top-rated free essay

Article Review

By ar66toy May 05, 2013 665 Words
Research Article Review
Ackil, J.K., & Zaragoza, M.S. (2011). Forced fabrication versus interviewer suggestions: Differences in false memory depend on how memory is assessed. Applied Cognitive Psychology, 25(6), 933-942. The goal of the current research was to compare incidence of false memories resulting from suggestive interviews involving forced fabrication with those involving exposure to misleading suggestions by the interviewer. Type of fictitious post-event information was manipulated within Pp (FF vs MS) and then the effects were compared relative to controls across several different retrieval and test conditions in two experiments. For the first experiment Ackil and Zaragoza found their participants in a general psychology class at a small liberal arts institution in rural Southern Minnesota who received extra credit for their participation. The total number of participants was 268. There was random assignment in this first experiment 136 Pp one week retention condition; 80 warned, 56 were not and 132 Pp two week retention condition; 76 warned, 56 were not. The method was: All Pp watched the same “eyewitness event,” a 9 minute excerpt from the film “Looking for Miracles.” All participants were all exposed to the same set of true and false event questions. For some false event questions Pp forced to generate the response which is considered a force fabrication condition. For other false event questions Pp read response aloud which is considered a misleading suggestion condition. Between experiments hypothesis was: there will be differences in false memory reports depending on the type of test, source recognition vs. narrative recall. Dependent variable: Extent to which Pp misattributed forcibly fabricated and suggested items to the witnessed event by answering affirmatively to questions on source recognition test. Measure of false memory was source recognition test, which encourages Pp to retrieve source specific info and tends to decrease false memory errors. Independent variables: Retention interval (one week or two weeks) and warning (warned that interviewer had asked false questions or not). The hypothesis: forced fabrication and suggested items will produce false memories for participants across variables (warned vs. not warned, 1 week vs. 2 week interval). The results did not show differences in false memory rates for subgroups. Warning alone nor verbal resistance alone became correlated with false memory rates. Memory for actual source of post event items was better for fabricated items than suggested ones. Although the experiment assessed time intervals and warnings, researchers found an unplanned factor of verbal resistance that needed further examination. For experiment two the method was the same as experiment except for a few exceptions. Every Pp forced to fabricate 3 items and read aloud 6 suggested answers to 6 false event questions. All Pp received a free recall test and all Pp were tested after a 2 week retention interval and all received a pre-test warning. There was only 69 students this time but taken from the same participants in experiment one but randomly. The dependent variable: The incidence of forcibly fabricated and suggested item that Pp gave to the witnessed event. The independent variable: False item type (Fabricated, suggested, and control) and resistance (Pp resisted or did not). Hypothesis: Forced fabrication will lead to greater false memory recall than misleading suggestions. The results for experiment two were the mean proportion of post-event items falsely recalled as a function of post-event item type(items fabricated with verbal resistance, items fabricated without verbal resistance, and suggested items). Items fabricated without verbal resistance were typically accompanied by more passive forms of resistance. Pp (when given warnings and verbal resisting) was more likely to freely recall their forced fabrication than those items that had been suggested (led to greater false memory). I found this article to be very interesting. I learned that the evidence from this study indicates that predictions about suggestive interview techniques resulting in false memory should look at the context or conditions under which the memory is assessed. I also learned that misinformation in interviews leads witnesses to false memory.

Cite This Document

Related Documents

  • Article Review Guideline

    ...EDER 893 Journal Article Review – Reading and Understanding Journals Choose the article that most interests you from among the abstracts listed. Then, acquire read, and evaluate the article as if you were reviewing it for publication. Use the following questions in addition to manuscript review guidelines for journals to direct your evaluation...

    Read More
  • Article Review Assignment

    ...things that make a paper a good paper…Today I will be discussing three of the most important… Intro paragraph—Purpose—and Conclusions. The opening paragraph…or intro paragraph in any type of writing…whether it is a novel…an essay…newspaper or magazine article or whatever it may be… it is a major part of any type of writing. ...

    Read More
  • How to Write a Book Review

    ...Writing Resources Writing a Book Review View in PFD Format A critical book review is a thoughtful discussion of a text's contents, strengths, and limitations. A book review should reflect your capacity to read critically and to evaluate an author's arguments and evidence. Compose your review as you would any essay, with an argument su...

    Read More
  • Review of Bill by Vern Myers

    ...Michael Hemmingson 9700 Gilman Drive PMB 241 La Jolla, CA 92093 michaelhemmingson@yahoo.com approx. 2,300 words My Review of Bill by Vern Myers Michael Hemmingson Bill: A Novella. Vern Myers. NY: Pelican Publishing. 102 pp. Cloth, $17.95. Reviewed by Gerald Bass To start, I would like you to know that I a...

    Read More
  • Performance Review Paper

    ...BOTOX UK LTD PERFORMANCE REVIEW FORM Date of Review …17th April 2013…….. Period Covered ……Oct 2012 - March 2013…… Name of Manager …Tessa Thomas… Name of employee …Angela Marraner…………. Job Role of Employee ……Senior Customer Sales Advisor………………………...

    Read More
  • Exploration of a Journal Article

    ...Exploration of a Journal Article In Sociology Lanika K. Jones Professor Robert Hammes Introduction to Sociology May 4, 2013 The article I choose was by Amy E. Singer, Ph.D. “A Novel Approach: The Sociology of Literature, Children, Book and Social Inequality. While reading this article I saw that this was a primary review of an ex...

    Read More
  • psych journal review

    ...PSYC101 Journal Article Review Assignment - Part 1 Article Content Identification and Summary Due: 11:55pm ET Sunday at the end of Week 3 of the 8-week course term You may work on this assignment ahead of its deadline but may not submit it prior to Week 3. Points Possible: 60 OVERVIEW: This is Part 1 of a two-part assignment design...

    Read More
  • Restaurant Reviews: a Genre that Rants and Raves

    ...Restaurant Reviews: a Genre that Rants and Raves Introduction For the past century people have turned to restaurant reviews to guide their culinary experiences. More and more we see this genre becoming apparent in our every day lives. With iPhone apps like Urbanspoon, Yelp, Forkly, Foodspotting, and the New York Times, reading restaurant...

    Read More

Discover the Best Free Essays on StudyMode

Conquer writer's block once and for all.

High Quality Essays

Our library contains thousands of carefully selected free research papers and essays.

Popular Topics

No matter the topic you're researching, chances are we have it covered.