The subtexts of fairy tales present the view that women are either helpless damsels or wicked vixens, created from the fantasies of male desires. How and to what extent does Angela Carter’s Snow Child challenge or reinforce this view?
Angela Carter’s The Snow Child is a feminist revision of the Grimm Brothers classic fairy tale Snow White. Whilst reading the story, it is clear that Carter challenges the “repeated familiar cultural stereotypes” which is a common theme in these fairy tales which have a huge impact on the minds of young children. Critics such as Kathleen Regan challenge these stories for portraying negative female stereotypes such as a “beautiful passive princess” and a “ruthless woman” who is “dangerously beautiful”. These relate to the helpless damsels and wicked vixens that we are referring to. The dangerous beauty of some of these stereotypical women can be related to the fact that they are created from the fantasies of male desire.
Carter’s characterisation of the Count and “his wife” give us an insight into the gender roles that she is trying to portray. A general rule of fairy tales is that the males should be of higher class than the women, and they should also show a social dominance. However Carter seems to go against this theme from the very beginning of the Snow Child as she tells of how the Countess rides a “black mare” whilst her husband is on a “grey” one. This gives the reader their first glimpse of the authority that the Countess has.
We see the Countess dressed in “glittering pelts” and “spurs” which conveys a sense of power and strength. We get the impression that the Countess is being held back by society because of her gender.
It could be argued that the mysterious transfer of the Countess’ clothes to the Snow Child represents the absurdity of the gender constraints that have been placed on women by society. It may also show that Carter feels it is ridiculous that females are stereotyped to two roles, the helpless damsel and wicked vixen. The clothing symbolises the transfer of power and shows that a man’s desire can turn a helpless damsel into a wicked vixen. We see this as the Snow Child becomes “furred and booted” and begins to replicate the Countess.
The Snow Child is quitter clearly the Counts “child of desire”. She appears “stark naked” to show her purity and innocence as she stands as a rival to the Countess, despite the fact she does not say a word throughout her entire existence. This takes away from the personality of the Snow Child and distances her from the audience as she seems to almost become a non-human like figure. The fact that Carter portrays a character with no personality may show that she feels that society does not value women’s views and opinions, and that women are here for the sole purpose of serving a man and fulfilling his “desire”.
Carter uses colour to reflect the gothic nature of the tale. We see this with the “red” of the blood, “white” of the snow and the “black” of the raven’s feather. The Count wishes for a girl as “white as snow” which symbolises her purity and virginity. The girls “red lips” could be Carters way of symbolising the danger that lies ahead. Whilst the “black of the raven’s feather” contrasts the purity of the white snow and symbolise the death and darkness which the audience are about to witness. Another way that Carter uses colour in the story is when the “black” and “grey mares” destroy the beauty and perfection of the “midwinter” snow by walking on it.
Carter characterises the Countess with colours which epitomise the height of male desires with her “glittering pelt of black foxes” and her “scarlet heels” suggesting that she is also a product of male lust. Male desire has been subverted by the gothic symbol of death and is now seen to represent danger rather than sartorial elegance. This allows Carter to challenge the preconceptions that are written into the symbolic use of colours within the fairy tale.
Overall I believe that it is undeniable that most fairy tales contain subtexts of profound sexism. Carter comments on the lack of responsibility taken by male protagonists in stories such as these. She does so by portraying the fact that the Count appears to go unpunished throughout all of the suffering that is going on throughout this tale. In the ideal male fantasies, punishment and pain for men is not seen as an option in any way. These tales are an integral part of society and early education. They have a lasting effect on the vulnerable minds of young children.
The Snow child reinforces some of the subtle stereotypes of women by almost showing they are afraid to voice their opinions. This is shown through the silence of the Snow Child and the fact that the Countess does not challenge her husband at any stage despite being portrayed as the wicked vixen that has more authority and power than a helpless damsel such as the Snow Child. Although Carter seems to challenge the larger prejudices against women when she states that the Count “didn’t last long” whilst having sex with the corpse of the Snow Child. This challenges men’s power and mocks the Count because of the standards he is willing to drop to in order to feel like he is receiving female affection.
Carter chose to represent fairy tales in this way in order to inspire a wave of new feminists in the 1970’s aiming to educate and raise awareness of female stereotypes such as the helpless damsel and the wicked vixen. Society has “largely ignored the position of women” and Carters tale was her attempt to try and change the “familiar cultural stereotypes” put in place by these fairy tales which have become common and are now widely accepted within literature, especially in stories of male fantasies and desire.
You May Also Find These Documents Helpful
-
In the author's article he presents the idea that girls should follow a more independent manner rather than the stereotype of princess who needs saving in modern films. With evidence from movies like Ella Enchanted where the princess is escaping the binds of having to marry her prince, rather than wait to be saved by her prince it is clear the author supports more feminist themes for modern fairytales.…
- 614 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
These stories are commonly told to children by the women around them to entertain or scare them. Those women were often older and the stories told by them are referred to as “old wives’ tales (1)”. Maria Tatar argues that fairy tales hold a special place in society not only in appearing in mainstream media for children and adults, but also in how they relate to the real problems faced by the readers. Given this fact, some would still argue that fairy tales are not worth the analytical attention they receive. When reading these tales one must keep a critical eye open to the subliminal messages communicated throughout. Tatar writes, “Trivializing fairy tales…
- 946 Words
- 3 Pages
Better Essays -
The story of Snow White is classic and there is an abundance of people who believe how the original tale goes. However, it is highly doubtful that people actually do. The first tale of snow white titled The Little Snow White by the Grimm Brothers is much more macabre in nature compared to the light hearted and kid-like retelling Snow White written by Roberto Piumini and illustrated by Anna Laura Cantone. This essay will hopefully show how warped stories can become over time.…
- 933 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
For Snow White, in order to obtain protection and shelter at the dwarves house she had to perform the traditional roles of a woman such as cooking and cleaning. The dwarves told her, "If you will keep house for us, and cook, make beds, wash, sew, and knit, and keep everything clean and orderly, then you can stay with us,". This passage reflects the gender roles portrayed in the story, because If Snow White had been a boy the dwarves would have asked her to help the work in the mines or with other manual labor. The novel also describes Snow White as completely dependant on the dwarves for protection due to her characterization of innocence and foolishness. Unable to protect herself when the dwarves leave her alone, she falls prey to the Queen’s…
- 625 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
John Pizer’s criticism of Donald Barthelme’s Snow White talks about the origin story of Snow White and how this modern adaptation completely skews the classic tale. The concept of the “anti-fairy tale” is brought up as Pizer compares Barthelme’s tale to those that preceded his. Barthelme is derives influence from multiple sources which focus on the disenchantment of the iconic Disney princess. From these influences, a new and much more jaded version of Snow White appears in which the traditional morals associated with her character are inverted and satirized.…
- 654 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
In The Snow Child, Carter may subvert the typical expected roles of parents as the behaviour of the Count and Countess towards their ‘child’ is deemed very unusual. The Count behaves in a particularly alarming manner, portraying an obvious sexual attraction to the girl who appears before him after listing the qualities he desires. She is a clear manifestation of his fantasy, and is described as the “child of his desire”, which immediately signals abnormality for the reader as “desire” perhaps suggests a sexual element whilst “child” reminds us that she fulfils the family role of a daughter, thus highlighting her childlike innocence. The girl is described as “stark naked”, implying an eroticism about her, and alluding to the idea of female nudity as a part of male fantasy which is disturbing and sinister for the reader considering the Count is a father figure to her. Also, after the child’s death Carter describes how the Count “thrust his virile member into the dead girl”, and this explicit, shocking description of the sexual act emphasises the disturbing…
- 1124 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays -
Snow White and a New Insight Fairy tales are often significant for enhancing imagination and different perspectives in the readers. Fairy tales are symbolic in our history and may currently still be present in our society. Fairy Tales also allow us to analyze the emotion of the characters and compare that to our culture as well as our own daily life. In “Snow White and her Wicked Stepmother” and the classic “Snow White” by Jacob and Wilhelm Grimm both focus intently on how envy, competition, hard-work, and mother daughter relationships and how that is still applied in our world today. The classic “Snow White” allows the reader to focus specifically on how the dwarves are emblematic toward the American dream and toward the common working man…
- 1103 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays -
Fairy tales help to establish gender roles at a young age to characterize and represent the ideals, values, and roles that each gender should succumb to. Females are taught to be kind, sweet, week, honest, self-sacrificing, and beautiful. On the other hand, males are taught to be courageous, brave, saviors, and wise. Many of these characteristics are shown in Snow White. However, in lemony Snicket’s, A Bad Beginning, the novel challenges many of these ideas by providing the reader with alternate views to gender roles. This is shown through the main protagonist, Violet.…
- 476 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
In today’s society women are always looked down upon, vulnerable, or expected to dependent. Fairy tales show how the gender roles in fairy tales are damaging to young women in society. In the fairy tale of Sleeping Beauty, the female character is put in danger and cannot save herself. She must rely on the male character in the tale to save her. “She shall fall into sleep that will last a hundred years. At the end of that time, a king’s son will find her and awaken her by a kiss.” This fairy tale is just one example of the many that portray similar stereotypes. This influences women in society that relying on men is okay and they have no power to be…
- 848 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
In “Snow White and Her Wicked Stepmother”, Sandra Gilbert and Susan Gubar formulate the cycle in which fairy tale women are subjected by the patriarchal society’s imprisonment, then turned against each other so they remain in power and are destined to repeat the cycle. Gilbert and Gubar examine how a sexual reference, like “she pricks her finger, and bleeds”, begins the cycle of the metamorphoses of the mother “into a wicked ‘step’ mother” (Gilbert Gubar 292). The wicked stepmother then tries many times to kill Snow White, through various “female devices” such as tight laces, a comb and an apple (Gilbert Gubar 294). Both women are imprisoned by “transparent enclosures” given to them by men; the Queen is trapped by her mirror, while Snow is trapped by her glass…
- 558 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
The fact that the girl is referred to as a “child” and he wishes for a “girl” gives the reader the hint that the Snow Child may be a product of his wish for a child, therefore the Count can also be labelled as guilty of incest, however there is no clear indication that the girl was his child. Part of this argument is the fact that the Countess becomes jealous of the girl, and attempts to humiliate her, ultimately killing her “pricks a finger on the thorn, bleeds; screams; falls,” This indicates that the girl was not his child, as she wouldn’t be jealous of their child, even though it wouldn’t be surprising if Carter intended that.…
- 598 Words
- 3 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
Regina Moore English 104 February 4, 15 Short Essay: Perrault’s Cinderella Folklore, modern media, and historical events within the western world have shown us time and time again that women are meant to be the fairer and weaker of the two sexes; while reiterating the idea that men are strong, valiant, and ultimately the saviors of all women. This notion has been used to fortify the difference between the two genders, asserting the claim that women cannot save themselves or each other, and can only find their “happily ever after” with the help of a man. Perrault’s “Cinderella: or The Glass Slipper,” is the story of a mistreated, but kindhearted, girl who eventually marries a prince and goes on to live happily ever after. Within Perrault’s “Cinderella,” women are illustrated as powerful, and are the sole characters that drive the plot. While the male characters within the story remain flat and generally unimportant, therefore challenging the gender dichotomy that has depicted women as demure, and men as being critical in the lives of women.…
- 1294 Words
- 4 Pages
Better Essays -
Fairy Tale Stereotypes in Anne Sexton’s “Cinderella”: Raggedly Ever After Anne Sexton’s “Cinderella” illuminates the unrealistic and prejudiced stereotypes in age-old fairy tales, stereotypes inadvertently etched on the minds of millions of children. Sexton uses a conversational tone that remains oblivious to the initial hardships of the “rags to riches” maiden to highlight the insignificance and passiveness of women and the influential and dominant character of men. She conveys to the world’s audience of fairy tale lovers the blatant inequality in “Cinderella,” showing that this model fairy tale simply does not add up to be “happily ever after.”…
- 2042 Words
- 9 Pages
Better Essays -
Youngs, G. (1999). The ghost of Snow White. International Feminist Journal of Politics, 1. Retrieved December 11, 2012, from a Pierre Guillermin Library, Lynchburg.…
- 2822 Words
- 12 Pages
Powerful Essays -
The story chosen is Snow White that has become the most popular princess among young girls. Snow White and similar fairy tales are playing bad with young minds by showing male characters stronger and powerful, which is also causing gender discrimination. Whether the fairy tales have significant impact on folks’ lives has been the most discussed phenomenon of the time. Many people agree to the notion that fairy tales and their myths do have an impact in young children’ life while the other rejects this. Scientifically and psychologically, it has been proven that children tend to adopt the habits they see around and that they play a vital role in shaping a child's mind and controlling his/her thoughts. “Two close readings of this version, one psychoanalytic and the other feminist, suggest that because Snow White is part of a literally as well as folkloric tradition, it may be studied as a cultural artifact and text valid in itself” (Shuli Barzilai, 515).…
- 598 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays