Preview

Social Justice In City Of Thieves: Written By David Benioff

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1536 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Social Justice In City Of Thieves: Written By David Benioff
Tayari Jones wrote, “I don't mind expressing my opinions and speaking out against injustice. I would be doing this even if I wasn't a writer. I grew up in a household that believed in social justice. I have always understood myself as having an obligation to stand on the side of the silenced, the oppressed, and the mistreated”. The novel, City of Thieves written by David Benioff demonstrates compelling consequences faced when a social injustice is present in a given society. City of Thieves is based off of World War II, in a society where people are mistreated for a variety of reasons. German soldiers take advantage of innocent women and force sexual relations in exchange for just enough food in order to survive. Russian Colonel, Grechko, gives …show more content…
The protagonist Lev and his new accomplice, Kolya, encounter a couple who invite the two boys up to their building with the offer of a dozen eggs. Lev and Kolya are assaulted by the couple who reveal themselves to be cannibals and try to eat the two boys. Whilst looking in disbelief at human remains, Lev says, “Maybe my brain tried to convince that they weren't looking at what they were looking at: a flayed thigh that could only be a women’s thigh, a child’s rib cage, a severed arm with the hand’s ring finger missing” (Benioff 58). As disturbing as that scenario is, it was the harsh reality innocent civilians faced during the time. The government does not care about the innocent civilians fighting for survival everyday, in a city lacking shelter and resources. The government causes inequality in the society, forcing things such as poverty and cannibalism to happen. The same issues are present in today's society. People are overlooked and mistreated by society. Approximately 4.9 million Canadians live in poverty today, which translates to 1 in 7 people in Canada. A commercial striving to end poverty, states: “If 4 million Canadians were to stop driving on highways, were to stop going out to shopping centres, were to stop going out in period, you would notice. But how can over 4 million people in Canada living in poverty …show more content…
The protagonist in the novel Lev is first portrayed as an innocent, seventeen year old kid. He loses his family, and is left on his own to fend for himself. His friends and him notice a dead german soldiers body on the ground. He lives in a city with lacking resources so naturally goes to pry any resources from the body. He is arrested for this act of looting by Soviet Union Colonel, Grechko. He is given a choice to find a dozen eggs in one week in a city with no food or resources, or be executed. This unfair and unnecessary decision made by the Colonel whom already had eggs, acted as some sort of entertainment to Grechko. This demonstrates the abuse innocent civilians received from the government and military for simply trying to survive in desperate times. After beating German soldier, Abendroth in a game of chess, Lev knocks down Abendroth and says, “I sat up and shoved the point of my knife deep into his chest, through the breast pocket of his jacket, below the cluster of medals, the blade sliding in all the way to the silver finger guard” (Benioff 231). Lev kills German soldier Abendroth because of the inhumane things he has done to the sex slaves including cutting off one of the girls feet. Throughout this “egg hunt”, Lev’s character transforms into a completely new person. He goes from being an ordinary, innocent kid, to killing another man in the span of

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    In Deborah Samson’s child and teenage years were rough because she lived in poverty. It didn’t make anything any better when her father left on a expedition at sea and never came back. She was taken from her mother and was in the care of her grandparents. When her grandparents passed away she moved in with a farmer living in Middleborough. She was only ten years old and was expected to work as an indentured…

    • 316 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Soldier X Summary

    • 476 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Erik Brandt is a 16 year old half Russian half German boy. He is in a program called Jungend which is also known as Hitler's Children Army. It is like Boy Scouts for German Kids. They boys in the Jungend are also enlisted soldiers who have to fight when it is needed. One day Erik is sent to fight in the war. He is shipped to the eastern front where the Germans have to fight Russia on Russian soil. Erik is uncomfortable because he is half Russian and German. He was aware of the things Germans were doing to Jews but he was convinced it was right and that Jews were preventing Germany's world domination. While traveling to Russia he becomes acquainted with some other boys in his platoon named Oskar, Jakob, and Fassnacht. They get attacks by aircraft and very few of the Germans die but the boys are pretty scared. When they reach their destination they go into the trenches and prepare to fight. Their commander explains the plan and teaches them how to use certain equipment like mines and grenades. When the first waves of Russians attack it is mainly infantry foot soldiers. The Germans win and Erik thinks it’s over and he is exhausted and tired. Then their commander says that was the easy one and tells them to prepare for tanks to start progressing. In the second wave the Germans start to drop and German hope looks lost. Erik is hit by a grenade and he is hurt. He is lying in pain in the bottom of a trench. With many dead bodies around him, he sees that playing dead won’t help because the Russians are stabbing every body they find with a bayonet. He knew he was running out of time. To his luck a tank broke down over him. He now has to think fast. He sees a dead Russian boy and puts on him uniform to disguise himself. He leaves the trench disguised as a Russian. As he is going he get shot by a surviving German in the side. He passes out and wakes up in hospital. When the soldiers he meets asks his name he says he has amnesia. He meets a young nurse in…

    • 476 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The events throughout the novel shape Lev, and act as an explanation for the behavior of the author’s fictional grandfather. Lev is a personified USSR, having been deeply affected by the situation forced onto them by the German invaders during a sensitive developmental period of their lives. Before chapter one, David Benioff writes in the point of view of a fictional author whose grandparents both experienced the Siege of Leningrad. To the unnamed author, the two were unlike the other retirees in Florida. “They don’t wear their seat belts in the car; they don’t wear suntan lotion in the sun. They have decided nothing can kill them but God himself…” (11). Modern day Russians are characterized as fearless, toughened by the history of their homeland. In this sense, the alleged author’s grandparent’s fit the description of the average Russian citizen, which is contextualized by the rest of the story. Lev’s character arc was heavily influenced by the books subject matter, with both being in opposition to Kolya’s personality. Despite their differences, both Kolya, Lev, and Leningrad were able to retain the humanity that their surroundings…

    • 992 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    During high school, I worked part time as a player attendant at the local country club golf course. During my time there, I formed a relationship with a member who later became a very important mentor of mine. Late into my senior year, he suggested I look into Investment Banking and loaned me his favorite book, Den of Thieves. The book was thick, nearly 600 pages, but told the story of Michael Milken and the insider trading of the 1980’s perfectly. As a high school senior with little business knowledge, I understood maybe 50% of the content, but the book sparked my initial interest in banking. Pursuing this interest, I found the booth for the Investment Banking Club at the Kelley Carnival and eagerly signed-up. Through attending the meetings…

    • 222 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The entire purpose of this documentary The Untouchables was to seek an answer to an abbreviated question: why has no Wall Street executive been criminally prosecuted for fraud tied to the sale of mortgages. But the unabbreviated question and the one that infuriates us as Americans is: why has no executive of a major Wall Street firm been criminally prosecuted for anything. Containing interviews with top prosecutors of the DOJ, government officials and industry whistleblowers, Frontline reports allegations that Wall Street bankers ignored pervasive fraud when buying pools of mortgage loans. Tom Leonard, a supervisor who examined the quality of loans for major investment banks like Bear Stearns, said bankers instructed him to disregard clear evidence of fraud. “Fraud was the F-word, or the F-bomb. You didn’t use that word,” says Leonard. “By your terms and my terms, yes, it was fraud. By the industry's terms, it was something else.” Hearing these statements infuriated me more for Leonard was trying to even inform his supervisors of what was going on what some points but they continued to ignore this as well. All the bankers were interested in was profit and money; this is a clear enough view for criminal intent, which the DOJ had been having trouble proving this without a reasonable doubt. If the U.S. Justice Department was serious about doing its job, it has a cornucopia of crimes to pick from: Wall Street CEOs and CFOs attesting to fraudulent financial filings with the SEC, money laundering, lying in prospectuses, illegal foreclosures, rigging the Libor interest rate benchmark and then selling interest rate swaps based on a rigged index to school districts, cities and counties across America, manipulating the futures market with a rigged Libor interest rate, and so forth. From this documentary alone it strikes me as odd that not a single Wall Street CEO or CFO is sitting behind bars serving time for any of these crimes that are so blatantly obvious. The closes…

    • 389 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    There is a lot that we can learn from people who have experienced history. Bella Spewack, specifically, is a great example of the struggle immigrants endured while trying to survive in America after immigration. Today, it is beneficial to learn about the personal views of people who lived in the past so we can gain a better understanding of how communities today were developed. Reading “Streets”, you can understand what the post immigration life was like in New York in the early years of Bella’s life. Bella included a lot of details in her memoir that allows the reader to understand how difficult life was for an immigrant. Even though “Streets” was written from the perspective of Bella, we can still rely on her opinions to give us an understanding of the difficulty immigrants faced while starting a new life.…

    • 1358 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    HUM 301 Sunflower

    • 3280 Words
    • 14 Pages

    After confirming that he is Jewish, a nurse escorts Simon to the bedside of a dying Nazi solider named Karl. With his yellow-stained bandaged head appearing through the semidarkness of the hospital room, Karl hauntingly recounts his involvement in the horrifying death of a father, a mother, and a dark-eyed child who are brutally shot down after jumping out of a burning building (Wiesenthal 42-43). Simon becomes extremely distressed with the imagery evoked by the untimely demise of the dark-eyed child, especially when he theoretically identifies the child with a six-year old named Eli (Wiesenthal 46). Indeed, while recalling the heart-wrenching scenes of the kindergarten extermination, Simon fights the urge to leave the hospital room as the dying soldier continues to recount the rest of his confession. With sincere remorse in his voice, Karl begs for the forgiveness of a Jew. The irony of this dying soldier's confession arises from the fact that "a murderer who did not want to be a murderer but who had been made into a murderer by his murderous ideology" was confessing his crime to a man that may die by the…

    • 3280 Words
    • 14 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    He backs up these facts with detailed approximations of the number of children born into poverty; “I again subtract fifty thousand for those women who miscarry, or whose children die by accident or disease within the year. There only remain a hundred and twenty thousand children of poor parents annually born.” (Swift…

    • 608 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    “Everyone has the right to freedom of thought, conscience, and religion.” (Article18). In the book thief by Markus Zusak this article was violated many times by Hitler and other characters. Hitler and the torture that he brought to characters such as Max, Liesel, and Hans violate many articles such as article 18 in the UDHR. These characters were not given the right to freedom of religion. Or given the chance to stand up for what they believe is right. Or even given the privacy they deserve in their own homes. However all of these characters must learn to change and adapt to life in this new cruel world.…

    • 695 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    The Book Thief

    • 308 Words
    • 2 Pages

    In the novel The Book Thief written by Markus Zusak, words have a huge impact on individuals. Everything that’s going on in the world changes the way that the characters are and how they react to specific events. In this essay the reader will understand about how the characters are most affected by words, these three characters are Liesel, a young girl who moved to Munich as a foster child, Max a Jewish man who hides himself from the world for the majority of his life, and Hitler the master behind all the brutal events in Germany. Throughout this essay the reader will have a better understanding of the impact that words may have on individuals.…

    • 308 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Food Bank Research Paper

    • 677 Words
    • 3 Pages

    “Food banks were first established as emergency relief for those in need of food. Nearly 20 years later, they have become an integral part of contemporary Canadian society,” (Theriault & Yadlowski, pg. 206). Furthermore, “the number of people thought to be in need of food aid to help them eat – in the form of food parcels and food banks – have been underestimated,” (O’Dowd, pg. 6). In fact, “more than two-thirds of people receiving assistance from food pantries get help on a regular basis, and the use of private food assistance has risen dramatically since 1980,” (Paynter et al, pg. 27). Therefore, “controversy has arisen, over whether food banks should even exist and who should be responsible for rectifying the…

    • 677 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    War Is Not a Game

    • 933 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Etgar Keret’s “Not Human Beings” is the story of Schmulik Stein, a soldier who is young and jaded by the realities of death and violence. As an officer during the Israeli-Palestinian conflict, he is forced to recognize the serious nature of conflict he is involved in when he is recruited to go with Israeli border patrol officers. He is then put to the greatest test of all, to dehumanize, stand his ground and witness things he may never be able to forget. At the end of the story Stein realizes that this is no longer a game but life and death. Keret suggests that while some people are exposed to the atrocities of war become demonized by it; others remain intact with their humanity but can ultimately become lost individuals due to the trauma.…

    • 933 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Poverty in Canada

    • 1503 Words
    • 7 Pages

    How can there be so many people in poverty? It is all around us even though Canada has made the G20 Richest Nations; they still have one of the highest poverty rates for in the industrialized world. Through reading many articles such as Ann Duffy and Nancy Mandell’s “Poverty in Canada”, others that I have found online, and my own personal experience I have learned the numerous reasons why so many people in a well industrialized nation such as Canada are struggling with poverty.…

    • 1503 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Food Insecurity in Canada

    • 936 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Food insecurity is a social determinant of health that is becoming more prevalent in Canadian society. Food security is an important aspect of public health in which there is growing evidence between the association of food insecurity and poorer health outcomes. According to Raphael (2009), food insecurity can be defined as “the inability to acquire or consume an adequate diet quality or sufficient quantity of food in socially acceptable ways, or the uncertainty that one will be able to do so” (p. 188). One would not think that in a higher income country such as Canada that food insecurity would even be a public health concern, but according to Health Canada (2012) 7.2% of Canadian households were food insecure between the years 2007 and 2008. In addition, food insecurity was positively correlated with lower income households. According to Health Canada (2012) 55.5% of food insecure households main source of income was from social assistance.…

    • 936 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Best Essays

    Student: Social Policy

    • 4675 Words
    • 26 Pages

    Child Poverty in Canada. Why are 10 percent of kids poor? TVO (2010) 1 hour approx.…

    • 4675 Words
    • 26 Pages
    Best Essays