Preview

Comparison of "Because I Could Not Stop for Death." and "Death Not Be Proud."

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
631 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Comparison of "Because I Could Not Stop for Death." and "Death Not Be Proud."
Essay prompt number 1.

In these particular poems about death, there are two different pictures painted of death. It is a clear contrast on the author’s individual point of view for such character. On both poems, the diction used to describe death is different from what I would use to describe death. It is very interesting that death is not described as an enemy, or a powerful and intimidating being. Both poems negate the mightiness of this character in different ways.

On Dickinson’s poem: “Because I could not stop for death.” Death is personified as an unintimidating, gentle guide; in charge of guiding you to eternity. the first paragraph of the poem talks about a kind helper, who takes you to immortality. Definitely, this poem is not describing the typical reaper that is hunting people to finite their lives. with eternity in your hands, Death seems like a patient and gentle character. It gives you a sense of relief being with Death gives you another perspective of peace, no stress matters; nothing that produces anxiety is with him anymore. the next stanza talks about the peaceful ride to eternity, what they see. Children playing reflects innocence, pure happiness. Gazing grain and Setting sun are expressions of things ending. Gazing grain ready to be reaped, or the sunset that indicates the end of a day. But also, the two are scenarios that bring peace to just watch. these paint a picture of coldness. Like if the ride went through a stage of cold, even darkness. This stanza in particular is a transition to the next stage on the ride, to eternality.
The final stage she states which points to immortality finally obtained. So the whole poem is the ride to immortality, even at the beginning of the poem immortality was in the carriage. Death himself is painted as a servant that is kind, patient, unintimidating, and nothing really point out to him being mighty or frightening.

On Donne’s poem: “Death be not proud.” Death is not personified as a

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    In the first stanza, the poet uses this specific diction to come to realize a young boy or girls imagination, “peppermint wind, moon-bird, grass grows soft and white.” Children are innocent, and their artistic imagination characterizes where there imagination can take them. In the second stanza, it could symbolize the children’s conception in the adult world, “asphalt flowers, dark streets, smoke blows black” (Siminoff,). This example explains that the children see the world as a dark, non-playful, challenging life style, which it can be. From the children’s perspective, it teaches them that they should take life at a slow pace, and not give up on childhood too quickly because living as a child is challenging, not knowing what to expect after childhood, and imagining life in the adult…

    • 817 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Death: Betjeman is open and even brutal in the physical descriptions in this poem of the effects of death.…

    • 741 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The woman leaves with Death without protestation, and permits him to take control in driving the carriage. She evidently realizes that there is no use in fighting it and instead allows herself to be taken on this journey. Dickinson depicts as Death treating her “kindly” and very respectfully as well. She is not externalized or disregarded as his metaphorical wife. Additionally, Dickinson used specific symbolism such as the vision of the children at the schoolyard to signify the youthful period of her life, the carriage that symbolizes her funeral wagon—the vehicle that Death is using to take his bride to the next destination. All of these elements that Dickinson used to personify the concept of death is quite effectively in getting the reader to think outside the box. Perhaps there is an Eternity after death. Perhaps Death isn’t such a scary concept to embrace at the end of one’s life. These are the kinds of thoughts that reading this poem conjure up, and sure it shows that Dickinson certainly had a rather interesting view of the afterlife in general. That she was able to build such an interesting imagery about such a morbid topic shows just how much of a skilled poet she was. She will be continue to be lauded for those skills far into the future, perhaps even into…

    • 1217 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In “Because I could not stop for Death” she writes death as a gentleman who is taking her for a ride. The first line of the poem says, “Because I could not stop for Death/ He kindly stopped for me” (1-2) Death as described as kind there, making it seem like it was almost a favor for her that he stopped and allowed her to ride with him. Or is a possibility that the speaker could not stop what they had been doing beforehand because no one truly stops for death. Death itself, however, has to stop for them instead. The word “kindly” simply makes death appear more humanized. The ride with death however is not the first ride of the speaker, towards the end of the poem, Dickinson reveals that the speaker was instead thinking back to the day they had first died. The carriage as well is an important part of the poem because while it carries death and the speaker, it also carries immortality. Again, Dickinson gives qualities to immortality that it otherwise does not possess, but the carriage known as immortality makes an ironic vehicle for the dying speaker to travel in. The personified qualities of death and immortality give the reader an easier understanding on the subject by making them a little more relatable with the idea that death is a gentlemen who escorts you, and the notion of immortality is actually the ride to the…

    • 511 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    The first line indicates the theme by using the word "death". In a critical analysis of the poem by Allen Tate, he says that "every image is precise and moreover not merely beautiful, but fused with the central idea" which in the poem is death (Tate, 84). Engle's main point on "Because I Could Not Stop for Death" is that Dickinson uses the poem to refute death in its entirety. She begins by citing the opening line of the poem. Engle interprets this line to mean that Death, as an end point, ceases to be: "It is simply not her nature to stop for Death. She realizes that she cannot recognize Death's power over her. Once she reckons with that eternal or divine bent within her, Death stops; that is, Death ceases to be what Death is- and end," (Engle 74). This brings in the other character in the poem that also takes the carriage ride with, almost posing as a silent chaperone. This character is Immortality. If these two men are separate entities, what is Emily Dickinson asserting about the end of human life? This seems slightly unclear.…

    • 1044 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    In the first stanza Dickinson writes, “Because I could not stop for Death- / He kindly stopped for me-” (Dickinson 1-2). Right away it appears as if the death was unexpected and there were no signs of it coming to the person. These theme continues through Dickinson’s poem as she takes this person through the experience of death in a carriage ride with Death itself. Through the carriage ride there is no sense of danger as Dickinson writes, “I had put away / My labor and my leisure to, / For His Civility-” (Dickinson 6-8). As they ride together there is a familiarity between them as if they are friends enjoying the presence of each…

    • 653 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The speaker tells us how death is patient and generous. Death not only is being a gentleman to the speaker, but he also takes her on a carriage ride. On the ride he takes her through places that she remembers, even one where she is left buried. We are left thinking that the speaker is alive throughout their journey and that death is taking her on a ride to her burial spot. But once we reach the last stanza of the poem, we are then surprised that the speaker has been dead for centuries and that it’s her spirit thinking about the day of her death. We are then told that her journey not only continues after her grave, but it goes on into…

    • 796 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    There is no mention of death being terrible in the poem. In fact, death is described as being almost peaceful. The narrator says,” We passed the fields of Gazing Grain-We…

    • 210 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    The third stanza is describing the snowstorm beginning; "Unwarmed by any sunset light The gray day darkened into night"…

    • 429 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Emily Dickinson wrote most of her poems for the period of sensitive apprehension during the civil war. Her poem, "Because I could not stop for Death", is a mischievous metaphor in which death is embodied as a man. The first lines of the poem "Because I could not stop for death / He kindly stopped for me—," (1-2) reflect that she is pending to meet death on his own conditions. Typically, death is described as with pessimistic associations, however, Dickinson describes her carriage ride with death as, "I had put away/ My labor and my leisure too,/ For His Civility," ( 6-8). By illustrating death as being civil, she expresses a courteous and gracious picture of death. This line has also a religious perspective; hence, Dickinson capitalized "His" in order to indicate God. The poem continues with a stanza telling about many things she passes during her carriage ride with death. "We passed the Fields of Gazing Grain / We passed the Setting Sun," (11-12). While they pass the scenery of the sun, Dickinson portrays the amount of time that is going by with detailed natural imagery, so the carriage ride with death appears to be eternal. The next…

    • 2166 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In the poem, death is portrayed as a gentlemanly suitor, who collects the speaker for a carriage ride, and sets her down in "Eternity" (24). For the enjoyment of Death's Company, the speaker sacrifices her interests and activities. On the ride they pass schoolchildren at play, fields of crops, and then the "Setting Sun," before stopping at a house, which seems like a "swelling of the ground" (12,18). Since pausing at the house, she notes that despite the passing of "Centuries," she still remembers the day, as if it were today, that she encountered Death.…

    • 1138 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Emily Dickinson's poetry can be seen as a study of deep fears and emotions, specifically in her exploration of death. In her famous poem #465 Dickinson explores the possibility of a life without the elaborate, finished ending that her religious upbringing promised her. She forces herself to question whether there is a possibility of death being a mundane nothingness. In this last moment of doubt in the appearance of the divine, the speaker in the poem find an independent and personal acceptance of a death without profundity or salvation.…

    • 1539 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The title: “Because I Could Not Stop for Death,” states that the speaker could not begin to grieve the loss. The speaker knew it had to end but could not bear to end it on his of her own, thus “Because I could not stop for Death,/ He kindly stopped for me;”(Lines 1-2). Dickinson mentions the speaker’s outfit as a symbolism of unpreparedness. “For only gossamer my gown/ my tippet only tulle,” (15-16). Dickinson’s word choice play a vital role throughout the poem. The term “immortality”(4) signifies that the journey would never end. The speaker is well aware that the journey embarked on was not a round trip. The speaker is taken on a journey filled with many experiences, all which he or she accepts and learns from. This journey illuminated the speaker’s perspective of grieving with the loss of something or someone.…

    • 743 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In the first stanza, Dickinson personifies death as a benevolent suitor, who has come to guide her on a journey from life to afterlife. She clearly welcomes death, and is unafraid of leaving her mortal life behind perhaps because as a woman, Dickinson was unattached to the world as she did not have a lover, and lived an extremely reclusive life. Therefore ending her life on earth was not a worry to her but rather something she received gladly. Death is personified in this stanza as Dickinson makes 'Death' a noun, she goes on to give him human characteristics such as 'kindly stopping' for the persona. Since she did not have the ability to die by her own will, she was glad when death came to meet her. The fact that he pays special attention to her by coming to meet her in a 'carriage' furthers his presentation as a suitor, perhaps the one Dickinson never acquired during her lifetime. The inevitability of dying is shown by use of punctuation with a full stop after 'Immortality' despite the lack of punctuation present in the rest of the stanza. This makes the reader realise that death will meet everyone, and it is our reaction to death which may make our journey into the afterlife…

    • 1663 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    In a critical analysis by Allen Tate he says that "the content of death in the poem eludes forever any explicit definition" (Tate 76-119). He believes that that this is one the greatest poems within the English language because it's flawless. Each image is precise and fuses with the central idea which in this particular poem is death. An example of her power to fuse into a single order of perception is in the third stanza where she refers to the children, the grain, and the setting sun (Tate 76-119). Tate speaks of the poem's "subtly interfused erotic motive, which the idea of death has presented to most romantic poets, love being a symbol interchangeable with death" (Tate 76-119). "Because I could not stop for Death," Tate calls attention to the startling irony of presenting Death, an embodiment of terror, as a gentleman, and even more ironically as the servant of Immortality (Tate 76-119).…

    • 1894 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays