pressure.” by Machael Rosenwald, the author addresses an issue widely faced by many children. Quitting sports because of the pressure their parents put on to them to keep playing to hopefully become a professional “elite athlete”. A survey was taken to see what the top factors contributing to kids happiness was. The results helped to prove the fact that children aren’t in games for winning or being the best. This is proven when the article reads, “...low on the list: playing in tournaments, cool uniforms and expensive equipment. High on the list: positive team dynamics, trying hard, positive coaching and learning”(Rosenwald 3). As this shows, children enjoy not being pushed to constantly be the best. Instead, they prefer being encouraged and not being forced into…

    • 478 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Deviance in Sport

    • 3788 Words
    • 12 Pages

    The forms and causes of deviance in sport are so diverse that no single theory can explain all of them (Blackshaw and Crabbe, 2004). What is accepted in sports as the norm may be seen as deviant in other spheres of society and what is seen as the norm in society can largely be seen as deviant in sports. Only on a racing track can you drive at speeds over 200 miles per hour at high risk of collision, outside the racing track it would be seen as a criminal offence. The social vacuum that has been created around sports is significantly proven to be different from the society we live in day by day. Deviance in sport can be argued, involves unquestioned acceptance of what is termed as the norms, when a social world accepts actions performed as routine and normal.…

    • 3788 Words
    • 12 Pages
    Powerful Essays