Running head: THE INFLUENCE OF DISCOURSE ON HEALTH CARE
The Discourse of On Reserve Housing
Centre of Nursing Science
MNS 620 Culture and Health
Margo deJong Berg
The Discourse of On Reserve Housing
The substance of this paper will be to discuss the discourse regarding the inequalities facing aboriginal peoples living on reserves in the northwestern corner of Ontario. Inequality is not naturally occurring; poverty is not an innate cultural trait that accumulates at the feet of the marginalized (Schick & St.Denis, 2005, p.304). Stephens, Nettleton and Porter stated in the Lancet (2005) “Aboriginal people in Canada suffer enormous inequalities in health and in accessibility to health care (p.4).” The discussion will review the discourse surrounding the significant implications substandard and over crowded housing has on the health of the First Nations people living in these communities. Many reserve communities face overcrowding and substandard housings, such that only 55% of on-reserve housing is not in need of major repairs or replacement (Indian and Northern Affairs Canada, 2000). The inadequacy of the housing conditions is visible evidence of the poverty and marginalization experienced disproportionately by Aboriginal people. It will also reflect on whether changing the dominant discourse would illuminate the poor health effects of substandard and overcrowded housing on this population. Therefore the purpose of this paper will be to analyze the discourse in a northern nursing practice setting as it relates to the housing issues of Aboriginal peoples living of reserve.
Currently the multiple ways in which Aboriginal problems are spoken of within academic, policy and a broader political discourse closely shapes how we view the chronically poor Aboriginal peoples. Looking at the discourse with regard to the housing conditions on reserves in northwest Ontario is a first step to understanding how housing affects the health of these communities. In 1986, the Ottawa Charter for Health promotion (WHO, 1986) recognized shelter as a basic prerequisite for health. People with low socio-economic status are more likely to be exposed to housing health risks and less likely to be aware of the risks and less able to address or avoid the risks (Canadian Council on Social Development, 2000). For instance housing policy for First Nations has been such a daunting problem it has been under review by the federal government since 1988, with no sign of resolution (Indian and Northern Affairs, 2000). Overcrowded housing conditions can increase exposure of susceptible people with infectious respiratory disease, and in doing so increases the probability of transmission. The association between overcrowded housing and the incidence of tuberculosis (TB), paediatric TB, and TB mortality has long been recognized (Hawker, Bakhashi, Ali & Farrington, 1999). Although TB was endemic in North America prior to the arrival of Europeans, the TB epidemic among Aboriginal people in this country did not begin until recently. A combination of malnutrition, confinement on crowded reservations with poor sanitation, and lack of immunity to the TB bacillus created the ideal conditions for a terrible epidemic (Health Canada, 1999). Another health issue related to poverty and poor living conditions is HIV/AIDS. Although incidence (new HIV infections among the total population) has gone down in the Canadian population, it appears that HIV rates have been steadily increasing in First Nations. Aboriginal people are at increased risk for HIV infections for several reasons, including social, economic, and behavioral factors such as poverty, substance use, including injection drug use, sexually transmitted diseases, and limited access to health services (Health Canada, 2004). Likewise mould and mildew in the homes is a common problem for people living...
References: Adeleson, N., (2003). Reducing health disparities and promoting equity for vulnerable populations. Aboriginal Canada: Synthesis Paper. Canadian Institute of Health Canada.
Benner, P.(1994). Interpretive phenomenology: embodiment, caring and ethics in health and illness. Sage Publishing Inc.
Canadian Broadcasting News Centre (April 2005). Canada ranked low in UN native report
Canadian Council on Social Development
Canadian Population Health Initiative. (2004). Improving health for Canadians. Ottawa: Canadian Institute for health information.
Chinn, P. (1985). Debunking myths in nursing theory and research. The Journal of Nursing Scholarship, 172, 45-49. Retrieved March 12,2008 from the World Wide Web Blackwell Synergy database.
Clark, M., Riben, P., & Nowgesic, E. (2002). The association of housing density, isolation and tuberculosis in Canadian First Nations communities. International Journal of Epidemiology 31:940-945.
COON COME, M. (2003). Remarks of Nations Chief Matthew Coon Come. Commonwealth Policy Studies Unit. London.
Government of Canada (2005). The government of Canada announces 1.2B in Aboriginal housing [on-line]. Available: www.cmhc-schl.gc.ca.
Devitt, J., Hall, G., and Tsey, K. (2001). Underlying causes in J. Condon J., Warman G., and Arnold L. (eds). The Health and Welfare of Territories, pp. 9-18. Epidemiology Branch, Territory Health Services: Darwin.
Health Canada. (1999). Tuberculosis in First Nations communities. Ottawa: Minister of Public Works and Government Services Canada; 2001.
Health Canada. (2003). HIV and AIDS. Ottawa: Minister of Public Works and Government Services Canada; 2003.
Health Canada. (1998). Proceedings of the national consensus conference on tuberculosis. Canadian Commission Disease Report; 24S2: 1-24.
Fontain, P. (2008). Canadian reserves 'make the best of the worst ' in struggle with the crumbling schools. Canadian Press.
Health Canada. (2000), Statistical profile on the health of First Nations in Canada. Author Heath Canada Retrieved from the World Wide Web Health Canada database.
Hickey, S., & Bracking, S., (2005). Exploring the politics of chronic poverty: from representation to a politics of justice? World Development, Vol. 33(6) PP 851-865.
Indian and Northern Affairs Canada. (2000). Report of the Royal commission on Aboriginal people: Gathering Strength (3). Retrieved from the World Wide Web March 22,2008. www.ainc-inac.gc.ca/ch/rcap/sg/si36.
Indian and Northern Affairs Canada. (1991). The Indian act past and present: A manual of registrations and entitlement. Ottawa: Canada.
First Nations Regional Longitudinal Health Survey (2002-03). Retrieved from World Wide Web on March 22,2008 from www.naho.ca/fnc/rhs>
Lawrence, R., & Martin, D
Lutz K.F., Jones K.D. & Kendall J. (1997) Expanding the praxis debate: contributions to clinical inquiry. Advances in Nursing Science 20(2), 23– 31.
Simons, J., Irwin, D. & Drinnien. (1987). The Search for Understanding. Maslow’s Hierarchy of Needs, West Publishing Company, New York.
Monti, E.J.& Tingen, M.S. (1999). Multiple paradigms of nursing science. American Nursing Science, 21 (4): 64-80.
National Aboriginal Health Organization (2004). Preliminary Findings of the First of the national regional longitudinal health survey (RHS): Adult Survey. First National centres.
Oldenburg, B. (2000). Socioeconomic determinants of health in Australia: Policy responses and intervention options. Medical Journal of Australia 172:89-492. Retrieved from the World Wide Web March 30,2008 Sage Publishers database.
Polit & Hungler (Eds.)(1997). Essentials of nursing research: method, appraisals and utilization (4th ed.). Lippincott-Raven Publishers.
Rossi, P. & Weber, E. (1998). The Social Benefits of Homeownership: Empirical Evidence from national survey. Housing Policy Debates Vol. 7(1). University of Massachusetts: Amherst.
Syme, S. (1998) 'Social and economic disparities in health: Thoughts about intervention ' The Milbank Quarterly 76(3): 493-502.
Syme, S. (2003). Social determinants of health: The community as an empowered partner. Preventing Chronic Disease 1(1): AO2. Retrieved March 30,2008 from the World Wide Web Sage Publishers database.
Statistics Canada (2000). Aboriginal peoples in Canada: Highest concentration of Aboriginal population in the north and on the prairies. Ottawa: Canada.
Government of Canada (1996). Royal Commission on Aboriginal Peoples: Adequate housing. Retrieved from the www.indigenous. bc.ca/rcap.htm.
Schick, C., & St. Denis, V., (2005). Troubling national discourses in anti-racist curricular planning. Canadian Journal of Education, Vol. 28(3): 295-317.
Stavenhagen, R., (2005). Special Rapporteur on the situation of human rights and fundamental freedoms of Indigenous people. Mission to Canada. Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights United Nations.
Stephens, C., Nettleton, C., & Porter, J. (2005) Indigenous peoples’ health-why are they behind everyone, everywhere? Lancet 366:10-13.
Vollman, A.R., Anderson, E.T., & McFarlane. (2004). Canadian: Community as partner. Lippencott Williams & Wilkens.
World Health Organization (1986). Ottawa Charter on Health Promotion. Geneva: WHO.
Yappa, L.(2002). How the discipline of geography exacerbates poverty in the third world. Futures Vol. 34(1). PP 33-46. Retrieved from the World Wide Web March 11,2008 Sage Publishing database.
Please join StudyMode to read the full document