Preview

Assess the Claim That Edward the Confessor Gave Too Much Influence to the Normans

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
819 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Assess the Claim That Edward the Confessor Gave Too Much Influence to the Normans
Assess the claim that Edward the Confessor gave too much influence to the Normans.
In my answer I will explain how each point, argument and source etc. affects how Edwards influence upon the Normans reached or maintained a high or low point within this time period. I will also say how these pieces of information are for and against the Influence towards the Normans.
We firstly know that Edward Was born in England but raised in Normandy thus meaning that Normandy could have first acquired a taste upon him meaning that he would prefer it to England. At this time there were many Viking raids going on within England. Sweyn took the throne in 1013 but later died in 1014 thus Aethlred sent Edward back to his ambassadors. Aethlred died in 1016 making Edmund Ironside (Edwards’s half brother) take up the fight against Cnut (Sweyn’s son) He also died leaving Edward to go into exile with his brother and sister, but his mother married Cnut even after all he had done possibly making an even bigger hatred for anything or anyone to do with England.
This is when Edward spent quarter of a century in exile within Normandy helping charters within Normandy signing them as potential kings of England. The man’s names were William of Jumièges, Robert I, Duke of Normandy. He also received support in Normandy during this time from his sister, Godgifu, who was married to Drogo of Mantes, count of Vexin. These two Normans along with Edward invaded England to get Edward on the throne but this did not work. He also received support from a small amount of continental abbots in particular Robert, abbot of the Norman abbey of Jumieges. He would later become Edwards Archbishop of Canterbury.
There is little amount of Norman influence during Edwards return to England. Harthacnuts death on the 8th of June, 1042 meant that Edward could succeed the throne but would need help which he received from the likes of Earl Godwin of Wessex. He also received of popularity from the people within London even

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    In 1016, Cnut of Denmark invaded England. He eradicated all opposition in a pogrom in Winter 1017, and ruled thereafter with a combination of Danes and newly promoted English Earls who profited from the Danish Conquest. Edward (the Confessor) fled to his father-in-law in Normandy. He finally regained the throne in 1042.…

    • 9305 Words
    • 38 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The book 1066 The Year of the Conquest by David Howarth is an overview of one of the most important years in England’s history. At the start of 1066 the death of King Edward would spark a series of events that would eventually lead to the changes in England. Throughout the book it discusses this dramatic year and all these events that took place from various different perspectives. These stories are from contemporary sources from all sides of the conflict explaining their perspective of what was happening during this time. As one might expect, the people living through this will obviously form bias opinions based on where they are from. Howarth does a great job of staying neutral, giving him the ability to tell every story as it is while also adding his own personal insight. In addition to the various perspectives, he does a great job of bringing forth a historic event and not holding it to today’s standards.…

    • 896 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Throughout this essay I will explain’ how significant money was in causing henry VIII to break with Rome`. Henry VIII is one of the most famous kings in English history. He was the second Tudor monarch and was known for having six wives. His break with Rome and the Roman Catholic Church established the Church of England. The break with Rome involved two of his six wives Catharine of Argon and Anne Boleyn. There were four main causes of the break with Rome which power played a large role in causing Henry VIII to split with Rome, along with the other causes Love, Faith and money.…

    • 1099 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    When Edward VI died in 1483, there was debate as to who was most suited to take up his position on the throne. It has been argued that Richard, Duke of Gloucester had himself set on usurping the throne from the rightful heir Edward V, as soon as his brother died. Others argue that it was never the case that his immediate wishes were to seize the throne; actions after his brother’s death led him to this decision. There is evidence for and against to support the principal statement.…

    • 926 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Source B is a historians summary of the events surrounding Lady Jane Grey’s brief reign. It begins to state how towards the end of Edwards reign he and Northumberland were very aware that…

    • 1539 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Why Is Robert 1 Important

    • 586 Words
    • 3 Pages

    The English king Edward 1 had passed away before he could have a final…

    • 586 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Richard, Duke of Gloucester always detested his brother Edward IV after his secret marriage to Elizabeth Woodville, as he was made to look a fool by him when he found out they was married. Furthermore, when society found out of this marriage, this almost put Gloucester at an advantage because in that century, the King was supposed to marry a person that would influence the Kingdom in a good way, not out of love. Nevertheless, Because of this, Gloucester revealed that it was rumoured that Edward IV was already married, when he was got married to Elizabeth Woodville. For this reason, the marriage was deemed illegitimate, thus making Edward V’s inheritance of the throne illegitimate. This was a very strong move from Gloucester, and ultimately, because of this, he gained the throne, and the power to…

    • 723 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The main reason why the Norman’s won was due to Harold’s death. After he died the Saxon’s lost all momentum,…

    • 407 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Best Essays

    Henry V made a significant impact on the outcome of the Hundred Years War. Henry V shifted the focus of the war to the north of France; the areas of Normandy and Brittany were now a central focus instead of lands close to Gascony in southern France. He was the first king to successfully conquer all of northern France and beyond, and not stopping at conquering, but securing permanent fixtures to ensure that his occupation would remain unchallenged. Henry V’s most important accomplishment was that of the creation of the treaty of Troyes, according to C.T. Allmand, “This was the most important treaty of the Hundred Years War”. This treaty secured the French crown for the English, achieving the goal Edward III possessed when he first invaded France.…

    • 3238 Words
    • 13 Pages
    Best Essays
  • Good Essays

    Edward IV, king of England, died suddenly and prematurely without an obvious cause in April 1483 aged only 40 years. Edward IV had been a strong king after 1471, and very much able to control the rival factions between the Yorks & the Lancaster’s, but his death opened up a Yorkist family feud. After the sudden kings death the throne should have passed smoothly to his son of Elizabeth Woodville; Edward V, who was aged twelve at the time. Edward V could rule with the help of a selected protector and council but things never work out to be simple. Edward IV’s death caused a political crisis in England for a number of reasons.…

    • 894 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    In 1470 Edward IV’s rule was challenged by the former monarch that he had usurped, Henry VI, and one of the key reasons as to why he was able to overcome this challenge was due to his popularity as king. Edward had proved to be an able king who was also young, strong and handsome, which is severely juxtaposed to the monarch he had usurped, as Henry VI was old, a less than capable ruler and thought to be insane. This meant that not only his original usurpation of Henry in 1461 was considered more acceptable to England’s population as it was most likely going to better the country; it also meant that Henry’s usurpation of Edward in 1470 was especially unfavourable with the population. Another reason why Edward was able to overcome his challenge of usurpation was at that time France was very unpopular with England, which is unsurprising as it is said that ‘England’s national hobby was going to war with France’, and Henry VI’s wife, Margaret of Anjou was the French kings niece. This marriage alone would be enough to make Edward appear more favourable with the general population; however it seemed likely that if Edward had not usurped, an alliance between the two countries would proceed, which only served to support Edward’s campaign to get back on the throne. Nonetheless, the most damaging factor to the position of the opposition is most likely the circumstances that the Lancastrian house found themselves in as with the deaths of both their key supporter, the Earl of Warwick, at the Battle of Barnet and of the Lancastrian heir, Edward, Prince of Wales at Tewkesbury, the Lancastrian position was no longer considered viable. The popularity of Edward IV was not repeated with Richard III however, and this combined with the fact he usurped a king that was showing great…

    • 1818 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Had the Anglo-Saxons coordinated a country-wide rebellion, by sheer numbers they may have been able to take back control of England and instate Edgar the Atheling, who had a strong claim to the throne, as the new King. Instead, the Anglos Saxons revolted in different regions at different times, allowing William to systematically stop each one, rather than be overwhelmed by many going on at roughly the same time all over the country, which allowed him to gain control over each region one by one. Another problem that the Anglo-Saxons faced, which made it easy for William to gain control, was that although they had gained foreign support from the Danes, during the East Anglian rebellion in 1070, they weren’t very loyal, and were easily bought off by William as he realised they were an important factor in the rebellion. This was a massive loss, as the Danish support meant the English could receive reinforcements, and meant William would be distracted, as they were set to attack in the north, away from Ely, in a hope to stretch William’s…

    • 1369 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Richard II was referred to “true count of Roen” by Glaber. The perspectives of the French can be seen accepting of the Norman leaders for legitimizing their power through religion and politics. Richard II emphasis on recording history of the house is important in building a cultural identity. He commissioned Dudo of St. Quentin to write the history. His work is regarded by most historians as unreliable in some facets of early Normandy, due to his commission of illustrating the Christian morals of Rollo and William Longsword. Richard II was able to build alliances through the marriage of his sister Emma to Ethelred of Wessex. This marriage proved key to Richard II’s grandson, William’s, claim to the throne of England. Through his marriage, he created an alliance with Brittany with the acceptance of the Duke of Brittany’s sister. His religious interest through his support Robert II the Pious, King of the Franks. His biggest contribution to Norman Monasticism was his role in persuading Cluniac reformer, William of Volpiano, to bring monks to settle at his church called Fecamp. By attracting this prestigious figure to his land he was able to build a respected establishment of monasteries. This establishment led to religious ties to the feudal system along with a growing connection between the Catholic…

    • 1281 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Richard

    • 861 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Edward IV, king of England, died suddenly and prematurely at Windsor castle – perhaps from a stroke, or peritonitis or even a chill caught while on a fishing trip – in April 1483 aged only 40 years. He had enjoyed a relatively successful reign, by the standards of the day, restoring peace after the disordered period of Lancastrian rule and providing his subjects with some much needed stability. Edward IV had been a strong king after 1471, able to control the rival noble factions, but his death opened up a destructive, disastrous Yorkist family feud. The throne should have passed smoothly to his son; Edward V. This however didn’t happen due to his brother, Richard duke of Gloucester wanting the power; Edward changed his will on his death bed so his wishes weren’t clear; his marriage to Elizabeth Woodville. On his death a bitter family feud was started.…

    • 861 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Fling

    • 583 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Edward V was the great-great-great-grandson of Edward III and the son of Edward IV, the previous king, therefore making him have a strong claim to the throne. When his father died he was only 12 years old and so people weren’t sure if he was ready to be king, or if he needed someone to watch over him. His uncle Richard Duke of Gloucester- later known as Richard III- was made protector and guardian of Edward which meant he partly controlled what Edward did. He wasn’t on the throne for very long and so didn’t have much of an influence during his reign. There was a brief conflict with the Woodville’s who were adamant they had more of a claim to the throne, but Richard had them arrested. Richard spread a rumour that Edward V was illegitimate to the throne which was why he needed a protector, however once Richard took the throne both Edward and his brother disappeared in the tower of London and were never seen again.…

    • 583 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays