Mr. Coulombe
English II
Legal Suffering The Percent of public who support euthanasia for the terminally ill or on life support is approximately 86 percent. Despite this, euthanasia or assisted suicide is only legal in four states in the US: Montana, Vermont, Washington, and New Mexico. Because of the illegality of euthanasia in most places, it is a wide spread crime in most cases outside these states, although, these terminally ill patients are suffering terribly without cure. An example of someone who committed this “crime” is nurse and activist, Barbara Huttman, a nurse from the San Francisco region, a patients’ rights writer, and proponent of legislature for terminally ill patients. The following article, “A Crime of Compassion” is a narrative written by Huttman and which appeared in Newsweek as a heart-wrenching story of Huttman’s struggle with a terminally ill patient in horrid suffering who’s right to die with dignity can’t be exercised. Huttman accomplishes her purpose to enact support for death for those terminally ill patients suffering by using extremely emotional moments, incredibly graphic moments, showing us the emotional bonds with the patient and his family as the story develops, along with the use of a multitude of literary devices. Huttman expresses incredibly poignant moments throughout the narrative that stirs piteous emotions within readers with the use of rhetorical devices to substantiate the emotional moments throughout the composition. She uses tone to show us the emotional toll that Mac’s toils take on her with the quote, “And every night I prayed that Mac would die, that his agonized eyes would never again plead with me to let him die.” (Huttman 345) This quote shows Huttman’s tone as depressing and filled with pity that allows her to accomplish her goal of allowing the reader to sympathize with her later actions. Huttmans use of symbolism to convey her emotional anguish is seen through: “At night I went home and tried to scrub away the smell of decaying flesh that seemed woven into the fabric of my uniform, it was in my hair, the upholstery of my car-there was no washing it out. (Huttman 344)” This “smell of decaying flesh” that follows Huttman around is more symbolic that the suffering of Mac is something that follows Huttman wherever she goes that she can’t dispose of. Another part of Huttman’s methodology to induce the reader to feel sorrow and shame is the use of graphic imagery. Huttman tells us that max is “a sixty pound skeleton kept alive by liquid food,” “IV solutions dripped into his veins,” and oxygen “piped to a mask on his face.”(Huttman 344) This graphic exhibit an excruciating, unbearable conditions that God would never allow, but whom science has created which Mac suffers through. The immense pain that Huttman feels for Mac is seen through the strong imagery is seen when Huttman doesn’t press the code until she believes it’s too late and she is “shrieked” for the code team to let Mac go: “No…don’t let them do this to him… for God’s sake... Please no more.” (Huttman 346)The image painted in our heads is like a mother’s son being tortured by terrorists and her plead for his suffering to end, which is Huttman’s point in showing us how much Mac means to her and how she feels his pain. Another example where Huttman use imagery to shows us the grave, over whelming emotions to rouse sympathy for her is by giving the readers direct quotes of Mac’s desire to perish from his degenerating condition: “Pain… No more…Barbara… do something… God, let me go.” (Huttman 345) Huttman’s article in Newsweek does an incredibly efficacious job in creating sorrow, pity, and understanding for the reader. Barbara Huttman asserts various points in her essay that allow us to understand the logical side of her argument of her “murder” by showing us his suffering and his right of basic free will, including his right to choose death. Huttman expresses the logistic aspect of her relationship with the first introduction of Mac, “a young, witty, macho cop who walked into the hospital with thirty-two pounds of attack equipment” (Huttman 344) who is the pinnacle of a healthy, bright, and vibrant man that “can’t get rid of a cough.” (Huttman 344) This foreshadowing is effective as we learn that Mac is a relatively healthy human which will cause a huge contrast to his later conditions. Seeing a man health’s dissipate beyond believe causes us to want him to put out of his misery accomplishing Huttman’s goal. Huttman’s imagery also shines a logical reason for her decision to euthanize a hopeless, broken Mac when she states: “The nurses stayed to wipe the saliva that drooled from his mouth, irrigate the big craters of bedsoresthat covered his hips, suction the lung fluids that threatened to drown him, clean the feces that burned his skin like lye, pour the liquid food down the tube attached to his stomach, put pillows between his knees to ease the bone-on-bone pain, turn him every hour to keep the bedsores from getting worse, and change his gown and linen every two hours to keep him from being soaked in perspiration.” (Huttman 344) This quote shows us the legal torture that Mac suffered in his terminally ill state, which gives suffice reason that he should have the right to be euthanized, confirming Huttman’s point. In Huttman’s essay, the strongest literary device that she uses to establish her point through logical reasons is with the use of rhetorical questions. These indirect rhetorical questions cause us to understands Barbara Huttman’s decisions to allow Mac to die, question keeping someone alive who is terminally ill and suffering, and playing God to cause suffering is fundamental wrong. Huttman asks us indirectly about the unreasonable behavior of the medical community with the quote, “Did we really believe that we had the right to force "life" on a suffering man who had begged for the right to die?” (Huttman 345) After seeing a question like this, presented to us in the essay, we can lucidly see that the medical community is infringing on the free will of Mac by keeping him in this debilitated, dying state. Huttman also uses the indirect rhetorical question to tell us from a moral perspective does it matter if it was legal or not, but that is regardless the right decision when someone is suffering. This form of logical persuasion by using the invalidity of the crime is seen in the quote “If a doctor had written a no-code order, which is the only legal alternative, would he have felt any less guilty? (” Huttman 346) With the use of imagery, diction, tone, symbolism, imagery, and the use of rhetorical question, Huttman conveys an eloquent message through logic and emotion to convince readers of her correct decision as well as supporting the argument for the legalization for Euthanasia. Her essay brings the point, that as human can we play God to cause suffering and anguish to a person which will not recover? From personal experience, I understand the help that euthanasia can bring to terminally ill people suffering across the world. My aunt, Norma, who was diagnosed with stage four terminal breast cancer two years ago was told she had a year left to live. For six months, she traveled the world, visited family, and fixed all her problems, and even forgave the people that had wronged her. After these six months the cancer became more apparent than her cough at first and she was hospitalized. A month later, still in the hospital and in terrible suffering, she was euthanized and put out of the terrible, unrecoverable fate she was in; this is because in Colombia the practice of Euthanasia to suffering, dying patients was legalized in 1997. As much pain as her death was to the entire family, her little suffering caused much closure. I would by an atrocity of she had to suffer prolong sufferings, if not legalized and my family would have gone through an exponential worse suffering if she had to live in those sub-human conditions. To prolong death when suffering and pain is present is a legal torture that no person should have to go through as humanities the right to die with dignity is a basic right of free will. This raises the point that until legislation is brought to legalize Euthanasia world-wide, we will continue to live in a world that prefers torture and pain, over dignity and free will.
You May Also Find These Documents Helpful
-
Euthanasia, the painless killing of a patient suffering from an agonizing disease, is a very controversial topic. Some argue that it is an act of murder and doctors should do all they can to extend life. Others argue that life should not be forced by resuscitation but patients should instead be relieved of their suffering through death. Barbara Huttman addresses the opposers of euthanasia in her essay, "A Crime of Compassion". Huttman tells the reader of her experience with Mac, a terminally ill cancer patient. Within the essay, Huttman explains how she watched the treatment take all he had, affecting Mac and those around him, and ultimately allows him die. Using rhetorical devices, she conveys the message that suffering patients should have…
- 1028 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays -
This would benefit many families and provide a precedent for future context, surrounding similar issues. The legal definition of the terms could be referred to and therefore provide a rigid law to settle similar cases. If amended the Act would provide legal classification of this area. If amended the Act would be very significant in Australia, but it ought to be amended for credibility and accountability once more recent evidence and interpretation surrounding these issues (which are more prevalent with increasing technology and medicine) is taken into…
- 1541 Words
- 7 Pages
Better Essays -
Should terminally ill patients be allowed to die with dignity? As a medical assistant you take care of every kind of patient. The young, middle aged, the elderly, the hurt, the sick, and the ones who can’t take care of themselves. During our clinical one of the rotations was an assisted living home. It wasn’t like most “nursing homes”. You didn’t walk in and immediately sense a dark or bad vibe. I had a sense of being needed by the residents. They needed me to take care of them because their families didn’t have the time or space to care for them like they wished.…
- 722 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
Imagine standing in a hospital room watching a man suffer in agonizing pain day after day and not being able to do anything about it. This is the situation that Barbara Huttmann faces in her essay "A Crime of Compassion." Huttmann, a nurse, is forced to watch Mac live in agonizing pain without legally being able to let him die. The message that she displays in her essay is suffering people should be permitted to die if they aspire to do so. Using various rhetorical devices, Huttmann portrays her message by first introducing Mac to the reader, then illustrating his suffering and finally letting him die.…
- 909 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
to death, it might be putting that person through a lot of pain but he 'll still…
- 1762 Words
- 8 Pages
Powerful Essays -
Physician-assisted suicide (PAS) is an issue that started in the 1980’s and continues to remain a current hot topic within the nursing practice. Governor Jerry Brown recently signed an assisted suicide bill into law (Lovett & Pérez-Peña, 2015). PAS will be in effect ninety days after its ruling on the floor. The governor stated that if he were battling a terminal illness accompanied by pain he would be comforted by the option and wouldn’t want to deny that to anyone. As with any issue, there has been opposition claiming that the ill and disabled may be coerced into choosing death over other options. Not only does this law change the way medicine is practiced, but it also affects nursing care.…
- 385 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
Control. It is a part of human nature to yearn for control. From the moment we are born we try to manipulate the environment in our favor. From a medical standpoint, when a patient can’t control the level of pain the quality of life is lowered partly due to the uncertainty. Assisted suicide offers an outlet for that uncertainty and pain. Assisted suicide should be legalized and employed under certain circumstances to help prevent suffering and to allow the patient to die with dignity; however, assisted suicide should only be considered as a last possible resource to avoid discrimination.…
- 676 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
Imagine having a terminal form of cancer and having no response to treatment. The physicians say there are only a few months left until death. Does one choose to suffer out the last few months of life with family or end his or her life peacefully, with dignity? Physician assisted suicide should be legal because one should have the choice to end his or her own suffering.…
- 1814 Words
- 8 Pages
Powerful Essays -
Through my research, I have learned a lot about the topic of death with dignity. I have gained awareness of many different perspectives from people encountering the agony of a terminal illness. People that have a terminal illness change because of their disease and they no longer are who they were before their disease. They are not as independent and often feel ashamed of what has happened to them.…
- 213 Words
- 1 Page
Satisfactory Essays -
Euthanasia has remained a heated debate among the pro-life and pro-choice community for several decades. Euthanasia is also known as assisted suicide as well as mercy killing. Those who support euthanasia argue that it allows a person to be put out of their misery; they believe that shortening a terminal patient’s pain and suffering is a final “act of mercy” (Medical News). Proponents of euthanasia allege that in the circumstance of having a terminally ill family member or friend, we should end their pain. Therefore, the “Euthanasia” image sends a panging feeling to the viewer’s conscience. The audience is left feeling uncomfortable, for the image leads them to feel liability for extending the pain of a terminally ill patient.…
- 995 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
In recent years, the amount of media coverage surrounding assisted suicide, or euthanasia, has increased. The term evokes a multitude of emotive responses. The Royal College of Nursing completed research on the issue of euthanasia initiating change in their policy of opposition to euthanasia (Robinson, Greenwood, 2009). This particular study received criticism based on the small sample size used for the study. Research is an organized inquiry carried out to provide information for solving problems. Solid research generates dependable data derived by professionally conducted practices and that can be used reliably for decision making (Cooper & Schindler, 2011). Our group seeks to address the research question, hypothesis, variables, and ethical issues along with discussing the significance and magnitude of finding some logical solution to the issue called “Euthanasia.” Assisted suicide gives the health care provider the option of avoiding care giving during a time of little demand for euthanasia services.…
- 2398 Words
- 10 Pages
Powerful Essays -
Should terminally ill people be able to decide their own fate on whether they live a helpless life or they die with dignity? The purpose of this essay is to explain the benefits of legalizing euthanasia for terminally ill patients to have that choice. A patient can only be classified as terminally ill if a medical doctor has determined that the individuals is over 18 years of age and their death will be directly correlated to their specified incurable disease. Life expectancy of these patients is typically six months or less (Klinger, pg. 111). The process of being qualified for physician-assisted death is a patient must be diagnosed as terminally ill from two doctors, pass a psychological analysis to verify sanity by two psychologists, and must have the support from family for nonfinancial reasons. Euthanasia should be made legal throughout the world because it improves a person’s life, helps prevent painful deaths, and saves the family and patient money.…
- 893 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
Euthanasia is a topic in which people have supported it, disagreed with it or are unsure of what they think about it. This is a sensitive subject because there are millions of instances we can evaluate and determine if they are morally right or wrong. All people interpret human euthanasia differently; some think we need it, some want it and some say we can control it, while others say there are alternatives and that we can never truly control it (Care, para. 14-20.) There are multiple forms of euthanasia that exist: active, passive, physician-assisted suicide, voluntary, non-voluntary and involuntary. Some are more tolerable in people’s opinions while others are unquestionably irrational. The end result of this practice is ever-changing because there are so many different perspectives one can take into account while making a decision to end the life of a fellow human.…
- 1509 Words
- 7 Pages
Better Essays -
I remember traveling to Los Angeles with my mom to meet her grandmother. My mom told me that her grandmother was sick, but I never imagined how sick she was. When we arrived at her grandmother's house, it was hard for me to believe that she was still alive. She did not move, did not blink, so I started asking questions. Grandma had been in bed over 20 years, she had paralysis. They had to bathe her occasionally, she was wearing diapers, and she lived out off of saline solution and a respirator. I knew that if she were able to speak, she would ask for euthanasia. Also known as assisted suicide and more loosely termed mercy killing, it basically means to take a deliberate action with the express intention of ending a life to relieve intractable suffering. Euthanasia is the practice of ending a life in a painless manner. Many disagree with this interpretation, because it needs to include a reference to intractable suffering. In the majority of countries euthanasia or assisted suicide is against the law. Although terminally ill patients may not be capable to make that decision, euthanasia should become legal in California because, every human being has the right to decide about their own life, permitting euthanasia is the only compassionate response to their pain, and legalizing euthanasia will stop patients’ suffering.…
- 1358 Words
- 6 Pages
Better Essays -
In my research paper, I will be discussing the question: should euthanasia by legalized? I will advocate for its legalization and provide substantial evidence to support my standpoint. I will also mention at least one argument from the opposition in hopes to avoid bias. In terms of the law, euthanasia, or assisted suicide, ought to be equated with homicide. Homicide is defined by the killing of one human being by another human being, and is punishable by life in prison or the death penalty. It is considered one of the most morally reprehensible crimes a person can commit. Yet voluntary euthanasia, or assisted suicide, is only punishable by a maximum of 14 years in prison. In this paper, I will elucidate on the dissimilarity in sentencing, and my endorsement of it.…
- 298 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays