Preview

'Wont' By Wilfred Kohl: Article Analysis

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
689 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
'Wont' By Wilfred Kohl: Article Analysis
In this article, written by Herbert Kohl, it talks mainly about how people assume that if someone chooses not to do something, it’s taken as they can't do it.  For an example, in the article It discusses that one of his fifth-grade students grandfather, Wilfredo, wouldn't learn to speak English. Kohl asked the grandfather when he got to know him if he would be able to teach him English. Wilfredo’s response was that he didn't want to learn in fear that it would cause for his culture and language not to be passed down each generation. Kohl discussed this matter with a few friends. The response that he got from his friends was that Wilfredo is saying this as "a cover-up of either his own fear of trying to learn English or his failure to do so." This then brought up the discussion of learning and not-learning. That to learn you must have the free choice and dedication to get it done. Kohl’s main point that he tries to get off is the difference between “can’t” and “wont”. In this example, …show more content…
He says “Not-learning tends to take place when someone has to deal with unavoidable challenges to her or his personal and family loyalties, integrity, and identity.” My friend Val was unable to graduate on time with us because his father and family believe that working and helping the family business is more valuable than his high school education. With this not-learning isn’t fully because of Val but because of his family loyalties just as Kohl says. One thing that I found interesting was when Kohl’s friends thought that Wilfredo wouldn’t learn English because he was fearful of failure. Which brings up the “can’t” and “won’t” learn. Kohl’s friends assumed that he “can’t” learn, but the fact is that he just decided he “won’t” learn. By Wilfredo not learning English it forces his grandchildren to learn Spanish and keep their heritage alive. In this case, not-learning protects their culture identify and/or sense of

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    udwig Wittgenstein once said in his book Logico Tractatus Philosophicus ,“The limits of my language means the limits of my world.” This quotation means language has no limit, it’s something that can be translated into a wide variety. Both Amy Tan in the essay, “Mother Tongue” and Richard Rodriguez in the essay, “Aria: Memoir of a Bilingual Childhood” write about their struggle with their identities not only because of their race, but also the language there families speak. Amy Tan and Richard Rodriguez both struggled with there families language conflicting with the need to speak the language of society. While children they share similarities with their struggles, and they differ in their perception of the importance of maintaining their families…

    • 555 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Movements for bilingual education rose in 1974 with the Equal Education Opportunity Act and Bingual Education Act, which ordered federally funded schools to meet special educational needs for students not proficient in English. Unfortunately, dropout rates and lack of English-language proficiency alarmed the states that these bilingual programs were not efficent. Because of this, arguments between English-only advocates and supporters of bilingual educations emerged. Articles such as the New York Times have proclaimed the failures of bilingual education. One cause could be the resistance of immigrants from English language acquisition, who hold tight onto their first language and culture. Despite this, studies show that generations following the immigrants increasingly became more fluent in English. The differences between immigrants and their following generations can be clearly seen in a brilliant poem written by a compassionate and hard working woman of the 20th century. Struggling to to accept her father’s way of separating English from Spanish, Rhina Espaillat, in her poem, “Bilingual/Bilingue”, shows a personal account of the realities of bilingualism and how it is possible to overcome language and culture barriers to learn a second language.…

    • 700 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Because she was unable to lie any more; she had inner conflict which has been reflected as a stream of unconscious thoughts about the terrible she'd been throw, which awakened her soul to tell the truth under any…

    • 284 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Richard Rodriguez is an American journalist and essayist who often writes about his life and the obstacles he has faced during so. He has become widely known due to his popular book, The Hunger of Memory. In the excerpt that’s presented, Rodriguez talks about how his life has changed tremendously due to education, and he goes on to describe how he feels “assimilated.” Rodriguez comes from Mexican Origins and is the son of Mexican Immigrants and throughout the excerpt he has an internal fight due to the fact that he feels as if he is now a stranger to his once familiar culture. However, the one thing that has taken Rodriguez as far as he has come is his education.…

    • 172 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Carter then describes that restrictive language policies still occur today due to the common misunderstanding of Spanish speakers. Carter presents the misunderstandings in the form of four myths: Latinos aren’t interested and cannot learn English, speaking Spanish hinders their ability to speak English, children will learn Spanish at home, and that Spanish is taking over schools. Carter disproves each myth by providing factual evidence and personal experience. For instance, Carter mentions that social science data shows that Latinos learn English at a fast rate and that some evidence suggests that policies restricting a student’s usage of a home language affect literacy skill in English. Carter also mentions that he has yet encountered a young person that refuses to learn English. Making language policies such as Proposition 227 nothing but problematic. Carter concludes his argument by stating that Spanish is an economy and cultural resource that should be cultivated not dismantled, and should, therefore, be provided as an educational policy along with…

    • 437 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    This seminar was about the Rehabilitating the "Wild Tongue" Philosophy at The University of Texas Rio Grande Valley. The speaker, Francisco Guajardo, divided his presentation into four major parts. Francisco starts off by giving a background information of his life. In the first few minutes of the presentation, I learned Francisco belonged to an immigrant family. His family migrated to the United States, in search for a better life. Francisco grew up in the city of Elsa, Texas beside his two brothers. Francisco first language was Spanish, but he later was introduced to the English language. While Francisco attended his first year of elementary school, his classroom became a test trial for bilingual instruction. Francisco states that rushing a Spanish speaking child into an English classroom will affect their language development.…

    • 270 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    He mentions that from an early age he knew that his parents knew could read and write both Spanish and English, he observed his father making his way through tax forms. Other times he watched his mother read, but he states that for his parents wasn’t actually necessary, they had never read an entire book. He got a scholarship to a school, and the teachers thought he was mental because he read by himself. At the end of each school day, for nearly six months he would stay with the teacher and he asked him every day why he was so reluctant to read by himself, he tried to explain himself, he said that written words made him feel alone, he wanted to add more to his explanation but he couldn’t, the teacher studied his face as he talked, she seemed to be more than listening, she said that he had nothing to fear. He mentions that books opened doors for him, it could introduce him to new people and new places he never imagined…

    • 679 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    In the story, the author is getting pulled in various directions. Rodriguez wants to stay true to his Mexican culture for his parents' sake claiming they, “...grow distant, apart, no longer speak,” but also wants to belong in American culture where his education has driven him to a position not many Mexicans get to or have to opportunity to be (Rodriguez 105). This story confronts the idea that anyone can succeed as long as they are willing to sacrifice their cultural identity in the process.…

    • 476 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Being a native Spanish speaker, Rodriguez’s knows how there are multiple ways of speaking a language. Similar to how the Chinese have their language and talk stories. Rodriguez’s shares love through the power of language with his family. Since Rodriguez shares a certain language with his family at home he feels that, “It is not possible for a child-any-child-ever to use his family’s language in school. Not to understand this is to misunderstand the public uses of schooling and to trivialize the nature of intimate life-a family’s language”. To him he believed that at home he a specific language that he shared with his family and no one else would be able to understand it. At home he was able to share love with his family through their language. He was against using this type of language at school because you cannot teach this to other people as it is something that comes naturally. Also if this type of language was used it would take away from the intimate aspect it contained as it would no longer be secluded to just his family. Moreover the family rarely spoke any language that was not theirs. “By, contrast, English, rarely heard in the house, was the language I came to associate with gringos”. To him there is only one language that he knows. Because of this it also makes it hard to learn in school since he does not want to have is family…

    • 1999 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    In the latter part of the fifth paragraph Rodriguez states “It is not possible for a child - any child - ever to use his family’s language in school” He describes his family language of Spanish and his family’s household practices such as raising chickens and painting the house yellow as things that made his family stand apart from the community he grew up in.…

    • 713 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Better Essays

    If you turn over a permission slip or handout from a public school in Southern California on the backside you will find the same English words translated into Spanish. The act of translating the paper for the “child’s” wellbeing only provides a false illusion to the parent’s that the need to learn English is trivial. In reality it actually hinders the immigrants’ chances of success by denying the full language immersion in English that is needed to thrive in America, not just survive. And once one group of immigrants is catered for, it unjustly secludes others of equal treatment. The responsibility of speaking English falls on the shoulders of every immigrant. The lack of a shared proficiency in the English language…

    • 1253 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Better Essays

    In Darkness We Meet

    • 1613 Words
    • 7 Pages

    Diaz states in this interview that, “learning English is such a violent experience as a kid.” He explains that it could be such a violent experience, especially for immigrants, because English seems to be this language that one has to perfect. Someone learning this language will punish them selves for every mistake they make, thinking everyone will be judging them, when in reality they’re their only critic. This “violent experience” is basically all created in ones head.…

    • 1613 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Better Essays

    Latinos in America

    • 995 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Many Americans don’t realize that the choice in language is not determined by the individual but lies in the choice parents or caregivers. This choice is one that will haunt individuals for the rest of their lives. In Barrientos’ case, her parents decided it would be best for her to only speak English. As Barrientos grew up, she embraced her parents choice, saw this as a positive trait, one that differentiated her from most Latinas. She enjoyed defying expectations. Since childhood, she felt that speaking Spanish translated to been poor, holding less desirable jobs and discrimination towards the Latino community. It is because of this that she enjoyed attending a public school that attracted few Latinos, she wanted to distance herself from the rest. In her opinion, not speaking Spanish gave her an edge over other Latinos and allowed her to successfully fit into the American Anglo society. In…

    • 995 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Based on Amy Tan’s “Mother Tongue”(Tan, 76-81) it is evident that language has an affect on our lives. Language defines the type of person I am generally and it has had an affect on my choices as well as my lifestyle. Language has become my way of seeing life in a different perspective. In Amy Tan’s “Mother Tongue”(Tan, 76) she discusses the way the language that she was taught affected her life in so many ways. I can definitely relate to Tan’s essay since I as well came from a bilingual home. Like her, I have intelligent immigrant parents and I am their main source of communication with people who don’t understand them. I believe the main idea of Tan’s “ Mother Tongue” is to stress that just because someone cannot speak the English language to perfection does not in any way make them less intelligent than someone who is born in this country who speaks fluently and understands English. However, what makes us different is that it is rare to find two people who speak the exact same English. Although Tan and I both helped our parents and came from non-traditional homes, Tan came from a Chinese family while I came from an Albanian family. We both had similar ideas about language being a major role in our families, and it was also a big challenge for both of us while we were raised by immigrant parents that spoke “limited English” (Tan, 78).…

    • 837 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Everyone knows that when people move to a new country the children will eventually speak the language natively and the adults won’t. The normal explanation is that children have a special ‘talent’ that they lose as they grow up. Teachers said that for adults, languages should be taught and studied instead of learned naturally. But are we any better with present language teaching? Why, for example, do adults in Central Africa do better when they move to a new language community than our modern students do? Could it be that early teachers were mistaken? Maybe adults can do what children do. Maybe it’s just adult behavior (not lack of talent) that prevents them from succeeding. THE MISTAKE – Children can do something that adults cannot. THE UNASKED QUESTION – What would happen if an adult were to just listen for a year without speaking? OUR ANSWER – Both adults and children can do it right, but only adults can do it wrong. Imagine a 4 year-old child and an adult reacting to somebody talking to them in a foreign language. The child most often just listens, while the adult usually tries to talk back. Now imagine that ‘not trying to speak’ was the child’s secret. It makes sense that listening to things that are always right would…

    • 894 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays