top-rated free essay

How far do you agree that due to its comic nature the relationships in

By HannahCooney Mar 09, 2015 382 Words
How far do you agree that due to its comic nature the relationships in ‘Much Ado about Nothing’ can be anything other than superficial?

The relationship between Benedick and Beatrice can be interpreted as genuine regardless of the comedic nature of the play by the portrayal of them both being mirror images of each other when Benedick describes himself as having ‘cold blood’ and Beatrice refers to herself as having a ‘hard heart.’ The parallel structure demonstrated in this scene adds to the element of the genuine underlying feelings they have through the use of dramatic irony as the audience can identify connections and similarities between the two that they seem unaware of, this can be seen as a comedic element but their feelings are still rendered as genuine due to their matching personalities which suggests that they would be a jubilant match. As well as this, the continuous references to their objection of marriage, such as Benedick claiming that if he were to be married they may ‘pluck off a bulls horns and set them in his forehead’ and Beatrice saying she ‘could not endure a husband,’ can be seen by the audience as Beatrice and Benedick covering up the feelings for each other which lay beneath their ‘merry war’ of conflict. However it can be argued that the relationship between Beatrice and Benedick is superficial due to its comedic element of gender reversal in Beatrice as women at the time did not have this attitude and mainly remained seen and not heard, any sort of banter from a woman was unexpected and misunderstood as shown by the Messenger taking Beatrice’s sarcasm literally when she refers to Benedick as ‘Signor Mountanto.’ In contrast, the relationship between Claudio and Hero can be seen as superficial because of the excessive language portrayed when Claudio describes Hero as the ‘sweetest lady,’ the use of the superlative makes what Claudio is saying seem over the top and cliché considering he has only seen Hero and not even exchanged words with her. This illustrated Claudio and Hero’s relationship as superficial because, unlike Beatrice and Benedick, it is not built on the solid ground of actually connecting with each other but only on a visual basis. This is supported when Claudio refers to Hero as ‘soft,’ ‘delicate

Cite This Document

Related Documents

  • How far do you agree that the failure o

    ...How far do you agree that the failure of Italian revolutionaries in the years 1820–49 was primarily due to a lack of popular support? I agree that the revolutions that occurred in the years 1820-49 were due to a lack of popular support. Other factors could be the strength of the Austria army, how there was no leader, a lack of unity and no...

    Read More
  • How Far Do You Agree That Instability I

    ...How far do you agree that instability in the Gulf Region in the period 1979-2001 was primarily caused by the actions of the Iraqi Government? The Iraqi government in the period from 1979 to 2001 was under the control of the Ba’ath Party and lead by Saddam Hussein, a Sunni Muslim whereas most of Iraq is Shiite Muslim. Hussein took control-as...

    Read More
  • How Far Do You Agree That Good Comedy Is Tragedy Narrowly Averted

    ...How far do you agree that Much Ado About Nothing shows the truth of the claim that “good comedy is tragedy narrowly averted”? “Good comedy is tragedy narrowly averted”: these words were spoken by Jonathon Bate and Eric Rasmussen in their publishing of ‘William Shakespeare: Complete Works’. They show how many elements of comedy cou...

    Read More
  • 'Antigone is an admirable character.' How far do you agree with this statement?

    ...'Antigone is a thoroughly admirable character.' How far do you agree with this statement? Throughout the play, Antigone is presented as an audacious and unorthodox female character, whose actions depict her independence and confidence. She dismisses the rules which she believes are false, and honourably battles against her uncle's rule to bri...

    Read More
  • Free Trade, A Necessary Evil?: How Far Do You Agree?

    ...“Free trade is a necessary evil”. How far do you agree? Free trade is a branch of economics that proclaims freedom of trade and non-intervention of government in private entrepreneurship. Its main feature is absence of “trade-distorting policies” which reduce imports. The effectiveness of free trade and should countries adopt it to boost...

    Read More
  • How far do you agree with the view that the ending of The Road is unbearably pessimistic?

    ...How far do you agree with the view that the ending of The Road is unbearably pessimistic? It is arguable whether or not McCarthy has one set ending because there are many possible ends in The Road. There is the literal end which is when McCarthy finished writing but there is the end of the focalisers’ journey on the road when they reach ...

    Read More
  • How do you do

    ...weather is just about always warm and pleasant. When it rains it feels nice to sit around and enjoy the water droplets fall on the skin and roll off. Almost all of the beaches are crystal clear with warm sand, but beware when in the water. The ocean swells can go from playful three-foot waves to humongous twenty-foot monsters in just under five ...

    Read More
  • How Far Do You Agree That the 1867 Reform Act Was Sucessfulte?

    ...additionally, the 1867 Reform Act also had a significant impact on the issues that were being addressed by politics. Whereas before, the aristocracy had basically decided what happened in the country, the act meant that issues were being brought to light that had never been discussed properly in public before. This was very important as it not o...

    Read More

Discover the Best Free Essays on StudyMode

Conquer writer's block once and for all.

High Quality Essays

Our library contains thousands of carefully selected free research papers and essays.

Popular Topics

No matter the topic you're researching, chances are we have it covered.