Preview

Summary Of When Breath Becomes Air

Powerful Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1646 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Summary Of When Breath Becomes Air
When Breath Becomes Air Throughout Paul’s experience with cancer, he reveals to the reader how dealing with mortality and being a neurosurgeon shaped that experience. Through this book, Paul details how he tries to tackle the question of his own mortality. At first, Paul tried to tackle this question by reading as much literature as possible. This plan worked, and Paul was exposed to different viewpoints on life and death. There was only one problem, even with reading all of these philosophical texts, he was still looking for the good life. In response to this dilemma, Paul decided that becoming a neurosurgeon was his best bet an answering this question, since he would be dealing with patients who were on the cusp of death. As a neurosurgeon, …show more content…
As a neurosurgeon, Paul was expected to give his patients their prognosis and possible treatments. The reason that Paul became a neurosurgeon was to find out the meaning of life. This is important because Paul had devoted a large chunk of his life to find out which life was worth living. At first, Paul stated that he wanted to be a writer, not a doctor. In fact, on page 19, Paul states that he wanted to be anything besides a doctor. It was only after he read a book form his old girlfriend that Paul decided to become a neurosurgeon, the book stated that the mind was a fiction of the brain, and Paul wanted to debunk that belief. Deontologically speaking, Paul saw it as his duty to find out what was a good life, and to live that good life. Further proof of this can be found when Paul had to choose between working on a research project, or working as a chef in the Stanford alumni camp. Instead of working on a highly valuable research project, Paul decided to work as a chef in the camp. Both of these choices represent the fundamental conflict in Paul’s life. On one hand, Paul could choose to be a doctor, and learn about mortality from terminally ill patients. On the other, Paul could explore different options for his life. Paul could become a writer, a teacher, or a professor, as he was trying to do later on. Instead, by being a physician, Paul could observe how death changed a person, and explore the vast responses a person would put up against it. Furthermore, after becoming a physician, Paul started to find the good life in treating the neurological disorders within a patient. However, Paul’s attitude soon changes when he is diagnosed with a rare form of lung

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Satisfactory Essays

    When Paul comes across Joseph Henisch, someone who once knew Keller before the loss of his family he realises how much Keller has changed as a result of the circumstances he endured…

    • 366 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    In the end of the book the protagonist’s problem finally is resolved, when he gains the courage to tell someone about the violent and angry behavior his brother shows all the time. At the end of the book Paul said to the police officer ,”I saw him, I saw Arthur Bauer sneak up on Luis Cruz, like a coward and hit him on the side of the head. Luis never even saw it coming… I saw - I heard Erik Fisher tell him to do it.” This is really where Paul overcomes his problem in the book by finally telling someone else about the things that he saw his brother do.…

    • 824 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Paul used to be a very sensitive and compassionate young man, who used to enjoy and write poetry before the war. However, all of this changed, as his time in the army made him completely detached from his feelings, disenabling him to experience certain feelings and emotions in the future. Paul describes his new self by saying, “We are dead men with no feelings, who are able by some trick, some dangerous magic, to keep on running and keep on killing.” Paul learned to take his mind completely off his feelings and emotions due to the terror of the war, and the shock of several events he witnessed, and insinuates that they have been transformed into ‘killing machines’. This once again demonstrates that Paul is a character of his time, as he demonstrates intense emotional coldness. The first indication that Paul is unable to mourn his comrades is found when Kemmerich’s death brings him down, but he is still not as depressed as one would be with the death of a…

    • 1512 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Western Front: Assignment

    • 303 Words
    • 2 Pages

    1. Paul feels alone in battle and his only friend and family seems to be mother earth. He finds comfort and protection with earth since he’s alone in battle and there’s nothing else protecting him except for earth’s materials like bushes and trees hiding him form the enemy. Like a mother would protect her son. I’m not sure if this has much to do with the Oedipus Complex but since Paul is loving the earth ever so passionately he probably subconsciously is yearning for something more than just a mother figure in his life.…

    • 303 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    One of the reasons why Paul is considered the noblest character is because of his loyalty towards people. First, in the beginning of the novel, one of Paul’s friend Kemmerich is badly injured and had to have his leg amputated, sadly things are getting any better for Kemmerich and in the course of time he eventually dies. Paul describes himself as “wretched with helplessness” (Remarque 30), and even though he was like that, he stayed with his friend until his very last seconds. This shows that Paul was loyal to his friendship with Kemmerich no matter how hard it was for him. Likewise, when he is injured with Kropp and they are on their way to the hospital, Kropp has a fever on their way to the hospital and has to stay at a Catholic…

    • 785 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Considering his experience on the front Paul is feeling hopeless and doesn't believe that he can make it. After all he is broken, rootless, and weary from the war. Also he is convulsing and about to die so he is obviously feeling hopeless because he really has almost no chance to live. He is also feeling like all this time in the war is pretty pointless since he doesn't even know what the war is about. He has been out there risking his life everyday for a reason that he doesn't even…

    • 553 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    For the greater part of the novel Paul relies on dehumanizing the enemy to survive the deep sense of guilt that emerges from killing other humans. However, when he is forced to take shelter in the same trench as the man he has killed, he needs a new coping mechanism to survive. Like Tim, Paul begins to see past the surface level of the dead soldier. He looks for familial ties in order to connect to this man. He says, “I see you are a man like me... now I see your wife and your face and our fellowship… He connects so deeply that he begins a fantasy about the man’s life where he sees himself as the dead soldier. He asks, “What would his wife look like? Does she belong to me now?” (Remarque 222) This is a very bold statement: it is as if by killing the man he somehow earns his wife. Even more frightening is when Paul says the “dead man is bound up with my life… I swear blindly that I mean to live only for his sake and his family… I have killed the printer, Gerard Duval. I must be a printer, I think confusedly, be a printer, printer....” I must become the printer now” (225). Part of this confession is that Paul feels bad for killing the man, and he hopes that reaching out to his family will make him feel better. However, the fantasy of adopting Gerard’s occupation speaks to a deeper truth. It is as if adopting this man’s life will keep the legacy of the…

    • 1469 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Paul’s thoughts on his youth are “And even if these scenes of our youth were given back to us we would hardly know what to do.” An immense amount of Paul and other soldiers’ youth was taken away from them too soon, even if these scenes of youth were given back to them they could not regain the old intimacy with these scenes. This quote also shows Paul’s loss of innocence. Paul has become wiser during the war, but this wisdom is leaving him with no hope in his future. Paul also says that if the scenes of their youth were given back to them “...it would be like gazing at a photograph of a dead comrade…” This quote shows how much Paul misses his youth but there is no way for him to connect with it. Youth and innocence is nowhere to be found for Paul and other…

    • 1015 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    One of the more obvious ways that the war had affected the conscience of Paul is shown later in the chapter nine when Paul is in a crater with the enlisted french man who is in the war. Paul stabs the man in the neck, and then realizes the consequences of his actions. He then writes a letter to the man’s family. In reflecting on his actions, Paul says “If only I had not lost my revolver I would have shoot him, stab him I can not” (Remarque pg. 221). When it comes to murdering a man, stabbing him is a more personal approach rather than placing a bullet in his cranium. This shows that Paul does not want to endure the war, rather he prefers to have it go away fast and painless.…

    • 872 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Although Paul enlisted by himself, he did not want to take part in the war. When the war was beginning, the stress that was put on Paul and his friends was greatly increasing. Through his teacher Kantorek, Paul was pushed to enlist because of how he spoke of national loyalty. Paul was not prepared, nor his friend, Joseph Behm, who was weak and the first of his peers to die. Several times throughout the book, Paul refers to Kantorek and how he should have never enlisted. Paul even blames the older generation for distrust. He states, “The idea of authority, which they represented, was associated in our minds with a greater insight and a more humane wisdom. But the first death we saw shattered this belief” (Remarque 47). Here Paul is explaining how he can only trust his generation. The older generations were the ones the boys used to trust. They were new to the world and trusted them to lead the boys in the right direction in their life, but they lead the boys to war, ultimately leading them to their death. To Paul, the pressure of society surrounded him coming from the people of Germany, the soldiers on the front, and even his family. Emotionally, Paul was broken by the war, at times he felt like breaking down in the arms of his mother, but he knew that was not socially acceptable. Although, Paul felt empty, he appeared strong and brave to civilians and family. He dare not…

    • 1703 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Throughout this story it is apparent Paul does not wish to slowly progress into perfection instead, Paul wants to experience instant gratification and while doing so Paul wants to move his way to the top and remain at the top. One down fall for Paul is that his method of personal achievement is attempted by being deceitful, telling lies to everyone that surrounds him including his teachers, his elders, and his father. Paul had the struggle of being successful yet, because of his hast, Paul was about to fail. In doing so, “he stood watching the approaching locomotive, his teeth chattering, his lips drawn away from them in a frightened smile; once or twice he glanced nervously sidewise, as though he were being watched.” (65). Paul appeared to think this was a time when he would be remember, that he would finally achieve what he was looking for, stardom, people would remember him and Paul ended his own life.…

    • 1124 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    He saw his friend Kemmerich get wounded and die right in front of him; he was told that the military was an honor and a great place to be, and now his best friend was dead. This made Paul begin to dislike his former teachers, as well as his commanding officers, especially when they just took away the body of one of the closest friends he had in order to replace it with someone else who had become wounded. This started Paul thinking that he was nothing more than a number. Seeing new recruits only worsened his hatred for his new life. Seeing them come in such big numbers made him think that if he died, there would be two more to replace him, rendering his existence meaningless. He already thought his life was meaningless since he had not yet lived, being so young. He believed that his life was in the hands of people like his drill sergeant, Himmelstoss, who had humiliated him in the past. Thinking that his higher ups thought nothing of him and did not care for him or his comrades, he took matters into his own hands and got his friends to take revenge against Himmelstoss, beating and whipping him when he least expected…

    • 822 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    “Mama said Life is like a box of chocolates, you never know what you are going to get”(tom hanks, actor in the movie Forrest Gump).This sort of tells us how life is unique and the quote tells us how anything can happen like the world being taken over for example. It is something we have to go through while living like how Paul has to go through having those glasses because of his decision to look at the solar eclipse without the proper protection. Paul goes through a lot of things in this book like he witnesses a sinkhole in his school and he decides to be brave and save other instead of thinking for himself. This brings me back to the quote “mama said life is like a box of chocolates, you never know what you are going to get”(Tom hanks, actor Forrest Gump). It brings me back to that quote because he did something amazing instead of saving himself. Just imagine you pick a chocolate box with a bunch of different types of chocolate in it and you don't know what they are so you just pick one and it could be a kind you don't like which is a bad decision and it could be one you do like which is a good…

    • 737 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    The Author Atul Gawande is a surgeon, staff writer for The New Yorker and a professor at the Harvard Medical School. Being Mortal: Medicine and What Matters in the End was an inspiring book that unwrap people’s mind for discussion and question our current practice of medicine and care. It is easy for audiences of all ages to relate to this book even if the young do not think about the process of death. It has a comprehensive coverage of medical sociology, where it deliberates on the evolution, controversial conversation of medicine and issues after medicine becomes impotent to people’s health. Gawande uses recounts of people (patients) and his own reflections on the stories to illustrate the dilemmas of the two facet of medicine: to attempt…

    • 1462 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    This is also shown through Paul’s relationship with Rosie who he, during the early stages of their association, dislikes, despite her obvious affection for him. But as he grows and matures, he gains appreciation for Rosie and even later on in the book where he becomes very self focused and self involved, he says that ‘at a time when most of my love was saved for myself, that I loved her was no small feat.’…

    • 597 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays

Related Topics