Top-Rated Free Essay

An Analysis of James Knustler’s Globalization’s Time Is Up

Good Essays
Globalisation’s Time is Up Critique

In James Knustler’s “Globalisation’s Time Is Up” the author tries to prove how the world is drastically changing due to the lack of available oil and energy sources. James believes “Today’s transient global economic relations are a product of very special transient circumstances, namely relative world peace and absolutely reliable supplies of cheap energy.” James’s arguments, although appearing sound and related to his thesis, is unfortunately filled with a few contradictory statements that ends up cheapening his essay. For example, James says “The American Civil War hardly affected the rest of the world.” In his thesis statement though he clearly states the economic relation of the world is directly reliant, on relative world peace. I don’t think the American civil war that shaped the America we know today, could be so easily discarded as a small war with no impact on how the world is today. Another problem with his thesis statement is the lack of one factual piece of evidence that shows the direct correlation between times there has been turmoil or expensive supplies of cheap energy and globalisation has suffered from it. Even though this might be true, a well written essay must back up arguments with factual evidence. Something James could have done to do this, is by showing concise data. James could of showed the direct correlation to when one of the above factors changes (World Peace, Cheap Energy) globalisation as a result also changed.
What James, is trying to state in his article is that the absence of cheap energy or relative world peace will lead to the extinction of globalization, as the world has experienced before in 1914 during the First World War. However from 1870 – 1914 the world saw an overall economic boom attributed to a number of factors specifically; relative stability, efficiency in production, coal and steam power and innovations in finance. During the first collapse, the world was transitioning from coal to oil, which had a major impact on global powers. This brought new power to some countries which were in position of such resources, and sent others searching for it. This was a determining factor of success in the First World War. Those who possessed it, or had access such as England and France ended up winning the war. These volatile conditions are again present in the world, as countries enter an unknown period beyond oil. The conditions we enjoy today will no longer be sustainable, from the car dependent suburban infrastructures to the big-box chain stores. These luxuries can be seen as the greatest waste of resources in the world’s history. On top of the economic uncertainties we face a new race of arms as nations compete to control the last of the oil deposits. China, who has prospered due to globalization, is dependent on oil resource and will seek it peacefully or otherwise. It also faces conflict in its international relations primarily with the United States, and also home grown problems such as environmental issues, and political turmoil. These present conditions are a sign of the demise of globalization. The world is on rout to major changes that will drastically change the way we currently operate.
The authors view on globalization is very bold, however lacks depth and authenticity. The article overall is very ambiguous and attempts to convince the reader by simply making statements and predictions without providing adequate analysis and proof. In his second paragraph, James states “Subtract either of these elements from the equation and you will see globalisation evaporate” James is referring to “Relative world peace” and “Cheap supplies of energy” There could be a correlation with these, but what James could have done to further fortify his argument, is an example of turmoil or expensive energy and how it made globalisation suffer.
Later on in the article James goes on to say “It all fell apart in 1914, and a new round of globalisation did not ramp up again until the mid-1960s.” This could have been the perfect time for James to state how there was a world war during the years he mentioned, and how globalisation suffered during these times, if they in fact even did.
Near the end of the article the author states how the remaining two-thirds of the oil are with people that want to destroy the US. The problem with this statement is that Saudi Arabia has the largest reserve of oil in the world and that the US is Saudi Arabia’s largest trading partner. For a country that is supposed to “resent the West” according to James, people would think that being the biggest trading partner with them would not be logical.
There is no denying the fact that the depletion of oil in this world is of grave concern, yet James used opinionated arguments for a factual subject. There are many things that were true in his article, but the way he chose to inform the reader would have been better put, if he had created sound arguments by showing factual data using real sources. Another major error that would have made this article a lot sounder is to make sure that there are no contradictory statements throughout the essay. Whenever there are contradictory statements in essay, it quickly threatens the credibility of the author. In this article, James clearly contradicted himself, when stating that the American civil war was not a big deal in the beginning of the essay thus creating doubt in the authors writing from the beginning.

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Title of Book - Jame Time For Bed Mom called Jame from kitchen and said its time to get ready for bed tomorrow is school. You need to take a bath and brush your teeth. Jame said but why ? I'm not sleepy yet. Mom replied Jame you may not know you are tired but you are. ( Illustration 1 Picture of mom talking to child) Then Jame said no I'm not mom, I am not tried I want to play some more. Mom replied you must go to sleep now because a good night's sleep makes you feel better in the morning…

    • 768 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Globalization’s Side Effects May.14. 2009 Discussing globalization’s side effects might not be appropriate without determining first what globalization is. Although everyone has his or her own definition and uses the term globalization in his or her own way, globalization…

    • 540 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Globalization’s Impact on Information Technology According to Carmel (2013), the impact globalization is having on the use of information systems in business is the need to transfer knowledge and information almost instantaneously anywhere in the world. This is because businesses are no longer isolated to just one location and, in order to stay ahead of the competition, accurate information needs to be disseminated quickly and securely. A business could start with the development of their product…

    • 321 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    continued onwards towards Europe is one of the oldest commercial links between countries. From China to Europe, people have done trade. Actually, the current way of globalization came up with the before the first outbreak of the First World War.’’ Since 1950, for example, the volume of world trade has increased by 20 times, and from just 1997 to 1999 flows of foreign investment nearly doubled, from $468 billion to $827 billion’’. (www.globalization101.org). Since the World War II, many governments have…

    • 1629 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    “The Fire Next Time” by James Baldwin was an interesting and very well written book. I found James Baldwin’s account of being black in America to be very honest and blunt. I related a lot with James and his relationship with the Christian Church. I understood his conflict with what he had been taught all his life to believe. I also in some ways felt like James was speaking to me as I was reading his letter to his nephew. I felt like James Baldwin was taking the words right out of my mouth when…

    • 513 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Over time have been enjoying Ta-Nehisi Coates’s writings. Not because he is a Black American but how excellent his essays and blog are in the world that is jammed with skilled critics who are led by ego and their awareness of certain ideas. He had a lot of hardships growing up in the streets of Baltimore. He had to do all he could to avoid all the evil that was served by the world to him. This has made him talk freely without fear of the various facts that need to be understood by the people and…

    • 1097 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Globalization China's global influence has grown tremendously since the turn of the new century. Now the second­largest economy in the world, its citizens are buying up consumer goods both domestically and overseas in record numbers. News reporter, Diane Sawyer, travels from Beijing to Shanghai exploring life in the Asian nation and the part the U.S. has played in shaping its economic initiatives. With an economic growth rate of ten percent per year, the goal of the Chinese government is to build the nation’s infrastructure…

    • 1914 Words
    • 1 Page
    Powerful Essays
  • Best Essays

    Globalization’s Impact on Management Styles MNGT 5000 Submitted to: Dr. Harvey C. Hutchison July 20, 2008 Myrtle Beach, South Carolina Abstract Globalization has had a very complex impact on management. Business leaders are finding themselves making frequent changes to their management strategies and styles to keep up with local as well as international competitors. This paper will give a definition of globalization as well as provide a description of the impact of globalization on…

    • 2408 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Best Essays
  • Good Essays

    “All the fears with which I had grown up, and which were now a part of me and controlled my vision of the world, rose up like a wall between the world and me” is an iconic line from the essay by James Baldwin, The Fire Next Time. Baldwin was, and still is, an icon for the black nation as struggles continue to unfold in American history. His personal narratives in the 1960s and 70s gave hope for the Civil Rights and gay liberation movement, since his experiences reflected much of the population fighting…

    • 722 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    relationship with God, and had his soul full of love by religion. But, he understood that not everyone in this country was living up to the loveable standards that the bible presents. James knew that a black person being treated equally in America was an impossible wish at the time, but he believed that the impossible could be made possible with hard work. James explained to his nephew in the introduction that he was born into a society that believed he was worthless, but infact he was anything…

    • 601 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays