top-rated free essay

Compare and Contrast Mlk and Malcolm X

By someone1 May 08, 2006 834 Words
Amidst the dark clouds, clouds that rose far away destroying the clear sky of this country over the course of decades, rose two significant figures. They were the fighters, the leaders, the teachers; they were the generals who led their forces of justice and equality against the numbering and thundering dark clouds; their men stood together, side by side, and fought courageously to win the war against the darkness of racism. These men, however, belonged to two forces; one was led by Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr. and the other, a much aggressive one, by Malcolm X. While being unquestionably different, they were alike; they both fought for the same goal, but on different battlegrounds.

Martin Luther King and Malcolm (Little) X were both students, and bright ones at that! They, amongst the conflicts that the society presented, managed rather peculiarly to keep their minds open; that is, to say, they amassed copious amounts of knowledge about the life in this world. They composed their own philosophies and believed them to be true. They were superlatively the most committed believers of their theories. They both felt compelled to end the racism that the world offered towards the African-American society. For that reason, they set out with one common goal: to abolish this racism forever.

As mentioned above, they both share some similarities and copious dissimilarities. Throughout their lives, Martin Luther King and Malcolm X were role models in the continuous battle against racism. They both gave powerful speeches on racism; however their intentions were delivered with different styles and purposes. King had a more positive and idealistic approach compared to Malcolm X's more pessimistic views. King was hopeful in believing that someday, blacks would achieve full equality with whites. Non–violent demonstrations and arguments were King's techniques in reaching equality. Malcolm X, on the other hand, viewed non-violence and integration as a way of the "whites keeping the blacks in their places". Malcolm X showed more fury towards white racism and encouraged more protest against white racists than King did. Although Malcolm X is more of an extremist, both men ultimately wanted respect for one's culture and history. King's positive attitude towards the future of racism in our country made him a different, and in many ways, a better activist. Malcolm X's rough childhood and past experiences shaped his pessimistic views. Because King was more idealistic, he gave a greater hope to the blacks. Malcolm X's more realistic speeches and views were seen as pessimistic; promoting separatism and no hope for blacks and whites ever reaching equality. Malcolm X's arguments were more of a negative reminder of the inequality blacks faced; while King brought about ideas for a hopeful future. Malcolm X's realization of the reality, that his beliefs, as he incorporated them from Elijah Mohammad – a key figure of African American Muslim society called the Nation of Islam, which organized many events against the Caucasian race and secretly employed illegal tactics to promote the idea that blacks should separate from whites – were incorrect. After taking a pilgrimage to Mecca, a holy city for Muslims, he learned that Islam teaches racial equality, and not inequality. King, on the contrary, remained with his starting belief: King believed that blacks and whites are equal, and that one day, this will be shown to the world. Dr. King, indeed, never had to change his beliefs. Malcolm X's often angry tone fueled the white racists. King was a bigger promoter of non-violence, which gave the whites less to criticize. Malcolm was an easier target for the whites because of his anger. His anger also triggered more hatred amongst the black community. It may have been more effective for Malcolm X to deliver his ideas in a way more similar to King's. Nevertheless, both Malcolm X and Martin Luther King were two of the most influential men of our history's past. They both had an ultimate goal of bringing hope to the blacks in our country; however they presented this goal with different ideas. King's more positive approach did a better job of giving hope to blacks. Without King's idealism, the African American dream for the future may have never been recognized. He gave the community a strong voice and a future to look forward to. Malcolm X's views were seen as ultimately leading to a separatist nation; which was less inspiring for the blacks. Ultimately, indeed, he changed his views and fought to present his views differently towards the end of his career. Where it is a painful fact that hostile bullets took these key figures away from us, the newer generation, it didn't take their teachings away. The above explanation clearly shows that Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. and Malcolm X were alike, yet very different; the evidence presented clearly shows that they fought for one goal – to abolish racism against African American. They will never be forgotten.

Cite This Document

Related Documents

  • Mlk and Malcolm X Compare and Contrast

    ...11/1/10 Compare and Contrast Professor Watson Compare and Contrast: Malcolm X and Martin Luther King Jr. The 1960’s was a tumultuous time in the United States of America. The civil rights movement polarized the citizens of the country. The civil rights movement was responsible for bringing equality to all men and there were two very dif...

    Read More
  • Compare Contrast Mlk Malcolm X

    ...Compare and Contrast Martin Luther King, Jr. once said, “Our lives begin to end the day we become silent about things that matter,” and staying silent is just what many civil rights activists, including Martin Luther King, Jr. avoided. Martin Luther King, Jr. and Malcolm X are just two of the prominent leaders during the civil rights m...

    Read More
  • Malcom X & Mlk Compare & Contrast

    ...Malcolm X & MLK Essay Malcolm X and Martin Luther king Jr are arguably the most well-known and first to be said or thought about African American individuals throughout history. They fought for what they stood for and both men did it in many different ways. As we all know in history there are no two great men that are alike. Their many...

    Read More
  • Mlk & Malcom X Compare/Contrast

    ...M.L.K and Malcolm X The two most influential civil rights activists in American history were Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. and Malcolm X. They supported equal rights for every race, but when comparing MLK’s “I Have a Dream’ and Malcolm X’s “The Ballot or the Bullet,” one sees the similarities in their rhetorical styles and differences ...

    Read More
  • MLK And Malcolm X

    ...Eilyn Morales Period 4 M.L.K. and Malcolm X Final Draft Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. and Malcolm X are the two best known African-American leaders of the last century. Both wanted to see black people in the best possible position, yet were very different philosophers, and differed on the use of violence to achieve their goals. As can be seen...

    Read More
  • mlk vs malcolm x

    ...Luther King Jr. and Malcolm x are two well-known African Americans in today’s society and historical figures. They both had a huge impact on the civil rights movement, even though they both had different ways of expressing their feelings about racism. As we all know two brilliant and brave men are never alike. Martin Luther King Jr. grew up in...

    Read More
  • Malcolm X

    ...The man known to as one of the most influential civil rights movement icon for black power demonstrated the anger the struggle and beliefs of African Americans during the 1960’s era. This man is known to Malcolm X who fought for a difference in the black community. Malcolm X preached about discrimination and racism in the midst all the hatred ...

    Read More
  • Malcolm X

    ..."To what extent did Malcolm X play a positive role in the Civil Rights Movement of the 1950s and the 1960s in America?" Word Count: 1923 words To a limited extent Malcolm X played a positive role in the Civil Rights Movement of the 1950s and 1960s in America. Malcolm X was an African-American Muslim minister, leader and human rights activ...

    Read More

Discover the Best Free Essays on StudyMode

Conquer writer's block once and for all.

High Quality Essays

Our library contains thousands of carefully selected free research papers and essays.

Popular Topics

No matter the topic you're researching, chances are we have it covered.