top-rated free essay

Poem Analysis for Different History by Sujata Bhatt

By Sanaya2 May 19, 2013 944 Words
The poem begins with “Great Pan is not dead; he simply emigrated to India” The delivery of this line as well as the meaning of these opening lines should be noted: where the confidently stated sentence creates a critical tone. The pause mode shows how the narrator firstly wants to dismiss any misconception regarding the Ancient Greek god of nature and that the truth is that “emigrated to India”. With this short and brief opening the reader is able to know that the poem deals with conflicting theories on tradition and culture. The narrator then continues to speak against untraditional behavior with the repetition of the phrase “a sin” due to how wrongful acts as listed in lines 9-14. The sins include actions such as “to shove a book aside with your foot”, “to slam books down hard on a table, a sin to toss one carelessly across 0a room.”With repeating the phrase, Bhatt manages to reinforce the negative commentary and intensifies the critical tone of the poem with each sin described. What is also to be recognized is how the narrator does not specify and indentify responsible for the committing of these sins, but still communicates a sense of tension towards other cultures who have disrespected traditional literature and therefore the meanings within the theme. Perhaps what is also meant by featuring a list of sins is to empahsise the wrong in mistreating books, to the extent of religious injustice which could evoke emotion and thought into anyone within the large and dominating Christian religion which crosses international borders. In line fifteen, the narrator tells the readers that they “must learn how to turn the pages gently”- use of second person narration. This language feature is greatly effective with how it speaks to the reader directly and includes them in the issue, whatever culture they may be. The line is a universal message, for how the narrator wishes to communicate the immense importance and urgency of having a respectful approach towards books. The line is also an imperative, where the commanding word “must” seems to give the readers no option but to obey. What this language feature contributes to the theme of cross cultural differences, is not an explanation or description but a universal solution to maintain the heritage within the books. One of the key aspects of the poem is Bhatt’s notable efforts to not disturb identities such as “Sarasvati”, the Hindu goddess of arts and knowledge, due to her extreme importance to the Indian culture. But what is interesting as well, is how the narrator says “without offending the tree/from whose wood the paper is made” It is through this personification that the non human object is acknowledged as a figure which deserves as an individual, for the significant role it plays in the nation’s culture. The personification also emphasizes to perhaps anyone of a different nationality, that as an individual, the tree should be seen with a sense of humanity- a sense which anyone from any culture could accomplish. Towards the end of the poem, comes the rhetorical questioning of the cross cultural issue. The narrator provocatively asks, “Which language has not been the oppressor’s tongue? Which language truly meant to murder someone?” The questions not only indentifies a harmful and dangerous oppressor or colonist but it shows how the Indian culture has been part of the damaged cultures and tongues that have been lost due to colonialism, which is also becomes a prominent theme in the poem. The tone of the questions should also be considered, the passion and sadness of the narrator is given through the questioning of the current world order. An extended metaphor also exists within the closing lines of the poem, where the parallels between the agriculture and the cross cultural difference are drawn, This is done with “after the soul has been cropped with a long scythe” and how they grow to love that “strange language”. The suggested outcome that the traditions, culture and language will fade into the words of other foreign language is made to seem sad, but with more analysis one could see that the narrator is indeed sad, but seems to accept the idea. This makes the final tone of “history”- where the pain and hurt has turned into peace. The peace may come from the narrator’s relations that the plant of Indian Culture has in fact, not died as suggested before, but that the plant has always been growing and developing even before the narrators time. The narrator may have realised that there was one moment where the traditions and language they held dear was once seen as radical by those further in the past. Through a well selected series of language and literary techniques/terms, Bhatt achieves to produce a poem which discusses the mistake made after the collision of very different cultures and then explains the truth and proper customs which have been lost. The narrator, in the process of this discussion also resolved the intense emotions they once had, by accepting that cross- cultural consequences such as colonialism do not ruin a history, but creates a different tone. The aspect of the poem which makes it so abundantly powerful is how the poet uses their own personal life experiences to write from the narrator’s perspective. Bhatt was born and spent her childhood in India and then moved to the united states of America for her education- knows best of the cultural difference between two vastly distinct nations and writes the poem as one of the “unborn grandchildren” hoping to hold on to the past, as she goes on into the unknown future.

Cite This Document

Related Documents

  • A Different History by Sujata Bhatt - Analysis

    ...Explore the ideas in the poem A Different History by Sujata Bhatt. Sujata Bhatt reflects and explores on the ideas of ‘culture, ‘values’, human struggle, religion combined with its beliefs and acquisition of foreign or strange language. Bhatt invites the readers and takes them through the culture of India and its religious beliefs that ev...

    Read More
  • Analysis of A Different History by Sujata Bhatt

    ...A DIFFERENT HISTORY A Different History written by Sujata Bhatt portrays the loss of language and cultures after colonization in India. This poem describes the bitterness and sadness Bhatt felt about her mother tongue and cultures. Bhatt explores the idea of history, culture and language throughout the poem. Bhatt uses two enjambments in t...

    Read More
  • A Different History by Sujata Bhatt Notes

    ...oppressor’s tongue? When another country is the conquerer, that country brings its language and culture to those who are conquered. SUMMARY ‘A Different History’ is in two linked parts: lines 1-18, then lines 19-29. The first stanza draws the link between western and Indian culture as Pan, the Greek god also exists through Indian ...

    Read More
  • Sujata Bhatt - Different History Summary

    ...The poetess Sujata Bhatt, while writing this poem has given importance to the culture and various religions in India. She has emphasized in her poem by repeating words and questions and thereby making her poem stronger. She writes about Indian traditions, lost identities, importance of language, cultural difference to create different moods and ...

    Read More
  • A Different History by Sujata Bhatt

    ...A Different History by Sujata Bhatt Wednesday November 09th 2011, 9:59 am  Filed under: A Different History This poem is written by Sujata Bhatt who emigrated from India. This poem is about the British Colonization in India and importance of religions and culture in India. There are 2 seperated parts in the story where there is 2 differen...

    Read More
  • A Different History Analysis

    ...Comment closely on “A Different History”, paying particular attention to how Bhatt presents differences. In the poem “A Different History” by Sujata Bhatt, the poet speaks about culture identity, the importance of language, and religion. Bhatt describes the history of India during the British colonization days, from her point of vi...

    Read More
  • Analysis of poem- Muliebrity- Sujata Bhatt

    ...The poem muliebrity by Sujata Bhatt, talks about the power women possess and the character of women, who take pride in what they do, even if it is just picking cow-dung. The poet speaks of a girl, who is a representation of village women, who does the tedious job of picking cow-dung outside a temple and the girl is described in a very reverentia...

    Read More
  • Explain How Sujata Bhatt Presents Different Attitudes Towards the Evolution of Language/Culture in Her Poem a Different History.

    ...native culture. The speaker of the poem A Different History, by an Indian Poet named Sujata Bhatt, expresses her feelings towards the change of her culture after the British Colonization. In this poem, the speaker explains in a disappointed tone how the culture and language changed as the generations passed on. Using strong diction and repetitio...

    Read More

Discover the Best Free Essays on StudyMode

Conquer writer's block once and for all.

High Quality Essays

Our library contains thousands of carefully selected free research papers and essays.

Popular Topics

No matter the topic you're researching, chances are we have it covered.