Preview

The Cultural Dilemma of Native Americans

Satisfactory Essays
Open Document
Open Document
679 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
The Cultural Dilemma of Native Americans
| The Cultural Dilemma of Native Americans | |

|

The Cultural Dilemma of Native Americans
In this painting by George Catlin titled “Assinneboine Chief before and after Civilization” it shows a very proud Assinneboine Chief standing straight and proud. His clothing expresses his Indian culture as he is dressed in leggings and shirt made of mountain goat skin, and finished with a pictured robe of buffalo hide over his right shoulder. Moccasins covered his feet and his tribal headdress decorated his head allowing his long hair to blend with the feathers of his headdress. In his left hand is his long pipe which he would smoke with those with whom he would want to make peace. The background which is painted in a lighter hue then the opposite side of the painting reveals a dirt road which leads to the capitol building in Washington, suggesting that the Chief is traveling to there with peaceful intentions. The only green in the painting is the landscape surrounding the Capitol building. Could this be to show the wealth of those who lived there, to depict that the grass may be greener on the other side?
When he returned to the northern plains of his people Chief Wi-jún-jon looked nothing like that proud Indian chief who journeyed into Washington to meet with President Andrew Jackson some 18 months earlier. (Smithsonian American Art Museum). He stepped ashore in what appeared to be a colonel's military blue uniform complete with epaulettes of gold, a sash and belt, broad sword and high-heeled boots. (Catlin) A blue umbrella in his left hand and a paper hand fan in his right, his pockets are filled with jugs of whiskey and a tobacco cigarette has replaced his long pipe; which is nowhere to be seen.
In the background lies the village to which he is returning the artist has painted this side in a darker hue perhaps depicting his thoughts on how this Assinneboine Chief has been refashioned to adapt to the “white man” ways. The only thing that remains



Bibliography: Catlin, G. (1844). LETTERS AND NOTES ON THE MANNERS, CUSTOMS, AND CONDITIONS OF NORTH AMERICAN INDIANS. Smithsonian American Art Museum. (n.d.). Retrieved from http://americanart.si.edu/collections/search/artwork/?id=4317.

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    ‘Palm Valley’ was painted in the 1940’s when indigenous people were still fighting to win their land back and gain equality. Albert painted many sacrosanct Aboriginal locations, portraying…

    • 316 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    While visiting the Jaycee Park Centre for the Arts, this picture of cowboys rounding up cows on a ranch instantly caught my eye. The picture is a standard size of 3x3, and is square shaped. It is enclosed within a golden frame, which makes it more conspicuous. I was drawn to the picture by the cowboy who is wearing the red scarf, and sky blue shirt. The artist James Spurlock, has used him to capture the observer’s attention by using bold colors on his clothes as opposed to the other two cowboys, and the cows. The artist has also created an impression of distance as the cows in the front appear to be large in size. and clearer as compared to the two cowboys in the background. The element of a middle ground is present which is portrayed by the cowboy with the red scarf. He appears to be positioned between the cows in the front, and the other two cowboys in the back. The artist has been able to imply the texture of the cows’ skin using different brush strokes. One can see the roughness of the cows’ skin even without having to touch the smooth oil painted canvas. One cannot immediately tell the time of day when the picture was taken. This is because the background is not blue, but rather it is a greyish color, and most probably the cowboys are trying to lead the cows back to their stables for shelter before it rain. In the process of rounding up the cows, the surrounding is filled with dust resulting in the dark gold background.…

    • 589 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    In this work of art, Napoleon is the only character riding a white horse and depicted front and center. All figures are anonymous, except Napoleon himself, who is clearly the subject in this painting and dons an ornate uniform and thick, bright red cape for warmth, unlike the lackluster troops in the background. The horse’s mane, tail and Napoleon’s cape are blown forward by the wind, following the direction in which Napoleon points. Even the wispy clouds in the sky seem to follow Napoleon’s command. The white horse rears as Napoleon points ahead, signaling his troops to charge onward up the winding mountain. In the background, there are approximately fourteen figures, three of which appear to be Napoleon’s soldiers hauling a wooden wagon, or cannon, up the…

