Study of Rhetorical Techniques and Proposition 8

Topics: Same-sex marriage, Homosexuality, Fear Pages: 4 (1193 words) Published: April 22, 2013
In the November 2008 United States election cycle, the state of California had Proposition 8 on the ballot. This was in response to the state legalizing gay marriage through the judicial system. After the legalization of the practice, opponents of gay marriage were able to put Proposition 8 on the ballot in an attempt to overturn the court ruling. Ultimately they were successful, but not without millions of dollars in campaign advertising. This paper will examine the main advertisement named, 'Gathering Storm'. This ad was shown throughout the state, and in retrospect seems to have turned the tide of the Proposition 8 battle, helping enormously to swing voters in favor of banning marriage between two members of the same sex.

The advertisement itself was, like many political ads, targeting a wide demographic of 'swing voters', voters who historically can fall on either side of an issue. It was played at prime time on regular rotation, but appeared to target a cross section of the population consisting of young to middle age professionals. The producers of the ad also seemed to be acutely aware of the wide range of diversity within California by making sure that all racial demographics had a speaking role in the ad. It is possible that this is an intentional choice by the creators of the ad as well, seeing as how the opponents of Proposition 8 often countered arguments by portraying the supporters as bigots who were attempting to limit human freedoms.

As the ad opens, an attractive white woman in business attire begins by saying, “There's a storm gathering.” In the background you can see ominous clouds swirling mightily behind her. The music is of an ominous nature, implying a dangerous situation. The camera then cuts to a wider angle, showing a mix of people standing in a desert with the same clouds behind them. It is worth noting at this point that California has deserts, and the most famous one of them to the locals is known as 'Death Valley'. There is no...


Cited: "National Organization for Marriage Gathering Storm TV Ad." Nation for Marriage. YouTube. 2008. Web. 07 Apr. 2009.
Continue Reading

Please join StudyMode to read the full document

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Proposition 8 Essay

    ...Proposition 8- Same-sex Marriage Proposition 8 has stirred up a controversial debate among the citizens in California as well as in the other states of the United States. This argument on same-sex marriage is not only about accepting how the new society had brought, but also about associating with the civil rights movements. Proposition 8 meant more than just a ban on same-sex marriage, it is a battle between the equality among gay couples and the old traditional definition of marriage, a development of love between a man and a woman. The argument over California’s Prop 8 was one of the most expensive running campaigns in the United States, second only to the presidential race. Both sides of the debate have spent millions of bucks into the campaign. Religious groups across the nation, including Catholics, Mormons and evangelicals, have gathered up in support of Proposition 8, which goes against the legalization of gay marriage. Groups that are anti-proposition 8 include Hollywood stars and celebrities like Brad Pitts, Ellen DeGeneres and Stephen Spielberg. Christians who are in support of banning gay marriage in California believe that the Bible prohibits homosexuality. If the Supreme Court decided to legalize same-sex marriage, churches would be forced to held marriage for gay couples; schools would be forced to...

    Read More
    664 Words 2 Pages
  • Proposition 8 Essay

    ... and not society. Homosexuals are not abnormal humans, so there is no reason to treat them any different, after all they are citizens who oblige to the same jurisdictions. In the brief article, 8 Is Not Hate: The Meaning of a proposition by Jennifer Roback Morse, Morse explains how marriage is a gender-based institution that attaches mothers and fathers to each other and to their children, but I disagree with her theory of marriage. I believe marriage is based on the love, trust, and the ability to provide for one another. If you were brought into this world as a homosexual then who are you to deny marriage to same sex partners, because although you deny marriage to same sex couples they’re not going to change their beliefs and values just because society does not accept them for who they are. Same sex couples should have the ability to choose their own spouses, without having to deal with ignorant bigots such as those who won’t accept others preferences, because of religious beliefs and values morals. If homosexuals have the same responsibility, consequences, and obligations as straight people then there is no reason to keep marriage away from same sex partner. Being homophobic is having fear of or contempt for lesbians and gays. Proposition 8 is seen as a discriminating proposition towards to gays and lesbians, because same sex couples are judged by almost all who don’t accept their sexual desires....

