Preview

Articles Of Confederation Dbq Analysis

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
715 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Articles Of Confederation Dbq Analysis
The period surrounding the Revolutionary War philosophically drew from the philosophies of J. Locke and C. Montesquieu. Both men wrote on the origin, need and extent of governments in their time, and created the basis for the liberal form of government. When the Articles of Confederation are compared to the individual philosophies of these two men, the Articles of Confederation proved an ineffective government economically speaking. It has been speculated upon that the most serious flaw in the Articles of Confederation is its inability to allow the federal form of government the power to tax. Taxes are the governments’ income, without them the government cannot provide the services vital to the stability of the country. John Locke theorized …show more content…
Reasons for Congresses inability to levy taxes are obvious when comparing the tax it wished to levy and Adam Smith’s 4 principles of sound tax policy. Smith, the father of modern economics, stated that one policy of a tax policy is that the tax must be levied at regular intervals and of constant quantities. Document H states that this proposed tax went against this principle also “bearing a burden on commercial states.” Even if the Congress under the Articles could tax, their tax will have been a bad one and it is a fact that the people of a country basically judge the government by its taxing …show more content…
failure under the Articles to get favorable trade agreements with foreign nations. Because the credibility of the Federal government was weak, meaning it was not sovereign in the Confederation and it did not represent the people as a whole.
The bargaining position of America was weak. According to Document D, all the U.S. could do was to “respectfully” ask Great Britain to lower its trade restrictions with the U.S. Because the U.S. Was expanding westward, navigations along the Mississippi became increasingly important to the economic well being of the U.S. Again the U.S. bargaining position, this time with Spain, was weak because the U.S. could not secure a treaty in total accordance with its economic stance and this treaty “would be limited” to a certain length of time. The failure of any government economically means that the government in question is a failure for a government is economic in nature. A government must have the power to tax so that it may provide vital services to its people. A government must provide a favorable balance of trade and government economic policies must be positive. The Articles of Confederation failed in all of these aspects and because of that proved to be

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    An effective government is one that will responsibly carry out and defend the wishes and rights of the people, while keeping the country stable and strong. Between the years 1781 to 1789, the Articles of Confederation did not provide the United States with an effective government. The Articles of Confederation lacked adequate powers to deal with economic, foreign commerce and foreign relations. It also did not have the power to enforce its will on the states.…

    • 595 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The system of national government provided by the Articles of Confederation had a number of flaws and was eventually discarded, however, it compiled a record of achievements over time. The Articles of Confederation helped the New World transition from colonies under British rule, through a revolution and into an independent government. Through the development of independence and a national government, the American Articles of Confederation put into place an ineffective government that consisted of a weak central government, due to the little power given to congress. The Articles were a huge example of what needed to be corrected in order to create the U.S. Constitution.…

    • 653 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Articles of Confederation failed for many reasons, Finances are one of them. The States only had state taxes. This means that states could refuse to give money to the Federal government. There were 14 different currencies among America, which lead to some weird trading and payments. These currencies included coins, crops, land, and many other things.…

    • 523 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Articles gave congress the power to pass laws but no power to enforce them. That means, if a state did not support or believe in the federal law, than they did not have to follow it, they could just ignore it. Also, congress had no power to levy taxes or regulate trade. The Articles of Confederation failed because of the lack of a strong central government. It also produced money under the Articles of Confederation and it did not hold its value. The Articles brought the economy way down to eventually collapses. In order to amend the Articles of Confederation, it required a unanimous decision and was extremely difficult.…

    • 570 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Locke’s ideas may have contributed to the Glorious Revolution in England, which started the idea of a Parliamentary government; which would eventually succeed monarchies. “The state of nature has a law of nature to govern it… no one ought to harm another in his life, health, liberty, or possessions,” (John Locke, Second Treatise of Government, Chapter II, Article 6). Jefferson became more in tune with Locke’s writings as the British exerted more control over the Colonies and increased taxes, “taxation without representation.” Based on that, the Founding Father’s decided to organize and form an independent country that was self-governing with the rights of its citizens at the forefront. “We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights, that among these are Life, Liberty and the pursuit of Happiness,” (Thomas Jefferson, Declaration of Independence, Article 2). Is evident through the Declaration of Independence and Constitution that the most important thing to Jefferson and the Founding Fathers was individual rights and freedom. The Articles of Confederation gave power to each state independently but did not set forth a central governing body overall. This flaw leads to the creation of America’s current Constitution, which established the laws that…

    • 1650 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    So in turn this caused problems in the new country. States were in disagreement with one another, state did not financially support the government under the Article of Confederation. Because there was no executive branch congress could not enforce any laws which have passed. Due to not having every state working with each other some states began to form their own military, creating their own money causing no stable economy. (HTT7) After the states noticed economic weakness, they began to ask for stronger Articles that would create a stronger government.…

    • 650 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Articles of Confederation was not very effective at solving economic issues. The economic problems were caused completely by the cost of the Revolutionary War. They tried to pass laws to tax the citizens in order to raise the money needed to pay for the war, but since there was no power to tax in the constitution, this was not very successful. Alexander Hamilton and Roger Morris attempted to rewrite the Articles of Confederation so that they could have the power to tax the states to pay for the war. They are almost successful in changing the constitution, but New York vetoed the changes. Since the Articles of Confederation was not rewritten and they still could not tax the states, they passed the debt on to the states. Then the states were on their own to pay the debt, so they passed new taxes. These taxes that the states passed were much higher than Parliament had ever tried to pass. America went into a depression in 1784 because of all the taxes that the people were required to pay.…

    • 801 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The articles of confederation failed for many reasons. The main reason was that the states had too much power leaving the federal government weak. There was no one person in charge, there was no executive branch. Congress didn’t have any power; decisions had to be approved by all 13 states.…

    • 841 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    In my opinion, the main reason the Articles of Confederation failed to live up to the needs of the new nation was financial troubles. Farmers were unable to pay their debts. Tariff wars began because each state changed tariffs on the other states when trading goods. Inflation was another big issue that caused many financial…

    • 283 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Again, as with independence, there were no guarantees undergirding this process of national development; the outcomes were neither assured nor foreordained. Rather, the Americans had to do some heavy political lifting to prepare the political ground for reform of their government, and some heavy intellectual and theoretical lifting as well to devise the mechanisms and institutions that they felt ought to be put into place as a new national constitution."19 The impact of the Articles of Confederation on the Constitutional Convention of 1787 is underlined "by more than 150 years of conventional wisdom which deemed the Articles to be a total failure. Not until 1940, did historian Merrill Jensen - in his first book, The Articles of Confederation (1940)-set out to redeem the articles from the strictures of conventional wisdom. Today we have a clear-eyed view of the strengths and weaknesses of the Articles and of the achievements of the government under the Articles as well as the…

    • 1923 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    The Articles of Confederation provided for a loose confederation or “firm league of friendship.” Unfortunately a clumsy Congress was the at the helm of the ship that was America. The Articles put no executive branch into place because King George III left unpleasant memories to the new independent states. Although Congress was dominant, it was severely impaired due to its limitations. The Articles of Confederation added to the financial problems, could do nothing to alleviate domestic problems, was unable to deal with diplomatic problems, and caused commercial problems both at home and…

    • 1473 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    One reason that the Articles of Confederation were not effective in solving the problems is that, it didn’t let the national government tax. The government can’t support the nation, if it didn’t have the ability to place taxes on imported goods. For example, there were many Americans who had fought during the war, and supplied goods to the army. They were given loan certificates which had made them wait, where soon the congress can pay them back, but they failed. The congress had owed 34 million to Americans and 10 million to foreign leaders. The little money that the congress made went to foreign leaders. But the Americans still had to wait with the certificates. To solve the problem, it was requested that there should be 5 percent tax on goods, so they can make more money.…

    • 882 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The people held a continental congress in which they wrote up the Articles of Confederation. People did not want a repeat of Britain’s tyranny so they created a system where the national government had very little power. This handicapped the progress of the new country because states could ignore any law passed by the federal government, and every state had their own currency. The Articles of Confederation caused America to plunge into an economic depression.…

    • 697 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Articles of Confederation were not a complete failure. It set up a foundation for the Constitution of 1787 to base its standards and laws of governing on as far as knowing what had and had not worked and tweaking them to fit what was needed at that time. As mentioned earlier the Articles of Confederation compared to the Constitution of 1787 (Doc. C) clearly states that under the Articles of Confederation it was of value that states alone could levy taxes. Meanwhile congress would fund the Common Treasury by making requisitions for state contributions. Where as under the Constitution of 1787, the federal government would grant all powers of taxation. This would benefit the states because while under the Articles of Confederation states were given an option to basically pay what they wanted when they want in turn making it difficult for the government to regulated money based of people’s actions of not paying what was needed.…

    • 804 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In order for a country to work to its fullest potential, it needs a great government. This government needs to do three important tasks. It needs to set up laws, enforce the laws, and provide many different services. Also, it needs to make sure it brings everyone together. Finally, if the government has a problem it should be able to be fixed easily. When the 13 colonies had the Articles of Confederation it couldn’t do many of the things it was supposed to do, thus it failed as a government.…

    • 520 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays