Preview

American Sign Language Advantages

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1106 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
American Sign Language Advantages
According to Mellon et al. (2015), 10,000 deaf children are born in the United States each year. Of these infants, more than 95 percent are born to hearing parents (p. 781). Often times hearing parents view their deaf children as disabled and try to “fix” them by giving them a cochlear implant (a device that is surgically implanted into a person’s cochlea to help them perceive sounds), or by mainstreaming their child in the public school systems, forcing them to learn to lip-read and speak. I don’t think this is fair to the children. They should have the option to learn American Sign Language (ASL) because it introduces so many opportunities that they wouldn’t otherwise receive.
While it’s understandable that hearing parents want to be able
…show more content…
“A cochlear implant is a device that provides stimulation directly to the auditory nerve, bypassing damaged hair cells in the cochlea that prevent sound from reaching the nerve. An implant does not result in ‘restored’ hearing for the recipient but does allow him or her to perceive sounds” (Cochlear Implant, n.d.). There are many helpful aspects of cochlear implants such as gaining the capability to interpret sounds and being able to speak. However, the implants require a lot of maintenance. “Wearing a cochlear implant is a lifetime commitment, and requires the recipient to maintain and care for the implant” (Cochlear Implant, n.d.). In addition, “children often require years of extensive aural rehabilitation” (Cochlear Implant, n.d.). Not only is this procedure time consuming with the care and rehab required of the surgery, it is also very expensive, with costs exceeding $40,000 (Cochlear Implant, …show more content…
As Clason (2014) said, “learning language and cognitive development through ASL is a basic human right that should be protected and that choosing cochlear implants steers families away from learning ASL and embracing Deaf culture” (The Importance of Deaf Culture, n.d.). There is a lot of controversy regarding CIs in the Deaf community. Many Deaf people see people who got the surgery as someone who isn’t proud of being Deaf and were trying to “fix” themselves. Deaf people often make fun of them, saying that they were attempting to become like a hearing person and rejecting the Deaf

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Cochlear implants characterize progress and globalization because they are a technology which attempts to “cure” deafness. The study by Wheeler, Archbold, Gregory, Skipp (2007) concludes “Cochlear implantation is a relatively new procedure, which has already had significant impact on the lives of many profoundly deaf children and adults, in providing useful hearing to those unable to benefit significantly from hearing aids”. The Cochlear implant holds effect in how I interact with society, with out the Cochlear implant I would be profoundly deaf and there for feel too inadequate to socialize among others. The CI has also helped others to understand what…

    • 1284 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Four common characteristics of minorities that underpin affiliation are (1) the group shares a common physical or cultural characteristic such as skin color or language, (2) individuals identify themselves as members of the minority and others identify them in that way, (3) there is a tendency to marry within the minority, and (4) minority members suffer oppression. To a large extent, members of the Deaf minority also share a common language (ASL in the U.S.) and, because of their common physical characteristic, that language will never die out. On the second count, Deaf people do indeed identify themselves as culturally Deaf and, third, they marry Deaf nine times out of ten. Both Carlin`s and Luczak`s poems, for example, reflect the opposite oppression that members of the Deaf World experience. In some ways like the members of other language…

    • 675 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    I just think about when I become a mother and if my child was born deaf, I would want my child to receive cochlear implants so they would be able to hear. Furthermore, when watching Sound and Fury, I saw the struggles the Artinian family faced by being deaf. It was hard to communicate with others outside of the deaf community, there was a glass ceiling for jobs and they felt as if they were constantly being judged by society. I would not want to see my child go through the struggles they had to go through because they are deaf. As a parent, your role is to provide the best possible life that you can for your children. So if you have a chance to let your child hear, why would you not do it? With all of this in mind, I truly believe that the cochlear implant operation should be able to be performed on infants even though they are unable to give…

    • 456 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The first step to receiving a cochlear implant is evaluation. Before any surgery is done on the patient, they will study them and be sure that cochlear implants are the best choice for not only the patient, but for the family as well. The family of the patient has to be willing to communicate with the child and help them either work on or establish language and speech skills (Cochlear Implants for Kids.)…

    • 1588 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    The biggest controversy of the deaf community has been the topic of a cochlear implant. The debate is centered around the expense, risk and idea of the implants causing deaf people to distance themselves from the deaf community rather than emerging themselves. This is due to the cochlear implants ability to provide a sense of sound to the deaf individual. It is only used when a hearing aid is not strong enough to provide adequate function. The cochlear implant involves a lot of time to consider the procedure because of cost, risk, and being a part of the deaf community. In order to make a decision of getting a cochlear implant one must have background knowledge on how a cochlear works, hearing vs. deaf, benefits, risk and cost.…

    • 1447 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    4. Who are those without privilege? Why? Those who, due to the age, medical contraindications or the lack of parental consent, can not put themselves this implant. Because this deprives them of the opportunity to be like everyone else, to hear and communicate like people who do not have hearing problems.…

    • 1331 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    As one would expect, struggles to preserve sign language, drive automobiles, obtain employment in private and government sectors, access information, recognize American Sign Language, be treated equally, and preserve the right to determine their own destiny strengthened the cohesiveness of the Deaf community over the years. At the same time, the growing diversity within the Deaf community no longer provided consensus or universal views on issues related to educational placements and technological advancements such as cochlear implantation. It is too early to discuss these issues from a historical standpoint,…

    • 618 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Gm vs Ford

    • 1438 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Initially a Deaf child’s journey begins with family and starts at birth but it’s not till the deafness is detected that important decisions start to be made. Interactions with the child are important as are the ways the child is interacted with. Choices have to be made by the family that will result in how a child is educated and socialized. These most important family influences can greatly help in positive development of the child or the lack of it. Some decisions that have substantial impact are: How will the child be educated? The choice between institutional and hearing schools. Should we opt for cochlear implants? These are just a couple many important decisions and choices that are made by the parents or caregivers.…

    • 1438 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    It has both a strong positive support and a strong negative support. The cochlear implant was invented to help deaf people who became deaf later in life, but their use for deaf children became controversial. Some reasons why deaf people have a negative view on the cochlear implant are because of the following: one are the effectiveness and risks of the implant. Now although it has a 90 to 95percebt of hearing and language improvement the ricks are very dangerous. Inserting a cochlear implant destroys any residual hearing in the operated ear. Although the standard surgical risks of a cochlear implant are all quite rare. They include: bleeding, infection, device malfunction, facial nerve weakness, ringing in the ear, dizziness, and poor hearing result. One long term risk of a cochlear implant is meningitis which is an infection of the fluid around the brain. People don’t like cochlear implants because there is the conflict between those who view deafness as a physical impairment and those whose it as a valued part of cultural identity. So the deaf community worries that if people get the cochlear implant they will lose touch with their deaf culture. They feel as though they will want to be hearing so they will try so hard to be hearing and live like a hearing person not paying attention to their true deaf side. They also worry that since deaf people want to be hearing so much, hearing people won’t…

    • 674 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Cochlear Implant Culture

    • 1646 Words
    • 7 Pages

    For example, when the cochlear implant first appeared on the market, it was met with indifference from the Deaf community members rather than the enthusiasm that medical professions expected. This was because they did not feel they were lacking and did not see the need of a prosthesis to effectively communicate (Blume 61). However, as the cochlear implant became more prominent, was approved for children, and was increasing implanted in deaf children born to hearing parents, there was greater dissent. For example, when one hearing mother approached the Deaf community considering implanting her child, “certain members of the deaf community…their feelings were so angry and so hurtful…[the parents] were called child abusers…and butchers” (Christiansen and Leigh 365). Through the perspective of the cultural view, this reaction is understandable. Deaf individuals feel a great sense belonging and pride in their culture like other cultural minority groups. To them, getting the implant would be denying the unknowing child the opportunity to be part of the Deaf culture. Additionally, their anger and opposition to a device with a goal to rid of deafness is not surprising. Many of them saw the cochlear implant as a step towards the “death of deafness” and the abolishment of their community and way of life (Christiansen and Leigh 368). Therefore, many of those holding the cultural view showed…

    • 1646 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Jerry Hassell

    • 597 Words
    • 3 Pages

    How the contemporary world indiscriminately treats deaf people like normal people is not a random incidence. This justly humanitarian treatment is a product of continued battle for Deaf recognition and rights in terms of education, communication, socialization, community, employment, etc. by influential people, some are deaf themselves, whose Deaf advocacy…

    • 597 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    On Thursday 27.Oct,2016 We had an event about "Cochlear Implant.” As a beginning we watched a short documentary about a girl from deaf culture, her parents were also deaf and they didn’t use any aids to help them to hear, except, sign language; they were against any technology to help them. They kept saying to her “this who we are,” unlike them, she couldn't adapt. Then, she heard about cochlear implant, and she wanted to do it, but her father felt that his heart is broken, also he felt that she is very embarrassing for being deaf person. After a while, he started to accept the whole idea because she wants to do it badly. After that, they went to Chicago to meet a girl that did a cochlear implant because they want to explore the whole idea before doing the surgery, but unfortunately we did not complete the movie because Dr. Afaf started to give us the first lecture which was about introducing deaf culture who needs hearing aids, and what are the…

    • 388 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Sound And Fury Analysis

    • 1909 Words
    • 8 Pages

    In comparison, hearing people speak to communicate. Cochlear implants are controversial amongst the deaf community because they fear that the use of cochlear implants will threaten their established culture and sign language. DEAF SCHOLARThey fear a deaf child with an implant may choose to leave the deaf culture because they are ashamed of their true identity. This may inevitably cause low self-esteem and lack of self-acceptance. The deaf believe cochlear implantation exploits the idea that being deaf is wrong or a disability that needs to be “fixed,” which decreases their potential of living life to its highest potential. Deaf scholar This is a common view of hearing culture, but the deaf community disagrees. A critical aspect of the cochlear implant debate has to do with the concept of deafness and at how hearing people perceive those who are deaf. (Deaf scholar) The deaf community does not think that they have a disability to be cured. They fully embrace their inability to hear and they stress the importance of accepting yourself. DEAF SCHOLAR Those who are hearing assume that spoken language is essential, yet they fail to see the importance of ASL and to understand the needs of the deaf community kind of from perspective of deaf PERSPECTIVE OF DEAF The deaf community also fears cochlear implants will cause separation. When deaf children have the implant, they will likely be exposed to only spoken language and will never learn ASL. FROM DEAEF SCHOLAR Because a child with a cochlear implant may want to speak more often than use ASL, it could potential create a language barrier between the child and the parents. Cochlear implants separate deaf people from deaf culture because they have the ability to hear, whereas their peers do not. Because of this, the deaf community may reject the child as a part of their community. The hearing…

    • 1909 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Better Essays

    When a mother is having a child, she and the father are always expecting a perfect and healthy baby. They do not realize their child could have any complications. When the doctor comes back and tells the mother and father their child is deaf, they have a lot to think about: Should we get an implant for them? Or should we just live on with it and have the child sign? Most of the time, the parents choose living with it and having their child sign. Not only do parents teach their deaf children to sign, but also children that have full hearing capabilities too. Teaching children sign language has gotten very popular over the past 10 years. Parents find it very helpful with communicating with a child who is not able to speak or…

    • 1025 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Deaf In America

    • 811 Words
    • 4 Pages

    4,022,334 deaf citizens currently resign in the United States. There is a good deal of issues going on in the culture that many are unaware of. I recently read a book titled, Deaf In America Voices From A Culture, which covers the details of deaf culture. It goes from the life of deaf children and how they learn to different types of sign language. This sparked my interest in the things we don’t know or don’t realize about deaf issues and struggles. There is a wide variety of representation of the deaf in Hollywood, social media, and the deaf students in America. I’m sure you already know about these issues but this is to reinforce how important these are and how these issues affect us. Deaf citizens are a crucial member of our society and…

    • 811 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays