Top-Rated Free Essay

Comparing Fiction and Non Fiction

Good Essays
Marlo Wilson

Business Literature

January 15,2007

Lynn Nelson

Comparing Narrative in Fiction and Non-Fiction Paper

Comparing Narrative in Fiction and Non-Fiction Paper 1

" My Lack of Gumption" a non fiction story by Russell Baker and "Forty-Five

Month a fiction story by R. K. Narayan were two very interesting readings. It

was quite amazing to see how two authors with totally unique writing styles

portrayed the same message. One was comprised of real characters while the

other was a figment of the author’s imagination. Although each author had a

different perspective they both very clearly conveyed the strong dislike that each

character had for the job they were doing at that time.

''My Lack of Gumption was a nonfiction story that took place in the early

nineteen hundreds. The main character of this particular story was an eight year

old child by the name of Russell. It became quite apparent to his mom that he

was very content with the idea of just listening to music and reading books.

Russell’s mother was a single parent who was strong willed and very motivated.

There is no way that she would ever be comfortable with idea of Russell not

doing something to contribute to the household. One day after school she invited

one of the top executives from Curtis Publishing Company over to meet Russell.

This soon led to the start of Russell’s career in journalism which was something

that his mom had always dreamed of. The very next week Russell found himself

trying to sell magazines on the corner of Belleville avenue in New Jersey. For

many days Russell attempted to sell these magazines however, he was not

successful. As the days progressed Russell started to become very

discouraged. He really hated this job. In fact he told his mom that this was not

Comparing Narrative Fiction and Non-Fiction Paper 2

the job for him. There was no way that his mother was going to listen to

anything that he had to say. She even threatened to take his belt and beat some

since into him as a result of his comments. Russell truly disliked the idea of

being a salesman but he disliked the money that it paid even more. After three

years of sales his mother finally decided to consider a less competitive career for

Russell. Her ultimate goal was to never allow him to quit. Eventually her

persistence led to the start of a career in writing.

" Forty Five a Month" which is a fictional story that also takes place in the

early nineteen hundreds. This story depicts the life of a father who spent his

entire life working very hard to provide for his family. Venkat Rao was married

and had a beautiful daughter named Shanta. Shanta loved her mom but she

was the apple of her daddy's eye. One day before school herfather promised to

take her to the cinema. This was something that they really enjoyed doing

however Venkat's job seemed to always stand in the way of the promises that he

made to her. She left school early one day and rushed home so that she could

go to the cinema. This was such an exciting time for Shanta. In fact she so

excited that she refused to eat or drink before she got dressed. She did not want

anything to stand in the way of her being ready when her father got home.

Shanta very patiently paced back and fourth as she anticipated his arrival.

Many hours had passed. It was starting to get dark outside and Shanta resigned

herself to the fact that she was not going to make it to the cinema. She was a

very intelligent little girl and her disappointment led her to have some pretty wild

Comparing Narrative in Fiction and Non-Fiction Paper 3

ideas about what she should do. She thought about going to his job and

demanding that he leave and take her to the cinema however, she very quickly

realized that she did not where he worked. Venkat worked as a clerk in

Company that had employed him for many years. Normally he reported to work

very early and did not return home until around seven or eight in the evening. He

was even expected too come into the office on Sundays. This was very troubling

for him. He literally had no time to devote to his family. In addition he was only

bringing home forty rupees a month. Which very clearly was not a lot of

money even during that time. Venakat was no different from any other hard

working man. He had to keep food on the table for his wife and child. He was

doing what he had to do in order to make a living. Eventually the disappointment

from his daughter really began to weigh on him. This ultimately led to the idea

that he would go into work and quit. He could not fathom how anything could

be more important than spending quality time with his family. He grew to resent

the company as well as his manager. Venkat went into work and wrote up his

letter of resignation. Just when he had gotten the nerve to quit they offered him

more money. He made a very challenging decision to continue working in-spite

of his wife and child.

Although these two stories were very different, they both had a very similar

message that each author wanted to convey to the reader. For example "My

Lack of Gumption" very vividly demonstrates how Russell really disliked his job

selling newspapers and wanted to quit after the first day. While "Forty Five a

Comparing Narrative in Fiction and Non-Fiction Paper 4

Month shows that Venkat also wanted to quit his job as a clerk because he was

unable to spend quality time with his family. Another interesting similarity that

unfolded was the fact that Russell felt that selling magazines for a major

corporation was paying him very little wages. He stated that the magazines were

a nickel each. Venakat Rao also felt that in-spite of the dedication that he had to

the company that employed him for many years he too was making very little

money. In fact he stated that they were paying him pennies while they were

making the big bucks. The idea of dedication is another similarity that comes to

mind. Even though Russell was an eight year old child his mother was the

driving force behind his desire to succeed, he eventually understood the

importance of working and making a living for himself. Venakt on the other was

married with a child and realized the significance of working to provide for his

family even at the expense of not being able to spend the quality time that he so


While it is very evident that one story is fictional and the other is non fictional

each author very successfully brought to life the feelings of the characters. The

setting, the use of language and the descriptives were very instrumental in

helping you feel like you were actually living through the experience. Both stories

made for easy reading and come highly recommended.

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Gambling, whether for life or money, is risky and success is not guaranteed, even if you ‘win’. Two different tales both involving risk. In “The Rocking-Horse Winner” by DH Lawrence a little boy named Paul is a very interesting, unique character. He is a passionate, exuberant little boy. Along with Bassett, the family gardener and his uncle Oscar, Paul gambles at the horse races. He is trying to make money for his family who is very poor. Paul has a way with ‘knowing’ which horse will win; he rides his childhood rocking-horse and while riding he gets a feeling about a certain horse and that horse is the one he gambles on. Paul doesn’t always get an answer but when he does, it is always right on. While in “The Lottery” by Shirley Jackson, the main character we focus on is Tessie, while she, like Paul, is gambling, she isn’t gambling by choice and definitely not for profit. Along with the rest of the village she lives in, Tessie is gambling for her life. Tessie is excited about the lottery each year, every year but this one, when her family is drawn, she protests that the lottery is unfair. She then proceeds to reluctantly draw a slip of paper and of…

    • 781 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    2. Compare and contrast what Richard Wright and Zora Neale Hurston learn in their autobiographical pieces.…

    • 815 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Fiction and Point

    • 499 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Chapter Five discusses the importance of point of view in literature and, more specifically, in the short story. Choose one short story from the course text about which you have not yet written, and analyze it in terms of point of view.…

    • 499 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    A lot of parents want their kids to read the book then watch the movie. But why? If you read the book, you have an image in your head of what the character looks like, what their voices sound like, and what the scene looks like, and usually it is pretty good. But when you watch the movie, all those images get shattered.…

    • 656 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Although many may strive to develop a utopian society, this ideal is only an unattainable dream that can never become reality; a wish that can never be brought to life. As many aim for this unrealistic ideal, many utopian societies first appear as is; a perfect society with a flawless government and harmonious people- at least on the surface. But when we are provided with a closer look at this supposed utopian society, it is revealed that, at some point in time, this society slowly began to spiral downwards. It would soon develop into a dystopian society where social values and standards have become greatly distorted and skewed. When applying the themes in this book to our current society, comparisons can be drawn in areas such as technology, social interactions and education in both societies.…

    • 1881 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Length: Your draft should be eight to ten double-spaced pages in length (excluding title and reference page)…

    • 270 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    to go on and get his Bachelors in management but the store manager of the grocery store had asked him to stay and become his assistant manager because he felt he would retire in a few years and thought Dan would be a perfect fit for his job. With him working so hard for the Grocery store he had moved up the latter quickly so he stayed and became the assistant. Two and half years later Dan got his shot at the Store manager's job after the other one had retired. Dan was the store manager there for 15 years. He told me it was a great experience and a wonderful opportunity but being in a smaller town and having a family he needed more. The Willmar Wal-Mart had been open for about five years and Dan had only heard good things he was hired there as an assistant manager…

    • 1331 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Non fiction essay 1

    • 560 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Rhetorical strategies are everywhere especially in the book As the Caged Bird Sings By: Maya Angelo. There are several examples of repetition, rhetorical questions, dialect, and similes but there are three that really stood out to me allusions, alliteration and parallelism. Just by knowing and understanding what these three rhetorical strategies were it made the book a lot clearer and I could understand it more. By using allusion, alliteration and parallelism, Angelo proves that it was hard growing up in the 1930’s as a young black woman.…

    • 560 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    He states that there was no follow up interview and is not really clear on what happened with that job. He states that he does want to seek employment and continues to go on weekly outings with his job coach.…

    • 1466 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Russell's Mom Analysis

    • 147 Words
    • 1 Page

    Russell’s mom is a typical caring mom, who devoted her life to attending her children and family. The author referred to her mom as the person always on the run, for she was always running while she was doing chores and serving the family. The time she was needed for the family is the happiest time of her life, even when her mind didn’t work, she stills remembered her child.…

    • 147 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    For many years Hollywood has been making blockbuster movies based on bestselling novels, but often these movies differ greatly from the novel . The movie The Power of One based on a book of the same name follows this trend. The Power of One tells the story of Peekay, a boy living in South Africa who dreams of becoming the welterweight champion of the world, and who tries to correct the injustice that goes on around him. Although the movie does keep the main themes of the novel like racism and how one person can change the world. The film adds new plot twists and characters that make the story more exciting, but also changes important characters and storylines from the book that makes the novel endearing.…

    • 1037 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    In performance an actor has less time to characterise and so can risk the character coming across as underdeveloped. The great realists of dramaturgy have relied heavily on implicit characterization which occupy the main body of their character driven plays. Examples of these playwrights are Henrik Ibsen, August Strindberg and Anton Chekhov. Such psychological epics as The Seagull indirectly characterise the protagonists so that the audience is drawn into their inner turmoils as they are slowly revealed over the three hours of time spent with the characters. The actors taking on these roles must also characterise over a long period of time, to the point that there seems to be no direct statement of who the character is at any point, this realism in acting requires the actor to characterise from their own persona as a starting point. The audience therefore does not recognise a realistic characterization immediately.…

    • 322 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Personally, I don't like either of the narrators. The Writer seems to have made that intentional. Both short stories were written in a way that made it seem that the pace that each narrator was quick especially in Orientation by Daniel Orozco. Both narrators were giving quick and precise instruction to its listener in the short stories. Both came off a bit arrogant in the way they said it. In Girl, i specifically found it mean the way she asked if the person sings benna in Sunday school and then later said she would never sing benna in Sunday school as if to say she is better than that. In Orientation, the narrator is that person that knows everything about everyone in the office and what goes on with them. that interfering and arrogant person.…

    • 328 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In the selection, "Teaching History Through Fiction: Valuable or Dangerous" there are two different arguments on whether historical fiction should be used to teach history or not.…

    • 941 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Book And Movie Comparison

    • 415 Words
    • 2 Pages

    There were many differences between the book and movie. One of the differences in the movie is there is a tornado tracker guy gets information on the tornado, but in the book there isn’t a tornado tracker guy. In the movie, Stacey doesn’t help get Dan ad Arthur out of the basement out of the basement, but in the book, she does. In the movie, the Mom doesn’t give instructions to Dan and Arthur, but in the book she does. In the movie, when Mom leaves the house, she’s checking if Grandmas okay, but in the book, she checks on Mrs. Smiley. In the book, Mrs. Smiley is one of the characters, but in the movie, she isn’t one of the characters. In the book, Dan drives the police car, but in the movie, Dan drives through roadblocks to get to Grandma. In the movie, the Dad got stuck under a car and got rescued, but in the book, the Dad never got stuck under a car. In the movie, Dan sneaks into the car when the Dad is looking for the Mom, but in the book, that doesn’t happen. In the movie, Dan has an earring, but in the book, he doesn’t. In the movie, Grandma dies, but in the book, Mrs. Smiley dies. In the movie, when the family…

    • 415 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays

Related Topics