top-rated free essay

Comparison between "Lord of the flies" and "Catcher in the rye".

By pammy1986 Jul 14, 2003 998 Words
Comparison Essay

The two books that I am comparing are The Catcher in the Rye, and Lord of the Flies. The two books are very interesting and are very opposite yet the same in many ways. In The Catcher in the Rye, Holden is an idealistic character who becomes more of a realist as the novel progresses, while in the Lord of the Flies, many characters assume different roles. But the main argument between the two novels is that Holden has a dream job of being the catcher in the rye. The catcher in the rye symbolizes that Holden is on an imaginary cliff, trying to keep the children from falling off. The rye symbolizes childhood and innocence, but falling off would mean falling into the "phony" world of adult-hood. Holden wants to keep the kids on the rye preserving their innocence. In the Lord of the Flies, the boys are stuck on an island without adult supervision and quickly lose their innocence, becoming savages. Jack is the leader of the savages, and he is always acting very wild and crazy on the island. Jack yelled this quote a number of times, " Kill the pig! Cut his throat! Kill the pig! Bash him in!" ( Golding 126). The theme I am trying to connect, is it possible to stay innocent your whole life, or will everyone eventually lose their innocence?

In the Lord of the Flies, Ralph and Piggy are the two main characters trying to keep innocence on the island by trying to restore a democratic island. Piggy tries to use his wisdom, while Ralph tries to use the little power he has left. But in order to restore democracy and innocence on the island they must compete with Jack, who is controlling the island by making everyone believe that eating meat is more important than being rescued. He even lets down his guard at the signal fire and loses their chances of being rescued; but even though Jack is not the right guy to be leader on the island, because he doesn't think for the long run, the boys like Jack because he fills their stomachs with meat. Ralph and Piggy can be compared to Holden's dream job of being the catcher in the rye. Both things are unrealistic, as it is impossible to keep kids from falling into adulthood and losing their innocence, because it is a normal, healthy part of life, and Holden eventually learns that, and Ralph and Piggy realize that it is unrealistic to compete with Jack's group of savages, and that everyone will eventually lose their innocence.

Holden Caulfield believes that all kids are innocent, and when they go into the adult world, they all become phonies. Holden feels that all adults in the book are phonies, except for the nuns. Holden thinks that all adults ruin children and take away their innocence. If Holden's thoughts were true, then Holden would think that the island in Lord of the Flies would be the most innocent place, but in Lord of the Flies the children lose their innocence by acting like savages. On the island they even kill each other! The reason the kids act like this is because there are no adults on the island; Holden would feel that with no adults the kids would live free and innocent, but the truth is that because there were no adults, the kids acted like savages. What is also ironic about this, is that Ralph and Piggy were the only ones on the island acting like adults, while Jack and the rest of the kids on the island were acting like the kids, so the only ones on the island that really acted innocent are the ones that acted like adults. Throughout the whole novel of Lord of the Flies, the kids act like savages because there are no adults, but the moment an adult steps onto the island, this restores order; the kids realize at the end that they acted like savages and the adult restores the innocence, which proves Holden wrong because Holden feels that adults take away our innocence, when they really keep it.

In The Catcher in the Rye, Holden feels that it is because of society that you can't keep your innocence, but in Lord of the Flies, the boys can't keep their innocence because there is no society. In The Catcher in the Rye, Holden feels that it is society that is destroying innocence. An example of this is how Holden saw the graffiti on the walls of his little sister's school, which read "fuck you" ( Salinger 201) This got Holden mad and depressed, and this is an example of how Holden feels that society takes away the innocence of children. In the Lord of the Flies, because there is no society, the kids lose their innocence. The kids lose their innocence, because there are no rules on the island, and leads the kids to believe that they can do whatever they want, and leads them to act like savages. What the two novels tell us, is that no matter what happens in society, we will always lose your innocence.

In both novels, everyone is losing their innocence, Holden is losing it but he doesn't face the facts at the beginning, but at the end of the novel, as Holden sees Phoebe on the carousel, he starts to realize that there is nothing he can do to prevent himself or Phoebe from growing up, and he realizes that everyone will eventually lose their innocence. In Lord of the Flies, the kids are losing their innocence and there is nothing that they can do about it, because there will always be a higher power to take away innocence, like Jack did in Lord of the Flies. In both novels the characters lose their innocence, but in both novels, at the end the characters face reality. This shows that everyone will eventually lose their innocence, and everyone will have to adjust to life without it.

Cite This Document

Related Documents

  • Lord of the Flies Comparison Between Raplh and Jack

    ...they react and behave afterwards shows how the true character of one is. When Ralph - a 13 year old boy in Golding’s novel, “Lord of the flies”, is faced with an adversity of leading a group of teenage boys to co-operate while they were stranded on an estranged island. His role was to lead them and maintain order by keeping them safe and ...

    Read More
  • Comparison Essay Between Catcher in the Rye and Death of a Salesman

    ...Pressures In Human Society A common idea presented in literature is the issue of the freedom of the individual in the constant pressures of society. In the play “Death of a Salesman” by, Arthur Miller, Willy Loman is a good example of this, as well as a sixteen year old boy named Holden Caulfield ...

    Read More
  • Apa: Comparison Between the Hunger Games and Lord of the Flies

    ...Comparing and contrasting the similarities and difference of group and individual survival between the Hunger Games by Suzanne Collin, Lord of the Flies by William Golding, and the 1990 film of Lord of the Flies directed by Harry Hook. BY: Becky Coutlee April, 23, 2012 D.Smith Comparing and contrasting the similarities and difference of gr...

    Read More
  • Comparison Between Lord of the Flies and Frankenstein

    ...Comparison between LOTF and Frank Characters THESIS: In both Frankenstein and Lord of the Flies, characters with similar personalities living in comparable environments often play similar roles, which in effect, develop their story’s plotline. The idea of ‘the evil in man’ plays a significant role in both novels, manifesting itself ...

    Read More
  • Catcher in the Rye Essay with Freud Comparisons

    ...I think Holden Caufield is one of the few sane characters in The Catcher in the Rye. List reasons why you think Holden is sane, or normal compared to the average teenager. I think holden is sane because he is like most other teens. They deal with emotions, mood swings, relationships with others, etc List some other characters and...

    Read More
  • Comparison of the Social Network and the Catcher in the Rye

    ...Extended Study – Comparative Texts Which techniques do J. D. Salinger and David Fincher use to explore the personal dilemmas of their protagonists, Holden Caulfield and Mark Zuckerberg, in The Catcher in the Rye and The Social Network? In David Fincher’s The Social Network and J. D. Salinger’s The Catcher in the Rye, a story of two y...

    Read More
  • Catcher in the Rye and Stand by Me: A Comparison

    ...Comparison and Contrast Essay: Catcher in the Rye and Stand by Me Themes in literary works are recurring, unifying subjects or ideas, motifs that allow us to understand more deeply the characters and their world. In The Catcher in the Rye and stand by Me, the major themes reflect the values and motivations of the characters. As its title ind...

    Read More
  • Lord of the Flies Comparison/Contrast Essay

    ...William Golding's Lord of the Flies is a novel about a group of boys who are lost on a deserted island and must do what they can to survive. At the beginning of the novel, two of the boys, Ralph and Jack, become leaders. These differences will form the main conflict in the story. The differences will cause them to hate each other and the anger...

    Read More

Discover the Best Free Essays on StudyMode

Conquer writer's block once and for all.

High Quality Essays

Our library contains thousands of carefully selected free research papers and essays.

Popular Topics

No matter the topic you're researching, chances are we have it covered.