top-rated free essay

A Passage to India Essay 3

By 3925943 Apr 04, 2009 964 Words
A Passage to India
In this excerpt from the novel A Passage to India, the author explores several themes through the use of figurative language, linguistic features, and literary devices.

One theme is the triviality and evanescence of mankind’s order and plans when juxtaposed with the splendor and immutability of the universe. This comparison draws attention to itself when the narrator begins his description of the sky:

“Some kites hovered overhead, impartial, …and with an impartiality exceeding all, the sky”(39)

The chauvinism that is expressed in this scene is in direct contrast to the meaningless and unimportant conversations being held by the attendants of The Bridge Party. Here, this description of the sky and its immensity occurs right after Ronny ends his condescending analysis on the uselessness and paltriness of the non-British people assembled at the tragically named “Bridge Party”. The “Bridge Party” itself is a horrible misnomer for this awkward social gathering in which the bridge itself is nonexistent, as neither side trusts the other enough to even attempt a casual conversation, let alone build a bridge! This misnomer doubles as a pun, for Bridge is a card game that is played among the high aristocracy; it has no place in a colonial city in rural India. Yet, the narrator deliberately uses it to draw attention to the segregation mankind imposes upon itself and distance itself even further from the impartial beyond. The kites hover above mankind for they do not seek to create schisms and factions in their society. The sky’s “impartiality exceeds all” because it is one with space; it is constant throughout and completely incorporated as one unit into this universe. All this goes on above man’s world, yet he continues to criticize and conquer his fellow man in an effort to gain supremacy over all men. What is the value of domination over such a partial aspect of this universe? As the author contemplates the transcendence of the universe he abruptly switches to an incredibly mundane conversation held by the guest:

“…more impartial even than they? Beyond which again…

They spoke of Cousin Kate”(40)

This example of Bathos once again proves the narrator’s point and elucidates even further the triviality of the ongoing dialogue. The impartial skies and space serve purely to show the absurdity and pettiness of the conversations and divisions at “The Bridge Party”, and to contrast the values held by guests at the party with the impartiality of the universe.

A major portion in this excerpt is the personification of everything that was dysfunctional about the British Empire in Ronny and the hosts of the party. The glaring faults in the British Empire were seen by all, but admitted by few. The snobbish behavior exhibited by the hosts and the dismissive manner in which the locals and anyone of social ranking lower than theirs is discussed is appalling. This fault revolves around the hierarchical nature of power in British colonies and the influence of higher authorities in relegating or promoting people in a social class below their own. This introduces into the plot a theme of toadying. The Indian man who wants a favor goes to the British man, while the British man goes to his superior, and so on. All that this does is hollow out the system and erase any concept of mutual respect among the classes, instead introducing contempt and patronization. This is shown here:

“ Isn’t that so Mrs. Turton? “Absolutely True,” said the great lady…

assured of her approbation, Ronny continued.”(39)

This incredible exchange epitomizes the point the author tries to make: Ronny derides the locals and legitimizes his behavior by seeking and obtaining the agreement of a woman of a higher class who wasn’t even interested in the conversation in the first place. Another hole in the British Empire that is explored is false love for the empire, which is here personified, tragically, by Ronny. “Ronny” is a hypocorism: it is a term of endearment given to loved ones and people you are close to. The fact that he is referred to as “Ronny” by everyone at the party indicates the hollowness of this “love”. This love refers to the love between the locals and the crown’ although the locals cooperated to some extent and adopted British customs and clothing, their trust and love for the British Empire was still grounded in fear. These among other weaknesses of the British Empire portrayed through personification allow the reader to look beyond the given text and gain a deeper understanding of the subtext in this excerpt.

This excerpt obviously contains more meaning than that which can be gleaned with only a cursory glance. Its themes are concealed beneath a layer of dialogue and reveal much about the circumstances of the characters in it.

In his novel A Passage to India, E.M. Forster uses a wealth of linguistic features stereotypes, to justify the meaningless attempts to bridge the cultural gaps.

In the Bridge Party that takes place at the start of the novel, the reader is introduced to some of these prejudices and cultural misunderstandings that are formed with the fusion of these two divergent cultures. Using the characters of Mrs. Moore and Adela Quested, Forster demonstrates the differences between the attitudes of the English who have lived in India for an extended period of time and those who are newly arrived in India and tend to have a more sympathetic, unbiased view of the native Indians.

The Bridge Party also poses the question of whether it is possible for an Englishman and an Indian to ever be friends, at least within the context of British colonialism. In the social gathering varied British views are expressed concerning their views on Indian inferiority.

Cite This Document

Related Documents

  • Essay on a Passage to India

    ...A Passage To India portrays the stance of the British people in India, wherein the Englishman is viewed as a racist, self-righteous and rude set who deny to relate to the Indians on an individual level or rather see Indians as a person. A Passage to India is divided into three sections: Mosque, Cave and Temple, each part portraying a symbolic me...

    Read More
  • Passage to India

    ...Meaning and Muddle in the Marabar Caves: A Look at E.M. Forster’s A Passage to India In E.M. Forster’s A Passage to India, the Marabar Caves occupy an important part of the plot. The purpose of this deserves exploration considering Forster entitles the entire second part of his novel to them. Are these caves symbolic of an exploration int...

    Read More
  • A Passage to India

    ...A Passage to India, written by E. M. Forster in 1924, is a novel exploring the widespread and uncontrolled tension and prejudice that existed in India in the 1920s. This tension was caused by animosity between the native Indians and the British officials who were ruling India at the time - in this novel, Dr. Aziz and the City Magistrate. Most...

    Read More
  • Passage to India

    ...The Indian vs. the European Religion and Way of Thinking Religion is probably the most definitive factor in the way Indians lead their lives, particularly if they practice Hinduism and this is why the clash between Hinduism and Christanity in A Passage to India parallels the conflict between the Indians and the British. Hinduism is best repr...

    Read More
  • Critique of Imperialism in a Passage to India

    ...| |The chief argument against imperialism in E. M. Forster’s A Passage to India is that it prevents personal relationships. The central question of the novel is posed at the very beginning when Mahmoud Ali and Hamidullah ask each other “whether or not it is possible to be friends with an Englishman”.[1] The answer, given by Forster himself...

    Read More
  • A Passage To India

    ...Kathryn MacLellan Mitchell November 25th, 2013 Racism in A Passage To India A Passage to India by E.M. Forster is a novel published in 1924, a time when India had not yet won its independence from the British. Forster had visited India during this time, so a lot of the setting comes from firsthand experience, although he does make up ...

    Read More
  • A passage to india

    ...The Politics of Representation in A Passage to India The discussion on A Passage to India as a political fiction has for long been dominated by the followers of a mimetic theory of literature, whose quest for empiricism tied to didacticism is achieved when they find the narrative content to be an authentic portrayal of India and a humanist ...

    Read More
  • Significance of Godbole in Passage to India

    ...In E. M. Forster’s A Passage to India, the reader experiences multiple layers within the novel beginning with the structure, the focus on relationships, and the characters. The author makes a concerted effort throughout the novel to build a bridge between Western and Eastern societies by using the characters to demonstrate the deep difference...

    Read More

Discover the Best Free Essays on StudyMode

Conquer writer's block once and for all.

High Quality Essays

Our library contains thousands of carefully selected free research papers and essays.

Popular Topics

No matter the topic you're researching, chances are we have it covered.