Preview

Once More To The Lake Comparison

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
809 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Once More To The Lake Comparison
Parents and grandparents sometimes gave us something unique that is usually worthy. Regardless of the price, it is very important and precious. These gifts are not limited to something physical, it can be a phrase, a story, a skill or even taking to a place. In “Kim Wilde” by Marjan Satrapi and “Once More to The Lake” by E.B. White, both are getting something from their families that satisfies them eventually. In both stories that have been written in narrative format, we determine the importance of families on the children’s feelings and perspectives over the time. At the end of both stories, the change of perspective of the narrators is obvious. The stories have similarities but, they have significant differences. In “Kim Wilde” we see that the family is giving the gift from their trip to the child that was demanded, and in “Once More to the lake” we see that the father is taking his son to a lake to spend …show more content…
He narrates the time that his father took him to a lake when he was child and then he takes his son to the same place. He compares the feeling of his father with his, when he takes his son to the lake. In the same time, He sees everything in the perspective of his father and uses the dual existence technique. According to this idea, White comes to the hint of understanding his father at that time he was a child and now he understands both his father and his son. The setting of the lake and White’s childhood, connections with the lake, demonstrate that White is denying his mortality. White’s refusal to accept that he is now the father, demonstrates the theme of man versus conflict. Since the writer is confronting an internal inflict. Part of White’s conflict is that he wants a more detailed back to the past to relive his puberty. The feeling of mortality and experiencing the feeling of his father when he was a child, are the things that were given to White in long term

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    White sees the lake identical to the lake of when he was a child, but he could not help but feel emptiness knowing it wasn't the same experience. E.B White compares the time he went fishing with his dad and how he's fishing now with his son. He then realizes how death is so close, for he is now the father and not the son. The author realizes that human lives experiences are immortal. In spite of the increasing amounts of technology, his son still has the same experiences that he had when he was a boy for example: sneaking out in the morning, being…

    • 201 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Grandparents can be more lenient with their grandchild then they were with their own child or children. This creates a pattern and family bonds for each passing generation. This ‘tender tale of the touching relationship between a grandmother and granddaughter is a tribute to the everlasting bonds of deep family ties’ (Booklist). The strong relationship between a grandmother and granddaughter relates to readers in a way of showing a grandmother’s love and how it affects a young child’s life. “My Grandmother Asked me to tell you she’s Sorry” also relates to readers in the theme of embracing differences and how important human compassion is towards those who are labeled as different in the views of modern society. One of Fredrik Backman’s greatest writing qualities is the way he incorporates stories into human life and how heroes are around in everyday life. “Childhood folklore and life experiences fuse together in unexpected ways” (Library Journal). This makes readers reflect on their own lives and maybe consider someone whom they may have misjudged in the past. “My Grandmother asked me to tell you she’s Sorry” by Fredrik Backman captures the heroism inside of a young girl and illustrates how life can be filled with hidden heroes “not all heroes wear…

    • 1415 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In Elwyn Brooks White’s essay “Once More to the Lake” we learn about a trip, that the author took with his son to a lake in Maine. The lake is very sentimental to White because his father brought him to very same lake as a child. During E. B. White’s trip to the lake with his son, he is able to compare and contrast what he sees to experiences from his time at the lake. Some of these experiences led White to believe that he was experiencing events from different family member’s lives. This leads him to believe that he is experiencing three different views during the time spent at the lake. Which leads to White trying to sort out what is still the same against what has changed at the lake.…

    • 887 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    On the way to the lake, White wonders how the lake would be different; " how time would have marred this unique, this holy spot . . .". He was certain there would be changes as he slowly descended into detailed reminiscences of the smells of his old bedroom and the "stillness of the cathedral". When White and his son settled into the campsite and as he heard his son sneak out to go to the shore, something White used to do, he adopted a "dual existence" and had, "by simple transposition", become his father and his son was himself as a young boy. The imagery used by White contributes to the comparison in the essay because it leads the reader through the entire passage with words so rich and alive the reader could feel exactly what White was feeling and in turn relate those feelings to their own experiences and fond memories. The speaker also uses the repetitive statement that " there had been no years", that is, he felt he…

    • 893 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    These themedion: “On Going Home”, and E.B White: “Once More to the Lake”. The fear of change comes into play when certain times people find themselves accosted by an internal conflict. In “On Going Home” and “Once More to the Lake” the conflict both stories had in common was the dwelling of the past, “Paralyzed by the Neurotic lassitude engendered by meeting one’s past at every turn, around every corner, inside every cupboard”. Some cope with the change of the present by facing reality and coming to terms with the present and accepting it, while others cling to the past and let it consume their lives until their cycle is over. E.B Whites essay, “Once More to the Lake,”…

    • 255 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Compare and Contrast

    • 1581 Words
    • 4 Pages

    “Once More to the Lake” written by E.B White and “An American Childhood” by Annie Dillard are both essays that reminisce about both authors’ childhood experiences. In the novel “Once More to the Lake”, White talks about his favorite spot during his childhood years where he would visit with his family once a month every year. In “An American Childhood” Dillard talks about growing up with her mother and the memories they shared together. Despite the differences between these two novels both authors talk about their childhood using symbolism, metaphors, personifications and many other literary devices.…

    • 1581 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Outside Edges

    • 692 Words
    • 3 Pages

    The relationships that family members share together are often changing. As strong as they are they are never constantly the same. As people grow so too does their personality and interests, these changes in a person’s life will often form and develop an old relationship once shared into a new one. In the story “Outside Edges” you see how a relationship between family members can change when David at the age of 8 discovers his new interest in maps of Canada. The author “Ivan Dorin” develops the idea how David’s obsession with maps creates a new relationship and a new way for he and his son spend time together. It shows how as one person’s interest’s change their relationship with others does as well.…

    • 692 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    What is there to be said for progress and evolution generation to generation? Have we yet found the balance of continuing legacy versus excelling in a new generation through advancement and straying from tradition? Every parent has the desire to pass along their heritage and to raise their child the way they were raised. However, there is something to be said for giving children the room they need to grow into their own people so they can make their own individual mark on this world. The question remains of how to balance a relationship between parent and child when it requires to be constantly changing and adapting. Roch Carrier’s “A Secret Lost in the Water” looks into the effects of growing up and growing apart from your parents, including a story line of one of the many ways that relationships between child and parent can change over time.…

    • 986 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Signatures and Apples

    • 777 Words
    • 4 Pages

    A young girl and boy take their first steps toward forging their identities. In Julia Alvarez’s “Dusting,” a girl decides that she wants to be more than a diligent housekeeper like her mother. In Alberto Rios’s “In Second Grade Miss Lee I Promised Never to Forget You and I Never Did,” a boy catches his first glimpse of romantic love by listening to his unconventional teacher. Both of these children learn important lessons about life from significant adults. And both Alvarez and Rios use strong figurative language to convey their feelings about these important formational moments from childhood.…

    • 777 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Because of this, it can be inferred that the reader is seeing the man’s life flash before his eyes, without the man being completely aware that this is what is happening. The reader sees the experiences that the man had as a kid, which can be connected to his experiences in the present. It is clear that the past version of the man’s self, which is indicated by the second person, is not just him as a kid, but rather a progression of his life. This is proven when stories are shared from the kid when he was older. For example, the story about the kid skim-diving is prefaced with “being a knowledgeable young fellow, not quite a kid any more” (83). This gives the reader a sense that the boy is growing up, and that the man is reflecting on lessons that he has learned throughout…

    • 805 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Starting with the father’s psychological struggles, the first being his wife’s death. When his wife committed suicide he felt like it was his fault as seen on page 38, “The dream bore the look of sacrific but he thought…

    • 826 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    A Day At The Lake

    • 183 Words
    • 1 Page

    “A Day at the Lake” is a narrative essay that follows all guidelines in the criteria. It is set in first person point of view. The writer uses vivid detail to describe important scenes and people. It contains meaningful dialogue that puts the reader in the writer’s shoes as he/she progresses through…

    • 183 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    In Carver’s another story “A small, good thing”, reflects the importance of reconciliation is related to a family. The narratives can be dramatically different among family members under the same roof. The core notion of reconciliation, according to Susan Dwyer, “is that of bringing apparently incompatible descriptions of events into narrative equilibrium.” Reconciliation is the act of bringing back harmony to the endangered relationships, accepting the coexistence, and pushing the family to carry on with mutual understanding. This essay proposes several questions while exploring the reconciliation theme inside a family dwelling. From Hanif Kureishi’s story “My Son the Fanatic”, Raymond Carver’s story “Elephant” and his another story “A small, good thing”, those stories give examples to illustrate the points below. Why reconciliation is needed? What is the basis of reconciliation? What…

    • 1551 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    In Tim Winton’s collection of short stories, ‘Minimum of Two’, family is a major, recurring theme. Winton displays his interest in exploring the idea of family within each story differently, containing the positive and negative influence that family has on the actions and emotions of the Nilsam family and his alternative protagonists. In ‘Distant Lands’, he deals with the feeling of obligation towards and the traditional expectations of family whilst in ‘The Water Was Dark’ the focus is on a need to separate oneself from negative family completely. ‘Laps’ focuses on how family can help you move on from her past.…

    • 718 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Therefore, I hold the view that parents surely have heavily influence on the development of their children’s characters. Indeed, since being tiny kids, the vast majority of children have had the habits of aping their closest people’s behaviors. In most cases, this plays an extremely vital role in laying the foundations for the life ahead of them. When they grow up, although their thoughts get more and more complicated as a mixture of numerous different ideas and cultures, education from their parents still have an important part in shaping their own characters.…

    • 3702 Words
    • 15 Pages
    Good Essays

Related Topics