Christopher Godat
English 1101
September 13, 2010
Should the Penny be Eliminated? The penny, a copper and zinc coin, that represents one cent in the United States currency, is as American as apple pie. It is part of our heritage to honor and recognize our founding fathers and past presidents for their contributions to the economic system of America. According to the Harris Poll #51 conducted online between June 10 – 16, 2004 including 2,136 adults, the majority favor keeping the penny in circulation (Source E). The United States is a democracy and I believe we should let the people vote on this important issue. Jim Kolbe, a U.S. Representative from Arizona tried to introduce a bill to discourage the use of pennies by establishing a system which would round up or down a cash transaction. It is dangling in a subcommittee. His press secretary states “It’s practically useless in everyday life”. However, is Kolbe’s argument about its uselessness or about increasing wealth in his home state? Arizona is rich in copper which is a predominant metal in larger denomination coins (Source A). One argument for eliminating the penny is the wasted time fishing for pennies on cash transactions. Jeff Gore, founder of “Citizens for Retiring the Penny” conducted a study with The National Association of Convenience Stores and Walgreens that determined handling pennies added 2 to 2.5 seconds to each cash transaction. After all of the numbers were crunched, he calculated that four hours per person were wasted each year searching for pennies. This equates to a national cost of over $15 billion dollars per year if each person’s time is worth $15/hour (Source B). How much time did he waste conducting this study? What he didn’t calculate was the extra profits these retailers received on impulse purchases while waiting on the patron to count his pennies. I believe these extra purchases greatly outweigh the “wasted time” counting pennies. William Safire advocates abolishing the penny from currency circulation and believes Lincoln would be ashamed to have his face on this specious specie. I beg to differ and believe he would be proud to be represented on something found in every household in America. He also states that over two thirds of pennies immediately drop out of circulation into piggy banks, behind cushions, or inside your sock drawer (Source C). However, Mark Weller found a 2002 study based on Federal Reserve data that stated the annual rate that pennies disappeared from circulation was around 5.6 percent – very similar to all forms of coinage (Source D). To commemorate Abraham Lincoln’s 200th birthday, President Bush signed legislation in December 2005 to issue Lincoln pennies in 2009 with four newly designed “tails” images. Each image depicts different aspects of President Lincoln’s life. This change was the first redesign of the penny in 50 years. According to Michael Bishop, executive director of the Abraham Lincoln Bicentennial Commission, “the penny is perhaps the most visible and tangible reminder of Lincoln’s significance in American history.” (Source F). I am a proponent of keeping the penny in circulation. They teach our children math skills and the value of saving. They are also a source of conversation on Abraham Lincoln’s contribution to the democratic system we enjoy today. If the penny is eliminated, our grandchildren will never know the significance of “putting in your two cents”.
Works Cited
Source A, Lewis, Mark. “Ban the Penny.” Forbes.com 5 July 2002. 8 February 2006 <http://www.forbes.com/2002/07/05/0705penny.htm>.
Source B, Kahn, Ric. “Penny Pinchers.” Globe.com 9 October 2005. 10 February 2006 <http://www.boston.com/news/local/massachusetts/articles/2005/10/09/penny_pinchers/>Source C, Safire, William. “Abolish the Penny.” Nytimes.com 2 June 2004. 3 November 2006
<http://www.select.nytimes.com/gst/abstract.html?res=F00911F63C550C718CDDAF089DC404482>.
Source D, Weller, Mark W. Letter. Unpublished letter to the New York Times. Americans for Common Cents. 7 Nov. 2006. <www.pennies.org.>. Source E, “Abolish the Penny? A Majority of the Public Says ‘No.’” The Harris Poll #51 15 July 2004. 8 March 2006 <http://www.harrisinteractive.com/harris_poll/index.asp?PID=480> Source F, “President Bush signs Lincoln Penny Redesign Into Law.” Abraham Lincoln Bicentennial Commission. 22 December 2005. 8 March 2006 <http://www.lincolnbicentennial.gov/press/news/12230527.php.>.
You May Also Find These Documents Helpful
-
According to the passage, the Lincoln penny had the initials of the designer, Victor D. Brenner on it. Americans complained the initials were too big and needed to be removed. This resulted in them removing them and later putting them back on, just smaller. Nowadays pennies from 1909 are very valuable and rare.…
- 270 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
One of the many reasons the penny should be deleted is because of the cost to actually manufacture one. The penny itself is created to hold the monetary value of the one cent, the lowest value, yet it costs 2.4 cents to manufacture each one thus making the tradeoff of creating a penny to be negative since the output is more than the input thus concluding towards a disincentive. “This, although is a small loss of money, can result in and will amount to the loss of millions of dollars over the cause of several years.” (Source A) Within today’s society, people have a hard time to buy anything with even the dollar. Even if someone is able to buy something with the dollar, the dollar simplifies to 100 pennies and since it costs 2.4 cents to create each individual penny, essentially 1.4 dollars are wasted. With America already submerged in a national debt of $18.34 billion, these costs that outweigh the benefits will not only raise our national taxes to compensate for the lost money, but will also dig into the education programs to raise funds for lost money thus cutting children’s education. “Essentially, the penny is so worthless that it does nothing but waste more money and time.” (Source B)…
- 1298 Words
- 4 Pages
Better Essays -
Annoying cashiers was something my siblings and I did quite unintentionally as kids. Down the block from the street we lived on, there was a little convenience store that sold Italian ices, ice cream bars, and a variety of assorted goodies; on hot summer days, we would gather what little change we could find in the couch cushions and pay for our selected treats with pennies, nickels, dimes, and, if the cashier was lucky, quarters. That was when I started thinking about pennies. Are pennies useful? Back in the day, you could buy a stick of gum for a penny! Now, with inflation, pennies do not have the purchasing power they used to. This has led to the question of whether the United…
- 927 Words
- 4 Pages
Better Essays -
o Americans had no currency, but they were constantly buying things from Britain, so that gold and silver was constantly draining out of America, forcing some to even trade and barter. Eventually, the colonists were forced to print paper money, which depreciated.…
- 2539 Words
- 11 Pages
Good Essays -
The penny is seen as time consuming, annoying, and useless because of the time spent in lines as someone rummages through their wallet to find all their pennies, the wasted space in pockets and on top of desk drawers, and the fact that they are not valued as much as other coins. Although these arguments are plausible, they would not justify the penny coin being expunged. Fishing for pennies in the grocery store line only requires a few seconds, they do not take up more than a few square inches at most, and the worth of the penny depends solely on the person who is in possession of it. Ridding the U.S. economy of the penny to speed up a cash transaction and empty up a few inches of space would be naïve, especially considering it's historical and cultural…
- 731 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
The primary purpose for Nickel and Dimed are for literary purposes, as the author seems to write with the goal of entertaining the reader. Throughout the story, the author regularly uses humor with the express purpose to entertain the reader. "It's good to know that something is cheaper than my time, or that in the hierarchy of the company's values I rank above Windex." (Page 307)…
- 354 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
. . [thus] render[ing] the penny unnecessary” (Source A). While this law may reduce the amount of pennies produce and thus reduce the amount of copper manufactured for pennies each year, Kolbe’s proposition has the ability to lead into an endless peril of ridding the economy of the lowest-value coins. If the penny is not used, will the nickel then be banned in a few decades? Then the dime? The quarter? Introducing such a system of currency would prove far too strenuous to Kolbe regardless, given the fact that fifty-nine percent of Americans aged eighteen and over oppose abolishing the penny, compared to twenty-three Americans favoring the abolition of the penny with eighteen percent of citizens having no official opinion (Source E). The time and money spent to conduct polls and attempt to persuade two-thirds of the American population to forfeit their pocket change proves fatal; it would be a waste of time and evidently a waste of money (including pennies!). Even our neighbors in Great Britain, Canada, Japan, and the U.S. have “the penny or penny-equivalent” coins (Source…
- 744 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
In conclusion, hopefully you now notice the importance's of why the government should stop the production of pennies. If the production of pennies is not stopped, moreover America’s inflation in the economy will only become worse(Maria Story). Some artifacts, no matter how valuable, are just not worth keeping. The Chicago Tribune put it perfectly, “Time to kill the…
- 678 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
No one will ever use pennies anymore.Several people when getting change back just throw the pennies anywhere.Now a days pennies lay around everywhere and are annoying. There's some people that may even be fooled by this coin. The penny should be killed. Many people now won't have to worry about finding this…
- 53 Words
- 1 Page
Satisfactory Essays -
Ultimately, the prodigal penny should be abolished because the coin devours valuable time, money, and resources that could be put to better use elsewhere. It is time to give up the search; get your hands out of the couch cushions. Stop searching through the dark abyss of your purses and bags. You won’t find much and whatever you find will not be worth much…
- 501 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
In modern day society, currency is an imperative part of our everyday living. From purchasing groceries to paying bills, it is integrated into practically every aspect of our culture. It is hard to imagine life without currency as a means of competitive exchange. However, in Colonial America, there were several different types of money used in numerous ways. One means of currency was not dominant over any other until well after the American Revolutionary War. The question arises, how did colonists handle fiscal transactions without a bank system in place? They did so in 3 different forms: Native American wampum, trading goods, and early forms of paper money such as “tobacco notes”. A fully functioning society is dependent upon a strong and opportunistic economy. Currency in Colonial America plays an integral part in forming the structure of society as we know it today.…
- 819 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
The reason that we need to keep the penny is because we don’t need anymore change in the US. If we remove the penny, then we will have to change. The nation is already changing so much because of the election and politics and the other things. So why change more?…
- 401 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
After reading Nickel and Dimed and reviewing the NASW Code of Ethics I found a few parts of the code of ethics Ehrenreich did not follow. I believe she was in breach of privacy and confidentiality, dishonesty, fraud, and deception, and integrity.…
- 1380 Words
- 6 Pages
Good Essays -
For twenty years, Americans had been bitterly divided over the nation's monetary standard. The gold standard, which the United States had effectively been on since 1873, limited…
- 259 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
Most machines that receive change won’t accept one cent coins anymore and the pennies will just collect in people’s wallets or pockets. Canada got rid of their pennies and it seems America may do the same at some point. It costs almost double one cent to make a penny, and this is not cost efficient. There is a lot of controversy over the matter. People have been discussing whether removing the penny would hurt or help the economy for some time now. In the Time Josh Sanburn claimed, “Pennies would likely be melted down and sold for their zinc and copper, which could yield millions of dollars for federal coffers” (Sanburn 1). Pennies may end up being a rare collectable in the far future, but as of now they remain a neglected form of currency with the increased use of digital transactions. Pennies will remain a staple in history no matter what their future…
- 1951 Words
- 8 Pages
Powerful Essays