Preview

Carl Degler A New Kind Of Revolution Analysis

Better Essays
Open Document
Open Document
2049 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Carl Degler A New Kind Of Revolution Analysis
"A New Kind of Revolution"
Carl N. Degler

In his article "A New Kind of Revolution", author Carl N. Degler explains how government institutions had evolved in colonial America before 1763, and how it was threatened by new English actions and Britain's desire to re-gain control over the colonies. English policies and practices were the structure that helped shape colonial government, but the original policies of mother England had many differences to that of colonial policy that can be seen in many way both micro and macro. By the 1850's, many of the English practices and policies had been forgotten, and a unique American government had formed. Colonial governments still resembled those in England in many areas. All but four of the colonies
…show more content…
This gave America an even more unique identity from the English, as they were no longer speaking the same but rather America had developed something unique on their own, this trend is still painfully obvious today. The colonists also believed themselves to be the hope of the world, or like the puritan ideal of a city on a hill, when they stood up to the tyrannical villain that Great Britain was believed to be. By the early 1760's the colonists were ready in a cultural sense to break away from Britain. The French and Indian War was a major turning point in helping the colonists decide to break away. After the war Britain had a large debt, and in order to pay it off they decided the colonies would play a larger role than what they were. They passed the Sugar Act which lowered duty on molasses to raise money and shortly afterwards passed the Stamp and Townshend Acts to increase revenue. These new policies caught Americans off guard. After the war they expected to return to the uninterested administration the mother country once followed. After the first acts were passed they began to complain and …show more content…
The process of creating the first real constitution began with the mass meeting of America's most prominent "demi-gods", the most prominent of which was George Washington, at Philadelphia on May 17, 1787. The first to arrive in Philadelphia was the young James Madison. In all, seventy-four delegates from different states were selected to attend the convention, and fifty-five actually appeared. All the delegates would not attend all the sessions. The convention was held in the paneled assembly room on the east side of the ground floor of the Pennsylvania State House, (the same room where the declaration of independence had been signed not long before. The convention was not only notable for who attended, but also who curiously did not. Among the names of the non-attendees were Thomas Jefferson and John Adams, both of which were foreign ministers, Jefferson to France and Adams to England. But Adams' presence was none the less felt at the convention as he had recently published "A Defence of the Constitutions of Government", a document which analyzed the constitutional structures of six American states. The types of men attending the

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Stamp Act Dbq

    • 570 Words
    • 3 Pages

    In the 1760s the British passed some laws and taxes to help repay war debts from the French and Indian War. In spite of this the Americans took action against Britain. The taxation without representation and the acts England passed on the colonists caused them to demand independence from England. The taxes such as the stamp act and tea act made the Americans furious to the point where they fought back against Britain.…

    • 570 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    After the French and Indian war the Americans were used to being neglected because the british needed all the troops they could get to fight the seven years. The Americans had experienced salutary neglect for so long that when the British came back the Americans did not like it. The British taxed the Americans with the sugar act and the intolerable acts without the representation deserved. This marked the beginning of the American Revolution.…

    • 511 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    On May 25, 1787, the Constitutional Convention opened in Philadelphia at the Pennsylvania State House. Which today is known as the Independence hall. 55 delegates attended from all the 13 states, all except Rhode Island. Rhode Island did not send a representatives because the state did not want a forceful central government interfering in its economic business. George Washington who would eventually become a national hero was voted to be the president of the convention by a unanimous…

    • 674 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    The American Revolutionary War Begin in 1775 as an open battle between the combined thirteen colonies and Great Brittan. The colonies won their independence in 1783 by The Treaty of Paris. The colonists had come to the New World seeking political, religious, and economic independence. The geographical distance helped to create an exclusive identity for the colonies. Americans felt that they deserved all the rights that Englishmen had. The British felt that the colonies were created to be used in the best way that suited the crown and parliament, meaning mercantilism where the colonies exist to benefit the mother country.…

    • 1732 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    The cause of the American Revolution can be argued but it is clear that it was caused from British missteps that lead to colonial determination to become a separate nation. After 1763, the British began to increase and assert their power over the colonies, who, in contrast, wanted to be less controlled. However, the colonies did not want complete independence prior to this increase in control from the British. Although the colonies did seem to have determination for an independent nation in England’s eyes, the British failed to recognize the colonies real intentions for government, limited expansion and economic success, and increased and controlled taxation in the colonies.…

    • 1389 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Before the conflict between the British wanting to collect more revenue, there was no cohesion between the thirteen colonies. After the war, the colonists felt a common bond that hadn’t existed before. The fact that the French were forced to vacate their colonies to Britain also meant that the lands west of the colonies became an attractive incentive for freedom from England. This was of course before the Proclamation of 1763 was put into action. The war greatly affected how the colonists socially interacted because they started to united with one another. The colonists had learned to unite against a common foe, which was Britain. With France removed from North America, the vast interior of the continent lay open for the Americans to colonize, but the English government did otherwise.…

    • 463 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    American Colonies Dbq

    • 859 Words
    • 4 Pages

    The colonists in the early 18th century felt closer to their homeland of England than they did to their neighboring colonies. It wasn’t until after the French and Indian War that the colonies started to feel unified in a way. Then with the addition of harsh tax acts and policies the colonists started to question being a part of the British Empire. These acts without the colonist’s consent started to stir up ideas about actually becoming an independent nation and revolting against their English rulers.…

    • 859 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Boston Tea Party

    • 1100 Words
    • 5 Pages

    The end of the French and Indian War and the attempt by colonists to make amends with King George III reinforced British identity throughout the American colonies. However, things such as the Declaration of Independence, the Boston Tea Party, the first Continental Congress, and Common Sense by Thomas Paine led to a unity and identity shift among the colonists in America. Therefore, there was more of an identity and unity change in the colonies instead of a continuity.…

    • 1100 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The three colonial regions were also different in their religious and political systems. In New England and the Middle colonies, the church was a dominant force in both society and government. The Southern colonies on the other hand, were mainly based on the plantation system and gave political power to those who owned land. Due to its diverse populations and ways of life, America was fraught with tension, and this tension manifested itself in the French and Indian War. The war created the sparks of American nationalism, created a desire of revenge in the French, and bankrupted the English. The Enlightenment and Great Awakening, also pushed Americans to rethink their relationship with the British. The British began to impose taxes and tariffs on the colonies in order to repay their debt. The colonies were not used to so much control because the British had been ruling by benign neglect, and the sudden imposistion of British control sparked a desire for independence. Many new groups were formed to support American freedoms and resist the British control. Events like the Boston Tea Party and the work done by the Continental Congress inspired American nationalism and allowed America to defeat the…

    • 468 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    There were acres of fertile land to be stolen from the Indians, a large surplus population in Europe eager to come and farm it, plenty of capital available from British investors, and a steadily growing industrial population in Western Europe, and subsequently in the eastern half of the USA needing cheap food. The Protestant promotion of Bible reading led to a literate and therefore more productive working class. Unskilled labour was cheaply available by import from Africa for the first half of the 1800s, after which it could be replaced by mass immigration from the poorer countries of Europe such as Ireland, Italy and Russia. And during all these years Britain was a superpower strong enough to impose world peace, so that the progress of the USA was not limited by the inconveniences of warfare between 1812 and its self-imposed mayhem of 1861-65.The thirteen colonies that became the USA were originally colonies of Great Britain. By the time the American Revolution took place, the citizens of these colonies were beginning to get tired of the British rule. Rebellion and discontent were rampant. For those people who see the change in the American government and society a real Revolution, the Revolution is essentially an economic one. The main reason the colonies started rebelling against 'mother England' was the taxation issue. The colonies debated England's legal power to tax them and, furthermore, did not wish to be taxed without representation. This was one of the main causes of the Revolutionary War. The Revenue Act of 1764 made the constitutional issue of whether or not the King had the right to tax the thirteen colonies an issue, and this eventually "became an entering wedge in the great dispute that was finally to wrest the American colonies from England" (Olsen, 6). It was the phrase 'taxation without representation' "that was to draw many to…

    • 308 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Better Essays

    The Articles were known as a "league of friendship" and they didn't provide for any type of effective power in a central government. The Articles led to problems and left the central government to regulate commerce between states, settles disputes, deal with foreign governments. They also didn't have power to levy taxes, enforce its decisions, manage the country's economic problems, or have an army. This meant that the country was weak and was bound to disasters. In May, representatives were to meet in Washington's newly built meeting house in Philadelphia. All the states sent delegates to represent the state besides Rhode Island. 55 delegates showed up and they began to draft the new document, later known as the Constitution. The Constitutional Convention met for 4 months and because of the poor weather and the travel was bad, an average of 35 delegates were present during the writing of the…

    • 1127 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    The colonists had refused to be ruled by what they had described as a tyrant, which is why they ceased fighting and declared themselves independent. Before the Declaration, the colonists had been withstanding a lot of oppression from their government 3,000 miles away, the British Parliament. Starting with the Proclamation Line of 1763, issued by parliament to prevent the colonies from having war with the surrounding Native Americans, this was one of the first causes that had caused the seed of distrust in the colonists to sprout. Because this Proclamation was issued soon after the French and Indian War, the British were up to their ears in war debt. As a result, the British had passed several acts raising colonial taxes. One of the first of these was the Sugar Act, which had set a tax on sugar purchased in the colonies specifically. The colonies had already been experiencing a multitude of financial difficulties, so a tax act to feed that struggle was indeed a burden. This was soon followed by the Stamp Act, which had placed a tax on every piece of printed paper they had used. The British were very relentless on reasserting their authority over the colonies, however, the colonists are even more so. Boycotting the goods the British taxed, the colonists were successful in…

    • 1086 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    road to unity

    • 873 Words
    • 4 Pages

    From 1750 to 1776 an increase in tension between the colonists and England led to ideas of unity. The British were very involved in the everyday American lives, but there was no unity within the colonies. The English parliament passed numerous acts that increased colonial taxes, making the colonists angrier than ever. More and more Americans began to realize their place in society and the necessity for unity. Due to the uprising in levels of crisis the Americans needed to come together as one. America developed its identity through three distinct phases from 1750-1776.…

    • 873 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    American Independence Dbq

    • 1358 Words
    • 6 Pages

    The United States, like many other countries, had to fight for independence from their homeland. It was the American colonies who paved the way into fighting for their freedom and independence. In eighteenth century, many countries were facing sever inflation by the British parliament. Their goal is to gain more money for King George III and pay war efforts back. Britain’s main target was the colonies of the British Empire, also known as the American colonies. Although, many American colonies consisted of mainly low poverty men, women, and children. The most significant period was from 1754 to 1773.The battles and events that occurred are the main reason the war began. Americans had to face the seven years war, sugar act,…

    • 1358 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Many events led the American Colonies to join together and fight for independence from Britain. It wasn’t economic disparity and it wasn't that the king was a belligerent leader. The British found out that they were not willing to pay England back for taking care of their own colonies in the New World. Geographical distance between England and the New World played a great deal into the problems that they were having. It took days and months just to send or even receive a message, they didn't have computers this wasn't the 21st century. The American Revolution was practically our first major war, by definition. The American Revolution evolved from beginning to end, between 1765 and 1783 in which the thirteen colonies rejected the British monarchy and aristocracy. They defeated the rule of Great Britain and founded the United States of America.…

    • 933 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays