Dream Act Essay Example
Are we unfairly penalizing children of illegal immigrants, who had no say when
they were brought to this country? Should Americans have to pay for illegal immigrants
to become citizens? Dream Act stands for California Development, Relief and Education
for Alien Minors. The Dream Act would allow a specific group of illegal immigrants to
obtain state grants, community college waive fees, and legal permanent citizenship. To be
eligible for the Dream Act you have to have arrived in the United States under the age of
16; be under the age of 30 on the day of enactment; have lived in the U.S. for at least 5
years; graduate from a U.S. highschool or has obtained GED in U.S.; and served in the
military or attended college for at least 2 years. (NASFAA) I don’t think anyone should
be forced to pay for something or someone they are not going to benefit from.
One of the reasons I am against the Dream Act is that I think it would promote
illegal immigration. If the Dream Act is put into place, would-be illegal immigrants
would have more of a drive to get over the border. They now know that they can bring all
their children illegally into the U.S. and they could one day become citizens. Also, the
state will be giving funds to illegal residents that would otherwise be available to legal
residents.
My opponents would argue that the state has already set aside funds for the Dream
Act. Since there are funds set aside, it wouldn’t be taking away money from legal
residents. I would have to disagree that the state isn’t taking money from legal residents just
by setting aside funds. Even if they did have funds set aside, the funds would eventually
deplete and they would have to take from legal residents anyways. Where did the funds to
set aside come from in the first place? Tax payers.
A second reason I disagree with the Dream Act is that it acts like a draft for illegal
they were brought to this country? Should Americans have to pay for illegal immigrants
to become citizens? Dream Act stands for California Development, Relief and Education
for Alien Minors. The Dream Act would allow a specific group of illegal immigrants to
obtain state grants, community college waive fees, and legal permanent citizenship. To be
eligible for the Dream Act you have to have arrived in the United States under the age of
16; be under the age of 30 on the day of enactment; have lived in the U.S. for at least 5
years; graduate from a U.S. highschool or has obtained GED in U.S.; and served in the
military or attended college for at least 2 years. (NASFAA) I don’t think anyone should
be forced to pay for something or someone they are not going to benefit from.
One of the reasons I am against the Dream Act is that I think it would promote
illegal immigration. If the Dream Act is put into place, would-be illegal immigrants
would have more of a drive to get over the border. They now know that they can bring all
their children illegally into the U.S. and they could one day become citizens. Also, the
state will be giving funds to illegal residents that would otherwise be available to legal
residents.
My opponents would argue that the state has already set aside funds for the Dream
Act. Since there are funds set aside, it wouldn’t be taking away money from legal
residents. I would have to disagree that the state isn’t taking money from legal residents just
by setting aside funds. Even if they did have funds set aside, the funds would eventually
deplete and they would have to take from legal residents anyways. Where did the funds to
set aside come from in the first place? Tax payers.
A second reason I disagree with the Dream Act is that it acts like a draft for illegal