    Read More
    833 Words 4 Pages
  • The Debate of Proposition 8 Essay Example

    ...Should sexual preference determine marriages? This is the ongoing debate our generation will have to address. California has been in the epicenters of this debate; as we witnessed voters oppose gay marriage in the elections of 2008. The success of Proposition 8 discriminated against those of homosexual orientation. Proposition 8 adjusted California’s marriage laws to prevent a change in language, favoring the majority of heterosexual America. As California’s constitution in article 1, section 7.5 reads, "Only marriage between a man and a woman is valid or recognized in California" (California Marriage Protection Act). This perception of marriage adopted to be law is built upon gender identity ideals that men and women have to fulfill. Women are to marry that of the opposite gender and sex. Accordingly, the language used to describe marriage was contorted by gender ideals in the fight for Proposition 8. Those for Proposition 8 argued it would restore the definition of marriage. From this perspective, marriage is seen as a tradition that is natural and immutable. To the contrary, the argument against Proposition 8 states, “OUR CALIFORNIA CONSTITUTION—the law of our land—SHOULD GUARANTEE THE SAME FREEDOMS AND RIGHTS TO EVERYONE—NO ONE group SHOULD be singled out to BE TREATED DIFFERENTLY” (Official California Legislative Information)....

    Read More
    1631 Words 7 Pages
  • Proposition 8: Banning Gay Marriage in California Essay

    ...Proposition 8: Banning Gay Marriage in California Gay marriage is one of the most controversial issues of our time. It’s splattered all over news shows, radio, and newspapers. Which politicians support legalizing same sex marriage? Who’s against it? Which celebrities are commenting about it this week? One of the most publicized events in the battle about same-sex marriage was Proposition 8. This was a California amendment passed November 4th of 2008, officially eliminating the right of marriage between anyone but a man and woman. Same-sex marriage was legal for 7 months in California. Even though the grandfather clause allowed the marriages issued within that time to stay valid, scores of future couples lost a rare opportunity to marry. (Ballotpedia) Proposition 8 affected the lives of gay people throughout California by depriving couples of legal rights unique to marriage, slowing gay rights progress, and setting a precedent of political inaction. Marriage is considered a celebration, a right of passage, and in most religions, a holy union. It’s the happy ending in fairy tales, the front page of gossip magazines, and the premise for many romantic comedies. The legal benefits, while less glamorous than a cinderella wedding, are an important part of marriage that are often overlooked. According to Lifetips, a gay marriage advocate site, married couples have rights like...

    Read More
    1581 Words 7 Pages
  • Essay about Rhetorical Techniques and Sadat

    ...‘Statement to the Knesset’ Anwar el Sadat, 20 November 1977 1. Read the full transcript of the speech 2. Annotate speech – noting rhetorical techniques, structural features and values/ memorable ideas 3. Read Stanners notes and add to your understanding of context and rhetorical strategies used 4. Read and complete the following Audience * The Knesset is the Israeli Parliament * The speech was also broadcast live all over the world Context * Born in 1918 in Mit Abul Kom, a town within the British Colony, Anwar al-Sadat grew up with anti- colonial sympathies. He became one of the first Egyptian students in a military school founded by the British where he pursued Maths, Science and military history. His interest in the Battle of Gettysburg and his meeting with Gamal Abdel Nasser while posted in a minor army base in Egypt re-enforced his militant anti –corruption and anti-colonial stance. * Sadat’s association with Nassar continued through the latter’s life and Sadat succeeded Nassar in 1970. As a result of Sadat’s opposition to the corrupt regime he was jailed twice and after the second term of imprisonment left the armed services to become Nassar’s minister for Public Relations in charge of monitoring the abdication King Farouk and Egypt’s independence from British colonialisation * Although overshadowed by Nassar during the latter’s lifetime Sadat became a militant leader who threatened...

    Read More
    1527 Words 7 Pages
  • rhetorical technique Essay

    ... Rhetorical Techniques1 Definitions & Examples for Students 1. Repetition: the purposeful replication of words or phrases in order to make a point. Example: “It is rather for us to be here dedicated to the great task remaining before us…that government of the people, by the people, for the people, shall not perish from the earth.” Abraham Lincoln 2. Simile: an explicit comparison between two things using like or as. Example: “Life is like an onion: You peel it off one layer at a time, and sometimes you weep." Carl Sandburg 3. Metaphor: An implied comparison between two things of unlike nature that yet have something in common. Example: "The energy, the faith, the devotion which we bring to this endeavor will light our country and all who serve it--and the glow from that fire can truly light the world.” John F. Kennedy 4. Symbolism: The practice of representing things by means of symbols or of attributing symbolic meanings or significance to objects, events, or relationships. 5. Parallelism: the similarity of structure in a pair or series of related words, phrases, or clauses. Example: "It is by logic we prove, but by intuition we discover.” Leonardo da Vinci 6. Alliteration: the repetition of similar sounds in two or more adjacent words. Example: “She sells sea shells by the seashore.” – Famous American tongue-twister for children 7. Rhyme: Rhyme is the similarity in sound of the ends of words Example: “For thy sweet...

    Read More
    402 Words 2 Pages
  • Rhetorical Devices and Literary Techniques Essay

    ... 2. Rhetorical Devices and Literary Techniques Rhetorical devices and literary techniques are closely related to tone and style. In fact, an author’s style partly consists of selecting and using certain devices; an author’s tone is partially determined by the type of techniques an author uses. Many SAT books will list lots of Greek terms you don’t need to know, such as synecdoche and anaphora. But the Critical Reading section won’t require that you know the names of rhetorical devices or literary techniques. Rather than bombard you with dozens of unfamiliar terms, we’ll categorize and clump the most common types of devices and techniques below and provide some examples and commentary. As we said, you won’t be specifically tested on these concepts, but they do lurk beneath the surface in the passages. Having a solid understanding of these devices and techniques will improve your ability to handle RPs. Focus on absorbing the similarities and differences between and among them. As you read through the list, note the one key feature all of these techniques and devices share: they allow words and sentences to carry more than only their literal meaning. Here is a list of the most important devices and techniques. We’ve included examples along with commentary on each one: Hyperbole I’m as hungry as a starving lion....

    Read More
    1320 Words 6 Pages
  • Essay about Rhetorical Technique

    ...Rising the social logic No one can argue that America is the country of the human rights and freedom and many people around the world dream to live in this great place. However, big problem is going to reshape the American society if nobody tried to solve it. The dilemma is simply that the rich got richer and the poor got poorer as a result of inequality of money distribution among rich and poor people.America had created a marvelous economic machine, but evidently it worked only for that at the top. Both Joseph E. Stieglitz and Timothy Noahintroduce a very critical issue which affects the American society in these days, is the widening gap between the rich and poor people. Stieglitz claims that the American economic system is failing for most of Americans and the inequality is increasing to the extent that one day will be unaffordable. The rising gap is created by the one top percent who are taking advantage of making a huge wealth. They are driven by their greed to accumulate big fortune upon poor’s shoulders. Stieglitz came up with some evidence to support his claim. One of these is the new statistics fromCensus Bureau’s statistics that shows that the one top percent gain 20 % of the total American income. Therefore, Noah says that this inequality income creates and retains the capitalism system which forms a serious threat upon middle and lower class (Noah The Great par 3). The top 1 percent may have the best houses, educations, and lifestyles, says the author,...

    Read More
    330 Words 2 Pages

Popular Essays

Become a StudyMode Member

Sign Up - It's Free