Period 5
Mr. MacIsaac
Due November 17th, 2014
Night/Darkness Compare and Contrast Essay
In Emily Dickinson’s poem We Grow Accustomed to the Night and Robert Frost’s poem
Acquainted with the Night the subject of darkness is reflected upon very differently. Dickinson views the darkness as natural for all of humanity, with her use of “we”, indicating that she is referring to not only herself, but everyone. However, in Frost’s poem, he is alone wandering the streets in the night, showing that he is individual in his struggles. The concept of darkness and the unknown are shown with two very different outlooks in the different poems, in Dickinson’s the night can be accustomed to, and it is not always so unknown. Yet, in Frost’s poem, the night is well known and it represents the solidarity he is feeling. While the ideas of darkness and night are similar in Dickinson and Frost’s poems, Dickinson’s poem views the darkness as manageable and new, whereas Frost’s poem views it as solitary and depressing.
The point of view in the two essays is used to distinguish between them. Emily Dickinson uses “we” to reference herself and humanity, implying that fumbling in the darkness is a natural thing, and that people should not be afraid of the darkness. She states that we will adjust and we will find our way through it. This indicates a sense of hopefulness and that when a person is lost, they will find their way. However, this is contrasting to Frost’s poem and the point of view he uses. Frost uses only first person, speaking as himself. He describes his solidarity as he wanders the streets alone at night. He describes a watchguard he sees and people he hears, however they
1
are not calling to him and he is completely alone. The tone of this poem is very depressing, where Dickinson’s tone is unknowing, but not fearing the unknown.
The structure of Dickinson’s poem is choppy with short statements, as if each is its own thought. The meter is rhythmical, however the author does not follow a specific rhyming pattern.
However, in Frost’s poem he strictly follows an “ABA” rhyming pattern. Frost’s poem flows more evenly throughout each stanza and is less separate. The night is not unfamiliar to Frost in this poem, he knows it well and has walked the streets at night before. He is alone, perhaps in life, and he is depressed, having no one to walk with him. He hears people calling out and sees the watchguard, however the people are not calling to him. He avoids the watchguard’s gaze, not wanting to be judged and not wanting him to know his story. Overall, Frost’s poem provides an intense feeling of being alone and depressed. Yet, in Dickinson’s poem she is describing the unknown, but it is not viewed as sad or depressing or alone. It is regarded as unknown, but not scary. She states that people become acclimated to the dark and that they grow accustomed to it so that they can live with the darkness.
The images used by Frost are of empty streets at midnight, and that it is raining and unlit.
He is alone and he can see the moon, using it to tell time and stating that the time is “neither wrong nor right”. The darkness is described by claiming that “I have outwalked the furthest city light” (Line 3). This creates an image of darkness for the reader. Auditory imagery is used with the calling of the people and visual imagery is used to show the streets. In Dickinson’s poem, she uses visual imagery to show people lost in the dark as well as tactile imagery, describing the bravest people perhaps hitting trees as they search through the darkness. Visual imagery is used, again, to show the darkness through “When not a Moon disclose a sign Or a star come out”
2
(Line 1112). She describes a lack of natural lighting through the moon or the stars. These poems are similar in their uses of visual imagery to describe the night and the overall darkness. They both reference the moon, Dickinson claiming that there is none, making the night darker. Frost, however, uses the moon to tell the time.
Both poems address the dark and the night, however they are entirely different.
Dickinson’s poem does not fear the darkness, and does not necessarily view it as negative. The darkness is natural and happens to everyone, however people can adjust to the darkness so that they can find their way. The darkness is only temporary, for soon our eyes will adjust and we will find our way out of the night. Yet, the darkness in Frost’s poem is unnatural. He cannot escape it, he has been in the dark before. The person is alone, wandering the streets, and their depression of “darkness” is unusual, they are out of the ordinary. He has been here before, and this darkness is not unnatural or unfamiliar to him, but he is alone in experiencing this darkness.
He knows it well and does not want to explain himself to anyone, as shown by his avoidance of the watchguard. There are few similarities between the two poems, they both refer to darkness and night, but they are very different. They use different tones, different meters and structures, different forms of imagery, and different points of view.
3
You May Also Find These Documents Helpful
-
The storm has died away, and still we are restless, uneasy, as if the storm were about to break. Almost all the affairs of men remain in a terrible uncertainty. We think of what has disappeared, and we are almost destroyed by what has been destroyed; we do not know what will be born, and we fear the future, not without reason… Doubt and disorder are in us and with us. There is no thinking man, however shrewd or learned he may be, who can hope to dominate this anxiety, to escape from, this impression of darkness.…
- 924 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
Showing facts on how the body need darkness, or else health problems would occur if not. Such as diabetes, obesity, cardiovascular disease and depression.That’s how powerful darkness is. He is letting the reader know how important it…
- 209 Words
- 1 Page
Satisfactory Essays -
“Acquainted with the Night” is written by Robert Frost. It is about a lonely man walking in the city. He writes in free verse with fourteen lines. Frost uses the devices metaphor, parallel-structure, and personification to convey the theme of the struggle of light v. darkness caused by depression.…
- 334 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
“Darkness is a lack of light as sin is a lack of Love”. When we understand that Holiness can never be hidden by darkness. This section encourages us to hide nothing for this is how we experience Peace and…
- 1061 Words
- 5 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
Frost creates a melancholic poem when the homeless man says that he is acquainted with the night. He is saying that the homeless man is isolated and depressed like the night and no one wants to be…
- 240 Words
- 1 Page
Good Essays -
There are many details that Frost added to give a person a better understanding of the speaker and his feelings. The idea of the speaker, "outwalk[ing] the furthest city light" shows that he is out of bed in the middle of the night walking aimlessly trying to get his problem lifted. It shows how disturbed and troubled the speaker is with this mysterious problem floating around. The line "I have looked down the saddest lane" shows how the speaker has sort of a woe-is-me attitude where he feels that because it is happening to him it must be the worst. When the speaker says that the cry he heard was not to "call [him]…
- 516 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
In contrast, in the last two lines of the first stanza, Frost portrays Thought as opposite of Love. Thought does not live in fear. Thought can wander and escape anywhere it would like to go. Thought is not dependent on anyone. The mind can think of anything that is desires. Love instead has to be reliable to only one and that cling to its loyalty. Frost uses the imagery of “dauntless wings” which would symbolize brave freedom.…
- 850 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
“I have passed by the watchman on his beat and dropped my eyes, unwilling to explain” (II. 5-6). Depression causes a person to distance themselves from the world. It also causes them to not want to associate themselves with people. In the poem, “Acquainted with the Night,” by Robert Frost, a persona seems to be walking aimlessly alone at night in the rain. The persona passes a watchman whom he refuses to associate himself with, so he drops his eyes. The persona also hears “an interrupted cry” that isn’t meant for him, showing how lonely he is. Robert Frost uses many metaphors and symbols to represent things such as depression and hope. In fact, in the poem,…
- 859 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
Depression is an ever-changing dual sword of solitude and struggle. Emily Dickinson’s poem “We Grow Accustomed to the Dark” illustrates the concept that depression is a scarring battle that brings similar individuals together in the hope of overcoming it; however, in Robert Frost’s poem “Acquainted with the Night” depicts depression as a lone ballet to be fought by the individual themselves. Both poems use personification, metaphors, and opposite points of view to illustrate their points.…
- 538 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
In the first stanza, the walk through the woods is set up, and the choice he faces is presented. In the first line, "Two roads diverged in a yellow wood", he words "yellow wood" indicates a "scared world". When having to make a big decision in life, having to choose which way to go, many are scared. Line two shows that the option of taking both paths and shying away from making the decision is not an option, which is unfortunate. The last three lines of the stanza really indicate he is by himself and he thought long and hard about the decision. Lines 4-5 show that he tried to "look down one", meaning he tried to see his future if he followed the path. He looked down "to where it bent in the undergrowth", meaning he could only see as far as to where it was time to, in a sense, grow up. Frosts use of narration is quite helpful in this because it makes relating to the poem easy for the reader, as he is in an almost "all mighty" narrator, speaking for himself and everyone else.…
- 825 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
Women were not the only gender that was oppressed; men were choked with expectations that would leave their shoulders sagging with enormous burdens. The father must be the ultimate role model in the family, indestructible and imperviable to stress and emotions. Men were not allowed to show their emotions, crying was for the weak hearted and frail. In Robert Frost’s Acquainted with the Night, the poem is about a depressed man. The man states that he has become acquainted with the night, implying that he has been going on his nightly routine for a while. On his nightly walks, whenever the narrator makes eye contact with the watchmen, he “dropped his eyes, unwilling to explain” (Frost 1301). This action can be seen as embarrassment. This embarrassment is from the man losing his job. The man has “walked out in the rain – and back in rain” (Frost 1301) and has “outwalked the furthest city light” (Frost 1301) on his job search. As the person that must be the bread winner in the family, losing his job is the ultimate humiliation at this time in America. He, therefore, travels at night to avoid people questioning his walks. Frost also describes the setting to be stuck in time, as if everything was frozen or if time was trudging on slowly. This is because the man has no one to share his burden with and is stuck in the limbo of…
- 1136 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays -
Robert Frost is often referred to as a poet of nature. Words and phrases such as fire and ice, flowers in bloom, apple orchards and rolling hills, are all important elements of Frost 's work. Remove them and something more than symbols are taken away. These ‘benign ' objects provide an alternative way to look at the world and are often used as metaphors to describe a darker view of nature and humans. In Frost 's poetry, the depth is as important as the surface. The darker aspects of Frost 's poetry are often portrayed through the use of symbolism, vivid imagery, and selective word choice. Frost 's poems appear to be simple on the surface, yet upon further scrutiny the poems reveal themselves as elusive. Frost utilizes ordinary objects to create a deeper meaning. For example, the poem Mending Wall, appears to be about the differences between two neighbors and their ideas on rebuilding a wall. On the other hand, the wall may be viewed, in a more general sense, as a symbol to represent all the antagonistic or mistrustful barriers that divide man from man. The gaps I mean / No one has seen them made or heard them made / But at spring mending-time we find them there (lines 9-11), illustrates the point that people become separated without even realizing it because we become so caught up in what is happening in our own lives. The darkness, held within the afore mentioned quotation, is the feeling of sadness. The fact that we do not take notice of one another creates a place that becomes more and more divided by differences. Likewise, the poem Nothing Gold Can Stay seems to represent the change of seasons. But further analysis reveals that the speaker is also paralleling the cycles of life with the change in seasons. So dawn goes down to day (7) illustrates that in life as in nature, golden moments fade away. Then leaf subsides to leaf (5) implies autumn, when the leaves begin to turn gold and fall to the ground. The color gold represents…
- 1016 Words
- 5 Pages
Better Essays -
These two examples show how the two poets use nature to portray their points between nature and people’s problems and feelings. Both Dickinson and Whitman involve people and their struggles or problems in majority of their poems. For instance, in the poem “I Hear America Singing,” and “Much Madness is Divinest Sense,” both poets compare the society to the individuals. Although the two have similarities in their writing, they also carry many differences.…
- 756 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
The researchers would like to dedicate this research paper to those people who have lost their ways and wander in darkness. We hope that even just a little bit, we are able to open your minds and touch your hearts. Always remember that no matter what happens, we will always be there for you and accept you.…
- 2361 Words
- 10 Pages
Good Essays -
Throughout Frost 's poetry it is clear to envisage that Frost himself had experienced great loss. His poem’s take you through some of the stages of grief he had experienced at various points in his life. There is a certain cathartic quality to his poems, it is obvious Frost used the medium of creative writing as a release from his grief, enabling him to process his losses, to accept and heal from them.…
- 1597 Words
- 7 Pages
Better Essays