The purpose in writing my critical evaluation essay is to do any analysis of a writer's point of view. In addition, it is to do an evaluation of the author's message. That is, what is the thesis or key idea the author was trying to get across. I will explore the writer’s arguments that were offered to prove the focal idea and a summary of the author’s solutions for action. It is my hope, with the critical evaluation, that I, along with the readers of my essay, will discover whether the author provided appropriate evidential support and the effectiveness of it. I also hope to provide some new insight and understanding to a topic that is so important to our history.
This assignment allowed me to research a topic that is so important to our history. I was greatly intrigued that a group of atomic scientists who were responsible for creating such a means of destruction were pleading to halt the use of the atomic bomb against Japan. Not only through the course of my critical evaluation did I learn more about the events that led up to the bombing of Japan, I developed an understanding of the struggles between science, politics, and moral obligation and consequences. Moreover, to believe that if this plea could have been written in a different way, it could have affected the course of history.
The difficulties I encountered during this writing assignment were ensuring I evaluated it in a logical manner, free from emotion due to the impact it had on our history. I attempted throughout the process, to perform research of the topic and make myself more knowledgeable of the events that led up to the petition and what took place after. I also had to ensure that while doing a critical evaluation of a topic does not mean to be negative. But rather, it means being objective and well-informed.
I enjoyed this assignment because it allowed me to revisit a topic in history that had such a huge impact. Although, I was aware of the author and who...
Cited: Szilard, Leo and Cosigners. “A Petition to the President of the United States.”
Atomicarchive.com. 2011. Web. 11 May 2012.
Please join StudyMode to read the full document