Preview

Veneration Without Understanding and Freedom of Conscience

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
664 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Veneration Without Understanding and Freedom of Conscience
Veneration without Understanding by Renato Constantino

Basically, this article is just about how Renato Constantino wants the readers to analyze the real story behind Rizal being our national hero, the aspects that contributed to such recognition, his condemnation of the revolution, and other factors that we failed to talk about over the years because they were not in our history books. Rizal, being our national hero, used writing to fight to gain our freedom from the Spaniards unlike Andres Bonifacio, he lead the KKK. Mr. Renato Constantino wants the Filipinos to analyze why Jose Rizal should be emulated? Was he really a hero at that who wanted the country to gain its own hold in the government but yet still a province of the Spain? Why is he called our hero? Is it because he died for our country? Or is it because he had enough courage to fight a losing battle, despite the fact that all he wanted to do was to surrender? The writer is not anti-Rizal. Rather, he is just trying to teach us how important it is to look into a much deeper sense, the attributes of a real and true hero, and the factors that should be considered so as to call someone, a hero. Although I think that he is ignorant about some things and maybe exaggerated a little bit in his article. Some people may find it more misleading than enlightening. I believe that Rizal is an extra-ordinary Filipino yet he is still just like us, a human being. Constantino is trying to say that we should understand that Rizal is not a god, but a person just like us. It is true that he was a necessary moment in our history but even though his heroism has been always talked about all the time, we cannot just think like him and base our point of view about our national goals to how he thinks. I mean, we can actually be a hero too by doing good things to people. But he can be our inspiration. Society evolves as time passes by and I mean that people today became more narrow minded. As a teenager who spends a lot

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Here are some final thoughts to end this paper. If you were in Rizal's position, would you actually continue to express your thoughts and fight for freedom even if it means risking your own life? Or will you stop expressing your thoughts to your fellow countrymen and save yourself from being killed? Remember, it's easier to say things than to do it, but maybe if you think of it as for the sake of those who are suffering then it wouldn't be so bad to sacrifice ones self isn't it? And perhaps you are that one spark that people need in order to light up an entire nation that would have a great impact on the entire course of our history and of our…

    • 682 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The following essays focus more specifically on Rizal. The fourth essay entitled “the Anatomy of the Anti-Hero” paints two different personas as illustrated by Guerrero and Radaic, both resisting the title of hero. The former painted Rizal’s nationalism as “political rather than social or economic” while the latter claimed he was “anxious, nervous, insecure.” And so, his heroism seemed questionable to Joaquin as Rizal is a Creole, or someone who did not seem entirely embody a Filipino.…

    • 857 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Prof. Constantino is one of the detractors of Jose Rizal. He is a duper and a dupe also and I was close in letting myself to get duped by him. Jose Rizal is definitely not the ideal hero of Prof. Constantino. Prof. Constantino made a criteria of his own hero. He set up a criterion of “revolutionary leadership” as the one that would govern the choice of a national hero. Jose Rizal did not lead or join the revolution and so Prof. Constantino do not classify Rizal as the national hero. Moreover, Constantino…

    • 605 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Philippines and Jose Rizal

    • 3071 Words
    • 13 Pages

    First of all we should clarify the meaning of a hero to make it quite simple to understand how Rizal became one. A hero symbolizes goodness. Rizal gave us freedom by using goodness. Jose Rizal became the Philippine national hero because he fought for freedom in a silent but powerful way. He expressed his love for the Philippines through his novels, essays and articles rather than through the use of force or aggression. He was a very amazing person at his time. He was humble, fighting for reforms through his writings instead of through a revolution. He used his intelligence, talents and skills in a more…

    • 3071 Words
    • 13 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    The Filipinos have a rich archive of history, from the prehistoric era, to the Spaniards rule in the Philippines, followed by the Americans and the Japanese, followed by the Marcos regime, up to the present situation of the country. All these events have a significant contribution to who the Filipinos are today. We have been honed for so long a time and still are being molded in this present generation. This study is important in order to awaken the Filipinos of today on whether or not the Philippine national hero should be called as such. Renato Constantino wrote in his article, “Veneration Without Understanding,” that 1) Rizal denied the revolution-- stressing primacy of education and his general regard to the revolution is not as high as expected 2) he was an American- sponsored hero and 3) was a limited Filipino and has loved the country in his own ilustrado way. On the other hand, Floro Quibuyen, another respected historian of his generation commented in his book, “A Nation Aborted,” 1) that there is a wrong dichotomy in formulating the ideas in Constantino’s article, 2) that there is an ideological conflict in any type, 3) that in politics, the conflict is among those who are in authority and 4) reform and revolution cannot be totally separated from each other. The results of the study are as follows: of the 50 respondents, 41 of them have read Jose Rizal’s Writings while 9 of them have not, 28 students say that Jose Rizal’s writings wake up their nationalism, 7 say they are good literature, and 15 say they are essential for every Filipino to read, 14 are aware of the issues regarding Jose Rizal as the national hero while 36 are not, 17 say that he still is suitable…

    • 6774 Words
    • 28 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    STUDENTS’ VIEWS ON FILIPINO HISTORIANS’ ARTICLES ABOUT JOSE RIZAL AS THE NATIONAL HERO OF THE PHILIPPINES A Paper Submitted to: Dr. Minerva V. Apita In Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements in: Philippine History with Politics and Governance Laylo, Anelle Nica M. September 7, 2011…

    • 645 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Dr. Rizal was a patriot, hero, and a martyr. He consecrated his God-given talent, and even sacrificed his own life, for the redemption and welfare of his people. Verily, a man of his heroism and versatility appears but once in the history of any…

    • 276 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Rizal DOc

    • 999 Words
    • 4 Pages

    The article shares the ideas and opinions in dialogues that usually represent conflicting views about Dr. Jose Rizal. Even though he is our national hero we still feel in need of a continuing dialogue on his ideas, principles and convictions. We know him as a profound thinker and a great doer who love our country and had remarkable patriotism. For that he was called the “First Filipino.”…

    • 999 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Another thing that I noticed was that they were comparing Rizal’s birth to Jesus’ birth. Logically speaking, these ancient beliefs or stories are not all true and because of this, it made me realize that other people, even in the same place since they have different groups or divisions has their own version of the story on how Rizal was born. Rizal as a prophet may be accepted in some way but not to the point that the Church will accept Rizal as a prophet sent by God from the heavens mostly because during Rizal’s time as he was writing his other books, he somewhat opposed the Church. So what is his relevance to the Church? Nothing, right? I know we may not have the same point of view but for me, everything in this article does not make any sense. Well it does, to other people or the ‘Rizalians’, but as a Catholic, I would not give in to this kind of idea nor even believe whatever other people believe in with regards to their beliefs in Rizal’s so called…

    • 1279 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Venerate Rizal!

    • 829 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Despite Constantino's unfortunate downgrading of Rizal, the essay does provoke a lot of questions. For me, the most intriguing was why Constantino brought up the principle of "ilustrado struggle" when he wrote of how Rizal repudiated the 1896 Revolution. There is another one of the things I have seen. The only time it seems Rizal wanted veneration was in his conflict with Marcelo H. del Pilar over leadership of La Solidaridad. I found that out of character for the National Hero, but it was apparently true. Nice to know he had some human flaws. But there is little information about that possibly ego-rift.…

    • 829 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Jose Rizal is our national hero but seriously i don’t know a lot about him. But when I watched the film about Dr. Jose Rizal I was shocked and amazed because of his sacrifice for our country. I though the he was a brilliant individual. He served as an inspiration to all Filipino. During his lifetime, he spent many years outside the Philippines, enriching himself through education, especially in Madrid, Spain. The distance did not diminish nor reduce his love for his country. Far from his motherland, he looked across the seas to find its strength, as well as its weaknesses, in order to uplift it from the abuses of foreign rule.…

    • 336 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Reflection of Rizal

    • 1286 Words
    • 6 Pages

    If our heroes our a reflection of our society, then how we approach Rizal is all the more damning for how small it makes us look. Maybe Nick Joaquin was right, maybe we have become a nation of…

    • 1286 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    First question is as a Filipino do we really need to honour Rizal? According to Constantino, he strictly contradicts the over exaltation of our national hero by some people. He believes that Dr. Jose Rizal is not worthy to be assigned as our national hero because of the following reasons: First is because he refused to take side to the revolutionary army; then he underestimated the power and knowledge of the mass; and lastly he never really promoted true freedom because he believes that it is just for the educated and not a national right. Constantino also denounced the Americans that lead the initiation of choosing Rizal for being a national hero because it served…

    • 1128 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Constantino describes the shallow knowledge of Filipinos about Rizal and Nationalism. Because of the developing time and world, many Filipinos do not have enough knowledge and knowings about it. They are not aware of what the history has brought us. A little thankful that I will know, where is my part of being a Filipino now. I think that everyone should be aware of this article because it will help us a lot on how we will measure our nationalism. All of us know the meaning of it, but seldom know the true interpretation of it. A little sad that we don’t know what will happen if through the years will be the same.…

    • 401 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    This work pointed out a lot of Rizal’s good traits and contributions to the nation. In fact, it mentioned a lot of what he did. However, Constantino kept on putting ‘buts’ after one thing Rizal has done. Was he seeking total action or just complaining about what Rizal contributed? I think by the mere fact that he can mention good things about the hero, it makes Rizal who he is. Regardless of how things ended up, I think the spark Rizal ignited was enough to start something that the Filipinos did to fight for the country.…

    • 500 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays