Preview

Do Adolescents Make Autonomous Medical Choices?

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
576 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Do Adolescents Make Autonomous Medical Choices?
Do adolescents have the right to make autonomous medical choices? This question is asked very frequently all around, and is given various answers. This topic places medical decisions at the forefront, meaning that the topic touches on questions of terminal illnesses, pregnancy, sexual transmitted diseases, palliative care, and all the other types of decisions that minors have to make. Merriam-Webster defines “adolescent” as “A young person who is developing into an adult; a young person who is going through adolescence, and Merriam-Webster defines “adolescence” as “1. The state or process of growing up; 2. The period of life from puberty to maturity terminating legally at the age of majority; 3. A stage of development (as of a language or …show more content…
Most scientific studies that have been conducted in relation to adolescents generally indicate that by age 14, adolescents have reached the point where they are capable of making decisions that are at least on par with the decision making capacity of young adults. Most medical professionals, especially those who work extensively with adolescents, recognize some tension in the belief that adolescents need to be treated as children. In the status quo, the age of 18 is treated as a magical number, at which point adolescents have reached the point where they are capable of making choices for themselves. Still, the treatment of adolescents across different segments of our society creates some problems with even this magical number. For instance, the fact that adolescents can, and often are, tried as adults for criminal acts they comment indicate that at least in some circumstances, society is willing to set aside the magical number 18, and recognize the ability of adolescents to make competent decisions, at least in as far as they are competent enough to be punished for their

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    In this case, Roper v. Simmons, Kennedy has once again shown himself to be one of the most powerful legal activists of our times, ready to impose his own sense of morality and law upon the rest of society. In his majority opinion, Justice Kennedy cited “the evolving standards of decency that mark the progress of a maturing society” and the court find the death penalty for juveniles to be cruel and unusual punishment, and thus unconstitutional. Moreover, Justice Kennedy turned to psychology as the platform for his argument. He stated that adolescents under age of 18 lack maturity and have “a underdeveloped sense of responsibility. Secondly, he stated that juveniles are ““more vulnerable or susceptible to negative influences and outside pressures, including peer pressure.” Finally, he argued that “the character of a juvenile is not as well formed as that of an adult. The personality traits of juveniles are more transitory, less fixed.” With the backing of American Psychological Association’s reasoning and Supreme Court’s majority opinion, the Roper decision will go down as one more milestones in the U.S. Supreme Court’s project of judicial activism and taking moral values into…

    • 1794 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The ethical article I chose to reflect upon discusses the ethical case of a teenager being forced into chemotherapy at the age of seventeen. This case is a difficult one, due to Cassandra still being underaged. With all these components in mind, I disagree with what the law/court decided Cassandra’s solution be. She should not have been forced into being administered chemotherapy by any means, even if she was still technically a minor. The law states that if you are a minor, you have to have parental permission to undergo a certain task or in this case, refuse treatment. So, it is also unethical to deny her mother the right to see or speak to her daughter after the court decided against them both.…

    • 356 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Best Essays

    Ethical Dilema

    • 2961 Words
    • 12 Pages

    Abstract This article will explore pediatric consent through the analysis of a clinical case study using the principles of biomedical ethics approach. Application of the principles of autonomy, nonmaleficence, beneficence, and justice will be dissected in order to attempt to establish resolution of the ethical dilemma. The main conflict in this case study deals with whether the wishes of an adolescent for end-of-life care should be followed or should the desire of his parents outweigh this request. In terminal cancer, the hope of early palliative care and dignity in dying serve as priorities in therapy. Application of the moral principles to both sides of the dilemma aided in providing an objective resolution to uphold pediatric consent. Keywords Consent, case study, decision-making capacity, end of life, ethics, pediatric oncology…

    • 2961 Words
    • 12 Pages
    Best Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    The essay “Little Adult Criminals” by the New York Times Editorial argues that children of the age 12 or 14 do not have sufficient emotional maturity to control their own impulses or understand their actions and the consequences that come with them, and therefore should not be tried in adult criminal court. The essay gives examples of two 14 year old boys, Lionel Tate and Nathaniel Brazill, who were both charged with murder. This article also includes medical research that shows that teenagers’ brains are still developing to back up their argument that teensagers should not be tried as adults. It also includes studies that have shown that minors who go through the juvenile system are less likely to be arrested again after being released since they are provided rehabilitation, unlike those who serve time in an ordinary prison. This article advances the argument that young teenagers should not be tried in adult criminal court and uses scientific evidence and past cases to back up their argument.…

    • 468 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Clearly there are legal and ethical issues that exist when it comes to Minors’ rights to refuse medical tests requested by their parents. In the United States, the legal system generally gives complete authority for medical decision making to parents, giving way to ethical issues that arise when caring for mature minors who are refusing medical procedures requested by their parents. In case study 1, the parents are requesting that their teenage daughter Camilla undergo invasive medical testing that she is opposed to. Because Camilla is a mature minor, the most important ethical issues that exist in this case is the violation of Camilla’s right to autonomy and self-determination, and nonmaleficence because she is both psychologically and physically opposed to the genetic testing requested by her parents. The ethical principles that should be used to help guide the care of Camilla, her family, and the healthcare providers involved in this case are Autonomy and Nonmaleficence.…

    • 941 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Neuroplasticity Crime

    • 666 Words
    • 3 Pages

    She found that 14-year-old plus adolescents performed just as well on adult tasks as did adults, however they relied on different functions of the brain. Adolescents rely mainly on the frontal lobe’s prefrontal cortex, whereas adults exhibit a more complex response. She thus concluded that “adolescents cannot be viewed at the same level as adults”.…

    • 666 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Teenagers accused of violent crimes should not be tried as adults in a court of the law. Teenagers brains are not fully developed, from the ages 13-18 a projected number of, “one percent of gray matter is lost every year in teenagers,” and these are the teens being tried as adults in court (Spinks). A growth of gray matter is an important development stage in teens. The gray matter grows mostly when the brain is stimulated through accelerated learning, social interactions and in athletics. In a teenagers brain, the stimulation occurs in the prefrontal cortex, which is located behind the forehead. If teenagers are not given the opportunity to plead their case in court, it can lead to other developmental issues. These issues can stunt other brain growths in teenagers. Thus, the growth of the frontal cortex is a study in teenage brain development. The frontal cortex becomes enhanced during young adult years, which can conclude to an undeveloped brain in teens. The adult punishments brought upon teenagers is discriminatory because of the slower brain development in teenagers. Many neuroscientists have concluded that, teenagers have a, “very immature brain structure” (Spinks). Adults have mature frontal lobes, as opposed to teenagers with non-developed and immature frontal lobes. Although the brain maturity in teens is an issue, adults continue to be biased regarding teenage crimes. Adults must consider brain development in teenagers when any teen is being accused of a crime.…

    • 266 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    At the age of 16 teens need to be able to take responsibility for their actions. How could they ever get jobs or even be successful adults if they don’t take responsibly. A response from Debate.org argues, “Minors should be tried as adults because they made the same mistakes as adults. If they had the guts to…

    • 432 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Teens deserve the right to medication without parental consent. They have to suffer because there is nothing they feel they can do to help themselves. An article says “Thirty states have addressed this issue already, using a variety of approaches to ensure that youth on their own can obtain basic medical care.” (Vento Liaisons) Teens feel helpless when they aren’t comfortable with telling their parents certain things and have no right in their own medical problems only some states have a maturity law or they lowered the age of consent, but what about the rest?…

    • 959 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Today’s court system has many difficult decisions to make everyday. One of the most controversial decisions is whether or not try certain juveniles as adults or not. On one hand, being tried as a minor is considered unconstitutional, while on the other side it seems necessary in order to protect society. Some of the factors the court considers when convicting a minor is “age, physical and mental maturity, past attempts and future potential for rehabilitation, harm suffered by the victim, use of a firearm, and public safety” (“) Many minors who have been convicted came from unstable homes, lived in poverty, or have been physically abused. (“Children” 1). Factors such as these make it hard for people to decide if minors should be tried as adults. However, before making a decision, it is important to learn all…

    • 685 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Juvenile Justice

    • 771 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Krikorian, Greg. "Many Kids Called Unfit for Adult Trial: Those Under 15 Often Blind to the Long-Term Results of Their Choices, a Study Says." The Sacramento Bee 3 Mar. 2003: 52-53. Print.…

    • 771 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Freedom, in itself, is a basic human right. Without freedom, you cannot pursue life as it was meant to be lived. Adolescents, no matter what age, race, or gender, should have the freedom to choose the way they live out their days autonomously. Therefore, I believe that adolescents should have the right to make autonomous medical choices if they are mature enough and can understand the consequences of the decision about to be made.…

    • 615 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    In the law, a juvenile is defined as a person who is not old enough to be held responsible for criminal acts. In most states the normal age is 18. In Wyoming a juvenile is a person under the age of 19. In some states a juvenile is a person under the age of 17, and in Connecticut, New York, and North Carolina, a juvenile is a person under the age of 16. These age definitions are significant because they determine whether a teenager accused of criminal conduct will be charged with a crime in adult court or will be required to appear in juvenile court (Bower, 2007). Juvenile courts generally have authority over three categories of children: juveniles accused of criminal conduct; juveniles neglected or abused by their parents or in need of assistance from the state; and juveniles accused of a status offense. This last category refers to the behavior that is prohibited only to children, such as absence from school , runaway from home, disobedience of reasonable parental controls, and purchase of alcohol, tobacco, or pornography (Musiani, 2006). Children in need of services are ones who are not abused or neglected but are needy in some other way. These children are usually from impoverished homes and require improved nutrition and basic health care. The question here is should children under a certain age, be tried for a crime as an adult or should they remain in the juvenile system.…

    • 1711 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Today, minors are using their age as a shield against capital punishment. Adolescents believe that since they are not eighteen they will not be punished for the crimes they commit. The death penalty is appropriate for juveniles in certain circumstances, such as murder and brutal crimes that are considered capital offenses. The rate at which the death penalty is carried out, as well as inconstancies in sentencing does not make it a deterrent. There should not be an age limit in all capital offenses for those who could face the death penalty. Adolescents should know what he or she are doing is wrong, and is a crime. An age limits does not predict when one is able to handle responsibilities. What they do is assume is that one should be able to take on new responsibilities, laws, and issues. One is not suddenly capable of driving at sixteen, and not immediately given the knowledge of the voting system at eighteen. How does a specific age predict when a person knows right from wrong? Though many people have different view points on capital punishment, present the background, arguments, and information on juveniles and the death penalty need to be analyzed.…

    • 1826 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Kathryn Hickey has a bachelor’s degree in Registered Nursing and works at Shriners Hospital for Children in Chicago. She is a credible source as she often deals with children or adolescents and is highly knowledgeable about the topic. Her article, “Minors’ Rights in Medical Decision Making”, was placed in the journal called JONA’s Healthcare Law, Ethics, and Regulation. This journal provides information on the changing regulations of healthcare and is…

    • 1854 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays