Preview

The Great Dangers of Civil Disobedience

Better Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1763 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
The Great Dangers of Civil Disobedience
Jack Sparrow
Mr Reffot Intellectual revolutions can often have a deep impact on society. Henry David Thoreau was looking to make such an impact by publicizing his transcendentalist beliefs and going a step further with his concept of civil disobedience. Lewis H. Van Dusen 's essay entitled Civil Disobedience: Destroyer of Democracy was published in 1969 and opposes greatly the beliefs of Thoreau. Van Dusen essentially deems civil disobedience as the assumption that you can be above the law should it not tailor to your beliefs. Van Dusen explicitly refutes the concepts of Thoreau suggesting that they, as the title of his work suggests, destroy democracy. Van Dusen feels that when man disobeys the law and separates from the democratic society he feels has failed, he simply pushes democracy further towards failure. While the ends laid out by Thoreau in Walden and Civil Disobedience, and Martin Luther King Jr. in Letter From Birmingham Jail, may be completely valid, the mean by which they chose to try and attain them, civil disobedience, is acted upon without true understanding of its detrimental impact to democratic society according to Lewis H. Van Dusen.
While Henry David Thoreau seems to feel he is presenting the ideals for how one should live their life and how government should function, in reality he is conveying an impractical message with detrimental effects. In his work Walden, Thoreau outlines the basic ideas of transcendentalism and keeps an account of his time spent living in the Walden woods. It is in the Walden woods that Thoreau concludes, "If we do not…forge rails, and devote days and nights to the work, but go to tinkering upon our lives to improve them, who will build railroads?...who will want railroads?"(1). Thoreau is conveying the message that within American society man has becomes so consumed with his own life that he has forgotten about striving towards progression. Thoreau feels that if every man spends his time concerned



Cited: King Jr., Martin L. "Letter from a Birmingham Jail [King, Jr.]." African Studies Center- University of Pennsylvania. Ed. Ali B. Ali-Dinar. Web. 18 Oct. 2010. <http://www.africa.upenn.edu/Articles_Gen/Letter_Birmingham.html>.

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Satisfactory Essays

    The letter written by Dr. King from the Birmingham Jail was addressed to his fellow clergyman, however when taken as a whole this writer beings to understand his audience is not limited to such a small ecclesiastic circle. In the letter from Birmingham Jail, Dr. King addressed multiple groups he felt contributed to the racial divide in Birmingham, namely the white majority, the Religious groups and the Moderate whites. Each group contributed to the racist climate through direct action, inaction or quiet consent.…

    • 83 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Martin Luther King's "A letter from Birmingham jail" was written in response to a published statement by eight fellow clergymen from Alabama who seriously criticized King for organization and participation in the protest march against segregation in Birmingham. King's letter was an attempt to defend himself from these accusations and to criticize white heads and moderators of the church. In the begging parts of the letter, Martin Luther King tries to reject the accusation of being an outsider in Birmingham. He also goes against the accusations that the protests where “untimely” by stating several reasons why this was appropriate time for…

    • 281 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    In this particular passage from “Civil Disobedience: Destroyer of Democracy” civil disobedient such as Socrates, Gandhi, and Thoreau are discussed and why Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. isn’t and shouldn’t be considered a civil disobedient. According to Lewis H. Van Dusen the definition of a civil disobedient is “The civil disobedient withholds taxes or violates state laws knowing he is legally wrong but believing he is morally right. The premises that supports the truth of the conclusion of the following passage are “The civil disobedient withholds taxes or violates state laws knowing he is legally wrong but believing he is morally right”, “Dr. King led his followers in violation of state laws he believed were contrary to the federal constitution”,…

    • 377 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Martin Luther King Jr.'s letter from Birmingham Jail was written on April 16, 1963 while he was incarcerated in the Birmingham City Jail. This letter addresses the criticism that a group of white men had thrown at him and his pro-black American organization about their non-violent actions against racial discrimination and injustice among black Americans in Birmingham. He notes that he doesn’t usually respond to letters of criticism but he thought that they were “good willed people and their criticism was sincerely set forth.” King writes this letter to defend his organization's actions. King's letter talks about…

    • 323 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    In April of 1963, while incarcerated in Birmingham City jail, Martin Luther King Jr. wrote an influential letter defending his anti-segregation protests. King had been arrested while participating in a peaceful anti-segregation march although several local religious groups counted on King for support. Since King’s arrest he had time to think deeply about the situation; therefore, he decides to reply back to the Alabama clergymen. Who had criticize Martin Luther King because he was simply doing something that was right and violence was not needed for King. “Letter from Birmingham Jail” is addressed to clergymen who had written an open letter criticizing the actions of Martin Luther King, Jr. during several protest in…

    • 925 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    In 1963, Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr. wrote “Letter from Birmingham Jail” from jail in Birmingham, Alabama in response to a public statement issued by eight white clergyman calling his actions “ unwise and untimely”. African Americans have been waiting to have there civil rights of freedom, but the social courts has requested them not protest on the street but to take it to court. Dr. King wrote, “This wait has almost always meant never.” This is why Dr. king addresses this matter in a letter about the battle of segregation. He hopes that this letter will stop this injustice matter, and show what the African American desire. Furthermore, Dr. King had four steps to achieve his goals by collecting facts, negotiation, self-purification, and direct…

    • 254 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    In “Letter from Birmingham Jail” (King Jr., Martin Luther. Letter From Birmingham Jail: Why We Can't Wait.), Martin Luther King Jr. writes back to the clergy on his actions and his demand for change and negotiation from a cell in Birmingham jail. In his letter, King explains the direct action in the Negro community is a demand for civil change, how he is disappointed in the blind eye in the white community, and how change is gained through love.…

    • 381 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Letter from Birmingham Jail details how and why MLK is in jail in Birmingham. Dr. King was unjustly jailed for leading a protest without a parade permit. This was infringing on his first amendment rights to peacefully protest, the actual reason was to stop their movement and continue segregation. Martin Luther King believed that he had a duty to be at Birmingham, because “injustice anywhere is a threat to justice everywhere.” He did not feel like he did not belong because he says that nobody can be an outsider as long as you’re within your country’s bounds. He was protesting the unjust laws, that he saw morally wrong because it degraded them as humans and was not harmonious with moral laws. Their equality had to be requested in the form of civil disobedience “freedom is never voluntarily given by the oppressor.” Such as the Boston Tea Party was an act of civil…

    • 1143 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Letter from Birmingham Jail is a letter written by Martin Luther King, Jr. while he was in jail for participating in peaceful protest against segregation. He wrote the letter in response to criticisms made by white clergymen. Dr. King’s goal of this letter was to draw attention to the injustice of segregation, and to defend his tactics for achieving justice. He uses a large number of rhetorical devices in his letter to reach his goal, including point of view, imagery, and rhetorical questions. He uses these rhetorical techniques along with a logical argument to demonstrate why his methods were right.…

    • 1288 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Throughout the first 21 paragraphs of King’s letter from Birmingham jail he develops the central claim of injustice in Birmingham. He justifies his claim by describing unjust laws and how the white moderate is hurting their cause and how the oppression that African-America’s faced in Birmingham. Creating these central claims, King emphasizes Birmingham’s cry for help to release them from the injustices.…

    • 534 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Dr. King’s Letter from Birmingham Jail was written in response to the violent racist terrorist attacks toward the African Americans in Birmingham, Alabama, as well as to respond to the criticism he received about his work in a respectful, yet powerful way. He was arrested and sent to jail while participating in a non-violent anti-segregation march because he had no permit. Treatment of African Americans were unfair and un-American and Dr. King had enough of the way African American’s were treated and in his letter wrote: “Injustice anywhere is a threat to injustice everywhere.” In order to spread freedom throughout Birmingham, Dr. King followed through with a plan built on facts, negotiation, and non-violent direct action mainly in the form…

    • 593 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Martin Luther King “Letter From a Birmingham Jail was a published statement by eight fellow Clergymen from the state of Alabama who awful criticized King for organizing and participating in the protest march among segregation in Birmingham. King’s letter was an attempt to defend himself from…

    • 677 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    In the written document, “Letter from Birmingham Jail” Dr. King recognizes the injustice his fellow African Americans and himself have been suffering over the years. He was…

    • 144 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Letter from a Birmingham Jail by Martin Luther King Jr. mentions the atrocities of racism and describes his endless battles against it. King does this in an effective and logical way. King establishes his position supported by historical and biblical allusions, counterarguments, and the use of rhetorical devices such as ethos, pathos, and logos. With the use of King's rhetorical devices, he described the ways of the Birmingham community and their beliefs, connected to the reader on an emotional level, and brought to light the overall issues dealing with segregation.…

    • 828 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    While incarcerated in a Birmingham jail for leading a peaceful march in Birmingham against racial segregation, King begins this letter acknowledging the recent criticism of white clergymen in Birmingham calling his actions "unwise and untimely." King uses logical appeal to make his case. In an unemotional straightforward tone, he explains that he is president of the Southern Christian Leadership Conference and the organization had been invited to Birmingham, the most segregated city in America, to help battle injustice; thus, he has a right to be there and he is not merely an “outsider” causing trouble. He defends his teaching of nonviolent means to fight injustice. With a personal and emotional tone, he illustrates the oppression of African-Americans and stresses that now is time for the victims to demand the end of prejudice. He clarifies that "justice too long delayed is justice denied;” therefore, his actions are not untimely. Martin Luther King…

    • 561 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays