Preview

Twyla As A Dynamic Character Essay

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
431 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Twyla As A Dynamic Character Essay
In Toni Morrison’s short story “Recitatif”, a young girl named Twyla is faced with hardships and turmoil that causes her to grow and change as a character. The story is centered around Twyla and her friend Roberta as they live in a girls’ orphanage together. Though both girls are equally round characters, Twyla seems to undergo the most change. Twyla is first shown as a protagonist, a young girl who demands the readers’ sympathy as she resides in an orphanage. As the story develops, we start to notice how unreliable she is as a narrator. Her story about Maggie changes every time we hear it. Was she really black? Did the girls push her? Twyla seems to be stuck in a child-like state, classifying people as “mean girls” and not taking blame for Maggie’s accident. Because of her unreliability, Twyla is arguably a dynamic character. It is impossible to predict how she will …show more content…
Her attitude towards her mother shows a lack of empathy and an uncaring personality. I was surprised when I saw her concern for her son, but her character seems more worried about his education than his wellbeing. She joins the opposing side of Roberta’s protest just to go against her. This woman is obviously hurt and shows slight sociopathic tendencies. Reading from her unreliable point of view is intriguing and opens the story for questions and discussions. This story is fascinating because both of the major characters are well rounded and dynamic. They also contrast with each other. Twyla’s hard heart and Roberta’s need for excitement. Roberta’s remorse at the end of the story shows not only how her guilt has preyed on her for years, but how Twyla has rationalized her form of the truth. Though readers will never know what exactly happened to Maggie, we can learn a lot about the characters from how they dealt with the

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Powerful Essays

    Recitative is a style of vocal music intermediate between speaking and singing; reflecting on the natural rhythms of speech”. In the story Recitatif this meaning is important because it points out the natural rhythm of speech between Roberta and Twyla’s relationship. Roberta is black and Twyla is white. They both have an unspoken understanding of each other because they are in an orphanage yet neither one of them are orphans. Due to them being in this orphanage their racial identities do not exist. They are no longer black/white but children in an orphanage whose mothers cannot take care of them. Twyla and Roberta both come from complete different backgrounds. Even at their young age yet they both have completely different ways that they see the world and their surroundings. This is prevalent when Roberta and Twyla meet again a few times throughout the years. Recitatif is about how people view, deal and handle life differently due to their race and circumstance even though one race may be sympathetic to another race that does not mean that truly understand or see the big…

    • 1180 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    The movie May also falls victim to attempts at increasing the dramatic element. Her character in the movie is childish and helpless. Even though she is portrayed in the novel as sheltered, so that she may be molded to the form of choice by her future husband,…

    • 494 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Her character greatly affected all the characters in the novel. She was the spokes holding their family wheel together. Darl longed for her approval, while Jewel had her sitting on a pedestal. Anse, even through all his selfish, narcissistic ways, looked up to her and felt attached to her, even beyond her death. He felt like he owed her something. Her character is similar to Vardaman’s character in the sense that they are both unable to fully express themselves. Vardaman resorts to comparisons such as ‘my mother is a fish’ (pg. 84) while Addie resorts to having an affair with Whitefield.…

    • 479 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Grenes Go Play Themes

    • 1885 Words
    • 8 Pages

    She’s likable and well established as being conflicted. She is clearly uncomfortable with the idea of the funeral and death. She doesn’t like others suffocating her with their condolences. She feels like a loner. She’s consumed with guilt and she blames herself for her father’s death. She struggles with guilt, grief, and healing. She’s caught between a controlling mother who thrives on anger and blame, and her deceased father, who saw good in people and was more of a peacemaker; he wasn’t afraid to say sorry.…

    • 1885 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    On first appearances of the character, when she talks to, George and Lennie in the barn, she gives off the impression that she is a “Troublemaker” and a bit “Tarty”, her body language is intentionally provocative this is shown when she displays her body in a confident way when…

    • 1412 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Better Essays

    The traits of Maggie were apparently different from Dee in that she wasn 't handed life 's opportunities and when it came to Dee, "that, 'no ' is a word the world never learned to say to her" (73). This statement in the beginning of the story brings an understanding as to the feelings that Maggie has conjured up while living in the shadow of an older sister. Alice Walker molded one daughter from the other, taking the strengths and qualities of Dee and omitting them in Maggie. Although Maggie does have strengths of her own, she is a character that unfortunately has a simple life and has made complex problems for herself. Learning more about Maggie 's character could be drawn from learning about Dee 's character as well. Maggie seems to be the pessimist, although she is only reacting to her sisters dramatic and overbearing presence. This shows true symbolic meaning when Dee arrives at their home and wants to take all of the important…

    • 1509 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    For example, the way that she threatens Crooks is where I begin to lose patience with her because he was just trying to get her away from his property because he knew she could get him fired and he just wanted her to realise that his room is not where she should be also because of the segregation and it being that they had to be in separate rooms and to not really talk to her, also this is something that she just doesn’t understand because she goes to talk to him anyway. She just thinks that he is trying to get rid of her and the way that he is always trying to tell her to go home and talk to her husband but they both know that her husband is in the “cathouse” not home she then tells them that she is “lonely” which they don’t care about because they have a dream and a possible ranch to go to when they are finished here also in them days if a lady said she was lonely they were expected to just go else where for attention. I also believe that she has some nice qualities, for example when she is talking to Lennie and she is talking on the same wavelength or level as him which can be seen as a kind of kinship between the two. I also think that she is kind of childlike because she wants the only thing that any child wants and that is attention, companionship and love which Lennie already gets from George but Curley’s Wife does not get that from anyone. This is the sort of behaviour…

    • 2239 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    She also has no respect for the anyone as seen when she enters Crook's room has no respect for the Candy, Lennie, and Crooks especially Crooks for him being Black. Also when she gets lonely she turns cruel because she is jealous she feels sorry feels sorry for herself so she is mean to others because she is jealous of friendship that is starting and she wants people to notice how lonely and upset she is. This makes the reader have mixed emotions toward her because they feel sorry for her because she is lonely but then we turn against because she uses her power against someone who has a lower status that…

    • 489 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Chuck's Monologue

    • 4993 Words
    • 20 Pages

    What do you think about her character? How might people from other cultures evaluate her as a mother observing her personality, behavior, and appearance?…

    • 4993 Words
    • 20 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Initially, Maggie perhaps comes across as a flat character who thinks that the world has always catered to her pretty sister Dee. However, as the story progresses to the main conflict, when Dee wants to take two quilts made by their Grandma Dee, Maggie shows herself to be a round character with many sides. When Dee first makes the request to take the quilts, Maggie is in the kitchen washing up the dishes and Mama notes “I heard something fall in the kitchen, and a minute or two later the kitchen door slammed.” (152) This statement shows Maggie’s frustration because again the world seems to be taking from her and giving to Dee (B&N). After hearing the exchange between Mama and Dee, Maggie seems to want to give in to her sister’s wishes, perhaps in an effort to please her.…

    • 650 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    one- This story , in my opinion, does not possess the warm-hearted, jolly, and happy side of a short story, we’d expect from a title, such as Everyday Use. Instead, this story is a more refreshing realistic tone of life and the harshness it may possess. There is a perfectly adequate amount of crudeness in the story, especially within the lifestyle of these individuals. The tone changes as the story continues on. In the beginning the story has a more worrisome, jealousy, and a want to be accepted feel, especially at the opening when it discusses Maggie and how she is ashamed of her burns, then peering at her sister in envy and awe. Then the mother’s want to be accepted by her daughter, Dee, who she feels would accept her if her appearance was different. Also, my assumption is greatly backed up by these two statements. The first quote being- “She thinks her sister has held life always in the palm of one hand, and that “no” is a word it never learned to say to her.” The last being the dream statement, which exemplifies the want for acceptance from her daughter– “Sometimes I dream a dream in which Dee and I are suddenly brought together on a TV program of this sort…Then we are on the stage and Dee is embracing me with tears in her eyes.” As the story continues the tone moves from worrisome to mystery and embarrassment. The mystery was shown by the want to know why the change in Dee and who this man was with her. The embarrassment, in my opinion was a underlining tone, because it was solely shown through actions like Maggie’s want to dash away when she noticed her sister arriving in the vehicle, and the ashamed statement Dee wrote once before her arrival. This statement was that “no matter where we family “choose” to live, she will manage to come see us. But she will never bring her friends.” Next tone I grasped was the anger of Maggie when Dee came to take the things she wanted and then Maggie wanting to just get it over…

    • 1457 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    The audience preoccupies itself in determining race, when in reality it proves only to mask the importance of this underlying sisterhood that cannot exist without its fellow feminine bloodlines. A powerful example of racial ambiguity, the character Maggie, which the two main characters saw as their mothers and never do agree on her racial identity, represents this idea of race as unfixed as the memory of her begins to fade in both of their minds. As well, Maggie served as the embodiment of the powerlessness of the girls, and so when the “gar girls” were abusing her, neither Twyla nor Roberta tried to help her, rather they viewed the weakness within themselves being attacked though her abuse. Maggie’s defenselessness outlined the struggles of being a woman, especially having a severe handicap, and being abused by other women was a strange form of “natural selection,” if you will, that sought to attack woman…

    • 728 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Alice Walker portrays the tough life of the main character Celie. Celie at a young age is raped by Pa then marries Mr.__ who does the same, he takes Nettie’s letters from her until she finds out and gets them back. She confronts him showing how far she has come to speaking up and showing courage. While married to Mr.__ she meets Shug who she soon falls in love with her. She makes her become herself and they move off to Memphis after Pa dies she inherits her the home and the dry goods store and soon makes a small business making pants. At the end of the novel she finally meets her children and Nettie after so many long years.…

    • 526 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    When thinking of dinosaurs, almost everyone can think of one movie they watched with them in it. The most obvious movie anyone thinks of is Jurassic Park. There are three different Movies in this sort of series, and the most recent one is Jurassic World. I watched this new film and is a very good film. The three things about this film that I am going to discuss are the different conflicts, character development, and the different effects used to move the plot.…

    • 655 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Country Lovers

    • 517 Words
    • 3 Pages

    She is hysterical, and is crying a lot. She is out of control and very offensive in the way that she´s accusing Paulus for pouring poison in the baby´s mouth.…

    • 517 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays