top-rated free essay

on being white

By Tayene-Santos Nov 27, 2014 664 Words

It is already understood by researchers in the Human Sciences field that gender is one of the most important topics concerning identity which is crucial “to understand social and cultural changes in contemporary life” (p. 289). The article “On being white, heterosexual and male in a Brazilian school: multiple positionings in oral narratives”, written by Luiz Paulo Moita Lopes, aims to expose how the social identities of whiteness, heterosexuality and masculinity are naturalized and constructed as the parameter to define the marginalized social identities, that is, the blackness, homoeroticism and femininity. To corroborate this argument, the author analyzes how a 14-year-old boy positions himself and others in the narratives he tells in his school.

Before presenting the collected data, the writer provides the perspective taken into consideration by him to analyze and better understand [ ]. The researcher points out a view of discourse and narrative as social constructionist approaches, which not only represent the world but also express our actions. The social identity, thus, is constructed in people’s local discursive practices and is legitimated by narrative, that is the tool used to position ourselves in a plot.

Afterwards, the survey goes further on these approaches and begins by exposing a brief overview and analysis of how the concept of positioning is constructed among different research fields, such as Cultural Studies, Social Sciences and Social Psychology. Moita-Lopes states that “the SIDs one identifies with or is identified with depend on the positionings one has occupied/will occupy in the narrative practices one has been or is involved with” (p. 296). In other words, social identity is generated according to how one positions him/herself, the listeners and the characters in a narrative.

The data collected to the research contains 24 hours of audiotaped classes and focus-group interviews with 5th grade students of the public sector school in the city of Rio de Janeiro. Three remarkable situations considered by the author as crucial to [enforce] his argument were transcribed in the text. In these occurrences, Hans is either telling a fact he experienced or participating in the construction of the narrative. Each one of them is used by the researcher to demonstrate how the student constructs himself as male, heterosexual and white, respectively.

In the first example, Hans is telling a story in which his father explains to him why his sister cannot be outside home for a long time, while boys are apparently allowed to do it. The use of elements such as the imperative, the use of specific lexical items in the narrative corroborate the author’s statement concerning men’s sexual incontinence. Also, the use of quotations to reproduce his conversation with his father, in contrast with the total ellipsis of his sister’s voice, are pointing that only men are entitled to speak. Therefore, masculinity here is constructed in opposition to femininity.

Subsequently, in the second narrative Hans and other pupils are talking about a classmate they characterize negatively as different, funny and strange. As they enumerate the boy’s attitudes, behavior, manner of speaking and walking, it is argued that Hans and his colleagues are constructing what being a heterosexual is by defining how homosexuals behave.

Lastly, in the third transcription it is possible to notice how Hans constructs himself as white by participating in one of his friends’ narrative. In the situation, Gail –one of the students participating in the discussion – tells that even black people tend to use pejoratives terms concerning skin color when they want to emphasize someone’s laziness. While engaging in the story, Hans positions himself as white by listing “things niggers do” (p. 306).

In short, this well-written survey focus on how Hans constructs himself by positioning his own figure as dominant in all the stories. Moita-Lopes concludes stating that “the social identities situated in a position of hegemony are unmarked and naturalized and constitute themselves by constructing the margins: femininity, homoeroticism and blackness” (p. 309).

Survey somewhat commonly remarkable meander doubtless concurrently ‘it might be argued that’ notewhorthy criscross

Cite This Document

Related Documents

  • White

    ... Spiritual Formation Across the Lifespan Virginia White Liberty University PSYC 210 – D05 Abstract One may wonder what spiritual formation is and how it happens. Spiritual formation is the way in which you are formed spiritually by learning about and having faith in God throughout your life. It is important that Spiritua...

    Read More
  • Being There

    ...flowers. When the President came to pay Mr. Rand a visit, Chance made a statement about the garden when the President asked him for his opinion. Chance said that “as long as the roots are not severed, all is well and all will be well” (Kosinski, 54). The President interpreted Chance’s statement as hope for the US economy. Chance became...

    Read More
  • Walter White: The Ethics of Being a Crystal Meth Kingpin

    ...Walter White: The Ethics of Being a Crystal Meth Kingpin Let’s begin a scenario: You wake up in your bed on your fiftieth birthday, next to your wife, who is five months pregnant with a child you didn’t intend to have, while your son (who has cerebral palsy) stirs in his sleep in the other room. You get out of bed and begin your day as you...

    Read More
  • BEING DIFFERENT, BEING UNPOPULAR

    ...BEING DIFFERENT, BEING UNPOPULAR In the world there are a lot of people, but nobody is the same. Every person looks different, maybe he has a black skin, green hair, is blind or deaf, but all humans have positive and negative characteristics. In small social groups, such as a normal class in school, differences are very clearly visible. Som...

    Read More
  • A Question of Identity: Being Yellow in a Black and White World

    ...“A Question of Identity: Being Yellow in a Black and White World” In “A Question of Identity The headline, the tweet, and the unfair significance of Jeremy Lin” by Jay Caspian Kang, racial prejudice and stereotyping in society is brought to light. People of different ethnicity are ostracized in the United States because Caucasians and...

    Read More
  • Snow White

    ...inevitably influence those children’s views of the world. Snow White is a classic fairytale that most Americans have at some point been exposed to and that has several different messages that are imprinted on the people who watch or read it. One of the main fantasies within Snow White is that of happily ever after and what exactly this fanta...

    Read More
  • Being Gay

    ...attack, Matt arrived at the hospital with hypothermia and severe brain trauma, with no chance of survival (Loffreda, 4). The perpetrators were found to be Russell Henderson and Aaron McKinney, who Matt had met after his drink at the bar (Loffreda, 1). Both Henderson and McKinney’s girlfriends had agreed to be their alibis, which, in the end wa...

    Read More
  • Being Msm

    ...BEING MSM …. (Issues and challenges faced by the MSM) SEEMA GREWAL (Presenter) M.A. (prev.) 2nd Semester Objective: • To identify the issues and challenges faced by MSM (m...

    Read More

Discover the Best Free Essays on StudyMode

Conquer writer's block once and for all.

High Quality Essays

Our library contains thousands of carefully selected free research papers and essays.

Popular Topics

No matter the topic you're researching, chances are we have it covered.