Toulmin Model Analysis

Good Essays
The Claim: The nuclear power industry is lobbying for the US government to not pass negative legislation.
The qualifier (the precedent): There is a long and well recorded history of interest groups in Washington lobbying for beneficial legislation to their interests.
The Support: because a recent press release states that the biggest nuclear power lobbying firm has recently committed itself to make a $$$ donation over the next 5 years. http://www.politico.com/news/stories/0311/51367.html The Rebuttal: Despite recent nuclear fears, nuclear power has a near-perfect track record in ‘safe’ zones.
The Warrant: The general public dislikes the notion that lobbying firms ‘buy’ or alter the opinion of lawmakers in Washington.
This cartoon is in the backdrop of the Japanese emergency to keep their nuclear reactor from going into meltdown. The main idea is that there has been a knee-jerk reaction in the United States towards fear about nuclear power and the nuclear power industry are funneling money into Washington to keep the law makers from passing negative legislation to appease the general public’s growing concern for nuclear safety

The Claim: This job applicant is not prepared for any job...
Support: because he has taken tests in high school that rely on answer sheets, like those used with standardized tests, and he cannot communicate effectively.
Warrant: The knowledge learned and tested in standardized tests is irrelevant to jobs in the real world; this hampers students’ communication skills.
Backing: Many people believe that standardized tests fail to measure the critical thinking skills and communication skills, especially, writing, that are required for success in the work place.
Rebuttal: A rebuttal is implied against the position that standardized testing is an adequate test of student’s knowledge and job skills. A rebuttal establishes what is wrong, invalid, or unacceptable about an argument and may also present counterarguments or new arguments that

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Toulmin Model

    • 517 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Back on “1958” Stephen Toulmin proposed the six terms as a model of communication designed to analyze the court room rhetorician’s argument. These included the three legs of communication, which are writer, subject, and audience supporting the claims of fact, value and policy, in others words, claim is an author’s proposition in which he/she is trying to prove a statement. In addition, Wayne Brockriede and Douglas Ehninger brought to coaction the six key terms in Toulmin model connecting the three…

    • 517 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    To illustrate the Toulmin Model, there is a situation where two friends, Amy and Penny, are arguing about which one of them would buy a particular dress. Amy claims she would because it suits her. As a result, Penny tells her to prove it. Amy explains how the dress is in her size, the color goes well with her, and that Penny only has enough money to buy some pants. With this new information, the data, Penny makes a realization, the warrant, of how her friend has a point so she lets Amy buy the…

    • 96 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Better Essays

    Toulmin Model

    • 1507 Words
    • 7 Pages

    Earth: Our Gift From God Brooklynn McMurray Liberty University Abstract This paper presents a Toulmin model argument for the care and usage of the Earth and its natural resources as dictated by God in the Holy Bible (NIV). The Old Testament provides many guidelines for man to live fruitfully on Earth. Because it was made by God and given to us, we must follow the guidelines that he has set forth in the care and preservation of our planet. Earth: Our Gift From God Before God created man…

    • 1507 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Toulmin Model Essay

    • 421 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Odukoya 1 Oluwatobi Odukoya Professor Isiah Ayafor English 102-014 3/12/2013 Essay 3 Toulmin Model Essay In this advertisement, the reader must “read between the lines” to find the claim because it is not initially stated. The claim is that if anyone joins the military, they will acquire qualities that they cannot acquire outside of the military. The support would be given by Dr. Jay Grossman, a man who served in the military for a year, and serving there created a passion within him to…

    • 421 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Toulmin Model

    • 468 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Josh Jones ENG 133-040 Mrs. Wagnon 26 February 2013 Harassing Illegals Legally? In the article, "Special Licenses for Immigrants Draw Protests in North Carolina," by David Zucchino, he tells a story of a fight over driver's licenses for illegal immigrants in North Carolina. The key issue with the license is that it has a pink stripe running across the top of the card, and a phrase saying "No Lawful Status," as well as a restriction on the back reiterating the same fact. Many people, including…

    • 468 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    What Is A Toulmin Model

    • 142 Words
    • 1 Page

    The information in the material shows of how a Toulmin model is used to analyze as well to create an argument outline. In this process the Toulmin model separates the components of an argument into pieces and analyze further more. It is composed of six points; the first point is the claim which is the main idea the essay. Secondly, we have the data where the writer use evidences to support its claim. Thirdly, is the warrant that connects the claim with the data. Fourthly, we have the backing which…

    • 142 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Better Essays

    Enright English 205 Augmentative Analysis Against the Toulmin Model The late Stephen Toulmin the creator of the Toulmin Model has constructed and contributed immensely to the analytical study of arguments. The Toulmin Model, a dynamic foundation of structured analysis commonly used to analyze any text in which an argumentative statement develops through the essential elements which goes to define the Toulmin process. In a textbook titled, Elements of Argument…

    • 1706 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    around 30% of the land coverage on Earth; however, we are losing enormous pieces of it daily. Not all of the deforestation is deliberate, yet there is an abundance of opportunities for people to contribute to the ending of deforestation. Using the Toulmin model for my research paper, I will prove the importance of raising awareness for the large-scale destruction of Earth’s forests. Raising awareness…

    • 368 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Toulmin Claim is a statement that youre asking the other person to accept,many people start with claims Ex: you should use a hearing aid Grounds/data: the basis of real persuasion made up of data and facts,plus the reasoning behind the claim Ex:over 70% of people over 65 years have hearing difficulties A warrant links data to a claim,legitimizes the claim by showing the grounds to be relevant Ex: a hering aid helps most people to hear better Backing or support:to an argument gives…

    • 267 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Better Essays

    The Toulmin Model of Argument (adapted from: http://schoolnet.org.za/twt/09/M9_argumentation.pdf) In his work on logic and argument, The Uses of Argument, Stephen Toulmin indicates three major, necessary parts of an argument, along with three additional, optional parts. The three major parts are the claim, the support, and the warrants. Claim: This is the disputable assertion for which a speaker argues. The claim may be directly stated or the claim may be implied. You can find the claim by asking…

    • 1524 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays