Preview

What Are You Doing Here By Mark Edmundson

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
807 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
What Are You Doing Here By Mark Edmundson
At this age all students are thinking about is what major should they study and what career will take them on the path they desire. Professor Mark Edmundson gives his own personal opinion on how you should choose an occupation in his essay: “Who Are You and What Are You Doing Here? A Word to the Incoming Class”. Some students would rather spend the rest of their lives walking into the same building doing the same dull job that can’t stand as long as they are making a lot of money. Others look past their yearly income and continue doing what they do because it’s what they love to do. According to Edmundson “To get it, you'll need to struggle and strive, be strong, and occasionally even piss off some admirable people” (Edmundson 406). His thesis states that you need to stick to your guns and stand up for yourself to get an education. What …show more content…
In Edmundson’s essay he goes on and explains the different factors that could sway a career choice. He wants to encourage incoming freshman not to just comprehend everything they learn and absorb the knowledge, but to follow your passion and understand why it has any worth. Living in a world especially like todays, it’s just now beginning to be acceptable to express yourself. The author claims that students are formed by the others around them “they are made to be “fathers son or mothers daughter; colleges want them to be well rounded students, civic leaders, and people who know what the system demands, how to keep matters light […]” (Edmundson 409). He goes on to express this about this almost in a crucial way but continues on about how being morphed by others can sometimes be a good thing, according to Edmundson, “in the long run it is killing” (Edmundson 410).That’s why he encourages students to speak up and be “aggressive and assertive” when it comes to deciding what they want to

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Satisfactory Essays

    In the paired reading titled “Closing Doors” by Gavin Rember, the author takes us through the journey he faced as a child in dealing with the Denver Department of Social Services. Through his writing Rember focuses heavily on the detailed descriptions to enhance his arguments and feelings of the reality that he had faced at one point in time. He lived life moving from house to house because money wasn’t something his family, which included him and his single mother, had much of. Rember had grown to hate this building because it’s the symbol for all his family had which wasn’t much. Finally Gavin was able to leave a troubled past and move on, when he goes to revisit the closed down building he feels less hatred for it as if finally in his life things are stable.…

    • 307 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    All the scenes that Jacob Crawford, portrayed, would and could have contributed to the increase of the American statistics. One of the most impactful scene of the movie is when a male civilian was grounded and two American police officers were applying pressure on his head. This scene had very strong emotional context, for it brutally should the police brutality, Jacob Crawford choose to use a relaxing and casual melody to accompany that scene, to subtlety indicated that this is but a thing of the norm. The music of the documentary only changed when the scene turned to the police surrounding a house. The music played induced an atmosphere of mystery and worry. Through the masterful use of documentary techniques, Jacob Crawford, presented and influenced the mind of the audience to agree and sympathies with his ideas. By using Archival Footage, Jacob Crawford is creating a scene of history. Hence, making the audience aware that this issue has being around for a while. The varies shot types created a simulation that the audience was there when the event was occurring.…

    • 278 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Bruce used dialogue to portray people, places and ideas in his poem to reflect on his personal values and moral. Discuss using o ne poem.…

    • 334 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    It's a person's choice of which path they want to take in the future but without help they can choose the wrong path. As Dr. Seuss said in his poem" I'm sorry to say so but, sadly, it's true and Hang-ups can happen to you." My Perspective is that careers is a very important course in high school because it helps students discover their skills and choose the right career. Careers will show kids how to create and do different aspects of getting a job and starting a career. It will let them explore the different opportunities for them in the future and educate them to choose the career best for them. In…

    • 287 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    In Mark Shiffman’s essay Majoring In Fear, Shiffman addresses the increase in students drive to rack up credentials with hopes of landing their high paying, secure job ten years down the road, instead of focusing on what they are truly interested in. He argues that millennials trade out their passion for ambition out of fear of failure.This leads students to opt for the more “practical” areas of study, like the STEM field, and neglect what they may genuinely care about, like the arts or humanities. Shiffman is surely right about students putting their energy into activities that may build their resume out of uncertainty of the future instead of activities that are meaningful to them. Society should push students to pursue what inspires them instead of what career path offers the most job security. This will not only preserve students’ mental health, but also aid in the reverse of the decline in the studies of humanities. However, while I agree on most points, Shiffman fails to address the importance of STEM; in today’s ever changing society global technological competition is more important than ever on both political and economic levels.…

    • 1057 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    I can say that I can concur with every one of them. He began off with this father, whom is a noteworthy good example for every one of us, who was an obstinate man. Yet, toward the end his father needed to acknowledge that he needs to bolster his child whatever choice he makes. Students additionally live later on as Edmundson said. They came to college with the expectation that they will land a decent paying position that they will like. With the end goal they should learn they require professors that are aspiring and need America to improve as a spot. Edmundson Has a point in this he says that most professors will normally simply go carry out their occupation towards their calling and that is it. I concur with the majority of his focuses since they are extremely relate capable and are seen all around. As I see it he composed this essay from his own experience as a student and professor. Presently Edmundson adds society to his point. We aren't given particular points of interest on the author's undertakings in college with his father's recommendation, yet he continues to bolster his message with data about most colleges. Case in point, college professors much like students, go about their work to progress. Regardless of what anybody says, this work has little to do with the basics of educating. What Edmundson is stating is that most professors aren't especially gave to instructing classes and teaching students, rather doing their own particular work with a specific end goal to better their own particular lives. The author then goes ahead to discuss diverse philosophies. I suspected that these philosophies just freely identify with the point, appearing to be fairly tangential. Be that as it may, citing from notable scholars makes Edmundson more dependable on the…

    • 1397 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    During the college years of a person’s life, some of the biggest and life changing decisions are made. The decision of choosing a college, picking a major, and then the pursuit of a career affect the rest of an individual’s life. College students often receive a great deal of advice, from many different people, concerning their career. There are many people that give the advice, “Do what you love,” while, in contrast, other people will give the advice, “Do what makes money.” These two pieces of advice are very conflicting and it brings up the argument - should you do what you love or what makes the money? For both sides of the argument, there is support and reasoning that is very valid and persuasive. By looking at the argument subjectively, it is difficult to choose a side; each argument has its pros and cons. I believe that there should be a balance of both. Everyone has passions and if an individual has the opportunity to turn his…

    • 989 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Response Paper

    • 620 Words
    • 3 Pages

    For many high school students, the obvious choice after graduation is going to college. But why has this become the norm? With many students being conditioned at a young to prepare for college, there might not seem like any other choice. As college tuitions continues to rise and the job market continues to decline, young adults have started to rethink the choice to attend college. After all, there have been many successful people who have not graduated college. This proves that one does not need to attend college to be successful and there are many different options besides a four-year university to gain knowledge that is useful for getting a job.…

    • 620 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Better Essays

    Edmundson believes their objective changed from higher education to entertainment. The colleges turned their focus into making consumers happy. Edmundson describes a happy consumer as, “one with multiple options, one who can have what he wants. And since a course is something the students and their parents have bought and paid for, why can’t they do with it pretty much as they please?” (pg. 44) Edmundson believes the problem with this way of thinking is that students will miss out on something that could change their whole way of thinking. College students don’t want to be challenged they just want to make it through the class. A financial officer at the college broke it down to Edmundson saying that “colleges don’t have admissions offices anymore, they have marketing departments.” (pg. 44) According to Edmundson, to stay in business this change was going to happen. It was inevitable. This turning point is when universities and individual departments started competing for students. Colleges had to become lax in grading and major requirements. The author has noticed changes in the layout of his university over the past couple of years stating, “the place is looking more and more like a retirement spread for the young.” (pg. 43) Edmundson believes these changes are related to universities conforming to the buyer’s market. He states,…

    • 1347 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Ny Times Review

    • 630 Words
    • 3 Pages

    I am convinced that the pressure to join the workforce at an early age and continue employment throughout college is a huge distraction to many students of today. People don’t see this as an accomplishment anymore because it is expected; most students are employed at some point during their education placing a burden on the student. According to Professor Ellen Greenberger, the lead author of the study called “Self-Entitled College Students: Contributions of Personality, Parenting, and Motivational Factors,” believe that parental pressure, competition amongst peers & a heightened sense of achievement anxiety as also to blame for student’s sense of entitlement. I can attest to the pressures of society to succeed this is, however, no reason to become an undeveloped…

    • 630 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    In “Should Everyone Go To College?” Isabel Sawhill and Stephanie Owen makes a solid valid point on whether or not college is for everybody. For many students ready to leave high school, wondering whether they should attend college is an issue that may lay heavy on one teenagers mind. There are few factors that could be a difficult decision depending on a person’s goals they are working towards. Some students jump straight into the work field after graduation high school. Others teenagers, may sign up for the military after graduation. While these are some options, research says higher education is very important in one’s life. Higher education provides opportunity for students that attend college are giving a great shot of a better career later…

    • 1212 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    The evaluation essay “Working at McDonald’s” by Amitai Etzioni, was originally published in the Miami Herald. In the essay, author observed carefully the situation of young people, especially who is on the education process working at McDonald’s the symbol of fast food chain restaurant. He has evaluated it by using his ideas and values for the essential pursuit of young people.…

    • 484 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Is College for Everyone

    • 1164 Words
    • 5 Pages

    In today’s society, students are constantly being pushed to work towards a higher education. President Obama recently encouraged students to pursue at least one year of college after graduating high school. Our whole school system relies on previous education to get to the next. Each level of education has a purpose and that is to prepare them for the next level. After grade school comes middle school, after middle school comes high school, and after high school comes college, but what comes after college? With the previous pattern, the next level after college would be a career, but is this necessarily true? Is this the only path students have? Many students end up attending a four-year college because they feel like they are suppose and this often results in students not having a proper career goal. When this happens, they often get confused and lost in all the academic chaos. Even when students do have a career goal, they are sometimes encouraged to go into colleges that do not fully provide the education they need for their specific career. Although attending a four-year college and obtaining a degree is desired by many, students should be encouraged to attend schools based on their career choices, not by society’s standards.…

    • 1164 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    En route to a meaningful career, it is oftentimes necessary to receive a formal education in the field that one wants to pursue. This education opens one up to the job opportunities that will provide sufficient income and open enough doors to allow that person to obtain the employment they desire. Many fields unyieldingly require this education, complete with a degree, to even consider look at your resume and consider you for a position. Now, an education is not easy to come by. It is expensive and takes years of consistent hard work and diligence. Oftentimes, the student finishes their studies burdened with debt. They are not only leaving their education started from ground zero, but instead, starting below zero. It is important for him to be able to make money in order to overcome this debt, about default on his loans, and become financially healthy. It is important for their education to be focused, streamlined and as inexpensive as possible. That way, he can graduate sooner, begin working younger, and therefore for a longer period of time, and position himself to become more successful. In addition to this, for many, money is likely not their only motivating factor. It can be easy to go down a path that you think will be what you want to do; only to find out it isn’t. If you are able to more quickly get through school, and do it cheaply, it becomes easier to change career fields and ultimately land a career in something that would provide not only financially for you, but emotionally as well. I believe that general requirements do add to one’s overall well roundedness as a person and helps them in understanding the world around them, but I believe that it something that should be the responsible of the individual to explore and let evolve in their personal lives. It is important that one can pursue their career path with a streamlined education, as those things that contribute to us become more well-rounded…

    • 1077 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Choosing the Right Major

    • 368 Words
    • 2 Pages

    All people go throw many stages from childhood to the end of their life. They build their dreams to become something worth in their lives such as a teacher, doctor or anything else. The most important part of these dreams to become reality is to choose the right major. Many people said students should decide what they want to be before they start studying in university. I disagree with them because students at university get help from their friends or teachers to choose their career. In addition to that, many students are changing their decision of major when they start studying at the university.…

    • 368 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays