Top-Rated Free Essay

Broken Spears

Powerful Essays
Focus Paper #1
The Broken Spears

The book The Broken Spears, by Miguel Leon-Portilla, presents an account of the Conquest of Mexico from the point of view of the some of the indigenous people who survived those events. The passages used, written in the native language of the victims, provide us a brief description of the encounters with the Spaniards that were not seen in the documented history of the conquest. Native priests and wise men had documented the welcoming of Cortes and his men as the arrival of their God Quetzalcoatl and other deities, the reaction to the march of these “gods” on several cities within the Aztec state, and the manner in which the Spaniards conquered this once, independent, well-structured, pre-Columbian American civilizations.
In the introduction to the book, it describes the development of a new state in Central Mexico during the 9th century known as the “Toltec Empire”. Toltec is a synonym for artist. As stated in the Cultural Stages of Ancient Mexico section of the introduction, the Toltec people were described as “superb artisans, devout worshipers, skillful tradesmen- extraordinary persons in every way.” Under the protection of their God, Quetzalcoatl, the Toltecs had extended their civilization and influenced regions down into the Yucatan and Central America. Their God soon departed, headed eastward, and promised that “someday he would return from across the sea.”
The Aztecs, a civilization that settled in the region during the middle of the 13th century, claimed to be from Toltec nobility and believed the arrival of the Spaniards to be ”Quetzalcoatl and other Gods returning from overseas.” In the ten years leading up to the arrival of the Spaniards, the Aztecs were witness to eight omens that, whether told by the Codex Florentio or the Historia de Tlaxcala, were believed to be the foretelling of that very arrival. Thus, when news of the arrival reached them, the King, Motecuhzoma, immediately sent out his messengers thinking this was the return of Quetzalcoatl.
Chapter 3, The Messengers’ journeys, begins by telling us that “the texts describing the instructions that Motecuhzoma gave to his envoys are presented first. These show clearly how the Nahuas attempted to explain the coming of the Spaniards by a projection of earlier ideas: they assumed that the new arrivals were Quetzalcoatl and other deities.” The messengers made their way to the Spaniards’ ships in order to pay reverence to their god. They said to him, "If the god will deign to hear us, your deputy Motecuhzoma has sent us to render you homage. He has the City of Mexico in his care. He says: 'the god is weary.’"
The emotions towards their gods began to change when the messengers delivered the report of what they had seen; “how the cannon roared, how its noise resounded, how it caused one to faint and grow deaf.” The messengers told him: "A thing like a ball of stone comes out of its entrails: it comes out shooting sparks and raining fire. The smoke that comes out with it has a pestilent odor, like that of rotten mud. This odor penetrates even to the brain and causes the greatest discomfort. If the cannon is aimed against a mountain, the mountain splits and cracks open. If it is aimed against a tree, it shatters the tree into splinters. This is a most unnatural sight, as if the tree had exploded from within." They become fearful of the news that Cortes was planning on marching on the city. This fear is described in Chapter 4, Motecuhzoma’s Terror and Apathy. “Motecuhzoma was distraught and bewildered; he was filled with terror, not knowing what would happen to the city. The people were also terrified, debating the news among themselves. There were meetings and arguments and gossip in the street; there was weeping and lamenting. The people were downcast: they went about with their heads bowed down and greeted each other with tears.”
When Cortes’ march began, some cities chose to welcome the Spaniards in an attempt to align themselves with Cortes, while others debated whether to take a stand or not. This gave us a great perspective of the varying confidence levels between the tribes in regard to their ability to defend themselves. In Tlaxcala, the lords of Tlaxcala “guided them to the city; they brought them there and invited them to enter. They paid them great honors, attended to their every want, joined with them as allies.” In Tenochtitlan, “when Motecuhzoma learned what had happened in Tezcoco, he called together his nephew Cacama, his brother Cuitlahuac and the other lords. He proposed a long discussion in order to decide whether they should welcome the Christians when they arrived, and if so, in what manner. Cuitlahuac replied that they should not welcome them in any manner, but Cacama disagreed, saying that it would show a want of courage to deny them entrance once they were at the gates. He added that it was not proper for a great lord like his uncle to turn away the ambassadors of another great prince. If the visitors made any demands which displeased Motecuhzoma, he could punish their insolence by sending his hosts of brave warriors against them.”
From Chapter 8, The Spaniards Arrive in Tenochtitlan, to Chapter 13, The Surrender of Tenochtitlan, a detailed account of the events that took place in the Aztec capital are given. It describes how Motecuhzoma met with Cortes, “He showered gifts upon them and hung flowers around their necks; he gave them necklaces of flowers and bands of flowers to adorn their breasts; he set garlands of flowers upon their heads. Then he hung the gold necklaces around their necks and gave them presents of every sort as gifts of welcome.” It also provides details on how the Spaniards imprisoned the Aztec King, took possession of the city, and seized all of his treasures.
The book gives a detailed description of The Massacre in the Main Temple During the Fiesta of Toxcatl that occurred during the Spaniards’ possession of the city. These events display the brutality of the Spaniards and the decision of the Aztec people to fight back and retaliate against the occupation of their city. The Spaniards Attack the Celebrants section of Chapter 9 describes it as follows: “when the dance was loveliest and when song was linked to song, the Spaniards were seized with an urge to kill the celebrants. They all ran forward, armed as if for battle. They closed the entrances and passageways, all the gates of the patio: the Eagle Gate in the lesser palace, the Gate of the Canestalk and the Gate of the serpent of mirrors.” “They attacked all the celebrants, stabbing them, spearing them, striking them with their swords. They attacked some of them from behind, and these fell instantly to the ground with their entrails hanging out. Others they beheaded: they cut off their heads, or split their heads to pieces.”
The Aztecs Retaliate section tells us: “when the news of this massacre was heard outside the Sacred Patio, a great cry went up: "Mexicanos, come running! Bring your spears and shields! The strangers have murdered our warriors!" The Aztecs were obviously enraged by the horrendous attack on their warriors during a time of celebration. The book displays the emotions of these people well and, even though it gave them a stronger will to fight, they would only last so long.
Throughout the book The Broken Spears we are introduced to the array of emotions and perspectives of the indigenous people, as told by the indigenous people. We are given a chance to see that there were a number of different interactions with Cortes and his army. This detailed account of the events surrounding the Conquest of Mexico provides the opportunity to see much more of the story than a textbook can allow.
The textbook, Traditions and Encounters, only gives a brief outline of the conquest of the city of Tenochtitlan. It does not give details of those events or the meetings between the natives and Cortes. It does not give information on any of the other cities that were massacred or surrendered to Cortes. All of the information in the textbook is delivered from a European attempt at objectivity. The amount space provided in a history book such as this for an in-depth review of these events is very limited. There is mention of the timeframe, 1519-1521, that Cortez was in Mexico, but the story begins at the point where he lead his soldiers to the Aztec capital which is approximately seven months after he first arrived.
In conclusion, while I think that the textbook Transitions and Encounters is a great tool for getting a snapshot of history, the book The Broken Spears is a great piece of work for the details of the Conquest of Mexico. Although I had a very difficult time deciphering which native was which and what city was where, I found the book very informative. The detailed accounts of what happened, as told by the victims “who managed to survive the persecution and death that attended the final struggle,” provide the perfect window into the events not covered in our textbook.

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    A. This document describes how although all narratives about the people and cultures begin with the arrival of Europeans too much credit is being given to their “discoveries” because before the Europeans the Native Americans (Aztecs) were doing the things the Europeans claimed to be doing first. The Aztecs came up with a way of living and a way of doing things before the Europeans did. Before the Europeans arrival the Aztecs had already created a powerful Empire.…

    • 1711 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Broken Spears

    • 854 Words
    • 4 Pages

    The author argues that the Spanish were completely at fault for the total destruction of the Aztec Empire. In Broken spears, the author explains how many factors other than Spanish power contributed to the downfall of the Aztecs. Not only did the Spanish have many advantages over the Aztecs, but also they also exploited them and took advantage of the cultural difference. The main key aspects to the Spanish victory, is that the Spanish were viewed as gods at first because of their appearance, the Aztecs welcomed the Spanish with gifts and festivities, which showed the Spanish had total control of people. The Aztecs also held a ritual ceremony for the arrival of the "god" that included a human sacrifice, which was seen by the Spanish as a disgusting act, this trigged Spanish hatred for the Aztecs. When the Spanish saw the resources that the Aztecs had, they quickly started taking advantage of the Aztecs weaknesses. The Spanish had more power; they were better equipped than the Aztecs and more advanced. The Aztecs' leader Montecuhzoma was a weak leader, he was more of a coward, more concerned with his well being and safety than the safety of his people and kingdom so he quickly surrendered under pressure. The Spanish used surrounding enemy tribes to take over the Aztec lands, then began to massacre men, women and children. When the Aztec became angry and started to fight back, they were quickly wrecked by the diseases the Spanish brought with them such as small pox and measles. The Spanish were immune to these diseases because they were well known in Europe and they had been exposed to them for years, but the Aztecs weren't so entire villages were wiped out in just few weeks which cleared the way for the Spanish to entirely conquer and destroy the Aztec empire.…

    • 854 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Burying the White Gods

    • 403 Words
    • 2 Pages

    “Burying the White Gods: New Perspectives on the Conquest of Mexico,” by Camilla Townsend, hits the points of why the Native Americans were submissive to the Spaniards. The thesis, in short, says that the Native Americans were not exactly conquered by the conquistadors. Instead, they thought the Cortes was a god, Quetzalcoatl. This in no way indicates the development, or lack thereof, in the Aztec society. The Aztecs invited the conquistadors into their society as gods; they were not conquered, per say, because of the Spain being unbearable.…

    • 403 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    During Cortes’s exploration, he dealt with many hardships because of the difficult terrain and Indian people he had encountered along the way. The encounters between Cortes and the Indians were also significant because he needed to encounter these people in order to be able to conquer Tenochtitlan. The Indian people that Cortes encountered gave him the exact power he needed against the Aztec empire. Furthermore, the exchange of disease, ideals, and plant and wildlife also had a very significant impact on history and the conquer of the Aztecs. The exchange of smallpox between the Spaniards and Aztecs is another factor that led to Cortes’s success. In addition, the exchange of ideals, plants, and wildlife led to a lot of what is present in today’s Mexico. Most of what Mexico is known for can be traced back to the Spaniards who conquered Mexico in 1519 . The exploration, encounter, and exchange that occurred during the conquering of the Aztecs by Hernan Cortes significantly impacted history, and led to many of the things seen in present day…

    • 1396 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Women In The Aztec Empire

    • 1592 Words
    • 7 Pages

    The Aztec’s claim to have originated from Aztlan, an island in a lake in northwestern Mexico. They were then led to central Mexico by Huitzilopochtli, the war god and the tangible representation of the sun (Coe and Koontz, 186). Huitzilopochtli became the Mexica’s most beloved and feared god. (religion which links to the war and human sacrifice that the Aztec’s highly valued and the political system in place-Aztec emperor).…

    • 1592 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    What three factors contributed to the defeat of the Aztecs? Though there appear to be several factors involved in the defeat of the Aztecs, three stood out above the others: (1) superstition, (2) weapons and warring tactics, and (3) the introduction of new diseases.…

    • 471 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Xochiquetzal Essay

    • 1035 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Markman, Roberta H., and Peter T. Markman. The flayed God: The mesoamerican mythological tradition : Sacred texts and images from pre-Columbian Mexico and Central America. [San Francisco, Calif.]: HarperSanFrancisco, 1992.…

    • 1035 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    When discussing the importance of Spanish alliances, it is important to discuss Matthew Restall’s interpretation of “the myth of the white conquistador”. A common myth in regards to the Spanish Conquest is that the Aztecs were conquered by a small group of white Spanish men. Within Restall’s book titled “Seven Myths of the Spanish Conquest”, he debunks the myth of the white conquistadors. Restall’s argues that “there is no doubt that the Spanish were consistently outnumbered by native enemies on the battlefield. But what has so often been ignored or forgotten is the fact that Spaniards tended also to be outnumbered by their own native allies. Furthermore, the invisible warriors of this myth took an additional form, that of the Africans, free and enslave, who accompanied Spanish…

    • 443 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    According to Broken Spears, before the Spaniards arrived in the New World, the Native American had started to see eight omens which was taken as bad signs for the future. For example, the first major of the eight was, “great column of flame which burned in night, shooting out such flame which burned in the night, shooting out such brilliant sparks and flashes that it sees to rain fire on the earth and it blazed like daybreak… this portent burned for a year.” (Portilla, 1962, p. 07) The next major omen was the seventh which was that men, who worked at Lake Mexico, saw a dark-feathered bird that resembled a crane and brought the bird to Montezuma who was full of dread and wonder. The first time Montezuma looked into the mirror of the bird’s he saw stars of the sign if Gemini and three stars of Taurus, which are said to be a bad omen and the second time he looked into it he saw a large sum of armed warrior accompanied by horses. So with these omens the Aztecs civilization was already at their peak and declining before the Spanish…

    • 1296 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Anderson also shared his views of Miguel Leon-Portilla’s book The Broken Spears. According to Arthur J.O. Anderson even though Miguel Leon-Portilla’s book is mostly of the defeat, the chaos, and grief the Aztecs endured, it is also a story that wanted to remind Spain of their debt they owe to the Aztecs . In my opinion, I also felt that this story was written to make the Spanish aware of their dark history and chaos they brought to ancient Mesoamerica. The book is written in the Aztec perspective and it depicts the Spanish as greedy, careless men who tried to annihilate any trace of Mesoamerican culture and tried to enforce their own way of life. So I do agree with Anderson and feel that the Spanish do owe a huge debt to the natives of Mesoamerican. Anderson also discussed how many natives after the conquest of Mexico were taught by Spanish Francian friars to read and write Spanish and Latin as well as to put their native language into Latin. Unos annles de la nacion Mexicana written in 1528 put native accounts written in Nahuatl with Spanish translation from the Franciscan fathers into one source. The Broken Spears included writings which traced back to the first transliterations such as Unos annles de la nacion Mexicana or The Codex Florentino and many other accounts. Anderson deeply appreciated the energy, artistry and poetry that went in Miguel Leon-Portilla’s book. He felt that Leon-Portilla selected a decent background of the Aztec culture and used effective sources that told the descriptions of the natives very well. He felt that the reader would find Leon-Portilla’s work to be interesting, accurate, and useful to…

    • 796 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Best Essays

    Wright, Ronald. “Aztec Resistance.” Stolen Continents: the “New World” through Indian eyes. Boston: Houghton, Mifflin, 1992. 144-160. Print.…

    • 1420 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Best Essays
  • Good Essays

    In every historical event there tends to be conflicting sides, each member has their own point of view based on a plethora of statistics. These statistics include but are not limited to, socio-economic classes, race, geographical boundaries, gender, etc. When two cultures interact for the first time there is bound to be some discrepancies over what truly occurred. These discrepancies are portrayed quite well through Bernal Diaz’s The Conquest of New Spain and The Broken Spears: The Aztec Account of the Conquest of Mexico, either side showed similarities, but at the same time they showed even more metamorphoses, making it nearly impossible to say either account holds more water than the other. The Aztec and Diaz agreed on two major points, the high ranking of Montezuma/Motecuhzoma and the accommodations the Spaniards were given, while variances included the light in which the Spaniards were depicted, and the motivation for the journey to Mexico.…

    • 1295 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Bernal Diaz Del Castillo

    • 1248 Words
    • 5 Pages

    As a conquistador under the command of Hernán Cortes, Bernal Diaz witnessed some of Latin America’s most interesting and least chronicled history. He was fortunate enough to be one of a select few Europeans to experience the Aztec empire at its height and to visit Tenochtitlan prior to its downfall. In an era where personal accounts of the historical occurrences are almost nonexistent, Bernal Diaz’s The True History of the Conquest of New Spain provides virtually the only window into this period. As a result, his text has become the most significant historical document concerning the Spanish conquest of Mexico. Perhaps the most poignant excerpt from The True History of the Conquest of New Spain is Diaz’s detailed description of his first impressions of the Aztec capital and emperor Montezuma.…

    • 1248 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Better Essays

    Broken Spears

    • 1475 Words
    • 6 Pages

    “The Broken Spears” is a collection of many accounts of the destruction of Mexico by…

    • 1475 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Bibliography: Clendinnen, Inga. "Fierce and Unnatural Cruelty: Cortes and the Conquest of Mexico" from Stephen Greenblatt ed. New World Encounters. University of California Press, 1993.…

    • 2687 Words
    • 11 Pages
    Good Essays