    • 535 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Caitlin Holm

    • 1114 Words
    • 3 Pages

    George Catlin and Bill Holm are both known as some of the finest painters of Native American life. In his life time, Catlin created more than five hundred paintings and collected an impressive number of Indian artifacts, and after returning to the East he began exhibiting his work in influential cities. As an artist, Holm’s diverse works range from carving and painting to beading and quillwork, always specializing in the visual art of Northwest Coast Native Americans. This led him to take on the role of practitioner and teacher of the Northwest Coast art style. Both these artists have found a fervent fascination with the varying aspects of these ingenuous people, and have sought to express this in their art; however, a great difference is seen in how both artists choose to express and interpret American Indians in their works. While one traveled west of the Mississippi River in the 1830s to record images of America's native people and sought to change American attitudes toward the dispossession and disempowerment of America's indigenous peoples, the other focused on the portrayal of Native American life through the historically accurate recreation of traditional dress, ornaments, and artifacts. Both artists have developed styles that beautifully portray and express different aspects of Natives lives that, while contrast in many ways, are both spectacular and though provoking…

    • 1114 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Mayas and Aztecs were polytheistic and believed in sacrifices. The Timuquans and Natchez worshiped the sun. All the tribes got married to the person the family picked for them.…

    • 1890 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Old Hunting Grounds

    • 586 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Within the painting are female Indians and a child watching a few tribesmen fishing, while a Chief Indian is standing, talking among two other tribesmen on land. Even more so the painting does not depict savage type Indians but peaceful ones living and being a part of nature. Nevertheless, the white settlers in there mass settlement in the background seem to dominant the Indian lands rather than be a part of it. Art elements of space and color play a pivotal role in Fisher's piece. Besides "Indians Visiting the Old Hunting Grounds" being realistic, it is quite textural and representational in style, with its usage of local color, creating a fictional historical picturesque scene.…

    • 586 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Sabine Women While imprisoned for his support of Robespierre during the French Revolution (#2) Jacques-Louis David began planning his next painting. After a visit from his estranged wife he began painting what would be called (#1) The Intervention of the Sabine Women. He completed the painting in 1799. 1 (Stanska)…

    • 588 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    All spiritual beliefs in Aboriginal culture relate back to the idea of creation and dreaming. The dreaming is the ongoing cultural and spiritual progression that informs identity and knowledge, which is expressed through traditional indigenous art. This reflects a spiritual connection to the land, which is represented by signs and symbols as well as other various techniques, which are unique to traditional indigenous art. Signs and symbols can represent a particular location, object or landmark, or a particular story or totem that would be specific to a particular tribe, corroboree or dreamtime story. In traditional indigenous artworks, there is no perspective or fixed vanishing points for landscape artworks because indigenous Australians do not see their environment as a landscape, but their particular world and universe. They create a concept of place by using signs and symbols to create a map-like artwork, which represents their particular ‘world’ and universe. Essentially, traditional indigenous Australian artists are painting their spirituality, by expressing their connection to the land through signs, symbols and their world.…

    • 850 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The article that we were assigned to read, made me a bit aggravated at some points. To start off, there were far too many contradictions in this article to be considered a "good read" in my opinion. The first thing that caught my eye while reading, was the giant, bold, blue paragraph sections that stated "fact." While reading numerous "fact" paragraphs, quite a few times I came across the phrase "most likely" "it was assumed" or "points to." These phrases, do not point to facts, nor do they belong in a facts paragraph. These phrases still point to doubt and uncertainty and for all the reader knows, can still be an opinion of the writer. Personally as a reader, when I place something in a fact or opinion category, I make sure that it is properly placed in its group. A fact, is something that is proven and definite, not something that can still be swayed into another group. Another contradiction that I saw, was stated in the first few "Fact" paragraphs, that every day is typically celebrated as a day of thanks for Native Americans. Every day is celebrated as thanksgiving. Then, in the last paragraph, it says that thanksgiving is a day of mourning for Native Americans. Thanksgiving serves as a day of thanks in the beginning of the article, then serves as a day of mourning in the…

    • 522 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    The Blackfoot Indians

    • 2400 Words
    • 10 Pages

    ice age caused the gap to freeze over. They came from Asia by following herds…

    • 2400 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Native American population is comprised of distinct and heterogenous ethnocultural groups that make up about 1.8 million of the total people in the United States. The American Southwest is particularly unique because of the environment, the Native traditions and culture, and the historical contact with the Spanish as well as the interactions with the United States government. An enclave describes an area surrounded by or within a territory in which the people in the area are culturally and/or ethnically different than the larger, surrounding territory. The American Southwest encompasses the tip of California, Arizona, the southern most portions of Utah and Colorado, western New Mexico, and the most western bit of Texas.…

    • 580 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Native American Sociology

    • 751 Words
    • 4 Pages

    A common saying within our society is that history repeats itself. This expression, although short and simple, is more accurate than one would think. This repetition is seen in all corners of history, in all walks of life, and in every single time period. It is almost exactly like the circle of life; an idea is born, the idea grows and develops, the idea is accepted, the idea is rejected, but the idea never dies. Instead, it haunts society until it is once again needed by the community. In the past, one sees how capitalism aided in the removal of Native Americans, now, today this is seen once again as history repeats itself.…

    • 751 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The second floor of National Museum of the American Indian contains many interesting exhibits that tell stories of American Indians, such as the livelihood of Native Americans in the present time and the culture of American Indians. There are many items that are related to American Indians’ lives in those exhibits. However, the author of this essay is interested in The American Indian which is the name of an oil painting that has been depicted in one of those exhibits, Our Live. This oil painting was painted on linen in 1970 by Fritz Scholder who was the renowned Native American artist of the 20th century. The painting depicts an American Indian man who beautifies his long black hair with a feather and holds a pipe tomahawk in front of the yellow and brown background. Additionally, the man covers the American flag over his body.…

    • 1070 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    visual art analysis

    • 412 Words
    • 1 Page

    The most remarkable of the painting is the man in the white shirt that was standing in front of the Napoleon troops took place on the left hand side of the painting. His clothes are white and clean contrasting to the other townspeople who were wearing dirty with blood stained. His snowy presents purity and also is believing of religion as well. He is holding his arm in an unmistakable reference which shapes like a ‘v’ and does similar to the Christ on the cross explores peace and independent. Thus, it also suggests the audiences that he is a martyr for the rest of the town. As a consequence of his stance, his left hand was pointing to the church at the background conveys ideology of their religion which is Catholic; his others hand are above the townspeople’s heads symbolises as a shield of protection. The man in the white shirt is standing out in the darkness of the sky. The dark sky is successfully represents the feeling of sadness and hopeless of the townspeople to audiences. Besides, there is a puddle blood in the foreground with a dead body on that. Though, there is a group of Spanish troops in the middle of the painting were standing with hands over their faces emphasises that they were suffering and sorrowful with a great lost. Those events encounter the Napoleon’s troops that lining up with guns. The guns were holding up between their faces and shoulders level pointing straight to the townspeople. The troops took place on the right hand side of the painting. They were wearing full uniform with hats and black shoes represents powerful and unity. They face were showing no mercy and inspirited.…

    • 412 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Cole Turner Blogs

    • 7602 Words
    • 21 Pages

    Schroon Mountain, Adirondacks, is an oil on canvas painting. It is a painting of Schroon Mountain in New York done by Thomas Cole around 1837. It is a naturalistic painting with use of natural colors, as well as shading and highlighting to give the viewer a sense they are staring into an actual landscape. It uses the triangle and pyramid, but the sweeping slopes of the mountains and the forested hill in the right foreground gives it a diagonal axis suggesting movement. The painting is meant to inspire awe and appreciation for the land that is the United States of America, a nation still in its infancy compared to the old nations of Europe. The painting essentially is the idea of Manifest Destiny, prevalent at that time, given form in art. It conveys the promise and potential of what awaits the citizens of this new nation, like Paradise or a Garden of Eden awaiting for the “Americans”, essentially white men, to explore and safeguard. There are two Native American figures in the landscape that is not apparent upon casual perusal. The indigenous people are depicted as if that they may as well be part of the landscape, and this reflects subconscious attitudes of the white Americans who see themselves as destined to safeguard this land.…

    • 7602 Words
    • 21 Pages
    Good Essays