Preview

Analysis Of Up Ghost River By Ed Metatawabin

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
976 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Analysis Of Up Ghost River By Ed Metatawabin
Teaching an entire generation that their way of life was an abomination, as Ed Metatawabin was taught in the Canadian residential school system, allowed indigenous peoples to be marginalized by the rest of Canadian society; thus creating a clear imbalance of power between cultures so that First Nations lacked the support they needed to progress as a community.

The dehumanization that the St. Anne’s residential school students were subjected to filled them with self hatred directed towards their traditional lifestyle. The St. Anne’s staff tasked themselves with killing the indian the Cree children by forcing religion, language and names upon their students. In the autobiography Up Ghost River by Edmund Metatawabin, Ed recalls how the name
…show more content…
Even in present day Aboriginal issues are often a mere afterthought for the majority of Canadians; during Ed’s early years it was accepted for society to scorn Canada’s indigenous peoples. In the novel, when Ed attempts to free himself from Mike Pasko, his rapist, when Ed considers informing the police he thinks, “Had I been born in a different body with a different history, I might have gone to the police…but I wasn’t wemistikoshiw. Our stories were different” (Metatawabin, 127). Ed had seen firsthand how the RCMP treated his people; he had such an apprehension about going to the authorities that he chose to stay trapped in a house with a sexual predator who abused him on a daily basis. The Canadian Government created a widely accepted dogma that indigenous peoples must be subjected to strict regulations for the betterment of Canadian society. At one point in the novel Ed informs his father of his plans to lobby against the government in order to improve the autonomy that Cree leaders would have within their own reserve. Ed’s father mentions how he had attempted to dispute the Indian Agent on housing rights regarding the reserve and he explained to Ed: “Remember when I tried to fight the Indian Agent on housing?...The Indian Agent didn’t think much of the idea. Said it wasn’t my land to begin with” (Metatawabin, 269). the Minister whose job is to supervise the government affairs with Canadian Indigenous Peoples has a lack of apathy for the well-being of those living on

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Series of traumatic events occurred while residential school were running, but it left a scars on aboriginal people forever. As an aboriginal women I get a lot of understanding from Pauline Johnsons “As it was in the beginning”, growing up on the Six Nation Reserve and having meet people who have experienced the same things as Pauline. Residential schools were open between the 1980’s and the 1990’s and the last school did not close until 1996, the year I was born. Pauline writes, “No more, no more the tepees; no more the wild stretch of prairie, the intoxicating fragrance of the smoke-tanned buckskin; no more the bed of buffalo hide, the soft, silent moccasin; no more the dark faces of my people, the dulcet cadence of the sweet Cree tongue”…

    • 245 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    She showed how her knowledge from Western schooling pushed her to learn more about Indigenous knowledge and how both forms can have a strong impact on the world. Also, it took a vast amount of strength for Gehl to overcome her position in society according to the Indian Act and fight against the government to achieve for herself, the good life. In this book, many topics are touched upon that bring to surface the problems within the Canadian government and the issues the government imposes onto the Aboriginal population. Lynn Gehl in Claiming Anishinaabe: Decolonizing the Human Spirit proves that sexism within the Indian Act of 1876, racialization and discrimination, colonialism through unfair treaties and denial of traditional Aboriginal land are all issues that affect the lives of the Aboriginal community and make their struggle towards Aboriginal status and mino-pimadiziwin much greater. In my analysis, I will show how racialization, discrimination, and colonialism has affected the Indigenous community and how sexism has both directly affected women in the Aboriginal community and Gehl in the process of achieving Indian…

    • 763 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Looking at the effects of Canada’s colonial past, the chapter of Monchalin’s textbook The Impact of Assimilation discusses the history of residential schools and the impact that they have had on Canada’s Indigenous community. The purpose of these horrendous and unethical establishments was to eradicate the culture, traditions, and language of Indigenous peoples. This was done by removing Indigenous children from their homes, denying them communication with their families while forcing them to adopt the beliefs of Christianity. Beginning in 1920, it became compulsory that all Indigenous children from the age of seven to fifteen must attend school however; this did not necessarily mean that they were required to attend a residential school. Though…

    • 212 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Two-Spirit Youth Speak Out!

    • 10414 Words
    • 42 Pages

    Acknowledgments……………………………….……………………………… Introduction……………………………………………………………………… Inter-generational Effects of the Residential School System on First Nations People………………………………………………………………….. Two-spirit History……………………………………………………………….. Analysis and Recommendations of the Needs Assessment Tool (NAT)……

    • 10414 Words
    • 42 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Yellow Quill Crisis

    • 211 Words
    • 1 Page

    However, it is widely accepted that the cultural genocide and social disruption perpetrated over generations through displacement, discriminatory legislation such as the Indian Act, and federal programs such as the residential school system created enduring hardships among Aboriginal peoples and hindered the re-establishment of social networks and the development of stable…

    • 211 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Better Essays

    These schools lasted from the 1880 up to the end of the 20th century with its primary objective of educating aboriginal children and take the Indian out of the child. This strategy was very damaging as children were separated from their families for extended periods and were prohibited from all cultural aspects of their aboriginal heritage. Children were severely punished for wrong doings and were subjected physical, psychological and sexual abuse. Residential schools damaged aboriginal culture and disrupted families all across Canada. The damaging effect has carried on for several generations and still exists in modern Canadian society. Since the young aboriginals were taken away at a young age, they did not have the nurturing from their families and lacked knowledge and skill on how to raise their own families. The environment of not knowing how to raise a family is very cyclical and continues to have devastating effects in today’s aboriginal communities. The implementation of residential schools was very devastating and was a form of cultural genocide (Hanson, 2011).The Canadian Government has tried resolving the issue by paying a 1.9 billion compensation package to the thousand of aboriginals affect by the Residential School system. Although the compensation budget and a formal apology by the prime minister is a kind gesture for Canada’s realization for the harm its…

    • 1300 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Hurt, shame, humiliation, and pain. The struggle for Indigenous people is a continuous cycle of abuse and one of broken hopes and dreams. In Deborah Miranda’s tribal memoir, Bad Indians, she uses her narrative along with primary sources and related stories to reassess previous knowledge about how the lives of American Indians were affected by colonialism. Through the use of tone, point of view, and counter discourse, Miranda sheds light on how the gender-based violence and sexual abuse that accompanies colonialism, despite the notion that settlers were following Christian ideals, shaped a new Indigenous society that tore their culture apart and led to a mosaic of their broken identities. By creating a distinction between historically dominant…

    • 1169 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Best Essays

    Métis Residential Schools

    • 2013 Words
    • 9 Pages

    The history of the Métis and Residential Schools is not new. For a century, the mutual lives of the Métis children were controlled by the missionaries and the Catholic Church, and became wrapped up in Federal Government policies. The Metis Residential School experience was similar to the Aboriginal one; that of social exclusion and mental and physical abuse. The procedures that were created for the Métis in Residential Schools harshly exposed how bureaucrats felt about the social order of the Métis’ station in the New Canada. The Residential Schools took part in creating a lower class structure for the Métis, which separated them even further from their First…

    • 2013 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Best Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    This book was written by people who were either in the Kamloops Indian Residential School or got to see it second hand. These stories of the schools were told by Aboriginal People to have a record of how the Residential Schools went for them, not by how other people made it seem. These horrific stories told build my argument in my essay of how improper and inhumane these schools were for people who did nothing to deserve it. The torture they went through and have had the courage to tell their stories is inspiring. These people wanted people to know what happened so history would not be repeated; they also wanted to let people know that although they had to go through those years, they survived as a whole. It is important to recognize that this…

    • 242 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    The government of Canada severely mistreated its aboriginal population according to the assimilation and residential schools, The White Paper and The National Indian Brotherhood, The James Bay Project and land claims, The Calder Case, The Mackenzie River Pipeline Issue, enfranchisement, The Meech Lake Accord, The Charlottetown Accord, Oka confrontation and Ipperwash, Ontario confrontation.…

    • 1216 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    The purpose of the schooling system was to remove all aspects of the Indigenous race and culture. Unfortunately, students had their hair cut, dressed in uniforms, given new names, and were not able to speak their native language. If any rule was broken, students were harmed physically and sexually. For example, a needle would be shoved into a Native Canadian student’s mouth if they spoke their own language. Students were also beaten and strapped, even tied down to beds, being abused sexually and physically for not obeying a leader's orders. Carole Dawson, an Indigenous Residential school student, states that the worst part was, “[p]robably the abuse. It's not only my own abuse. I saw the abuse of others” (109). Young children witnessed abnormal treatment of others, and they also experienced inhumane behaviour. In addition, escaping was common in Residential schools however, the punishment was severe. Many Indigenous students that attempted to escape Residential schools and succeeded, ended up dying from starvation, frostbite, or hypothermia. In fact, over nine-thousand Indigenous Canadians died from their futile efforts of leaving Residential schools. Celia Haig-Brown quoted a female residential school survivor as saying, “[t]hey said they were going to give me a real short haircut for my punishment” (qtd. In Quinlan et al. 68). Furthermore, Indigenous children were not able to see their own families again, the isolation affects the students emotionally, even to this day. Ingrid Annault states “[t]he worst part, besides the second thing of being there was not having your family, not having anybody to hug you and tell you they loved you” (107). A child's innocence is torn and damaged once they are separated from their family. The closest element Native children had from seeing their family was “a mere wave in a dining room” (Erin Hanson) however,…

    • 1368 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Better Essays

    When residential schools opened the Aboriginal people were told that they would get the educational rights that they had requested for their communities. Aboriginal leaders wanted to understand and learn more about the western culture that they felt were important. Regrettably, they did not prepare for the serious of unfortunate events that would come from these schools. “Though the Indians cooperated with these first residential schools and helped finance them, they soon recognized that their educational objectives were very different from those of the government and missionaries. The official policy of assimilation demanded a complete rejection of anything Indian.” (A.Grant pg. 59) When the aboriginal people found out that the school were set up for assimilation and…

    • 1553 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    However Canada tries to hide a dirty little secret, and that happens to be residential school. Residential schools came to into effect in the early 1870s and the last one was not close until 1996.("The Residential School System."). As mentioned earlier, the charter was no created until 1982, this means Canadians were breaking the first section of the charter, which are the fundamental freedoms ("Rights and Freedoms in Canada."). Residential schools were designed to "kill the Indian in the child"("The Residential School System."). Contrary to what the public believed back in the 1870s, these schools were not always the best for the children, they were taking from their families and force to follow a religion and language that was not their own.("The Residential School System.") Canadian aboriginals were subjected to all kinds of abuse while attending these schools. ("The Residential School System.") Emotional, Psychological, physical and most importantly sexual abuse were found in almost every school.("The Residential School System.") Many Canadians are under the notion that residential schools were designed to teach aboriginal children about catholic religion, this is not the truth.The truth is that residential schools were also underfunded compared to the white schools.("The Residential School System.") and although the children were taught Christianity, the children were groomed to became house maids or farmers.("The Residential School System.") The majority of children who were sent away at the age of 18 only had a fifth-grade education. ("The Residential School System.")this type of Trauma had to be endured by many generations of Canadian aboriginals. The so call " free" education came with a deadly price.In 1907, medical inspector P.H. Bryce reported that 24 percent aboriginal children were dying in residential homes, this number did not counter in the number of death of children…

    • 587 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Residential School System

    • 1896 Words
    • 8 Pages

    Williams, which discusses the use of segregation of First Nations people and placing them into separate educational institutions in order to assimilate them into society, namely the Residential School System. As well as the abuse within, and mental illness caused by, that system. The paper also looks at the educational policies inflicted on the indigenous people during the time of state formation/nation building, and its ties to it. There is a strong point made on how education was the main tool used to assimilate young first nations people because it forced the acquisition of the conquerors language and customs . The segregation and assimilation plan put forth by the government allowed for the construction of the residential school system, which separated young first nations children from their family and therefore from their influence. They were forced to learn the British way of life, punished for using their own languages, and were taught that they were inferior to the British . This system put forth by the Canadian government was all in an attempt to rid itself of the ‘other’ in their society, and in doing so chose to manipulate the education system for their own agenda. This system, whose last school did not close until 1996, caused widespread mental health problems among the children who survived it which is an impact that has lasted for generations . Canada has always focused on the idea of education for citizenship…

    • 1896 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    In the 19th century, the Canadian government came up with an idea to start assimilating Aboriginal peoples into the dominant culture. This meant taking 150,000 children away from their homes and communities and placing them into residential schools. The assumption of Aboriginal peoples culture being peculiar, was greatly believed by the government and many people. The cruel saying “beat the Indian out of them” unfortunately became true, because that is exactly what took place in residential schools. Being exposed to many awful ways of abuse, including mental, emotional, and physical, caused the men and women who attended residential schools to be struggling further on in their lives, specifically regarding cultural practises, and parenting.…

    • 1023 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays