Preview

The Bonesetter's Daughter Summary

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
2040 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
The Bonesetter's Daughter Summary
The Bonesetter’s Daughter is a novel about three generations of Chinese women. The novel starts off with a short prologue told in the perspective of LuLing Liu Young. LuLing is the daughter of “Precious Auntie”, a horribly disfigured nursemaid who is later revealed to be her mother, and the mother of Ruth, a “ghost-writer” who authors self-help books. Ruth lives with her boyfriend Art and his two teenage daughters, Dory and Fia in an apartment in San Francisco. She mysteriously loses her voice for several days per year around August 12. Ruth is nearly driven to the brink of exhaustion from trying to cope with everything life is throwing at her- her job, her boyfriend, her mother, as well as her past. The novel is divided into 3 parts; Part …show more content…
In part one, Ruth describes her dark and depressing past with her mother who told tales of ghosts, curses and suicides. Ruth seemingly wishes to escape her past and her mother’s volatile behavior. However, when her mother begins to show signs of dementia, Ruth goes back to relive her mother’s past through her autobiography and learns of how much her mother truly loves her. Amy Tan, the author of The Bonesetter’s Daughter, didn’t learn her mother’s true name until after her mother’s death and Ruth reflects this by not fully knowing her mother’s past before it was too late to talk to LuLing about it. Clearly, Tan wishes to emphasize the important bond that is ever-present within a family and how as Tan puts it,” A person should consider how things begin. A particular beginning results in a particular end.” p.153. In order for someone to truly understand who they are and how they got to this point, they have to understand their past and what experiences had shaped their lives before. The second theme is that of how lies can destroy even if original intents were benevolent. Ruth, as a “ghost-writer” doesn’t actually write for herself, rather she writes for other authors. In her childhood, she also symbolically wrote for Precious Auntie whenever LuLing asked her. These lies she told …show more content…
She’s filled with a deeper understanding of most of her mother’s antics when Ruth was a child, and makes it her mission to have her mother be her top priority. She goes to live with her mother to make sure she’s safe, leaving Art wondering if he did something wrong. In reality, Ruth is determined to treat her mother with the care she should have as a child, and explains this to him. To her surprise, Art agrees and supports her, even taking out the money to send her to an assisted-living residence. After he explains to her that it is not a nursing home and will treat her like a human being, as well as give her the proper care, they still must trick her into living there as they know the difficulty of her mother and money. This ending sequence brings back the root of their problems- lying. They’ve seen where lying lands people, even little white lies, they still insist on tricking her. However, the catch is that this is for LuLing’s benefit, not completely anyone else's. As Art admits, “I don't mean it as a condition for getting us back together or getting rid of your mother or any of that. It’s not a condition for anything,”(Tan, 367) He is genuinely supporting Ruth because he really wants to help LuLing. The only way to get her to agree to this help is by lying about it, and in this way, it’s perfectly

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    She tells countless stories of her father and the liar’s club, a group of men sitting around and telling their life stories. Karr recognizes her father’s lies, but sits quietly. As a child she was exposed to many of her parents fights, recalling, “we’d go...to see who'd thrown what or who passed out” (Karr 39). Her mother was mentally unstable, pulling a butcher knife on the children and even burning their clothes. After all they had witnessed through their mother's deteriorating state of mind, they still chose to live with her during the divorce. Their loyalty to their mother shows the endurance of love and family, where not even a knife to them can scare them away. Walls also uses anecdotes, but to achieve an entirely different purpose. Walls tells story of each of the many places she moved around with her family, each consistent with their bad living conditions. Her summer was not filled with vacations and water parks as other kids, yet still enjoyed it because “each day we had more light to read by” (Walls 168). She recognized that this was not her ideal life, and had always been set on making a better life for herself until she could finally say the words “I actually live on Park Avenue” (Walls 268). Her anecdotes showed the reader that the past does not define oneself, and one can make himself into something greater than what they were raised to…

    • 969 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    The Color of Water

    • 309 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Throughout my reading of this prolific non-fiction novel, one thing that seems to keep appearing frequently in my reading is the burden of secrets and their effects, more specifically with Ruth and her Jewish family. Ruth’s family was kept a secret for the majority of her own children’s adolescent years. Her desire to never speak of the relatives that claimed her “dead” seemed to haunt Ruth and deter her relationship with her own children. Secrets and mysteries appear often in this memoir; for much of James’ childhood, he knew little to nothing about his mother’s Jewish background, Ruth simply discouraged him from such intense curiosity. His mother’s secrecy as well as his desire to know of his own hidden roots is what inevitably drove him to write this novel. Furthermore, in her years as a young Jewish woman living in Suffolk, Virginia, Ruth at one point became pregnant with a child from her boyfriend Peter who was African-American. In the late 20’s and 30’s, biracial relationships were unspoken of; black men were often times shot or lynched for even looking in the same direction as a white woman. Ruth knew that she could not confide in her immediate family and so her mother, after finding Ruth’s bracelet in the back alley in which the blacks lived, suggested that Ruth go and live with her grandmother in New York. Additionally, Ruth also kept the terrifying secret of the sexual abuse inflicted on her by her father, Tateh which caused her to fear and even despise him. These ominous secrets from the past continued to linger into the present and seemed to complicate the relationship of James and his mother as well as Ruth with the rest of her…

    • 309 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    My Antonia Summary

    • 512 Words
    • 3 Pages

    The novel, My Antonia, begins with Jim Burden, who is a New York City Lawyer. He gives a friend his journal of his Nebraska childhood. It is in the form of memories from a friend, Ántonia Shimerda. Jim starts his story in Nebraska when he was 10 years old. He had arrived to live with his grandparents after his parents die in Virginia. Jim first sees the Shimerdas on his trip towards Nebraska. They are a Bohemian immigrant family who were on the same train. When he arrives, he discovers that the Shimerdas have taken up residence in farm adjoining his grandparents. Jim becomes quick friends Ántonia; the Shimerdas around his age who has a passion to learn English. Jim decides to tutor Ántonia in her English teachings. Most of their time together is spent in the hills enjoying each other’s company. However, the mood shifts with the suicide of Mr. Shimerda. The Burdens find it difficult to connect with the Shimerdas, but try to be helpful as they can. As a result of the suicide, Ántonia and Jim find that they cannot stand each other. Several years after the suicide, the Burdens move to town. By chance, Ántonia becomes a maid to the family next door to the Burden’s, the Harlings. Jim…

    • 512 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    No. Just no. The well-known fantasy film, The Mortal Instruments: City of Bones is a total disappointment. Harald Zwart took an incredible book filled with emotion, adventure, and mystery and transformed it into 130 minutes of nothing. Cassandra Clare’s amazing writing and characterization was demolished by the horrible directing and simply not good enough acting. I’m sure Clare went home in tears.…

    • 627 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In Music in His Bones: Book One Billionaire Romance, Amerine Graham introduces readers to the Wilson family, who owns and operates Wilson Records, a top company in the recording industry. In the opening scene, brothers Kay, Nathan, and Chris Wilson are put to a challenge by their father and CEO, Wilhelm Wilson, of finding the next big act in the music industry. The challenge in hand, the brothers go their separate ways. Kay Wilson, eldest son and emotionally damaged ex-rocker turned music executive, goes on the hunt.…

    • 468 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Sometimes Ruth May does something, or something happens to her that reflect something she thought would make her happy. When she first meets Nelson, the little boy who is helping them survive in Kilanga, he gives her a charm to keep her safe from death. To use it you just need to think if a safe happy place and when you die you will go there instead and be safe. Ruth May trusted her friend and when she believes she is dying because of the ants she thinks of where she would be happy and safe. “I know what it is: it’s a green mamba snake up in the trees. You don’t have to be afraid of them anymore because you are one. They lie so still on the tree branch; they are the same everything as the tree. You could be right next to one and not even know. It’s so quiet there. That’s just exactly what I want to go and be, when I have to disappear.” (Kingsolver 304) Ruth May see’s the green mamba as a sign of happiness. She thinks it’s something that means safety and happiness. When they find one in the chicken house, she doesn’t see it as particularly dangerous, but upon its exit the mamba proves that it is. “I could only stare at Ruth May’s bare left shoulder, where two red puncture wounds stood out like red beads on her flesh. Two dots an inch apart, as small and tidy as punctuation marks at the end of a sentence none of us could read.” (Kingsolver 364) The same thing that brought her happiness and that she didn’t see as a threat became her undoing. The same snake that was suppose to keep her safe killed her (AAAAHHHHH still mourning tbh). Ruth May act of happiness in believing that the snake would make her safe was what caused her to die instead of bringing people closer…

    • 1590 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    At the beginning of the book it starts to talk about Ruth, James McBride's, mother. We learn of the life Ruth had and who her family was. Learning that Ruth was Jewish and the her family consisted of two siblings and her parents. The father was Fishel Shilsky and the mother was Hudis Shilsky. These two got an arranged marriage in order to get/stay in the U.S. Fishel, or Tateh (meaning father), was a mean and crude father and never really liked his children. Hudis, or Mameh (meaning mother), was kind of mild and loved her children, but also suffered from polio. Tateh used to be a rabbi, but then moved to the colored part of town and started a business. Mameh never really loved him, but she could not leave him because she could not provide for the…

    • 1844 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    She wanted the best for every single one of her kids. Also, she was missing the great religion aspect of her life. Furthermore, she needed the guidance to get back on track with her life. Consequently, Ruth has stumbled upon something that turned her life around. She found someone that would change her life in the matter of seconds. His name, was Dennis Adams McBride. They met up in the city of Harlem. He was from North Carolin and played a huge role in Ruth’s life. He believed in the Christian faith. He also was black, and for that reason, shows Ruth’s understanding about racism. Ruth was always against it. She even stated she hated people that were racist. Alternatively, they got married after a few years of dat ing. “See, a marriage needs love. And God. And a little money. That’s all. The rest you can deal with. It’s not about black or white” (McBride 233). This more importantly shows her non racism thoughts towards the black community. As a result of this marriage, Ruth converted from a Jew to practicing Catholicism with Dennis. From then on, it was the best for Ruth and Dennis. Unfortunately, a few months into Ruth’s pregnancy with James, she had lost her husband. Dennis ended up dying from lung cancer. Ruth was in shock and she prayed for him ever since. Afterwards, she then had James. When he was grown up, they both shared their Catholic faith and both wanted the best for each…

    • 810 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Kathy asks Ruth why she never pursued the possibility of getting to office job she had always dreamed of. With a barely audible voice, Ruth tells her, “How could I have tried… It’s just something I once dreamed about. That all,” (230). Ruth again shows the idea that her fate is sealed and there was no possibility of defying the life she was given to live.…

    • 968 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    2. Ruth’s life was a very interesting but emotionally upsetting with how she grew up with her parents and later on when she lived on her own. The first most important events in Ruth’s life was when her father, who she called Tateh, sexually abused her at a very young age when she lived in Sullfolk, Virginia, This impacted Ruth’s self-confidence very much so because her father treated her with no love and kindness but instead treated her like she was nothing important to him. She really felt unloved and not worthy of him because of how Tateh treated her. The second most important even in her life was meeting Frances her first very close friend. Frances was very impactful in Ruth’s Life because she showed Ruth that is was okay to be Jewish in her town and that education is very important. Also another thing that Frances did to Ruth was begin Ruth’s journey toward going to church and begin a relationship with God. The third most important even in Ruth’s life was when she met Peter who she met at her father’s work and later she became pregnant with his child. This was a very important moment in…

    • 887 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Lovely Bones Analysis

    • 799 Words
    • 4 Pages

    My eyes move from page to page scrutinizing each word like Susie Salmon watching her family live life. I have finished The Lovely Bones By Alice Sebold. As the time keeps moving forward, the search of Susie Salmon’s murder continues. The police have found evidence that Mr. Harvey is the murder and now trying to find him. As the police continue that search, Susie is walker watching her family move on from her death until; she has reached her moment to go to her heaven. Many events in the story made me connect and evaluate. The Sister Hood of The Traveling By Ann Brashares is about a group of friends that all fit into a magic pair of jeans and they all agree to share the pants over the summer as they all go on their summer vacation trips. The…

    • 799 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Last Rites of Indian Dead

    • 335 Words
    • 2 Pages

    She appeals to the emotions of the reader by putting in the personal touch with her family connection. She also makes people realize that it just isn’t about bones , it is about someones family. I think it strengthens her reasons, because you know she cares and she isn’t just writing a story.…

    • 335 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    The Lovely Bones

    • 320 Words
    • 2 Pages

    For my book of the month I chose to read The Lovely Bones by Alice Sebold. The book was an amazing experience because it was very exciting, it drew wonderful pictures in my mind. This book was heartfelt, but yet at times it was funny.…

    • 320 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Color of Water

    • 811 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Ruth is a tough, big-hearted character. She loves her children dearly but she refuses to any questions about her past and feed into their curiosity, especially James, son of Andrew. Ruth is at times reluctant to bring up her painful past which is why she chooses to avoid it. Following her second husband’s death, Ruth began the habit of riding her bicycle through the…

    • 811 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    The Color of Water

    • 7118 Words
    • 29 Pages

    * Ruth is reluctant to talk about her family because she felt that was the past and she just didn’t feel like opening up about something she felt “dead” about.…

    • 7118 Words
    • 29 Pages
    Powerful Essays